Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
Author Message
GoBuckeyes1047 Online
All American
*

Posts: 3,075
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation: 302
I Root For: Ohio State
Location:
Post: #81
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-19-2025 01:52 PM)OdinFrigg Wrote:  Just wait, at large picks will eventually turn into wild card games.

2/2/2/2/1+5 or 7 with 3-5 or 4-7 at-large play-in games while preserving CCGs if you guarantee the top 2 champs a bye and next 2 champs a home game.
(This post was last modified: 06-19-2025 03:47 PM by GoBuckeyes1047.)
06-19-2025 03:46 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
tf8693 Offline
All American
*

Posts: 2,902
Joined: Jul 2023
Reputation: 333
I Root For: Notre Dame
Location:
Post: #82
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-19-2025 03:46 PM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  
(06-19-2025 01:52 PM)OdinFrigg Wrote:  Just wait, at large picks will eventually turn into wild card games.

2/2/2/2/1+5 or 7 with 3-5 or 4-7 at-large play-in games while preserving CCGs if you guarantee the top 2 champs a bye and next 2 champs a home game.


Not sure how anyone gets a first round bye in a 16-team field. I'll leave that aside for now and show you what this format would have looked like last year if it had been in effect (final CFP rankings in parentheses):

AQ bids

B1G: Oregon (1), Penn State (4)
SEC: Georgia (2), Texas (3)
ACC: SMU (10), Clemson (16) (guaranteed home game)
Big XII: Arizona State (12) (guaranteed home game), BYU (17)
G5: Boise State (9)

Wild cards (Note: to avoid certain all-conference matchups, I adjusted in certain cases):

Colorado (23) at Notre Dame (5)
Army (22) at Ohio State (6)
Syracuse (21) at Tennessee (7)
Missouri (19) at Indiana (8)
Illinois (20) at Alabama (11)
South Carolina (15) at Miami (13)
Iowa State (18) at Ole Miss (14)

If you go with a 14-team field with 5 at-large bids, then:

Missouri (19) at Notre Dame (5)
South Carolina (15) at Ohio State (6)
Iowa State (18) at Tennessee (7)
Ole Miss (14) at Indiana (8)
Miami (13) at Alabama (11)

SEC fans might enjoy seeing those games, but I'm struggling to find a planet on which this would be considered a fair format. Then throw in the fact that only Notre Dame and Ohio State would be guaranteed to host first-round playoff matchups with a win.
(This post was last modified: 06-19-2025 07:12 PM by tf8693.)
06-19-2025 07:11 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
GoBuckeyes1047 Online
All American
*

Posts: 3,075
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation: 302
I Root For: Ohio State
Location:
Post: #83
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-19-2025 07:11 PM)tf8693 Wrote:  
(06-19-2025 03:46 PM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  
(06-19-2025 01:52 PM)OdinFrigg Wrote:  Just wait, at large picks will eventually turn into wild card games.

2/2/2/2/1+5 or 7 with 3-5 or 4-7 at-large play-in games while preserving CCGs if you guarantee the top 2 champs a bye and next 2 champs a home game.

Not sure how anyone gets a first round bye in a 16-team field. I'll leave that aside for now and show you what this format would have looked like last year if it had been in effect (final CFP rankings in parentheses):

AQ bids

B1G: Oregon (1), Penn State (4)
SEC: Georgia (2), Texas (3)
ACC: SMU (10), Clemson (16) (guaranteed home game)
Big XII: Arizona State (12) (guaranteed home game), BYU (17)
G5: Boise State (9)

Wild cards (Note: to avoid certain all-conference matchups, I adjusted in certain cases):

Colorado (23) at Notre Dame (5)
Army (22) at Ohio State (6)
Syracuse (21) at Tennessee (7)
Missouri (19) at Indiana (8)
Illinois (20) at Alabama (11)
South Carolina (15) at Miami (13)
Iowa State (18) at Ole Miss (14)

If you go with a 14-team field with 5 at-large bids, then:

Missouri (19) at Notre Dame (5)
South Carolina (15) at Ohio State (6)
Iowa State (18) at Tennessee (7)
Ole Miss (14) at Indiana (8)
Miami (13) at Alabama (11)

SEC fans might enjoy seeing those games, but I'm struggling to find a planet on which this would be considered a fair format. Then throw in the fact that only Notre Dame and Ohio State would be guaranteed to host first-round playoff matchups with a win.

I suspect ND keeps their offer of just being in the top 14-16 and they're in. Also worth noting that the rankings and matchups likely be based on the rankings prior to the final ranking as the play-in games would probably be played the same week as CCGs though they could be played after CCGs, but announced prior to them.

Knowing this, Army would've been playing in a CCG so they probably aren't playing in an at-large play-in, and Iowa St. regardless of result is in the CFP because they're the 2nd team in the B12 and played in their CCG, but easy enough to swap BYU in for Iowa St.. Also, Boise St. and Arizona St. could get the 1st round home game, not Clemson, because they're the next 2 champs in the CFP Rankings.

With the 16 team with 2 byes is the 14 team CFP with 2 play-in games instead of the traditional 16 team bracket. I will say I do like the look of the 14 team CFP model for the at-large games knowing SC plays Tennessee (I wouldn't avoid conference matchups) and BYU plays OSU, maybe Mizzou playing ND depending on if ND participates.

As to your concerns about Tennessee and Indiana not hosting if they win their WCG, they do get an easier opponent to play (well Tennessee did) despite playing on the road like Texas and Penn St. got this year in the QFs in their bowls. It also doesn't impact the overall bracket as you can still get the top 8 ranked teams in the QFs with no wonky results like we had with the 12 team without straight seeding. I'm okay if they do straight seeding, but I think the P4 conferences would prefer their CCGs to have some stakes instead of none outside just winning your conference.
(This post was last modified: 06-20-2025 07:22 AM by GoBuckeyes1047.)
06-20-2025 07:21 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
random asian guy Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,215
Joined: Aug 2014
Reputation: 652
I Root For: VT, Georgetown
Location: Suburban Hell
Post: #84
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-19-2025 01:10 PM)random asian guy Wrote:  I think many people vastly underestimate the B1G's desire for the AQ model. The number of bids is just one factor; the most important thing is money.

The AQ model would introduce play-in games and more SEC-B1G challenge games, generating additional revenue. I don't know whether it’s a coincidence, but Joel Klatt of Fox and Josh Pate of CBS strongly support the AQ model.

For the SEC, both the AQ model (more money) and the 5-11 model (greater representation if SOS becomes more critical) are probably acceptable options. But for the B1G, the choice is between more money (AQ model) or less money (5-11 model).

Thus, it would be naive to assume the B1G will easily give up on the AQ model, even if the SEC and other conferences agree on nine conference games or ten P4 games. To me, the 9 conference game argument seems like an excuse to avoid endorsing the 5-11 model and that's probably why this CFP issue remains unresolved.

Personally, I believe the B1G’s best offer to the SEC would be a 4-4-2-2-1-3 model with modified ranking criteria emphasizing SOS for at-large selections. Under this model, the SEC can still aim for six bids (with four guaranteed bids). However, the SEC doesn't appears eager to push the AQ model probably because of public backlash. Then Petitti may have to give something to the M2 to gain their support and present the AQ model as a "P4 consensus".

That’s a tall task.

From Dellenger:

Yes, the SEC’s decision may ease and make more productive conversations with Big Ten officials over a future format, but it doesn’t mean Big Ten leaders will jump to agree with the proposed “5+11” format that the SEC, ACC and Big 12 have openly supported.

In fact, on Thursday, one Big Ten official told Yahoo Sports that while the SEC’s move is a positive step, the league has more concerns, most notably related to the CFP selection committee’s criteria of choosing what would be 11 at-large playoff teams.


https://sports.yahoo.com/college-footbal...12154.html

I told you that it’s not about 9 games. It’s about money.

It doesn’t appear Petitti’s 24-28 team playoff idea is getting much traction according to Dellenger’s article. Instead the SEC responded by moving to 9 games (only after the committee “enhanced” the selection criteria).

Now what? The ball is in Petitti’s court. Is he going to fold and accept the 5+X model?

What’s his next move?
08-22-2025 06:05 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,977
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13520
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #85
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(08-22-2025 06:05 PM)random asian guy Wrote:  
(06-19-2025 01:10 PM)random asian guy Wrote:  I think many people vastly underestimate the B1G's desire for the AQ model. The number of bids is just one factor; the most important thing is money.

The AQ model would introduce play-in games and more SEC-B1G challenge games, generating additional revenue. I don't know whether it’s a coincidence, but Joel Klatt of Fox and Josh Pate of CBS strongly support the AQ model.

For the SEC, both the AQ model (more money) and the 5-11 model (greater representation if SOS becomes more critical) are probably acceptable options. But for the B1G, the choice is between more money (AQ model) or less money (5-11 model).

Thus, it would be naive to assume the B1G will easily give up on the AQ model, even if the SEC and other conferences agree on nine conference games or ten P4 games. To me, the 9 conference game argument seems like an excuse to avoid endorsing the 5-11 model and that's probably why this CFP issue remains unresolved.

Personally, I believe the B1G’s best offer to the SEC would be a 4-4-2-2-1-3 model with modified ranking criteria emphasizing SOS for at-large selections. Under this model, the SEC can still aim for six bids (with four guaranteed bids). However, the SEC doesn't appears eager to push the AQ model probably because of public backlash. Then Petitti may have to give something to the M2 to gain their support and present the AQ model as a "P4 consensus".

That’s a tall task.

From Dellenger:

Yes, the SEC’s decision may ease and make more productive conversations with Big Ten officials over a future format, but it doesn’t mean Big Ten leaders will jump to agree with the proposed “5+11” format that the SEC, ACC and Big 12 have openly supported.

In fact, on Thursday, one Big Ten official told Yahoo Sports that while the SEC’s move is a positive step, the league has more concerns, most notably related to the CFP selection committee’s criteria of choosing what would be 11 at-large playoff teams.


https://sports.yahoo.com/college-footbal...12154.html

I told you that it’s not about 9 games. It’s about money.

It doesn’t appear Petitti’s 24-28 team playoff idea is getting much traction according to Dellenger’s article. Instead the SEC responded by moving to 9 games (only after the committee “enhanced” the selection criteria).

Now what? The ball is in Petitti’s court. Is he going to fold and accept the 5+X model?

What’s his next move?

The SEC needs to quit any communication or association with the Big Ten until those guys actually want to negotiate. We'll be fine without them. We will especially be fine without them if there is cooperation between the ACC and Big 12. We simply need to move ahead with the 5 + 11 and they can either participate or take their marbles and go home. Those idiots think CFB will be run by them. Sankey made a good faith gesture, now they want to revisit the agreement which led to the SEC's 9 game schedule compliance to tinker with Strength of Schedule emphasis? To hell with them. 3 of the 4 conferences can hold a viable championship, at least far more viable than the conference that jobbed the selection committee last year with the Michigan President chairing it when 2 years prior the violations of his team, involving the whole staff, including the stealing of signs, attendance at games with filming prohibited by the NCAA rules, and inappropriate payments and favors were all used to win the championship and should have resulted in forfeitures, the abnegation of the championship, and harsh penalties. The NCAA won't do that because the Big Ten is their best shot at survival. It reveals deeper issues within the upper escehon of college football and the desperation to assert dominance over protcols by the Big Ten. Lock them out and run a championship between the Big 12, ACC and SEC encompassing the area they are desperately trying to enter, and lets enjoy our own culture and doing our own thing. The SEC has given them what they wanted from us, and now that's not enough. Cleary they are the problem. Just tell them bye! They don't contribute to baseball, we don't have hockey, and their basketball hasn't done anything in years. We can run our own tournament too! 07-coffee3
08-22-2025 06:44 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
RUScarlets Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 9,715
Joined: May 2012
Reputation: 313
I Root For: Rutgers
Location:
Post: #86
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
The top two CCs directly into the NYD QFs with the two play-ins Army Navy weekend will probably need some buy-in from the M2 as well. Mainly, M2 CCs (or 3rd and 4th highest CCs) guaranteed a home game.
08-22-2025 06:54 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
cubucks Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,595
Joined: Apr 2015
Reputation: 641
I Root For: tOSU/UNL/Ohio
Location: Athens, Ohio
Post: #87
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(08-22-2025 06:44 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(08-22-2025 06:05 PM)random asian guy Wrote:  
(06-19-2025 01:10 PM)random asian guy Wrote:  I think many people vastly underestimate the B1G's desire for the AQ model. The number of bids is just one factor; the most important thing is money.

The AQ model would introduce play-in games and more SEC-B1G challenge games, generating additional revenue. I don't know whether it’s a coincidence, but Joel Klatt of Fox and Josh Pate of CBS strongly support the AQ model.

For the SEC, both the AQ model (more money) and the 5-11 model (greater representation if SOS becomes more critical) are probably acceptable options. But for the B1G, the choice is between more money (AQ model) or less money (5-11 model).

Thus, it would be naive to assume the B1G will easily give up on the AQ model, even if the SEC and other conferences agree on nine conference games or ten P4 games. To me, the 9 conference game argument seems like an excuse to avoid endorsing the 5-11 model and that's probably why this CFP issue remains unresolved.

Personally, I believe the B1G’s best offer to the SEC would be a 4-4-2-2-1-3 model with modified ranking criteria emphasizing SOS for at-large selections. Under this model, the SEC can still aim for six bids (with four guaranteed bids). However, the SEC doesn't appears eager to push the AQ model probably because of public backlash. Then Petitti may have to give something to the M2 to gain their support and present the AQ model as a "P4 consensus".

That’s a tall task.

From Dellenger:

Yes, the SEC’s decision may ease and make more productive conversations with Big Ten officials over a future format, but it doesn’t mean Big Ten leaders will jump to agree with the proposed “5+11” format that the SEC, ACC and Big 12 have openly supported.

In fact, on Thursday, one Big Ten official told Yahoo Sports that while the SEC’s move is a positive step, the league has more concerns, most notably related to the CFP selection committee’s criteria of choosing what would be 11 at-large playoff teams.


https://sports.yahoo.com/college-footbal...12154.html

I told you that it’s not about 9 games. It’s about money.

It doesn’t appear Petitti’s 24-28 team playoff idea is getting much traction according to Dellenger’s article. Instead the SEC responded by moving to 9 games (only after the committee “enhanced” the selection criteria).

Now what? The ball is in Petitti’s court. Is he going to fold and accept the 5+X model?

What’s his next move?

The SEC needs to quit any communication or association with the Big Ten until those guys actually want to negotiate. We'll be fine without them. We will especially be fine without them if there is cooperation between the ACC and Big 12. We simply need to move ahead with the 5 + 11 and they can either participate or take their marbles and go home. Those idiots think CFB will be run by them. Sankey made a good faith gesture, now they want to revisit the agreement which led to the SEC's 9 game schedule compliance to tinker with Strength of Schedule emphasis? To hell with them. 3 of the 4 conferences can hold a viable championship, at least far more viable than the conference that jobbed the selection committee last year with the Michigan President chairing it when 2 years prior the violations of his team, involving the whole staff, including the stealing of signs, attendance at games with filming prohibited by the NCAA rules, and inappropriate payments and favors were all used to win the championship and should have resulted in forfeitures, the abnegation of the championship, and harsh penalties. The NCAA won't do that because the Big Ten is their best shot at survival. It reveals deeper issues within the upper escehon of college football and the desperation to assert dominance over protcols by the Big Ten. Lock them out and run a championship between the Big 12, ACC and SEC encompassing the area they are desperately trying to enter, and lets enjoy our own culture and doing our own thing. The SEC has given them what they wanted from us, and now that's not enough. Cleary they are the problem. Just tell them bye! They don't contribute to baseball, we don't have hockey, and their basketball hasn't done anything in years. We can run our own tournament too! 07-coffee3

So now you want to form an alliance with the ACC and BIG XII? Wow!

"Inappropriate payments" statement coming from an Auburn and SEC Fan? Please!

Don't worry JR, as soon as the 5+11 doesn't work out for the SEC, that New York Attorney of yours will be on his soapbox demanding change.
08-22-2025 07:33 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,977
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13520
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #88
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(08-22-2025 07:33 PM)cubucks Wrote:  
(08-22-2025 06:44 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(08-22-2025 06:05 PM)random asian guy Wrote:  
(06-19-2025 01:10 PM)random asian guy Wrote:  I think many people vastly underestimate the B1G's desire for the AQ model. The number of bids is just one factor; the most important thing is money.

The AQ model would introduce play-in games and more SEC-B1G challenge games, generating additional revenue. I don't know whether it’s a coincidence, but Joel Klatt of Fox and Josh Pate of CBS strongly support the AQ model.

For the SEC, both the AQ model (more money) and the 5-11 model (greater representation if SOS becomes more critical) are probably acceptable options. But for the B1G, the choice is between more money (AQ model) or less money (5-11 model).

Thus, it would be naive to assume the B1G will easily give up on the AQ model, even if the SEC and other conferences agree on nine conference games or ten P4 games. To me, the 9 conference game argument seems like an excuse to avoid endorsing the 5-11 model and that's probably why this CFP issue remains unresolved.

Personally, I believe the B1G’s best offer to the SEC would be a 4-4-2-2-1-3 model with modified ranking criteria emphasizing SOS for at-large selections. Under this model, the SEC can still aim for six bids (with four guaranteed bids). However, the SEC doesn't appears eager to push the AQ model probably because of public backlash. Then Petitti may have to give something to the M2 to gain their support and present the AQ model as a "P4 consensus".

That’s a tall task.

From Dellenger:

Yes, the SEC’s decision may ease and make more productive conversations with Big Ten officials over a future format, but it doesn’t mean Big Ten leaders will jump to agree with the proposed “5+11” format that the SEC, ACC and Big 12 have openly supported.

In fact, on Thursday, one Big Ten official told Yahoo Sports that while the SEC’s move is a positive step, the league has more concerns, most notably related to the CFP selection committee’s criteria of choosing what would be 11 at-large playoff teams.


https://sports.yahoo.com/college-footbal...12154.html

I told you that it’s not about 9 games. It’s about money.

It doesn’t appear Petitti’s 24-28 team playoff idea is getting much traction according to Dellenger’s article. Instead the SEC responded by moving to 9 games (only after the committee “enhanced” the selection criteria).

Now what? The ball is in Petitti’s court. Is he going to fold and accept the 5+X model?

What’s his next move?

The SEC needs to quit any communication or association with the Big Ten until those guys actually want to negotiate. We'll be fine without them. We will especially be fine without them if there is cooperation between the ACC and Big 12. We simply need to move ahead with the 5 + 11 and they can either participate or take their marbles and go home. Those idiots think CFB will be run by them. Sankey made a good faith gesture, now they want to revisit the agreement which led to the SEC's 9 game schedule compliance to tinker with Strength of Schedule emphasis? To hell with them. 3 of the 4 conferences can hold a viable championship, at least far more viable than the conference that jobbed the selection committee last year with the Michigan President chairing it when 2 years prior the violations of his team, involving the whole staff, including the stealing of signs, attendance at games with filming prohibited by the NCAA rules, and inappropriate payments and favors were all used to win the championship and should have resulted in forfeitures, the abnegation of the championship, and harsh penalties. The NCAA won't do that because the Big Ten is their best shot at survival. It reveals deeper issues within the upper escehon of college football and the desperation to assert dominance over protcols by the Big Ten. Lock them out and run a championship between the Big 12, ACC and SEC encompassing the area they are desperately trying to enter, and lets enjoy our own culture and doing our own thing. The SEC has given them what they wanted from us, and now that's not enough. Cleary they are the problem. Just tell them bye! They don't contribute to baseball, we don't have hockey, and their basketball hasn't done anything in years. We can run our own tournament too! 07-coffee3

So now you want to form an alliance with the ACC and BIG XII? Wow!

"Inappropriate payments" statement coming from an Auburn and SEC Fan? Please!

Don't worry JR, as soon as the 5+11 doesn't work out for the SEC, that New York Attorney of yours will be on his soapbox demanding change.

Auburn never did anything as bad as what Michigan has been found guilty of, and SMU didn't seek to gain unfair advantages in a contest, just for players. So stow it!

I followed up on violations in the Southeast in about a 3 state area that went partially into two others and did it throughout the 80's and a little bit more. We had people who took entrance tests for players, paid players, bought cars for players, and one that gave a major player's dad a $40,000 a year job, but none of them sought to gain an advantage over the schools they would be playing by attempting to steal signs with the filming of signals from the sideline while posing as fans in the stand from the other side. That's next level! And your Buckeyes likely suffered at their hands for that as well. Harbaugh has proven to be a skank.

And during my time in following up every program that recruited that area, including your Buckeyes and a few other Big Ten schools along with A&M, Nebraska, and other SWC schools and every school in the SEC save Vanderbilt and every school in the ACC save Georgia Tech who was then coached by Bill Curry were guilty of something, including Auburn. Schools were notified and if they dropped recruitment they didn't get reported. Two were majorly burned by things I found out, one in the SEC and one in the SWC. So, I know violations. Harbaugh's total corruption of staff constitutes lack of institutional control and is right there with what SMU did at the height of their scandal which resulted in the Death penalty. So the old payola isn't even in the neighborhood of what Michigan did.
08-22-2025 07:51 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
The Beaver Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,341
Joined: Apr 2024
Reputation: 955
I Root For: Penn State
Location:
Post: #89
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(08-22-2025 07:51 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(08-22-2025 07:33 PM)cubucks Wrote:  
(08-22-2025 06:44 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(08-22-2025 06:05 PM)random asian guy Wrote:  
(06-19-2025 01:10 PM)random asian guy Wrote:  I think many people vastly underestimate the B1G's desire for the AQ model. The number of bids is just one factor; the most important thing is money.

The AQ model would introduce play-in games and more SEC-B1G challenge games, generating additional revenue. I don't know whether it’s a coincidence, but Joel Klatt of Fox and Josh Pate of CBS strongly support the AQ model.

For the SEC, both the AQ model (more money) and the 5-11 model (greater representation if SOS becomes more critical) are probably acceptable options. But for the B1G, the choice is between more money (AQ model) or less money (5-11 model).

Thus, it would be naive to assume the B1G will easily give up on the AQ model, even if the SEC and other conferences agree on nine conference games or ten P4 games. To me, the 9 conference game argument seems like an excuse to avoid endorsing the 5-11 model and that's probably why this CFP issue remains unresolved.

Personally, I believe the B1G’s best offer to the SEC would be a 4-4-2-2-1-3 model with modified ranking criteria emphasizing SOS for at-large selections. Under this model, the SEC can still aim for six bids (with four guaranteed bids). However, the SEC doesn't appears eager to push the AQ model probably because of public backlash. Then Petitti may have to give something to the M2 to gain their support and present the AQ model as a "P4 consensus".

That’s a tall task.

From Dellenger:

Yes, the SEC’s decision may ease and make more productive conversations with Big Ten officials over a future format, but it doesn’t mean Big Ten leaders will jump to agree with the proposed “5+11” format that the SEC, ACC and Big 12 have openly supported.

In fact, on Thursday, one Big Ten official told Yahoo Sports that while the SEC’s move is a positive step, the league has more concerns, most notably related to the CFP selection committee’s criteria of choosing what would be 11 at-large playoff teams.


https://sports.yahoo.com/college-footbal...12154.html

I told you that it’s not about 9 games. It’s about money.

It doesn’t appear Petitti’s 24-28 team playoff idea is getting much traction according to Dellenger’s article. Instead the SEC responded by moving to 9 games (only after the committee “enhanced” the selection criteria).

Now what? The ball is in Petitti’s court. Is he going to fold and accept the 5+X model?

What’s his next move?

The SEC needs to quit any communication or association with the Big Ten until those guys actually want to negotiate. We'll be fine without them. We will especially be fine without them if there is cooperation between the ACC and Big 12. We simply need to move ahead with the 5 + 11 and they can either participate or take their marbles and go home. Those idiots think CFB will be run by them. Sankey made a good faith gesture, now they want to revisit the agreement which led to the SEC's 9 game schedule compliance to tinker with Strength of Schedule emphasis? To hell with them. 3 of the 4 conferences can hold a viable championship, at least far more viable than the conference that jobbed the selection committee last year with the Michigan President chairing it when 2 years prior the violations of his team, involving the whole staff, including the stealing of signs, attendance at games with filming prohibited by the NCAA rules, and inappropriate payments and favors were all used to win the championship and should have resulted in forfeitures, the abnegation of the championship, and harsh penalties. The NCAA won't do that because the Big Ten is their best shot at survival. It reveals deeper issues within the upper escehon of college football and the desperation to assert dominance over protcols by the Big Ten. Lock them out and run a championship between the Big 12, ACC and SEC encompassing the area they are desperately trying to enter, and lets enjoy our own culture and doing our own thing. The SEC has given them what they wanted from us, and now that's not enough. Cleary they are the problem. Just tell them bye! They don't contribute to baseball, we don't have hockey, and their basketball hasn't done anything in years. We can run our own tournament too! 07-coffee3

So now you want to form an alliance with the ACC and BIG XII? Wow!

"Inappropriate payments" statement coming from an Auburn and SEC Fan? Please!

Don't worry JR, as soon as the 5+11 doesn't work out for the SEC, that New York Attorney of yours will be on his soapbox demanding change.

Auburn never did anything as bad as what Michigan has been found guilty of, and SMU didn't seek to gain unfair advantages in a contest, just for players. So stow it!

I followed up on violations in the Southeast in about a 3 state area that went partially into two others and did it throughout the 80's and a little bit more. We had people who took entrance tests for players, paid players, bought cars for players, and one that gave a major player's dad a $40,000 a year job, but none of them sought to gain an advantage over the schools they would be playing by attempting to steal signs with the filming of signals from the sideline while posing as fans in the stand from the other side. That's next level! And your Buckeyes likely suffered at their hands for that as well. Harbaugh has proven to be a skank.

And during my time in following up every program that recruited that area, including your Buckeyes and a few other Big Ten schools along with A&M, Nebraska, and other SWC schools and every school in the SEC save Vanderbilt and every school in the ACC save Georgia Tech who was then coached by Bill Curry were guilty of something, including Auburn. Schools were notified and if they dropped recruitment they didn't get reported. Two were majorly burned by things I found out, one in the SEC and one in the SWC. So, I know violations. Harbaugh's total corruption of staff constitutes lack of institutional control and is right there with what SMU did at the height of their scandal which resulted in the Death penalty. So the old payola isn't even in the neighborhood of what Michigan did.
SMU wasn't given the Death Penalty over the specifics of what they were caught for, its for continuing to do it after being caught only a year or two before.

For what its worth, Stallions actions were largely ineffectual, much more so than recruiting bribes, I don't think Michigan won a single game due to sign stealing, tons of teams won games on the back of unfair recruiting, especially in the SEC but esppppeccialy in the SWC.
08-22-2025 08:11 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
random asian guy Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,215
Joined: Aug 2014
Reputation: 652
I Root For: VT, Georgetown
Location: Suburban Hell
Post: #90
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-15-2025 09:52 PM)random asian guy Wrote:  It’s obvious that the Big Ten is the one that really pushed for 4-4-2-2-1 CFP model. But, Petitti has remained radio silent, even as reporters and pundits have asked him to speak out since Greg Sankey’s SEC spring meeting.

I’m not sure if Petitti will start speaking publicly to sway opinion. He seems to prefer working behind the scenes, possibly using pro-Big Ten media (Joel Klatt?) to communicate.

i do expect Petitti will try to persuade the ACC and/or Big 12. If one or both of the M2 conferences endorse an AQ model and the SEC comes around, we would see a 4-4-x-x model. Joel Klatt has already floated a 4-4-2.5-2.5 idea on his show, which might signal the Big Ten’s willingness to offer an additional AQ to the M2 conferences.

I also suspect the ACC might be more receptive than the Big 12. Jim Phillips previously mentioned a potential play-in game. The problem is , during the ACC spring meetingg, many in the ACC pushed for three AQ spots, which may be too much for the SEC to accept.

So I’m very curious about how Petitti will solve this.

What do you think?

Remember I was questioning Tony Petitti’s next move after your 4-4-2-2-X plans got stalled. He wanted a format that would put 8 Big Ten teams in the mix for the playoff.

I thought he would propose something palatable to the ACC/B12, but I didn’t know what his move would be.

Seventeen months later, we got this monstrosity of a 24-team playoff format. When he floated this 24-28 team playoff idea, everyone scoffed at it. But football coaches started to endorse that idea. ADs, too. The ACC and the B12 quickly changed their minds. The SEC coaches and ADs pressured.

ESPN didn’t want this expansion, but they caved in. Now those idiots on Twitter blame ESPN for the expansion as if the evil ESPN singlehandedly expanded it. It’s all Tony and the B10’s masterpiece.

Well done, Big Ten. You got what you want.
11-09-2026 07:39 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.