Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
2025 CFP Race (who is this year's #11 team? Notre Dame?)
Author Message
quo vadis Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 56,023
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
Post: #121
RE: 2025 CFP Race (10 wins won't be enough for teams like Vandy and Georgia)
(11-23-2025 11:40 AM)Crayton Wrote:  Notre Dame only 76% likely to make the playoff after a win over Stanford; any buyers on that datum?
)snip)

I think if ND wins we are in, 100%.

Not saying we necessarily deserve to be 100% in, just that we are.
11-23-2025 11:56 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,947
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #122
RE: 2025 CFP Race (10 wins won't be enough for teams like Vandy and Georgia)
Looks like you’re overstating BYU’s odds, as the committee has them behind OU, Alabama and ND right now, despite the fact that their resume looks eerily similar to Ole Miss’ and Oregon’s. What’s the difference between those 3 schools…similar SOR, similar top win for all 3, nearly identical SOS…oh, wait, I got it, one of them is not in the P2. I firmly believe that if BYU was in the B1G or SEC, they’d be in the 6-8 range right now instead of #11. So, you have them where they SHOULD be rather than where the obviously biased CFP Committee has them.

Hmmm, but wait. Utah and Texas Tech are getting plenty of love from the CFP Committee, as is ND. What is wrong with BYU that they got the shaft last year and could get it again this year, with a team they defeated poised to leapfrog them yet again?
(This post was last modified: 11-23-2025 12:03 PM by bryanw1995.)
11-23-2025 11:59 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quo vadis Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 56,023
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
Post: #123
RE: 2025 CFP Race (10 wins won't be enough for teams like Vandy and Georgia)
(11-23-2025 11:59 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  Looks like you’re overstating BYU’s odds, as the committee has them behind OU, Alabama and ND right now, despite the fact that their resume looks eerily similar to Ole Miss’ and Oregon’s. What’s the difference between those 3 schools…similar SOR, similar top win for all 3, nearly identical SOS…oh, wait, I got it, one of them is not in the P2. I firmly believe that if BYU was in the B1G or SEC, they’d be in the 6-8 range right now instead of #11.

Probably. Then again if BYU were in the SEC I don't think they'd be 10-1 either.

In any event, I believe BYU has a clear path - they beat UCF they are in nB12 title game, and win that and they are in the playoffs. I can't feel that bad for a team that controls its destiny.
11-23-2025 12:02 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,947
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #124
RE: 2025 CFP Race (10 wins won't be enough for teams like Vandy and Georgia)
(11-23-2025 12:02 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 11:59 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  Looks like you’re overstating BYU’s odds, as the committee has them behind OU, Alabama and ND right now, despite the fact that their resume looks eerily similar to Ole Miss’ and Oregon’s. What’s the difference between those 3 schools…similar SOR, similar top win for all 3, nearly identical SOS…oh, wait, I got it, one of them is not in the P2. I firmly believe that if BYU was in the B1G or SEC, they’d be in the 6-8 range right now instead of #11.

Probably. Then again if BYU were in the SEC I don't think they'd be 10-1 either.

In any event, I believe BYU has a clear path - they beat UCF they are in nB12 title game, and win that and they are in the playoffs. I can't feel that bad for a team that controls its destiny.

I think they’d have the same record as Oregon or Ole Miss if they’d played their schedules. Not every team in the SEC has a top 10 SOS.

Oregon SOS 24
BYU SOS 28
Ole Miss SOS 33
(This post was last modified: 11-23-2025 12:12 PM by bryanw1995.)
11-23-2025 12:09 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Crayton Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,313
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
Post: #125
RE: 2025 CFP Race (10 wins won't be enough for teams like Vandy and Georgia)
(11-23-2025 12:02 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 11:59 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  Looks like you’re overstating BYU’s odds, as the committee has them behind OU, Alabama and ND right now, despite the fact that their resume looks eerily similar to Ole Miss’ and Oregon’s. What’s the difference between those 3 schools…similar SOR, similar top win for all 3, nearly identical SOS…oh, wait, I got it, one of them is not in the P2. I firmly believe that if BYU was in the B1G or SEC, they’d be in the 6-8 range right now instead of #11.

Probably. Then again if BYU were in the SEC I don't think they'd be 10-1 either.

In any event, I believe BYU has a clear path - they beat UCF they are in nB12 title game, and win that and they are in the playoffs. I can't feel that bad for a team that controls its destiny.

But that is the essence of SOR, it compares those schedules. The difficulty of BYU's schedule looks just like Ole Miss's SEC schedule (using the publicly available FPI):

BYU is 4-1 against the #7, #8, #30, #31 and #34 teams (CCG vs. #7)
Miss is 4-1 against the #6, #14, #25, #27 and #36 teams (CCG vs. #6)

But, yes, BYU controls their own destiny. Unlike Notre Dame?
(This post was last modified: 11-23-2025 12:46 PM by Crayton.)
11-23-2025 12:45 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
SouthEastAlaska Offline
All American
*

Posts: 3,335
Joined: Aug 2013
Reputation: 508
I Root For: UW
Location:
Post: #126
RE: 2025 CFP Race (10 wins won't be enough for teams like Vandy and Georgia)
(11-23-2025 12:45 PM)Crayton Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 12:02 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 11:59 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  Looks like you’re overstating BYU’s odds, as the committee has them behind OU, Alabama and ND right now, despite the fact that their resume looks eerily similar to Ole Miss’ and Oregon’s. What’s the difference between those 3 schools…similar SOR, similar top win for all 3, nearly identical SOS…oh, wait, I got it, one of them is not in the P2. I firmly believe that if BYU was in the B1G or SEC, they’d be in the 6-8 range right now instead of #11.

Probably. Then again if BYU were in the SEC I don't think they'd be 10-1 either.

In any event, I believe BYU has a clear path - they beat UCF they are in nB12 title game, and win that and they are in the playoffs. I can't feel that bad for a team that controls its destiny.

But that is the essence of SOR, it compares those schedules. The difficulty of BYU's schedule looks just like Ole Miss's SEC schedule (using the publicly available FPI):

BYU is 4-1 against the #7, #8, #30, #31 and #34 teams (CCG vs. #7)
Miss is 4-1 against the #6, #14, #25, #27 and #36 teams (CCG vs. #6)

But, yes, BYU controls their own destiny. Unlike Notre Dame?

Just my opinion, I don't think Notre Dame controls anything. If Vandy and Michigan win next weekend I would put both of them in before Notre Dame. Also when comparing BYU to ND, I give the edge to the school with the better record because their SOS are similar. To bad for BYU though because Notre Dame wins the popularity contest. 04-cheers
11-23-2025 12:52 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
The Beaver Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,343
Joined: Apr 2024
Reputation: 955
I Root For: Penn State
Location:
Post: #127
RE: 2025 CFP Race (10 wins won't be enough for teams like Vandy and Georgia)
(11-23-2025 12:52 PM)SouthEastAlaska Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 12:45 PM)Crayton Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 12:02 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 11:59 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  Looks like you’re overstating BYU’s odds, as the committee has them behind OU, Alabama and ND right now, despite the fact that their resume looks eerily similar to Ole Miss’ and Oregon’s. What’s the difference between those 3 schools…similar SOR, similar top win for all 3, nearly identical SOS…oh, wait, I got it, one of them is not in the P2. I firmly believe that if BYU was in the B1G or SEC, they’d be in the 6-8 range right now instead of #11.

Probably. Then again if BYU were in the SEC I don't think they'd be 10-1 either.

In any event, I believe BYU has a clear path - they beat UCF they are in nB12 title game, and win that and they are in the playoffs. I can't feel that bad for a team that controls its destiny.

But that is the essence of SOR, it compares those schedules. The difficulty of BYU's schedule looks just like Ole Miss's SEC schedule (using the publicly available FPI):

BYU is 4-1 against the #7, #8, #30, #31 and #34 teams (CCG vs. #7)
Miss is 4-1 against the #6, #14, #25, #27 and #36 teams (CCG vs. #6)

But, yes, BYU controls their own destiny. Unlike Notre Dame?

Just my opinion, I don't think Notre Dame controls anything. If Vandy and Michigan win next weekend I would put both of them in before Notre Dame. Also when comparing BYU to ND, I give the edge to the school with the better record because their SOS are similar. To bad for BYU though because Notre Dame wins the popularity contest. 04-cheers
Vandy would have to jump a bunch of spots to be in over Notre Dame. That should happen but I can guarantee it won't based on last year. It is asking a lot to jump a team up three or so slots over other teams that won with them actually having pulled an upset that week.
11-23-2025 04:16 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
RUScarlets Online
Heisman
*

Posts: 9,715
Joined: May 2012
Reputation: 313
I Root For: Rutgers
Location:
Post: #128
RE: 2025 CFP Race (10 wins won't be enough for teams like Vandy and Georgia)
Vandy is out… barring Ole Miss upset or something crazy like Auburn/Furd wins. They have no shot.

UM has a slim shot, but they need to trounce tOSU. TTech probably out with a loss, but I don’t think Vandy jumps them.
11-23-2025 04:41 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quo vadis Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 56,023
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
Post: #129
RE: 2025 CFP Race (10 wins won't be enough for teams like Vandy and Georgia)
(11-23-2025 12:09 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 12:02 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 11:59 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  Looks like you’re overstating BYU’s odds, as the committee has them behind OU, Alabama and ND right now, despite the fact that their resume looks eerily similar to Ole Miss’ and Oregon’s. What’s the difference between those 3 schools…similar SOR, similar top win for all 3, nearly identical SOS…oh, wait, I got it, one of them is not in the P2. I firmly believe that if BYU was in the B1G or SEC, they’d be in the 6-8 range right now instead of #11.

Probably. Then again if BYU were in the SEC I don't think they'd be 10-1 either.

In any event, I believe BYU has a clear path - they beat UCF they are in nB12 title game, and win that and they are in the playoffs. I can't feel that bad for a team that controls its destiny.

I think they’d have the same record as Oregon or Ole Miss if they’d played their schedules. Not every team in the SEC has a top 10 SOS.

Oregon SOS 24
BYU SOS 28
Ole Miss SOS 33

IMO, metrics like SOR and SOS are great, and among the very best we have to go on, but there are IMO intangibles about playing an SEC schedule that probably can't be quantified, the "meat grinder" aspect. IMO, BYU just does not have the athletes to stand up to the rigors of an SEC schedule. They would get worn down in a way they do not in the nB12.

For example, to be 10-1 right now, BYU would have to win 2 out of 3 games vs LSU, Oklahoma and Georgia, all played within a 28 day period. I think they lose at least two of those right there.

They'd also have to avoid upsets against talented underachievers like Florida and South Carolina. They'd have to beat arguably the best G5 team in Tulane. Heck, even bad teams like Mississippi State and Arkansas probably have as much talent as they do. They'd be favored and likely to win any of those games, but IMO a loss in at least one is likely.

So I don't see it, but that's just MO.
(This post was last modified: 11-24-2025 08:24 AM by quo vadis.)
11-24-2025 08:21 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
WhoseHouse? Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 10,210
Joined: Dec 2015
Reputation: 729
I Root For: UH
Location:
Post: #130
RE: 2025 CFP Race (10 wins won't be enough for teams like Vandy and Georgia)
(11-23-2025 12:02 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 11:59 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  Looks like you’re overstating BYU’s odds, as the committee has them behind OU, Alabama and ND right now, despite the fact that their resume looks eerily similar to Ole Miss’ and Oregon’s. What’s the difference between those 3 schools…similar SOR, similar top win for all 3, nearly identical SOS…oh, wait, I got it, one of them is not in the P2. I firmly believe that if BYU was in the B1G or SEC, they’d be in the 6-8 range right now instead of #11.

Probably. Then again if BYU were in the SEC I don't think they'd be 10-1 either.

In any event, I believe BYU has a clear path - they beat UCF they are in nB12 title game, and win that and they are in the playoffs. I can't feel that bad for a team that controls its destiny.

Didn’t have that energy with Bama last year lol
11-24-2025 09:56 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quo vadis Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 56,023
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
Post: #131
RE: 2025 CFP Race (10 wins won't be enough for teams like Vandy and Georgia)
(11-24-2025 09:56 AM)WhoseHouse? Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 12:02 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 11:59 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  Looks like you’re overstating BYU’s odds, as the committee has them behind OU, Alabama and ND right now, despite the fact that their resume looks eerily similar to Ole Miss’ and Oregon’s. What’s the difference between those 3 schools…similar SOR, similar top win for all 3, nearly identical SOS…oh, wait, I got it, one of them is not in the P2. I firmly believe that if BYU was in the B1G or SEC, they’d be in the 6-8 range right now instead of #11.

Probably. Then again if BYU were in the SEC I don't think they'd be 10-1 either.

In any event, I believe BYU has a clear path - they beat UCF they are in nB12 title game, and win that and they are in the playoffs. I can't feel that bad for a team that controls its destiny.

Didn’t have that energy with Bama last year lol

The nB12 is IMO different. You don't face the same challenges as in the SEC, so I have less sympathy for teams that control their fate and don't get it done. In the SEC, it's almost impossible for anyone to do that, the competition is just much tougher. That's why the SEC should join the B1G in demanding 4 autobids, to avoid travesties like last year.

To me, given BYU's nB12 membership, getting in with two losses to Texas Tech is asking for too much unless some significant upsets happen among the top 8-12 teams this week. The league is not a two-bid league in a 12-team playoff, as they say in hoops. Root for ND to lose to Stanford, Alabama to lose to Auburn, Oklahoma to lose to LSU, maybe something else and there might be a spot for a BYU that loses the CCG and finishes 11-2 or whatever.
(This post was last modified: 11-24-2025 10:10 AM by quo vadis.)
11-24-2025 10:03 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
WhoseHouse? Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 10,210
Joined: Dec 2015
Reputation: 729
I Root For: UH
Location:
Post: #132
RE: 2025 CFP Race (10 wins won't be enough for teams like Vandy and Georgia)
(11-24-2025 08:21 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 12:09 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 12:02 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 11:59 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  Looks like you’re overstating BYU’s odds, as the committee has them behind OU, Alabama and ND right now, despite the fact that their resume looks eerily similar to Ole Miss’ and Oregon’s. What’s the difference between those 3 schools…similar SOR, similar top win for all 3, nearly identical SOS…oh, wait, I got it, one of them is not in the P2. I firmly believe that if BYU was in the B1G or SEC, they’d be in the 6-8 range right now instead of #11.

Probably. Then again if BYU were in the SEC I don't think they'd be 10-1 either.

In any event, I believe BYU has a clear path - they beat UCF they are in nB12 title game, and win that and they are in the playoffs. I can't feel that bad for a team that controls its destiny.

I think they’d have the same record as Oregon or Ole Miss if they’d played their schedules. Not every team in the SEC has a top 10 SOS.

Oregon SOS 24
BYU SOS 28
Ole Miss SOS 33

IMO, metrics like SOR and SOS are great, and among the very best we have to go on, but there are IMO intangibles about playing an SEC schedule that probably can't be quantified, the "meat grinder" aspect. IMO, BYU just does not have the athletes to stand up to the rigors of an SEC schedule. They would get worn down in a way they do not in the nB12.

For example, to be 10-1 right now, BYU would have to win 2 out of 3 games vs LSU, Oklahoma and Georgia, all played within a 28 day period. I think they lose at least two of those right there.

They'd also have to avoid upsets against talented underachievers like Florida and South Carolina. They'd have to beat arguably the best G5 team in Tulane. Heck, even bad teams like Mississippi State and Arkansas probably have as much talent as they do. They'd be favored and likely to win any of those games, but IMO a loss in at least one is likely.

So I don't see it, but that's just MO.

Yah BYU doesn’t have the same caliber of athletes of Vanderbilt lol

Obviously an SEC schedule is tougher but it also affords you an additional loss or two. BYU basically had to go 12-1 on a top 30 schedule to make the playoffs. That’s a pretty tall task. They’d probably have had a better shot at making the playoffs going 9-3 on UTs schedule than 11-2 on their own.
11-24-2025 10:10 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quo vadis Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 56,023
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
Post: #133
RE: 2025 CFP Race (10 wins won't be enough for teams like Vandy and Georgia)
(11-24-2025 10:10 AM)WhoseHouse? Wrote:  
(11-24-2025 08:21 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 12:09 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 12:02 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 11:59 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  Looks like you’re overstating BYU’s odds, as the committee has them behind OU, Alabama and ND right now, despite the fact that their resume looks eerily similar to Ole Miss’ and Oregon’s. What’s the difference between those 3 schools…similar SOR, similar top win for all 3, nearly identical SOS…oh, wait, I got it, one of them is not in the P2. I firmly believe that if BYU was in the B1G or SEC, they’d be in the 6-8 range right now instead of #11.

Probably. Then again if BYU were in the SEC I don't think they'd be 10-1 either.

In any event, I believe BYU has a clear path - they beat UCF they are in nB12 title game, and win that and they are in the playoffs. I can't feel that bad for a team that controls its destiny.

I think they’d have the same record as Oregon or Ole Miss if they’d played their schedules. Not every team in the SEC has a top 10 SOS.

Oregon SOS 24
BYU SOS 28
Ole Miss SOS 33

IMO, metrics like SOR and SOS are great, and among the very best we have to go on, but there are IMO intangibles about playing an SEC schedule that probably can't be quantified, the "meat grinder" aspect. IMO, BYU just does not have the athletes to stand up to the rigors of an SEC schedule. They would get worn down in a way they do not in the nB12.

For example, to be 10-1 right now, BYU would have to win 2 out of 3 games vs LSU, Oklahoma and Georgia, all played within a 28 day period. I think they lose at least two of those right there.

They'd also have to avoid upsets against talented underachievers like Florida and South Carolina. They'd have to beat arguably the best G5 team in Tulane. Heck, even bad teams like Mississippi State and Arkansas probably have as much talent as they do. They'd be favored and likely to win any of those games, but IMO a loss in at least one is likely.

So I don't see it, but that's just MO.

Yah BYU doesn’t have the same caliber of athletes of Vanderbilt lol

Obviously an SEC schedule is tougher but it also affords you an additional loss or two. BYU basically had to go 12-1 on a top 30 schedule to make the playoffs. That’s a pretty tall task. They’d probably have had a better shot at making the playoffs going 9-3 on UTs schedule than 11-2 on their own.

I know that BYU vs Vanderbilt comparison is supposed to elicit a laugh, but it prompted me to look at the 24/7 talent composite, and Vanderbilt is #55 nationally while BYU is #70. Basically, BYU has close to a top- G5 level of talent.

And yes it is a tall task, and they have the bad luck that some west Texas oilmen poured $25m into Tech's roster and created a mini- superteam. In a 16 team playoff a non-champ BYU would be worthy. But 12 teams isn't a lot and with 5 gobbled up by ridiculous autobids it is very tough for any at-large teams.
11-24-2025 10:15 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
WhoseHouse? Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 10,210
Joined: Dec 2015
Reputation: 729
I Root For: UH
Location:
Post: #134
RE: 2025 CFP Race (10 wins won't be enough for teams like Vandy and Georgia)
(11-24-2025 10:03 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-24-2025 09:56 AM)WhoseHouse? Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 12:02 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 11:59 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  Looks like you’re overstating BYU’s odds, as the committee has them behind OU, Alabama and ND right now, despite the fact that their resume looks eerily similar to Ole Miss’ and Oregon’s. What’s the difference between those 3 schools…similar SOR, similar top win for all 3, nearly identical SOS…oh, wait, I got it, one of them is not in the P2. I firmly believe that if BYU was in the B1G or SEC, they’d be in the 6-8 range right now instead of #11.

Probably. Then again if BYU were in the SEC I don't think they'd be 10-1 either.

In any event, I believe BYU has a clear path - they beat UCF they are in nB12 title game, and win that and they are in the playoffs. I can't feel that bad for a team that controls its destiny.

Didn’t have that energy with Bama last year lol

The nB12 is IMO different. You don't face the same challenges as in the SEC, so I have less sympathy for teams that control their fate and don't get it done. In the SEC, it's almost impossible for anyone to do that, the competition is just much tougher. That's why the SEC should join the B1G in demanding 4 autobids, to avoid travesties like last year.

To me, given BYU's nB12 membership, getting in with two losses to Texas Tech is asking for too much unless some significant upsets happen among the top 8-12 teams this week. The league is not a two-bid league in a 12-team playoff, as they say in hoops. Root for ND to lose to Stanford, Alabama to lose to Auburn, Oklahoma to lose to LSU, maybe something else and there might be a spot for a BYU that loses the CCG and finishes 11-2 or whatever.

Just pointing out that Bama controlled their own destiny late last year before they lost to mediocre OU team and that didn’t stop you from feeling bad for them.

If BYU gets left out I’m not going to lose sleep over it but by the objective metrics their resume would get them if they had a different conference tag. I mean just look at Indy last year who got with sub 50 SOS and no ranked wins. Truth is the B12 would’ve been better off if Utah had won the Holy War. Utah looks like the better team by the eye test but losing that game (which falls in Whittingham because he left points on the table multiple times) pretty much ended any shot they had at seriously contending for an at-large.
11-24-2025 10:21 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
WhoseHouse? Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 10,210
Joined: Dec 2015
Reputation: 729
I Root For: UH
Location:
Post: #135
RE: 2025 CFP Race (10 wins won't be enough for teams like Vandy and Georgia)
(11-24-2025 10:15 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-24-2025 10:10 AM)WhoseHouse? Wrote:  
(11-24-2025 08:21 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 12:09 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 12:02 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  Probably. Then again if BYU were in the SEC I don't think they'd be 10-1 either.

In any event, I believe BYU has a clear path - they beat UCF they are in nB12 title game, and win that and they are in the playoffs. I can't feel that bad for a team that controls its destiny.

I think they’d have the same record as Oregon or Ole Miss if they’d played their schedules. Not every team in the SEC has a top 10 SOS.

Oregon SOS 24
BYU SOS 28
Ole Miss SOS 33

IMO, metrics like SOR and SOS are great, and among the very best we have to go on, but there are IMO intangibles about playing an SEC schedule that probably can't be quantified, the "meat grinder" aspect. IMO, BYU just does not have the athletes to stand up to the rigors of an SEC schedule. They would get worn down in a way they do not in the nB12.

For example, to be 10-1 right now, BYU would have to win 2 out of 3 games vs LSU, Oklahoma and Georgia, all played within a 28 day period. I think they lose at least two of those right there.

They'd also have to avoid upsets against talented underachievers like Florida and South Carolina. They'd have to beat arguably the best G5 team in Tulane. Heck, even bad teams like Mississippi State and Arkansas probably have as much talent as they do. They'd be favored and likely to win any of those games, but IMO a loss in at least one is likely.

So I don't see it, but that's just MO.

Yah BYU doesn’t have the same caliber of athletes of Vanderbilt lol

Obviously an SEC schedule is tougher but it also affords you an additional loss or two. BYU basically had to go 12-1 on a top 30 schedule to make the playoffs. That’s a pretty tall task. They’d probably have had a better shot at making the playoffs going 9-3 on UTs schedule than 11-2 on their own.

I know that BYU vs Vanderbilt comparison is supposed to elicit a laugh, but it prompted me to look at the 24/7 talent composite, and Vanderbilt is #55 nationally while BYU is #70. Basically, BYU has close to a top- G5 level of talent.

And yes it is a tall task, and they have the bad luck that some west Texas oilmen poured $25m into Tech's roster and created a mini- superteam. In a 16 team playoff a non-champ BYU would be worthy. But 12 teams isn't a lot and with 5 gobbled up by ridiculous autobids it is very tough for any at-large teams.

Right and that would put Vanderbilt on the bottom half of the B12 talent wise, a league that BYU has done pretty well in. Obviously that lack of star talent hasn’t prevented either Vandy or BYU from finding success.
11-24-2025 10:24 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quo vadis Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 56,023
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
Post: #136
RE: 2025 CFP Race (10 wins won't be enough for teams like Vandy and Georgia)
(11-24-2025 10:21 AM)WhoseHouse? Wrote:  
(11-24-2025 10:03 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-24-2025 09:56 AM)WhoseHouse? Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 12:02 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 11:59 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  Looks like you’re overstating BYU’s odds, as the committee has them behind OU, Alabama and ND right now, despite the fact that their resume looks eerily similar to Ole Miss’ and Oregon’s. What’s the difference between those 3 schools…similar SOR, similar top win for all 3, nearly identical SOS…oh, wait, I got it, one of them is not in the P2. I firmly believe that if BYU was in the B1G or SEC, they’d be in the 6-8 range right now instead of #11.

Probably. Then again if BYU were in the SEC I don't think they'd be 10-1 either.

In any event, I believe BYU has a clear path - they beat UCF they are in nB12 title game, and win that and they are in the playoffs. I can't feel that bad for a team that controls its destiny.

Didn’t have that energy with Bama last year lol

The nB12 is IMO different. You don't face the same challenges as in the SEC, so I have less sympathy for teams that control their fate and don't get it done. In the SEC, it's almost impossible for anyone to do that, the competition is just much tougher. That's why the SEC should join the B1G in demanding 4 autobids, to avoid travesties like last year.

To me, given BYU's nB12 membership, getting in with two losses to Texas Tech is asking for too much unless some significant upsets happen among the top 8-12 teams this week. The league is not a two-bid league in a 12-team playoff, as they say in hoops. Root for ND to lose to Stanford, Alabama to lose to Auburn, Oklahoma to lose to LSU, maybe something else and there might be a spot for a BYU that loses the CCG and finishes 11-2 or whatever.

Just pointing out that Bama controlled their own destiny late last year before they lost to mediocre OU team and that didn’t stop you from feeling bad for them.

If BYU gets left out I’m not going to lose sleep over it but by the objective metrics their resume would get them if they had a different conference tag. I mean just look at Indy last year who got with sub 50 SOS and no ranked wins. Truth is the B12 would’ve been better off if Utah had won the Holy War. Utah looks like the better team by the eye test but losing that game (which falls in Whittingham because he left points on the table multiple times) pretty much ended any shot they had at seriously contending for an at-large.

This year looks tougher than last year to get in. Last year, no P2 teams with two or fewer losses were left out. This year, both the SEC and B1G could have a two loss team that is left out.

Last year, Alabama deserved sympathy IMO because they were by the metrics one of the 12 best teams. They were kept out by the IMO stupid structure of the CFP, which put in two bad ACC teams and Boise thanks to autobids and in the case of SMU, poor decision making.

BYU might suffer the same fate, and if they do, I will express sympathy for them as well.

Right now, just win and get in.
(This post was last modified: 11-24-2025 11:08 AM by quo vadis.)
11-24-2025 11:08 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
ccbfan Offline
Special Teams
*

Posts: 792
Joined: Aug 2005
Reputation: 71
I Root For:
Location:
Post: #137
RE: 2025 CFP Race (10 wins won't be enough for teams like Vandy and Georgia)
(11-01-2025 08:41 AM)Crayton Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 06:58 PM)ccbfan Wrote:  CFB have no idea how to deal with good loses.

A 3 lose team could lose to OSU, Alabama, Indiana and beat 4 ranked teams and will still lose out to a 1-2 lose p4 team with 0 rank win.

We’ll see how well Illinois finishes if they have 3 losses like that. :) right now I have them around where Ole Miss finished last year.

We're almost about to see this with Texas if they beat Texas A&M.

Florida lose was bad but other 2 loses are at #1 OSU and at #4 Georgia.

Defeated top 10 A&M, Vandy, OU

BYU and ND would be what they're up against.
11-24-2025 11:42 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
DirtyDukes Offline
All American
*

Posts: 3,824
Joined: Mar 2013
Reputation: 135
I Root For: Dukes, bud!
Location: Museum District
Post: #138
RE: 2025 CFP Race (10 wins won't be enough for teams like Vandy and Georgia)
(11-23-2025 11:40 AM)Crayton Wrote:  JMU also slips a bit after their narrow victory over WSU.
[Image: attachment.php?aid=12252]

I know, I know UNT beat the brakes off them earlier in like week 3 this season, but we beat a WSU by 4 who lost to #19 UVA by 2 and #4 Ole Miss by 3 in October.
11-24-2025 12:16 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
AztecEmpire Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,079
Joined: May 2020
Reputation: 105
I Root For: SDSU
Location:
Post: #139
RE: 2025 CFP Race (10 wins won't be enough for teams like Vandy and Georgia)
The amount of credit the SEC gets for having athletes instead of teams is way overblown, especially in this era where teams are turned over every year. No offense but that was the old model when kids could only transfer once and would have to sit our a year unless they were a grad. Having highly rated recruits onbviously doesnt hurt but using it to underpin all the early season rankings feels like something that made sense in 2005 but not 2025. The last two years of the BIG breaking the SECs stranglehold on the 'Ship sorta proves it too.
11-24-2025 12:19 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,947
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #140
RE: 2025 CFP Race (10 wins won't be enough for teams like Vandy and Georgia)
(11-23-2025 12:52 PM)SouthEastAlaska Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 12:45 PM)Crayton Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 12:02 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 11:59 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  Looks like you’re overstating BYU’s odds, as the committee has them behind OU, Alabama and ND right now, despite the fact that their resume looks eerily similar to Ole Miss’ and Oregon’s. What’s the difference between those 3 schools…similar SOR, similar top win for all 3, nearly identical SOS…oh, wait, I got it, one of them is not in the P2. I firmly believe that if BYU was in the B1G or SEC, they’d be in the 6-8 range right now instead of #11.

Probably. Then again if BYU were in the SEC I don't think they'd be 10-1 either.

In any event, I believe BYU has a clear path - they beat UCF they are in nB12 title game, and win that and they are in the playoffs. I can't feel that bad for a team that controls its destiny.

But that is the essence of SOR, it compares those schedules. The difficulty of BYU's schedule looks just like Ole Miss's SEC schedule (using the publicly available FPI):

BYU is 4-1 against the #7, #8, #30, #31 and #34 teams (CCG vs. #7)
Miss is 4-1 against the #6, #14, #25, #27 and #36 teams (CCG vs. #6)

But, yes, BYU controls their own destiny. Unlike Notre Dame?

Just my opinion, I don't think Notre Dame controls anything. If Vandy and Michigan win next weekend I would put both of them in before Notre Dame. Also when comparing BYU to ND, I give the edge to the school with the better record because their SOS are similar. To bad for BYU though because Notre Dame wins the popularity contest. 04-cheers

ND doesn't need to out-point BYU, they need to out-point the loser of the Big 12 CCG, which seems quite likely, and would be just as likely if BYU was at #8 instead of 11. Hard to see Vanderbilt passing ND at this point, the Committee has made it abundantly clear that beating middling teams by large amounts carries more weight with them than tough road wins against good teams.
11-24-2025 12:20 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.