(07-07-2026 11:11 AM)sigke Wrote: (07-05-2026 07:04 PM)solohawks Wrote: (07-05-2026 09:49 AM)Sitting bull Wrote: (07-02-2026 11:13 AM)solohawks Wrote: (07-02-2026 10:14 AM)JonP Wrote: This has always puzzled me. Maybe the votes to add schools were closer than I might think? I always assumed they were near-unanimous, though I believe additions only require a 3/4 majority.
W&M, UR and Villanova would have needed just one more school to form a bloc that could sway all CAAF membership decisions. It's strange that they didn't.
Richmond and Villanova had no way of preventing Monmouth, Hampton, A&T, and Campbell because they were added as CAA all sports members and thus automatically received an invite to CAAFC
They could have voted against Bryant but the AEast bloc wants to make sure its members are taken care of so that vote was probably a gentleman's agreement to keep peace
My gut is Richmond has been looking for a way out of CAA football for awhile. They strongly considered the Patriot League when the CAA took over from the A10 but decided/got pressured to stay with their long time FCS rivals. I believe there used to be a clip out there with a CAA chant at a Richmond football game when this original debate was going on which is quite funny considering the history of Richmond and the CAA
https://www.mcall.com/2005/03/05/richmon...ll-league/
When JMU and Delaware left and the W&M game could be continued non conference it really wasn't a surprise to me that Richmond left. Then when Richmond actually pulled the trigger, it made complete since for their two biggest remaining rivals to leave to form a round robin league again with like-minded schools and also guaranteeing the Richmond - W&M game end the season. Patriot League football best captures what the old Yankee/A10/CAA football had for the newly added trio. Its no where near the same but it's as close as you can get
Now the Patriot League has more former Yankee conference members than the CAAFC
I think you have one thing above backwards. I believe it was Richmond that announced a move to the PL before Delaware later announced they were moving to CUSA. It was the Delaware move, not Richmond, that motivated W&M and Villanova to move in my view.
Delaware announced November 2023
https://bluehens.com/news/2023/11/28/del...ull-member
Richmond announced May 2024
https://patriotleague.org/news/2024/5/14...tball.aspx
W&M announced April 2025
https://patriotleague.org/news/2025/4/25...tball.aspx
Villanova announced June 2025
https://patriotleague.org/news/2025/6/5/...-2026.aspx
Delaware leaving so closely after JMU triggered Richmond
Richmond leaving triggered W&M which then made it a no brainer for Villanova
Not to mention JMU leaving was the last straw that triggered Delaware, while ODU leaving obviously trigged JMU too.
Yep
Richmond tanking the SoCon merger forced the CAA to look north
Ga State was always just a temporary add that was a token compromise to appease UNCW's desire for a southern partner
ODU starting football and then going FBS so quickly started the gradual dissolution of the post ECU/Richmond setup that saw it rise to it's greatest success
ODU wanted to move to FBS and they wanted JMU and Delaware to move too but those two were not interested
https://jmusportsblog.com/?p=5580
VCU wasn't going to stay without ODU either and immediately jumped to the A10 skipping the traditional lame duck year. GMU did the same a year later... Both did so with short notice to avoid the CAA auto bid ban
JMU and Delaware didn't want to abandon FCS quite yet but didn't want the CAAFC to become an overblown monstrosity so the original plan appears to have been Elon and Stony Brook for all sports with Albany football only and non football Charleston and I believe UNCG.
That would have given CAAFC and CAA proper 12 members each
Maine, UNH, URI, Albany, Stony Brook, Villanova
Delaware, Towson, Richmond, JMU, W&M, Elon
Northeastern, Hofstra, Stony Brook, Drexel, Delaware, Towson
JMU, W&M, Elon, UNCG, UNCW, Charleston
That would have worked great. But Hofstra threw a hissy fit about Stony Brook joining for all sports and thus they only got a football only invite instead of being a two division 12 team conference the CAA proper was a nonsensical, unsustainable 10 team round robin conference from Boston to Charleston.
The 10 team set up didn't work and JMU wasn't happy so they ended up leaving anyway, which led to everything we previously discussed about Delaware, Richmond, W&M Football, and Villanova all finding more appropriate homes as the neighborhood changed too much