Garden_KC
Heisman

Posts: 5,000
Joined: Jan 2023
Reputation: 142
I Root For: Landscaping
Location:
|
G6 median massey composite w/ new 2026 lineups
The 2025 Massey composite rankings only have so far 5 polls but interesting to look at because it includes new teams for 2025.
https://masseyratings.com/ranks
PAC 80.5
SBC 95
AAC 95.5
MWC 105
MAC 106.5
CUSA 121.5
-The nuPAC is the best G6 conference, definitely as step up from MWC 3.0 who is bouyed somewhat by the addition of Northern Illinois.
-SBC 16 with Ohio, Toledo, WKU instead of LaTech would have had a median ranking of 87 which closes about half the gap between itself and nuPAC.
-The MAC is closer in strength to SBC/AAC than what it is CUSA. WKU at 95 would help the MAC a little bit and always reliable to make the MAC Tournament (Top 8 qualify) along with making a bowl game.
-The AAC without Memphis & Tulane clocks in at 105.5 which puts it right around MWC/MAC level and substantially below the SBC.
(This post was last modified: 07-14-2025 08:31 PM by Garden_KC.)
|
|
| 07-14-2025 08:29 PM |
|
GreenBison
Heisman

Posts: 8,953
Joined: Jun 2002
Reputation: 735
I Root For: Marshall | SBC
Location: West By God!
|
RE: G6 median massey composite w/ new 2026 lineups
You’re gonna make some people mad
|
|
| 07-14-2025 08:44 PM |
|
SkullyMaroo
Moderator

Posts: 12,883
Joined: Mar 2009
Reputation: 848
I Root For: South Alabama
Location: Mobile
|
RE: G6 median massey composite w/ new 2026 lineups
I wonder what this would look like if you took the 10 year Massey Composite average ranking for each school and then averaged those out. I might piggyback of your post and calculate that tomorrow. That might give us more of an indication of what we could expect since lifting just one season doesn’t take into account the schedule differences some of these teams would have had. It also might not take into account teams that had an out of place season (either good or bad).
|
|
| 07-14-2025 09:59 PM |
|
bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,874
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: G6 median massey composite w/ new 2026 lineups
(07-14-2025 08:29 PM)Garden_KC Wrote: The 2025 Massey composite rankings only have so far 5 polls but interesting to look at because it includes new teams for 2025.
https://masseyratings.com/ranks
PAC 80.5
SBC 95
AAC 95.5
MWC 105
MAC 106.5
CUSA 121.5
-The nuPAC is the best G6 conference, definitely as step up from MWC 3.0 who is bouyed somewhat by the addition of Northern Illinois.
-SBC 16 with Ohio, Toledo, WKU instead of LaTech would have had a median ranking of 87 which closes about half the gap between itself and nuPAC.
-The MAC is closer in strength to SBC/AAC than what it is CUSA. WKU at 95 would help the MAC a little bit and always reliable to make the MAC Tournament (Top 8 qualify) along with making a bowl game.
-The AAC without Memphis & Tulane clocks in at 105.5 which puts it right around MWC/MAC level and substantially below the SBC.
This is without any data. Just preseason polls.
|
|
| 07-14-2025 11:04 PM |
|
Garden_KC
Heisman

Posts: 5,000
Joined: Jan 2023
Reputation: 142
I Root For: Landscaping
Location:
|
RE: G6 median massey composite w/ new 2026 lineups
(07-14-2025 11:04 PM)bullet Wrote: (07-14-2025 08:29 PM)Garden_KC Wrote: The 2025 Massey composite rankings only have so far 5 polls but interesting to look at because it includes new teams for 2025.
https://masseyratings.com/ranks
PAC 80.5
SBC 95
AAC 95.5
MWC 105
MAC 106.5
CUSA 121.5
-The nuPAC is the best G6 conference, definitely as step up from MWC 3.0 who is bouyed somewhat by the addition of Northern Illinois.
-SBC 16 with Ohio, Toledo, WKU instead of LaTech would have had a median ranking of 87 which closes about half the gap between itself and nuPAC.
-The MAC is closer in strength to SBC/AAC than what it is CUSA. WKU at 95 would help the MAC a little bit and always reliable to make the MAC Tournament (Top 8 qualify) along with making a bowl game.
-The AAC without Memphis & Tulane clocks in at 105.5 which puts it right around MWC/MAC level and substantially below the SBC.
This is without any data. Just preseason polls.
They are but the basis of the information was formed from last year's performance.
All the conclusions I could have made without looking at this data. Some however on here talk about the MWC as a P6 and imagine CUSA poaching MAC teams....
|
|
| 07-15-2025 12:40 AM |
|
Tiger1983
BBA

Posts: 41,575
Joined: Apr 2006
Reputation: 2987
I Root For: Tigers - GTG!
Location: The enemy’s lair
 
|
RE: G6 median massey composite w/ new 2026 lineups
The composite shows Navy and Army with a significant slide from last season. My cursory review indicates those schools accounting for most of the AAC's rating. The reasons for the drop are unclear to me.
https://masseyratings.com/ranks?s=cf&d=20250821
(This post was last modified: 07-15-2025 07:59 AM by Tiger1983.)
|
|
| 07-15-2025 07:58 AM |
|
Tiger1983
BBA

Posts: 41,575
Joined: Apr 2006
Reputation: 2987
I Root For: Tigers - GTG!
Location: The enemy’s lair
 
|
RE: G6 median massey composite w/ new 2026 lineups
The composite shows Boise (#27) and Tulane (#29) neck and neck for the CFP G6 slot. The school with a stronger conference would have an advantage.
|
|
| 07-15-2025 08:02 AM |
|
ballantyneapp
Banned
Posts: 5,645
Joined: Mar 2018
I Root For: App
Location:
|
RE: G6 median massey composite w/ new 2026 lineups
(07-15-2025 08:02 AM)Tiger1983 Wrote: The composite shows Boise (#27) and Tulane (#29) neck and neck for the CFP G6 slot. The school with a stronger conference would have an advantage.
Tulane has 2 very winnable p4 games while Boise only has Notre dame that can be a signature win
|
|
| 07-15-2025 08:17 AM |
|
b0ndsj0ns
Legend

Posts: 30,775
Joined: Oct 2009
Reputation: 1639
I Root For: ECU
Location:
|
RE: G6 median massey composite w/ new 2026 lineups
(07-15-2025 08:02 AM)Tiger1983 Wrote: The composite shows Boise (#27) and Tulane (#29) neck and neck for the CFP G6 slot. The school with a stronger conference would have an advantage.
I don't think the stronger conference is actually any advantage at the G5 level for getting the bid. The only advantage strength of conference brings is if you have multiple top 25 teams in the league. The level of consideration I suspect the committee gives between winning a bunch of games against 75-80 ranked G5 schools vs 100-120 ranked G5 schools is next to zero. Lists of things I think they consider at the G5 level.
1. Did you beat a P4 school?
2. Did you play a really good P4 school close?
3. What's your overall record?
4. Did you happen to beat a ranked G5 school?
Don't think it goes a bit further than that. I think the actual best thing for maximizing the chances of getting the playoff bid for a G5 league would be a top 3 or so that is consistently ranked or close to it and then the rest of the league is pure trash that never beats the top. There's no benefit to being the "SEC of the G5" where everyone in the league is good enough to beat everyone.
|
|
| 07-15-2025 08:46 AM |
|
HP-TBDPITL
Heisman

Posts: 5,528
Joined: Jun 2010
Reputation: 250
I Root For: College Sports
Location:
|
RE: G6 median massey composite w/ new 2026 lineups
(07-15-2025 08:46 AM)b0ndsj0ns Wrote: (07-15-2025 08:02 AM)Tiger1983 Wrote: The composite shows Boise (#27) and Tulane (#29) neck and neck for the CFP G6 slot. The school with a stronger conference would have an advantage.
I don't think the stronger conference is actually any advantage at the G5 level for getting the bid. The only advantage strength of conference brings is if you have multiple top 25 teams in the league. The level of consideration I suspect the committee gives between winning a bunch of games against 75-80 ranked G5 schools vs 100-120 ranked G5 schools is next to zero. Lists of things I think they consider at the G5 level.
1. Did you beat a P4 school?
2. Did you play a really good P4 school close?
3. What's your overall record?
4. Did you happen to beat a ranked G5 school?
Don't think it goes a bit further than that. I think the actual best thing for maximizing the chances of getting the playoff bid for a G5 league would be a top 3 or so that is consistently ranked or close to it and then the rest of the league is pure trash that never beats the top. There's no benefit to being the "SEC of the G5" where everyone in the league is good enough to beat everyone.
Bolded is most important....and equally important is that they play in the CCG.
At the end of the year if a G6 conference has two teams ranked in the Top 25 playing in their conference championship game, the winner is likely to get the bid. The only caveat might be if another conference has someone ranked HIGHER than BOTH of the other conference's teams...then they likely wont drop with a win.
|
|
| 07-15-2025 09:19 AM |
|
Tiger1983
BBA

Posts: 41,575
Joined: Apr 2006
Reputation: 2987
I Root For: Tigers - GTG!
Location: The enemy’s lair
 
|
RE: G6 median massey composite w/ new 2026 lineups
Mainly due to a late surge by legacy schools, the AAC finished first among the G-5's last season according to Massey Composite ( https://masseyratings.com/ranks?s=cf&d=20250121&c=1).
I compared last year to the current Massey Composite ranking (negative is unfavorable while positive is favorable):
Navy (-31)
Army (-22)
Charlotte (-12)
Temple (-8)
NT (-5)
ECU (-4)
Tulsa (-3)
Memphis (-2)
Rice (-2)
USF (-1)
UAB (+4)
Tulane (+12)
FAU (+14)
UTSA (+18)
Overall (-26)
|
|
| 07-15-2025 10:14 AM |
|
Tiger1983
BBA

Posts: 41,575
Joined: Apr 2006
Reputation: 2987
I Root For: Tigers - GTG!
Location: The enemy’s lair
 
|
RE: G6 median massey composite w/ new 2026 lineups
(07-15-2025 09:19 AM)HP-TBDPITL Wrote: (07-15-2025 08:46 AM)b0ndsj0ns Wrote: (07-15-2025 08:02 AM)Tiger1983 Wrote: The composite shows Boise (#27) and Tulane (#29) neck and neck for the CFP G6 slot. The school with a stronger conference would have an advantage.
I don't think the stronger conference is actually any advantage at the G5 level for getting the bid. The only advantage strength of conference brings is if you have multiple top 25 teams in the league. The level of consideration I suspect the committee gives between winning a bunch of games against 75-80 ranked G5 schools vs 100-120 ranked G5 schools is next to zero. Lists of things I think they consider at the G5 level.
1. Did you beat a P4 school?
2. Did you play a really good P4 school close?
3. What's your overall record?
4. Did you happen to beat a ranked G5 school?
Don't think it goes a bit further than that. I think the actual best thing for maximizing the chances of getting the playoff bid for a G5 league would be a top 3 or so that is consistently ranked or close to it and then the rest of the league is pure trash that never beats the top. There's no benefit to being the "SEC of the G5" where everyone in the league is good enough to beat everyone.
Bolded is most important....and equally important is that they play in the CCG.
At the end of the year if a G6 conference has two teams ranked in the Top 25 playing in their conference championship game, the winner is likely to get the bid. The only caveat might be if another conference has someone ranked HIGHER than BOTH of the other conference's teams...then they likely wont drop with a win.
In the past, there was a correlation between earning a NY6/CFP spot and conference strength as measured by Massey Composite. I do not recall the factor, but it was material (although not +1). Correlation does not mean causation, but it is meaningful.
It makes sense because SOS is a consideration for selection and the reader may recall AAC members use to state with confidence a one-loss AAC school had an edge over an undefeated squad from another conference.
|
|
| 07-15-2025 10:19 AM |
|
SkullyMaroo
Moderator

Posts: 12,883
Joined: Mar 2009
Reputation: 848
I Root For: South Alabama
Location: Mobile
|
RE: G6 median massey composite w/ new 2026 lineups
If you take the 5-year average Massey Composite ranking for each school and average it out for the new membership, you'd get the following averages:
74.23 - Pac-12
82.14 - Sun Belt
86.89 - AAC
91.67 - MWC
94.05 - MAC
95.99 - CUSA
Caveats:
-Oregon State and Washington State previously played 9 P5 conference games which would reflect in their older ratings
-These numbers do not include new CUSA members Delaware and Missouri State since they're moving up to FBS in 2025
The following teams did not have 5 year's worth of data:
(4) UConn, Old Dominion, and New Mexico State did not play 2020 due to Covid-19
(3) James Madison (2022-2024)
(2) Jacksonville State (2023-2024)
(1) Kennesaw State (2024)
|
|
| 07-15-2025 11:15 AM |
|
bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,947
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: G6 median massey composite w/ new 2026 lineups
(07-15-2025 07:58 AM)Tiger1983 Wrote: The composite shows Navy and Army with a significant slide from last season. My cursory review indicates those schools accounting for most of the AAC's rating. The reasons for the drop are unclear to me.
https://masseyratings.com/ranks?s=cf&d=20250821
Reversion to their long term averages would be my guess. Maybe they had big senior classes last year, too?
|
|
| 07-15-2025 11:28 AM |
|
goofus
Heisman

Posts: 5,718
Joined: May 2013
Reputation: 304
I Root For: Iowa
Location: chicago suburbs
|
RE: G6 median massey composite w/ new 2026 lineups
Curious who expects Ore St and Wash St to maintain their historical massey ratings now that they have dropped to a G6 level conference?
I am not certain, but my assumption is those 2 will drop to the same level as their new conference mates in the new Pac and their 5-year massey ratings will reflect that in the future.
|
|
| 07-15-2025 11:29 AM |
|
b0ndsj0ns
Legend

Posts: 30,775
Joined: Oct 2009
Reputation: 1639
I Root For: ECU
Location:
|
RE: G6 median massey composite w/ new 2026 lineups
(07-15-2025 10:19 AM)Tiger1983 Wrote: (07-15-2025 09:19 AM)HP-TBDPITL Wrote: (07-15-2025 08:46 AM)b0ndsj0ns Wrote: (07-15-2025 08:02 AM)Tiger1983 Wrote: The composite shows Boise (#27) and Tulane (#29) neck and neck for the CFP G6 slot. The school with a stronger conference would have an advantage.
I don't think the stronger conference is actually any advantage at the G5 level for getting the bid. The only advantage strength of conference brings is if you have multiple top 25 teams in the league. The level of consideration I suspect the committee gives between winning a bunch of games against 75-80 ranked G5 schools vs 100-120 ranked G5 schools is next to zero. Lists of things I think they consider at the G5 level.
1. Did you beat a P4 school?
2. Did you play a really good P4 school close?
3. What's your overall record?
4. Did you happen to beat a ranked G5 school?
Don't think it goes a bit further than that. I think the actual best thing for maximizing the chances of getting the playoff bid for a G5 league would be a top 3 or so that is consistently ranked or close to it and then the rest of the league is pure trash that never beats the top. There's no benefit to being the "SEC of the G5" where everyone in the league is good enough to beat everyone.
Bolded is most important....and equally important is that they play in the CCG.
At the end of the year if a G6 conference has two teams ranked in the Top 25 playing in their conference championship game, the winner is likely to get the bid. The only caveat might be if another conference has someone ranked HIGHER than BOTH of the other conference's teams...then they likely wont drop with a win.
In the past, there was a correlation between earning a NY6/CFP spot and conference strength as measured by Massey Composite. I do not recall the factor, but it was material (although not +1). Correlation does not mean causation, but it is meaningful.
It makes sense because SOS is a consideration for selection and the reader may recall AAC members use to state with confidence a one-loss AAC school had an edge over an undefeated squad from another conference.
The old AAC by the end of the season would have 2-3 teams in the top 25 and usually another 2-3 teams receiving votes. The big key is getting late season and championship game ranked vs ranked matchups.
In basketball the bottom of the league being more respectable than awful matters a lot for getting multiple bids for the league. In football what matters more is there being enough quality at the top, and the bottom being awful doesn't really harm that prospect. The league can't have just exclusively bottom teams, but having 3 top 25 caliber teams and then bad teams that can't ever beat the 3 good teams doesn't hurt you because basically the committee barely cares about the details of the overall strength of G5 leagues.
|
|
| 07-15-2025 11:31 AM |
|
Garden_KC
Heisman

Posts: 5,000
Joined: Jan 2023
Reputation: 142
I Root For: Landscaping
Location:
|
RE: G6 median massey composite w/ new 2026 lineups
(07-15-2025 11:15 AM)SkullyMaroo Wrote: If you take the 5-year average Massey Composite ranking for each school and average it out for the new membership, you'd get the following averages:
74.23 - Pac-12
82.14 - Sun Belt
86.89 - AAC
91.67 - MWC
94.05 - MAC
95.99 - CUSA
Caveats:
-Oregon State and Washington State previously played 9 P5 conference games which would reflect in their older ratings
-These numbers do not include new CUSA members Delaware and Missouri State since they're moving up to FBS in 2025
The following teams did not have 5 year's worth of data:
(4) UConn, Old Dominion, and New Mexico State did not play 2020 due to Covid-19
(3) James Madison (2022-2024)
(2) Jacksonville State (2023-2024)
(1) Kennesaw State (2024)
One thing I will say in favor of CUSA is they'll have an advantage bringing up their numbers from a lower baseline as the FCS call ups ramp up.
Revisit this once we progress through the non-conference schedule.
|
|
| 07-15-2025 11:50 AM |
|
bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,947
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: G6 median massey composite w/ new 2026 lineups
(07-15-2025 11:29 AM)goofus Wrote: Curious who expects Ore St and Wash St to maintain their historical massey ratings now that they have dropped to a G6 level conference?
I am not certain, but my assumption is those 2 will drop to the same level as their new conference mates in the new Pac and their 5-year massey ratings will reflect that in the future.
They weren't particularly good until their last year or 2 in the Pac. No reason to think that they won't continue to have success now that they're at the top of the food chain in the smaller pond instead of the bottom in the bigger pond.
|
|
| 07-15-2025 12:33 PM |
|
Morning MAC
Bench Warmer

Posts: 120
Joined: Jan 2025
Reputation: 12
I Root For: Michigan ASU MAC
Location:
|
RE: G6 median massey composite w/ new 2026 lineups
(07-15-2025 11:31 AM)b0ndsj0ns Wrote: (07-15-2025 10:19 AM)Tiger1983 Wrote: (07-15-2025 09:19 AM)HP-TBDPITL Wrote: (07-15-2025 08:46 AM)b0ndsj0ns Wrote: (07-15-2025 08:02 AM)Tiger1983 Wrote: The composite shows Boise (#27) and Tulane (#29) neck and neck for the CFP G6 slot. The school with a stronger conference would have an advantage.
I don't think the stronger conference is actually any advantage at the G5 level for getting the bid. The only advantage strength of conference brings is if you have multiple top 25 teams in the league. The level of consideration I suspect the committee gives between winning a bunch of games against 75-80 ranked G5 schools vs 100-120 ranked G5 schools is next to zero. Lists of things I think they consider at the G5 level.
1. Did you beat a P4 school?
2. Did you play a really good P4 school close?
3. What's your overall record?
4. Did you happen to beat a ranked G5 school?
Don't think it goes a bit further than that. I think the actual best thing for maximizing the chances of getting the playoff bid for a G5 league would be a top 3 or so that is consistently ranked or close to it and then the rest of the league is pure trash that never beats the top. There's no benefit to being the "SEC of the G5" where everyone in the league is good enough to beat everyone.
Bolded is most important....and equally important is that they play in the CCG.
At the end of the year if a G6 conference has two teams ranked in the Top 25 playing in their conference championship game, the winner is likely to get the bid. The only caveat might be if another conference has someone ranked HIGHER than BOTH of the other conference's teams...then they likely wont drop with a win.
In the past, there was a correlation between earning a NY6/CFP spot and conference strength as measured by Massey Composite. I do not recall the factor, but it was material (although not +1). Correlation does not mean causation, but it is meaningful.
It makes sense because SOS is a consideration for selection and the reader may recall AAC members use to state with confidence a one-loss AAC school had an edge over an undefeated squad from another conference.
The old AAC by the end of the season would have 2-3 teams in the top 25 and usually another 2-3 teams receiving votes. The big key is getting late season and championship game ranked vs ranked matchups.
In basketball the bottom of the league being more respectable than awful matters a lot for getting multiple bids for the league. In football what matters more is there being enough quality at the top, and the bottom being awful doesn't really harm that prospect. The league can't have just exclusively bottom teams, but having 3 top 25 caliber teams and then bad teams that can't ever beat the 3 good teams doesn't hurt you because basically the committee barely cares about the details of the overall strength of G5 leagues.
I do think the older 'brand' programs in the AAC are better positioned to get in the CFP than PAC schools, for the reasons b0ndsj0ns states.
In the short term, ECU, Temple, USF, Memphis, Tulane, and Tulsa are in a good spot both access and money wise.
But in 5 years, if 2 or 3 of them leave, I think those stranded will be on the losing end of both access and money.
|
|
| 07-15-2025 12:38 PM |
|
SkullyMaroo
Moderator

Posts: 12,883
Joined: Mar 2009
Reputation: 848
I Root For: South Alabama
Location: Mobile
|
RE: G6 median massey composite w/ new 2026 lineups
(07-15-2025 11:50 AM)Garden_KC Wrote: (07-15-2025 11:15 AM)SkullyMaroo Wrote: If you take the 5-year average Massey Composite ranking for each school and average it out for the new membership, you'd get the following averages:
74.23 - Pac-12
82.14 - Sun Belt
86.89 - AAC
91.67 - MWC
94.05 - MAC
95.99 - CUSA
Caveats:
-Oregon State and Washington State previously played 9 P5 conference games which would reflect in their older ratings
-These numbers do not include new CUSA members Delaware and Missouri State since they're moving up to FBS in 2025
The following teams did not have 5 year's worth of data:
(4) UConn, Old Dominion, and New Mexico State did not play 2020 due to Covid-19
(3) James Madison (2022-2024)
(2) Jacksonville State (2023-2024)
(1) Kennesaw State (2024)
One thing I will say in favor of CUSA is they'll have an advantage bringing up their numbers from a lower baseline as the FCS call ups ramp up.
Revisit this once we progress through the non-conference schedule.
CUSA gained just by losing UTEP.
|
|
| 07-15-2025 12:44 PM |
|