bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,873
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: 2025 CFP Race (who is this year's #11 team? Texas?)
(12-01-2025 04:50 PM)WhoseHouse? Wrote: (12-01-2025 04:31 PM)bullet Wrote: (12-01-2025 04:27 PM)WhoseHouse? Wrote: (12-01-2025 04:12 PM)bullet Wrote: (12-01-2025 01:04 PM)UpStreamRedTeam Wrote: They essential did, the rest of their OOC games were San Jose State, UTEP, and Sam Houston State. They HAD to play one P4 team to get to nine. Maybe next time beat 4-8 Florida.
Let's see.
Indiana-Old Dominion, Kennesaw St., Indiana St. plus Purdue, Maryland, Michigan St. and Wisconsin, the bottom 4 teams in the Big Ten. Their 9 conference wins included 6 of the bottom 7.
Texas Tech-Arkansas St., Ark. Pine Bluff, Oregon St. plus Oklahoma St. The bottom of the Big 12 isn't as bad as the bottom of the Big Ten, but they did have 4 of the bottom 5 (but somewhat balanced with 4 of the top 5)
Ohio St. played Texas, but also Grambling and Ohio U. And Purdue, Wisconsin, Rutgers. Michigan was the only other team in the top 6 of the Big Ten they played.
Notre Dame played (and lost) to Texas A&M and Miami. They beat USC. They also played Purdue, Arkansas, NCSU, Boise St., Navy, BC, Pitt, Syracuse and Stanford. Only one of their 6 ACC opponents had a winning conference record. They played the bottom two teams in the ACC, the last place team in the Big Ten and the last place team in the SEC (although they did beat Arkansas soundly). Notre Dame, like Texas and unlike, IU, Ohio St., Texas Tech, Alabama, Georgia, Oregon, Ole Miss, Texas A&M, BYU, Miami, Vanderbilt and Utah (all the schools rated ahead of Texas) did NOT play an FCS school.
In fact, Texas, Notre Dame, Michigan, USC and Tulane (!) were the only schools in the top 25 to not schedule an FCS team.
I love how y'all make your arguments without any context or comparison. When put in context, they make no sense.
Ofc SHSU was the 2nd worst team in FBS this year, UTEP the 5th worst, and SJSU the 16th worst. If we we're being honest there are plenty of FCS teams better than all three of those schools.
If you were being honest, you would compare it to the schedules of the other ranked teams.
Okay lets look at BYU who's also getting left out
#4 Tech on the road L
#13 Utah at home W
#21 Arizona on the road W
#30 TCU at home W
#31 ISU on the road W
#44 Cincy on the road W
#46 ECU on the road W
#80 UCF at home W
#82 WVU at home W
#89 Stanford at home W
#90 Colorado on the road W
Portland St (FCS) W
Texas Schedule
#1 Ohio State on the road L
#5 Georgia on the road L
#9 TAMU at home W
#11 OU in Dallas W
#14 Vandy at home W
#57 Florida on the road L
#60 Kentucky on the road W
#62 Miss St on the road W
#84 Arkansas at home W
#121 SJSU at home W
#132 UTEP at home W
#136 SHSU at home W
Even treating the SHSU game as an FCS opp and not factoring it in that's an average opponent rating of 50.5. BYU had an average opponent rating of 48.2 and played an extra road. They also went 11-1 as opposed to 9-3. Do you think Texas would've gone 12-0 on that schedule because apparently BYU needed to if they wanted an at-large this year.
Not sure what ranking system you are using, but convenient that you leave Portland St. out who was 1-11 in the Big Sky, so probably about 250 or so. Your post is dishonest by excluding them from your calculation. That changes the BYU average to about 70.
My problem isn't so much with BYU but with all the two loss teams. But only Oregon, Alabama and Ole Miss have played even one of Ohio St., Indiana and Georgia. Texas played 2 of the 3 and both on the road.
If you look at the top 10, who are all likely to make the playoff, games vs. top 10 teams:
Ohio St.-none
Indiana-win over Oregon
Texas A&M-Notre Dame
Georgia-win over Ole Miss, loss to Alabama
Oregon-loss to Indiana
Texas Tech-none
Ole Miss-win over OU, loss to Georgia
OU-win over Alabama, loss to Ole Miss
Notre Dame-loss to A&M
Alabama-win over Georgia, loss to OU
None with more than 2 games or 1 win. Texas has played FOUR of these teams and has two wins, OU and A&M with losses at Ohio St. and Georgia.
Now I'm pretty sure Texas will be on the outside. But the committee has to change the way they evaluate teams. 2-2 vs. playoff teams IS a playoff resume.
(This post was last modified: 12-02-2025 11:29 AM by bullet.)
|
|