Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
Villanova Football to the Patriot League
Author Message
The Beaver Online
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,351
Joined: Apr 2024
Reputation: 958
I Root For: Penn State
Location:
Post: #161
RE: Villanova Football to the Patriot League
(05-09-2026 05:55 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  
(05-08-2026 10:56 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(05-08-2026 03:14 PM)solohawks Wrote:  
(05-08-2026 02:31 PM)The Cutter of Bish Wrote:  
(05-08-2026 02:13 PM)solohawks Wrote:  That was a low cost lateral move to help Richmond play more like minded schools followed by it's two top FCS rivals who didn't want to get left behind

I struggle with the context of that "lateral" claim with the move. Time will tell if Patriot rivals or overtakes CAAFC in FCS presence. Like, I get how the conference affiliation with those schools could be seen as rivaling and surpassing any but the Ivy in the FCS and non-major realm, but, as an athletic conference...that's not yet proven.

I'm squinting to see how leaving W&M and Villanova behind only to get them back together in a different place is really better. Hopefully, it's at the gates.

If you are Richmond, W&M and Villanova its just not that big a deal...at least in my perception

You keep your top two rivals plus
Instead of Towson you are playing Georgetown
Instead of Monmouth you are playing Bucknell, Lehigh and Lafayette
Instead of Stony Brook and Albany you are playing Fordham and Colgate
Instead of Maine, UNH, URI, Bryant and Sacred Heart you are playing Holy Cross

The 3 Out of conference games can be used to play any instate/border state CAA and SoCon teams like VMI and Elon plus maybe Campbell and Hampton

I guess recruiting is a worry, but you can get an at large bid from the Patriot if you win just like you can in the CAA.

Its interesting, I'd argue that starting in New York the CAAF has bigger/better names but below that I'd much rather be associated with the PL schools.

New Hampshire is a name. Colgate has a national title appearance this century and Fordham has Vince Lombardi and the Seven Blocks of Granite. Holy Cross has a 30 for 30 about a two-way playing Heisman finalist Gordie Lockbaum. All three have history on their side.

Idk you’re going to have to explain how Stony Brook, Bryant, and co. are significantly better “names.”
Maybe I am reading his post wrong but I thought UNH was in the CAAF. As to Fordham, Colgate and and Holy Cross, I associate them all with bad football from forty years ago. I'd rather be with the northeastern state schools.
05-09-2026 08:58 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
TUowl06 Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,641
Joined: Oct 2009
Reputation: 130
I Root For: Temple/DePaul/K-State
Location: NEPA & Manhattan, KS
Post: #162
RE: Villanova Football to the Patriot League
I credit Zablenoise on the W&M Board for compiling this data. I updated it to include the 2025 season.

Quick note on Colgate, in addition to their playoff history they also claim two Payton Award Winners (1-AA/FCS Heisman); 1987 Kenny Gamble & 2003 Jamaal Branch.

CAA Members
Albany (26 years): 3 playoff appearances, '19 2R, '23 SF
Bryant (18 years): never made the playoffs
Campbell (18 years): never made the playoffs
Elon (26 years): 4 playoff appearances, never made it past the 1st round
Hampton (30 years): 5 playoff appearances, never made it past the 1st round
Maine (48 years): 8 appearances, '13 2R, '01 QF, '02 QF, '11 QF, '18 SF
Monmouth (32 years): 3 playoff appearances, '19 2R
New Hampshire (48 years): 20 appearances, '04 QF, '05 QF, '06 QF, '08 QF, '09 QF, '10 QF, '11 2R, '12 2R, '13 SF, '14 SF, '16 2R, '17 QF, '22 2R
Rhode Island (48 years): 5 appearances, '81 QF, '84 SF, '85 SF, '24 2R, '25 2R
Stony Brook (26 years): 4 appearances, '11 2R, '12 2R, '17 2R
Towson (39 seasons): 3 appearances, '11 2R, '13 Final

Patriot League Members...And don't forget the PL did not participate in the playoffs from 1986 through the 1996 season. Holy Cross was hurt the most by the ban. Lehigh and Lafayeytte each had a really good team in the late 80s, early 90s.
Bucknell (48 years): never made the playoffs
Colgate (44 years): 11 appearances, '82 QF, '03 Final, '15 QF, '18 QF
Fordham (37 years): 6 appearances, '02 QF, '13 2R, '13 2R, '14 2R
Georgetown (33 years): never made the playoffs
Holy Cross (44 years): 6 appearances, '83 QF, '21 2R, '22 QF
Lafayette (48 years): 5 appearances, never made it past the 1st round
Lehigh (48 years): 13 appearances, '79 Final, '80 SF, '98 QF, '00 QF, '01 QF, '10 2R, '11 2R, '24 2R, '25 2R
Richmond (44 years): 14 appearances, '84 QF, '00 QF, '05 QF, '07 SF, '08 Champs, '09 QF, '14 2R, '15 SF, '16 QF, '22 2R, '23 2R
Villanova (41 years): 17 appearances, '97 QF, '02 SF, '08 QF, '09 Champs, '10 SF, '14 QF, '16 2R, '21 QF, '23 QF, '24 2R, '25 SF
W&M (44 years): 11 appearances, '90 QF, '96 QF, '04 SF, '09 SF, '10 2R, '15 2R, '22 QF
05-09-2026 09:20 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Florida tribe fan Offline
Special Teams
*

Posts: 838
Joined: Oct 2014
Reputation: 37
I Root For: Tribe
Location:
Post: #163
RE: Villanova Football to the Patriot League
Roughly speaking there is FCS football east of the Mississippi and west of the Mississippi. The newly constituted Patriot League is a perfectly fine east of the Mississippi FCS league. Just like in the rump CAA, some schools draw a little and some barely draw. One Patriot League benefit is that all the members play each other annually. This wasn’t the case in the CAA. Others may disagree, but I personally think it’s a benefit that delusions of grandeur are decidedly bounded in the Patriot League. Might make for better stewardship.
05-09-2026 09:41 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
ccd494 Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,784
Joined: Jan 2017
Reputation: 290
I Root For: Maine
Location:
Post: #164
RE: Villanova Football to the Patriot League
I'm not sure that it matters, really at all, what FCS conference you are in once you get above the NEC/Pioneer type level. In any of those conferences, if you win 8+ games you are pretty much guaranteed a playoff berth. No school anywhere in the FCS (outside of maybe the Montanas and the Dakotas) is a big enough draw to put thousands more butts in seats. No team travels particularly well. FCS attendance basically comes down to three factors:

1. How well is your team doing?
2. What's the weather like?
3. Is there an on-campus homecoming type event?

Other than that, whether you are playing Maine or Colgate or Wofford or Southeastern Louisiana is pretty immaterial unless the opponent is your one big rival. The average attendee at an FCS game is there to see their team, and really has no conception whether visiting Towson is 3-6 or 6-3. It's not a national sport in that anyone is tuned into any school but their own.
05-09-2026 10:21 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
ZooMass84 Offline
Special Teams
*

Posts: 715
Joined: Dec 2016
Reputation: 62
I Root For: UMass, Wisconsin
Location: Casino
Post: #165
RE: Villanova Football to the Patriot League
(05-09-2026 09:41 AM)Florida tribe fan Wrote:  Roughly speaking there is FCS football east of the Mississippi and west of the Mississippi. The newly constituted Patriot League is a perfectly fine east of the Mississippi FCS league. Just like in the rump CAA, some schools draw a little and some barely draw. One Patriot League benefit is that all the members play each other annually. This wasn’t the case in the CAA. Others may disagree, but I personally think it’s a benefit that delusions of grandeur are decidedly bounded in the Patriot League. Might make for better stewardship.
There is an FCS/FBS hybrid football school in Western Mass, which is east of the Mississippi.............it's called UMass03-lmfao03-lmfao03-lmfao
05-09-2026 10:22 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
The Cutter of Bish Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 8,837
Joined: Mar 2013
Reputation: 364
I Root For: the little guy
Location:
Post: #166
RE: Villanova Football to the Patriot League
The moves could have been made years ago, though; that FOIA into CAA/CAAFC about Patriot approaching these three (and potentially UNH) to join from what feels like a forever ago. Nothing has really changed in the respective conferences since then beyond the losses of James Madison and Delaware. Or, the additions of Monmouth, A&T, Hampton, and Bryant. So, Richmond, why did you start this?

Villanova's coming seasons will be interesting to monitor. Attendance has not been great for them home and away, except at some of the known contributors (i.e., W&M, Delaware, UNH, etc.). What attendance looks like when Bucknell and Georgetown are coming in, and vice-versa...if it's decent, it's a positive. I mean, the realities for VU football are three PA teams, one in DC, one in NYC, and a likely Ivy League scrap...get on that rotation with Temple, Delaware, Pitt, Penn State, Rutgers, Syracuse, BC, Army, Navy, or some other ACC school...it looks like it should work. We'll see.
05-09-2026 02:43 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
ccd494 Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,784
Joined: Jan 2017
Reputation: 290
I Root For: Maine
Location:
Post: #167
RE: Villanova Football to the Patriot League
(05-09-2026 02:43 PM)The Cutter of Bish Wrote:  The moves could have been made years ago, though; that FOIA into CAA/CAAFC about Patriot approaching these three (and potentially UNH) to join from what feels like a forever ago. Nothing has really changed in the respective conferences since then beyond the losses of James Madison and Delaware. Or, the additions of Monmouth, A&T, Hampton, and Bryant. So, Richmond, why did you start this?

Villanova's coming seasons will be interesting to monitor. Attendance has not been great for them home and away, except at some of the known contributors (i.e., W&M, Delaware, UNH, etc.). What attendance looks like when Bucknell and Georgetown are coming in, and vice-versa...if it's decent, it's a positive. I mean, the realities for VU football are three PA teams, one in DC, one in NYC, and a likely Ivy League scrap...get on that rotation with Temple, Delaware, Pitt, Penn State, Rutgers, Syracuse, BC, Army, Navy, or some other ACC school...it looks like it should work. We'll see.

The losses of Delaware and James Madison aren't exactly inconsequential. Delaware was easily VU's biggest rival in the CAA. James Madison was the strongest program in the league. The additions have, by and large, been teams that Villanova at best doesn't care about and at worst actively sees them as being well beneath them.

Villanova could count on a big attendance bump from Delaware. JMU was maybe the only other team in the league that had any kind of sidewalk fan name recognition. Without those schools, what the heck is the point of the CAA? At least back when those schools were in the league the CAA was a national power. Now it isn't. Without Villanova, Richmond, and W&M, how many bids is the CAA looking at? 2? Maybe 3? They can do that in the PL, with less travel, with more prestigious academic peers. Attendance won't change.
05-09-2026 03:59 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
ccd494 Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,784
Joined: Jan 2017
Reputation: 290
I Root For: Maine
Location:
Post: #168
RE: Villanova Football to the Patriot League
To put it bluntly, as was posted here years ago: "The price of playing the teams you want to play in the CAA is playing the teams you don't want to play." Richmond, Villanova, and W&M, in a series of dominos, found themselves out of balance.

Not getting to play Delaware and James Madison anymore brought the list of schools those programs really wanted to play to basically each other. Towson and Maine and UNH and URI were fine, but not worth the cost of playing Campbell and NC A&T and Hampton.

And believe you me, the northern schools are doing this math, too. There just isn't a waiting league for them.
05-09-2026 04:02 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
solohawks Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 25,729
Joined: May 2008
Reputation: 1187
I Root For: UNCW
Location: Wilmington, NC
Post: #169
RE: Villanova Football to the Patriot League
(05-09-2026 10:21 AM)ccd494 Wrote:  I'm not sure that it matters, really at all, what FCS conference you are in once you get above the NEC/Pioneer type level. In any of those conferences, if you win 8+ games you are pretty much guaranteed a playoff berth. No school anywhere in the FCS (outside of maybe the Montanas and the Dakotas) is a big enough draw to put thousands more butts in seats. No team travels particularly well. FCS attendance basically comes down to three factors:

1. How well is your team doing?
2. What's the weather like?
3. Is there an on-campus homecoming type event?

Other than that, whether you are playing Maine or Colgate or Wofford or Southeastern Louisiana is pretty immaterial unless the opponent is your one big rival. The average attendee at an FCS game is there to see their team, and really has no conception whether visiting Towson is 3-6 or 6-3. It's not a national sport in that anyone is tuned into any school but their own.
This!

Well said
05-09-2026 08:43 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
solohawks Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 25,729
Joined: May 2008
Reputation: 1187
I Root For: UNCW
Location: Wilmington, NC
Post: #170
RE: Villanova Football to the Patriot League
(05-09-2026 04:02 PM)ccd494 Wrote:  To put it bluntly, as was posted here years ago: "The price of playing the teams you want to play in the CAA is playing the teams you don't want to play." Richmond, Villanova, and W&M, in a series of dominos, found themselves out of balance.

Not getting to play Delaware and James Madison anymore brought the list of schools those programs really wanted to play to basically each other. Towson and Maine and UNH and URI were fine, but not worth the cost of playing Campbell and NC A&T and Hampton.

And believe you me, the northern schools are doing this math, too. There just isn't a waiting league for them.

When is the AEast going to pull the plug on CAA Football and take control of the league

Maine, UNH, Albany, URI, Bryant and Sacred Heart could easily start their own thing

Monmouth and Stony Brook would follow plus you have Merrimack out there for 9. Towson is there for a 10th depending on if they want to go north or south
05-09-2026 08:48 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
The Cutter of Bish Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 8,837
Joined: Mar 2013
Reputation: 364
I Root For: the little guy
Location:
Post: #171
RE: Villanova Football to the Patriot League
(05-09-2026 03:59 PM)ccd494 Wrote:  The losses of Delaware and James Madison aren't exactly inconsequential. Delaware was easily VU's biggest rival in the CAA. James Madison was the strongest program in the league. The additions have, by and large, been teams that Villanova at best doesn't care about and at worst actively sees them as being well beneath them.

Villanova could count on a big attendance bump from Delaware. JMU was maybe the only other team in the league that had any kind of sidewalk fan name recognition. Without those schools, what the heck is the point of the CAA? At least back when those schools were in the league the CAA was a national power. Now it isn't. Without Villanova, Richmond, and W&M, how many bids is the CAA looking at? 2? Maybe 3? They can do that in the PL, with less travel, with more prestigious academic peers. Attendance won't change.

I think that's a bingo on the first bolded part. Richmond leading the charge. The second, Patriot's got to get as many if not more than CAAFC for this to be a lateral move.

solohawks Wrote:
ccd494 Wrote:To put it bluntly, as was posted here years ago: "The price of playing the teams you want to play in the CAA is playing the teams you don't want to play." Richmond, Villanova, and W&M, in a series of dominos, found themselves out of balance.

Not getting to play Delaware and James Madison anymore brought the list of schools those programs really wanted to play to basically each other. Towson and Maine and UNH and URI were fine, but not worth the cost of playing Campbell and NC A&T and Hampton.

And believe you me, the northern schools are doing this math, too. There just isn't a waiting league for them.

When is the AEast going to pull the plug on CAA Football and take control of the league

Maine, UNH, Albany, URI, Bryant and Sacred Heart could easily start their own thing

Monmouth and Stony Brook would follow plus you have Merrimack out there for 9. Towson is there for a 10th depending on if they want to go north or south

FWIW, I think at least one or two of W&M, Villanova, and Richmond are waiting for such a breakaway and just got tired of it. I don't see this Patriot arrangement being a long-term thing for all three of them. But...just do something already if you're the northern schools.

The signaling by the football conference (and AmEast) with Bryant...enough already?
05-10-2026 05:36 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
solohawks Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 25,729
Joined: May 2008
Reputation: 1187
I Root For: UNCW
Location: Wilmington, NC
Post: #172
RE: Villanova Football to the Patriot League
(05-10-2026 05:36 AM)The Cutter of Bish Wrote:  FWIW, I think at least one or two of W&M, Villanova, and Richmond are waiting for such a breakaway and just got tired of it. I don't see this Patriot arrangement being a long-term thing for all three of them. But...just do something already if you're the northern schools.

The signaling by the football conference (and AmEast) with Bryant...enough already?

I disagree. I think this is the long term play.

The CAAFC 3 are no longer competing against large public state schools but against like minded small private schools. The only New England trip is now Holy Cross.

The geography is better, the chances of winning are better and you get to maintain round robin with your historic rivals. It just makes a lot of sense.

The only thing I don't understand is what is binding the AEast and other non CAA northern schools to the CAA FC.

Perhaps they like having those VA and NC games for recruiting? But it would make a lot more sense to consolidate, make Towson pick a side and force the southern schools to do their own thing
05-10-2026 06:28 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Fighting Muskie Offline
Senior Chief Realignmentologist
*

Posts: 15,080
Joined: Sep 2016
Reputation: 1214
I Root For: Bishop Sycamore
Location: Secret Lair
Post: #173
RE: Villanova Football to the Patriot League
Bringing CAAFB under their own roof and trimming off the long road trips is certainly the prerogative of OG members Maine, New Hampshire, and Rhode Island. Albany and Bryant would be onboard and I think the rest fall in line.

A 9 member league of:
Maine
UNH
URI
Bryant
Albany
Sacred Heart
Stony Brook
Monmouth
Towson
makes for a great bus league and if they wanted Merrimack as a 10th so no one gets an awkward bye week that would work too.

I just don’t see how these schools benefit from having Hampton, NC A&T, Campbell, and Elon around.
05-10-2026 10:38 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
ccd494 Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,784
Joined: Jan 2017
Reputation: 290
I Root For: Maine
Location:
Post: #174
RE: Villanova Football to the Patriot League
I'm not sure that would be the league. Towson, SBU, and Monmouth as all sports CAA members would likely figure something else out. Towson was in the PL once, can they get back in? Monmouth would love the PL. SBU's divorce from AE was acrimonious enough that they may be all huffy about putting an AE logo back on.

I think the hold up in a full divorce is that an America East football league would look more like:

Maine
UNH
Bryant
Albany (?)
URI (?)
Merrimack
Stonehill
Central Connecticut
Sacred Heart (?)

And that's a lot less appealing. Would URI want in on that? They've actually committed some money to their program and updating Meade. Would this be the push for Albany to say "nope, we're going to the CAA?" Sacred Heart finally got into the CAAF, if there's a rump league of Stony Brook, Towson, Monmouth, Albany, and some other mid-Atlantic teams, is that more appealing than the New England league? And, 25 years ago when AE last had a real opportunity to bring football on board, UVM and BU sunk it. Would UVM try to do that again?

And the big question, if Maine and UNH are in a New England bus league with teams that within the last 20 years were in D-II or the NEC, is that worth spending millions of dollars a year on fully funding a football program?

So, no, none of the New England schools are happy about Campbell and Hampton and NC A&T. But at this point I think the balance is still towards the CAA. But you better believe there are discussions.
05-10-2026 04:06 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
solohawks Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 25,729
Joined: May 2008
Reputation: 1187
I Root For: UNCW
Location: Wilmington, NC
Post: #175
RE: Villanova Football to the Patriot League
(05-10-2026 04:06 PM)ccd494 Wrote:  I'm not sure that would be the league. Towson, SBU, and Monmouth as all sports CAA members would likely figure something else out. Towson was in the PL once, can they get back in? Monmouth would love the PL. SBU's divorce from AE was acrimonious enough that they may be all huffy about putting an AE logo back on.

I think the hold up in a full divorce is that an America East football league would look more like:

Maine
UNH
Bryant
Albany (?)
URI (?)
Merrimack
Stonehill
Central Connecticut
Sacred Heart (?)

And that's a lot less appealing. Would URI want in on that? They've actually committed some money to their program and updating Meade. Would this be the push for Albany to say "nope, we're going to the CAA?" Sacred Heart finally got into the CAAF, if there's a rump league of Stony Brook, Towson, Monmouth, Albany, and some other mid-Atlantic teams, is that more appealing than the New England league? And, 25 years ago when AE last had a real opportunity to bring football on board, UVM and BU sunk it. Would UVM try to do that again?

And the big question, if Maine and UNH are in a New England bus league with teams that within the last 20 years were in D-II or the NEC, is that worth spending millions of dollars a year on fully funding a football program?

So, no, none of the New England schools are happy about Campbell and Hampton and NC A&T. But at this point I think the balance is still towards the CAA. But you better believe there are discussions.

W&M left CAAFC with ZERO negative consequences from the CAA proper

If Maine, UNH, Bryant, Albany, URI, and Sacred Heart told Stony Brook, Monmouth and probably Towson that they were starting America East football and the CAA 3 were welcome to join as affiliates under non punitive terms, do you really think the CAA 3 would say no out of loyalty to the Southern CAA 4?

I think it will come sooner than later
05-10-2026 04:12 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
ccd494 Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,784
Joined: Jan 2017
Reputation: 290
I Root For: Maine
Location:
Post: #176
RE: Villanova Football to the Patriot League
(05-10-2026 04:12 PM)solohawks Wrote:  
(05-10-2026 04:06 PM)ccd494 Wrote:  I'm not sure that would be the league. Towson, SBU, and Monmouth as all sports CAA members would likely figure something else out. Towson was in the PL once, can they get back in? Monmouth would love the PL. SBU's divorce from AE was acrimonious enough that they may be all huffy about putting an AE logo back on.

I think the hold up in a full divorce is that an America East football league would look more like:

Maine
UNH
Bryant
Albany (?)
URI (?)
Merrimack
Stonehill
Central Connecticut
Sacred Heart (?)

And that's a lot less appealing. Would URI want in on that? They've actually committed some money to their program and updating Meade. Would this be the push for Albany to say "nope, we're going to the CAA?" Sacred Heart finally got into the CAAF, if there's a rump league of Stony Brook, Towson, Monmouth, Albany, and some other mid-Atlantic teams, is that more appealing than the New England league? And, 25 years ago when AE last had a real opportunity to bring football on board, UVM and BU sunk it. Would UVM try to do that again?

And the big question, if Maine and UNH are in a New England bus league with teams that within the last 20 years were in D-II or the NEC, is that worth spending millions of dollars a year on fully funding a football program?

So, no, none of the New England schools are happy about Campbell and Hampton and NC A&T. But at this point I think the balance is still towards the CAA. But you better believe there are discussions.

W&M left CAAFC with ZERO negative consequences from the CAA proper

If Maine, UNH, Bryant, Albany, URI, and Sacred Heart told Stony Brook, Monmouth and probably Towson that they were starting America East football and the CAA 3 were welcome to join as affiliates under non punitive terms, do you really think the CAA 3 would say no out of loyalty to the Southern CAA 4?

I think it will come sooner than later

I don't think they would want to not join out of fear of consequences or loyalty. I think all three would want to look for better options, and any that could finagle a PL invite would take it. If that wasn't coming, they'd all have different concerns. Towson would have some geographic choices to make.

I could absolutely see a world where SBU tries to create some alternative league that looks like SBU, Towson, Monmouth, URI, Sacred Heart, all sports CAA member Albany, maybe a Duquesne or something. Solely out of spite towards AE.
05-10-2026 05:01 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
solohawks Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 25,729
Joined: May 2008
Reputation: 1187
I Root For: UNCW
Location: Wilmington, NC
Post: #177
RE: Villanova Football to the Patriot League
(05-10-2026 05:01 PM)ccd494 Wrote:  
(05-10-2026 04:12 PM)solohawks Wrote:  
(05-10-2026 04:06 PM)ccd494 Wrote:  I'm not sure that would be the league. Towson, SBU, and Monmouth as all sports CAA members would likely figure something else out. Towson was in the PL once, can they get back in? Monmouth would love the PL. SBU's divorce from AE was acrimonious enough that they may be all huffy about putting an AE logo back on.

I think the hold up in a full divorce is that an America East football league would look more like:

Maine
UNH
Bryant
Albany (?)
URI (?)
Merrimack
Stonehill
Central Connecticut
Sacred Heart (?)

And that's a lot less appealing. Would URI want in on that? They've actually committed some money to their program and updating Meade. Would this be the push for Albany to say "nope, we're going to the CAA?" Sacred Heart finally got into the CAAF, if there's a rump league of Stony Brook, Towson, Monmouth, Albany, and some other mid-Atlantic teams, is that more appealing than the New England league? And, 25 years ago when AE last had a real opportunity to bring football on board, UVM and BU sunk it. Would UVM try to do that again?

And the big question, if Maine and UNH are in a New England bus league with teams that within the last 20 years were in D-II or the NEC, is that worth spending millions of dollars a year on fully funding a football program?

So, no, none of the New England schools are happy about Campbell and Hampton and NC A&T. But at this point I think the balance is still towards the CAA. But you better believe there are discussions.

W&M left CAAFC with ZERO negative consequences from the CAA proper

If Maine, UNH, Bryant, Albany, URI, and Sacred Heart told Stony Brook, Monmouth and probably Towson that they were starting America East football and the CAA 3 were welcome to join as affiliates under non punitive terms, do you really think the CAA 3 would say no out of loyalty to the Southern CAA 4?

I think it will come sooner than later

I don't think they would want to not join out of fear of consequences or loyalty. I think all three would want to look for better options, and any that could finagle a PL invite would take it. If that wasn't coming, they'd all have different concerns. Towson would have some geographic choices to make.

I could absolutely see a world where SBU tries to create some alternative league that looks like SBU, Towson, Monmouth, URI, Sacred Heart, all sports CAA member Albany, maybe a Duquesne or something. Solely out of spite towards AE.

The southern members would be there too which means URI and Sacred Heart would likely jump ship
05-10-2026 06:50 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
jcohen42 Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,416
Joined: Feb 2016
Reputation: 101
I Root For: Drexel
Location:
Post: #178
RE: Villanova Football to the Patriot League
(05-10-2026 04:06 PM)ccd494 Wrote:  I'm not sure that would be the league. Towson, SBU, and Monmouth as all sports CAA members would likely figure something else out. Towson was in the PL once, can they get back in? Monmouth would love the PL. SBU's divorce from AE was acrimonious enough that they may be all huffy about putting an AE logo back on.

Towson and Monmouth are not getting into the Patriot League. The Patriot wants the round robin, and I would be shocked if they ever expand above 10 members.
05-10-2026 10:19 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Fighting Muskie Offline
Senior Chief Realignmentologist
*

Posts: 15,080
Joined: Sep 2016
Reputation: 1214
I Root For: Bishop Sycamore
Location: Secret Lair
Post: #179
RE: Villanova Football to the Patriot League
An America East takeover isn’t rocket science—

Maine, UNH, Albany, and Bryant are all full members and would lead the charge.

URI is a long time rival of Maine and UNH—they will be on board with whatever they want to do. That’s 5.

Securing the 6th and final necessary member is easy. Sacred Heart will follow whatever the other New England schools do. Merrimack is there as a potential 7th if you absolutely need them to gain leverage, but at this point, America East pretty much already has it.

Stony Brook and Monmouth aren’t going to want to stay in a CAAFB with a bunch of long road trips. They’ll likely flip when the writing is on the wall. Towson might be the last hold out but I think they make the smart choice and go where the numbers are.

CAAFB has to bring in Gardner-Webb and Charleston Southern to remain a 6-team circuit.
05-11-2026 07:26 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
The Cutter of Bish Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 8,837
Joined: Mar 2013
Reputation: 364
I Root For: the little guy
Location:
Post: #180
RE: Villanova Football to the Patriot League
(05-10-2026 06:28 AM)solohawks Wrote:  
(05-10-2026 05:36 AM)The Cutter of Bish Wrote:  FWIW, I think at least one or two of W&M, Villanova, and Richmond are waiting for such a breakaway and just got tired of it. I don't see this Patriot arrangement being a long-term thing for all three of them. But...just do something already if you're the northern schools.

The signaling by the football conference (and AmEast) with Bryant...enough already?

I disagree. I think this is the long term play.

The CAAFC 3 are no longer competing against large public state schools but against like minded small private schools. The only New England trip is now Holy Cross.

The geography is better, the chances of winning are better and you get to maintain round robin with your historic rivals. It just makes a lot of sense.

The only thing I don't understand is what is binding the AEast and other non CAA northern schools to the CAA FC.

Perhaps they like having those VA and NC games for recruiting? But it would make a lot more sense to consolidate, make Towson pick a side and force the southern schools to do their own thing

I can see Richmond keeping football in the Patriot League for the long haul. Villanova may prefer it too (administratively, at least), though fan backlash is another matter. Still, Villanova probably has to stay flexible if an opportunity ever emerges to align with larger FBS programs.

W&M is the one I’m least sure about. It’s easier for Big East and A-10 schools to place football elsewhere when it's their outlier sport. A CAA school only leaving CAAFC without fully divorcing itself from the conference feels different.

Maybe jettisoning CAAFC is just the symbolic “trial separation” before a full CAA divorce for W&M. But, I think they’re in the most unique spot geographically and institutionally. An expanded round-robin Patriot League football schedule could create strains that, unless W&M dominates the league, may get old quickly. I also think they’ll miss playing so many southern programs.

Villanova has some vulnerabilities too, particularly with former NFL alumni and the handful of donors (with fingers left to spare) who may care if Patriot League success doesn’t come quickly enough.

That also brings things back to the northern CAAFC schools and the bad politics hanging over both the CAA and America East. I agree with the skepticism around Stony Brook and some of the AmEast schools; there’s enough tangible bitterness there to create this kind of deadlock and leave programs like URI and Towson in awkward spots.
05-11-2026 07:51 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.