Missouri and Oklahoma are OUT. Georgia and BYU are IN. Illinois? They lost but are still one of the 7 most likely at large teams. Oregon was already OUT while Indiana is now most likely to finish as a 12-1 at large; be prepared for seeing them at #1 after Ohio State loses to Michigan.
Utah knocked out Arizona State, hard, from the At Large Tracker. USC supplanted Michigan.
UCLA (!?&@#) has entered the chat. One of the 12 next most likely conference champs to make the playoff. The Ponies have also ascended to this level. Texas makes its reappearance after blasting Oklahoma. Temple, Fresno, Old Dominion, and Louisiana Tech have been eliminated.
(This post was last modified: 10-12-2025 07:46 AM by Crayton.)
(10-12-2025 07:44 AM)Crayton Wrote: Missouri and Oklahoma are OUT. Georgia and BYU are IN. Illinois? They lost but are still one of the 7 most likely at large teams. Oregon was already OUT while Indiana is now most likely to finish as a 12-1 at large; be prepared for seeing them at #1 after Ohio State loses to Michigan.
Utah knocked out Arizona State, hard, from the At Large Tracker. USC supplanted Michigan.
UCLA (!?&@#) has entered the chat. One of the 12 next most likely conference champs to make the playoff. The Ponies have also ascended to this level. Texas makes its reappearance after blasting Oklahoma. Temple, Fresno, Old Dominion, and Louisiana Tech have been eliminated.
I might have to go back and check but I believe I was the first one on this board to float the crazy idea that UCLA’s first win in its new era might not be a fluke, so much so that running the table might be a (tiny) possibility. Now with two wins it’s still crazy talk. But it’s already an amazing story. Even one more win or two would make for one of the most stunning in-season turnarounds in sports history.
Texas Tech is out and in their place is the winner of the Utah-Cincinnati game in 2 weeks. Yes, I have introduced elimination games. Winners have > 50% chance of making the playoff (if they win out), while losers drop below 50%. For example, Illinois holds onto their 12th spot of the playoff, but Washington will have a chance to eliminate them this week.
In the G5, USF-Tulane is our most likely American Conference Championship Game, for a playoff spot. An 11-2 Boise and 12-1 JMU have distant hopes of crashing the party, but it seems they may need a 3-loss American (or ACC?) champ to do so.
(This post was last modified: 10-19-2025 07:36 AM by Crayton.)
RE: 2025 CFP Race (who will be the Big 12’s 2nd playoff team?)
Washington defeated Illinois and grabs the... wait! We've got a steal! A 12-1 Georgia Tech is now the most likely ACC Champion, bumping Miami to at large status, and stealing the Big Ten's 3rd bid.
An 11-2 USF is still the most likely G5 representative. The non-American contenders are still hovering around the #20-#25 range. But remember, that is an average, Strength of Schedule/Record depends a lot on how well other teams do.
This week Oklahoma-Tennessee is an elimination game, as is USC-Nebraska and ISU-ASU.
(This post was last modified: 10-26-2025 07:33 AM by Crayton.)
(10-26-2025 07:33 AM)Crayton Wrote: Washington defeated Illinois and grabs the... wait! We've got a steal! A 12-1 Georgia Tech is now the most likely ACC Champion, bumping Miami to at large status, and stealing the Big Ten's 3rd bid.
An 11-2 USF is still the most likely G5 representative. The non-American contenders are still hovering around the #20-#25 range. But remember, that is an average, Strength of Schedule/Record depends a lot on how well other teams do.
This week Oklahoma-Tennessee is an elimination game, as is USC-Nebraska and ISU-ASU.
Nice to see UVa hanging around with a very slim chance in this CFP discussion. It’s fascinating that the ‘Hoos have no realistic shot as an at large selection…7-1 record with a painfully close loss at NC State, but weak SOS and weakening game-control. The closing schedule gets harder (at 5-2 Cal, 5-2 Wake, at 4-3 Duke & Hokies rivalry.
The discussion of CFP expansion with AQs will gain support in the (currently unlikely) scenario where UVa
1. finishes the regular season at 11-1,
2. loses a close ACC Championship Game,
3. misses the playoffs
It’s similar to the SMU versus Alabama debate from last year…except that unlike SMU, UVa has no opportunity to make its case other than to win every game. Yes, Virginia is actually relevant again in football.
(10-26-2025 07:33 AM)Crayton Wrote: Washington defeated Illinois and grabs the... wait! We've got a steal! A 12-1 Georgia Tech is now the most likely ACC Champion, bumping Miami to at large status, and stealing the Big Ten's 3rd bid.
An 11-2 USF is still the most likely G5 representative. The non-American contenders are still hovering around the #20-#25 range. But remember, that is an average, Strength of Schedule/Record depends a lot on how well other teams do.
This week Oklahoma-Tennessee is an elimination game, as is USC-Nebraska and ISU-ASU.
Nice to see UVa hanging around with a very slim chance in this CFP discussion. It’s fascinating that the ‘Hoos have no realistic shot as an at large selection…7-1 record with a painfully close loss at NC State, but weak SOS and weakening game-control. The closing schedule gets harder (at 5-2 Cal, 5-2 Wake, at 4-3 Duke & Hokies rivalry.
The discussion of CFP expansion with AQs will gain support in the (currently unlikely) scenario where UVa
1. finishes the regular season at 11-1,
2. loses a close ACC Championship Game,
3. misses the playoffs
It’s similar to the SMU versus Alabama debate from last year…except that unlike SMU, UVa has no opportunity to make its case other than to win every game. Yes, Virginia is actually relevant again in football.
If the ACC still gets a second team, in that scenario, it may mute any complaints from the ACC. Houston is likely in a similar spot (according to that graphic); easy road to the CCG and little forgiveness if they have a 2nd loss.
It won’t happen but these conferences should add a flex week prior to rivalry week, to help balance these schedules. GT vs. UVA would be a good game that week.
(10-26-2025 07:33 AM)Crayton Wrote: Washington defeated Illinois and grabs the... wait! We've got a steal! A 12-1 Georgia Tech is now the most likely ACC Champion, bumping Miami to at large status, and stealing the Big Ten's 3rd bid.
An 11-2 USF is still the most likely G5 representative. The non-American contenders are still hovering around the #20-#25 range. But remember, that is an average, Strength of Schedule/Record depends a lot on how well other teams do.
This week Oklahoma-Tennessee is an elimination game, as is USC-Nebraska and ISU-ASU.
Nice to see UVa hanging around with a very slim chance in this CFP discussion. It’s fascinating that the ‘Hoos have no realistic shot as an at large selection…7-1 record with a painfully close loss at NC State, but weak SOS and weakening game-control. The closing schedule gets harder (at 5-2 Cal, 5-2 Wake, at 4-3 Duke & Hokies rivalry.
The discussion of CFP expansion with AQs will gain support in the (currently unlikely) scenario where UVa
1. finishes the regular season at 11-1,
2. loses a close ACC Championship Game,
3. misses the playoffs
It’s similar to the SMU versus Alabama debate from last year…except that unlike SMU, UVa has no opportunity to make its case other than to win every game. Yes, Virginia is actually relevant again in football.
USF: SOS thus far 41, remaining 97
Tulane: SOS 64, remaining 78
Boise St: SOS 57, remaining 93
Virginia current SOS: 95, remaining: 67
Memphis: SOS 116: remaining: 77
Virginia would have no better than the 4th best SOS if they were in the g5 this year. That's comparatively much worse than SMU, I think that their pre-CCG SOS was still higher than any g5's last year at least.
They've managed to get by with several VERY close wins against a schedule that's quite a bit weaker than even SMU's very easy schedule last year (#75 going into the ACC CCG). It's one thing for Alabama to squeak by with a close win against a very talented but struggling USC, but to balance that with 4 wins against teams that are still ranked. It's quite another for UVA to squeak out 4 straight games, 3 of those in OT and one a 2 pt home win over WSU. It's ok to struggle SOMETIMES, but if you struggle every time regardless of the competition then it appears that you're more lucky than good.
UVA is also different from SMU of 2024 in that they do at least have a quality win against a ranked Louisville. SMU didn't beat anybody last season. That probably would have gotten UVA in the CFP even with a CCG loss using the 2024 rules, but now that SOS is taken into account...I'd guess no. There are lots of scenarios where one or even both of the M2 get in multiple teams this season, 9 ranked teams between the 2 of them provides lots of opportunity for most to get some quality wins, but UVA probably needs to win the ACC to get in. But Texas Tech, BYU, Miami or GT could all easily get in even with a CCG loss. BYU and GT b/c they had only one loss, Miami b/c they've had lots of quality wins and a quality overall schedule, and Tech b/c their one loss thus far was about as close as you can get with their starting QB hurt (presuming that he's back and healthy for the CCG ofc) and they've otherwise looked borderline dominant.
(This post was last modified: 10-26-2025 03:12 PM by bryanw1995.)
Generally a P2 teams needs 10 wins to get an at large, an M2 needs 11, a G5 12. If we use 50% as the breakpoint, here are the projected exceptions to those rules:
(10-30-2025 03:32 PM)Crayton Wrote: Generally a P2 teams needs 10 wins to get an at large, an M2 needs 11, a G5 12. If we use 50% as the breakpoint, here are the projected exceptions to those rules:
42% 10-3 Ohio State
29% 10-2 Ole Miss
24% 10-2 Indiana, Nebraska, Vanderbilt, Texas A&M
24% 11-2 Georgia Tech
16% 10-2 Ohio State
12% 11-2 Virginia
8% 11-1 Houston
1% 11-2 Houston
I'm confused, why is 10-2 OSU so much less likely to get an invite than 10-3 OSU? Losing the B1G CCG shouldn't hurt much, but it has to hurt at least a little bit, right? Also, are you saying that Indiana, Nebraska, Vanderbilt and A&M are all at a 24% to chance to make the CFP at 10-2? That's confusing when we consider the current and remaining SOS for the 4 schools:
A&M: 14 current, also 14 remaining SOS
Vanderbilt: 32, 8
Nebraska: 67, 23
Indiana: 42, 33
I'd also question how an 11-2 GT that lost their CCG + another game, just barely keeps squeaking by substandard opponents, and has a SOS of 82, 43 would get in over either Vanderbilt or A&M.
All of that to say nothing of BYU, Pitt, Utah and Miami:
Oregon at 10-2 is a lock imo. Their sos for the rest of the season is currently #18 according to Massey and ESPN has them at #12.
What if Alabama has 2 losses and they are FSU and Auburn? Those would be considered bad losses, right? Does sos trump bad losses in this situation? I'd personally still have them in the playoff...I think?
(This post was last modified: 10-30-2025 04:17 PM by cubucks.)
(10-30-2025 04:16 PM)cubucks Wrote: Oregon at 10-2 is a lock imo. Their sos for the rest of the season is currently #18 according to Massey and ESPN has them at #12.
What if Alabama has 2 losses and they are FSU and Auburn? Those would be considered bad losses, right? Does sos trump bad losses in this situation? I'd personally still have them in the playoff...I think?
For any other school, they'd be out. But it is Alabama.
(10-30-2025 04:16 PM)cubucks Wrote: Oregon at 10-2 is a lock imo. Their sos for the rest of the season is currently #18 according to Massey and ESPN has them at #12.
What if Alabama has 2 losses and they are FSU and Auburn? Those would be considered bad losses, right? Does sos trump bad losses in this situation? I'd personally still have them in the playoff...I think?
For any other school, they'd be out. But it is Alabama.
How short your memory is. Didn't Alabama get unfairly left out behind an SMU that only beat one team with a winning record all season in 2024?
(10-30-2025 03:32 PM)Crayton Wrote: Generally a P2 teams needs 10 wins to get an at large, an M2 needs 11, a G5 12. If we use 50% as the breakpoint, here are the projected exceptions to those rules:
42% 10-3 Ohio State
29% 10-2 Ole Miss
24% 10-2 Indiana, Nebraska, Vanderbilt, Texas A&M
24% 11-2 Georgia Tech
16% 10-2 Ohio State
12% 11-2 Virginia
8% 11-1 Houston
1% 11-2 Houston
I'm confused, why is 10-2 OSU so much less likely to get an invite than 10-3 OSU? Losing the B1G CCG shouldn't hurt much, but it has to hurt at least a little bit, right? Also, are you saying that Indiana, Nebraska, Vanderbilt and A&M are all at a 24% to chance to make the CFP at 10-2? That's confusing when we consider the current and remaining SOS for the 4 schools:
A&M: 14 current, also 14 remaining SOS
Vanderbilt: 32, 8
Nebraska: 67, 23
Indiana: 42, 33
I'd also question how an 11-2 GT that lost their CCG + another game, just barely keeps squeaking by substandard opponents, and has a SOS of 82, 43 would get in over either Vanderbilt or A&M.
All of that to say nothing of BYU, Pitt, Utah and Miami:
If I'm misreading what you wrote, sorry about that. Are you saying that these are the probabilities that these teams finish with those records?
You’re reading it right. These are the probabilities, given that record, that a team makes the playoff. Strength of Record is the primary way teams are sorted, but there are 3 additional considerations.
1. The biggest additional consideration is that we’re not strictly comparing apples to apples; these teams are not compared against the same set of 12 other potential playoff teams. A 10-2 P2 team would be ranked #3, #4, or worse in their conference. In a scenario where that same team goes 10-3, they were ranked #1 or #2 in their conference, meaning they had ~2 extra at large spots not taken up by conference mates to cushion the blow of a CCG loss (which, yes, would be minor but still something), making the playoff more often than if they were 10-2.
2. How you finish matters. Do you drop your last two games? Does your star player get injured? Human committees tend to have a recency bias to them. A 10-2 A&M or Ohio State likely ended the season with a loss. If there is another 10-2 team like Miami or Pitt who ended with some good wins (and a generally strong eye-test), the committee is going to err on the side of the hot hand (or hot “brand” though I refuse to model that).
3. The underlying FPI that ESPN uses is different than my own. It looks like I have the P4 more as more equal with each other than ESPN does. That could also be a function of me looking at season-ending numbers (after more .500 play within each conference) while the numbers you cite are current/future SOR after only 9 weeks. Not sure.
I know there were a few specific examples included in your post, but I may dive deeper into a handful of those next week. Explorations like that can help uncover ways to change and improve my model.
(10-30-2025 04:16 PM)cubucks Wrote: Oregon at 10-2 is a lock imo. Their sos for the rest of the season is currently #18 according to Massey and ESPN has them at #12.
What if Alabama has 2 losses and they are FSU and Auburn? Those would be considered bad losses, right? Does sos trump bad losses in this situation? I'd personally still have them in the playoff...I think?
For any other school, they'd be out. But it is Alabama.
That and Alabama would probably still have more Top 25 wins than anyone else.
I think SOR is your starting point, and then you use head-to-head, loss count, eye test, to make small tweaks. 10-2 Alabama (like last year) would be 100% in; 9-3 would require some help.
(This post was last modified: 10-30-2025 06:45 PM by Crayton.)
(10-26-2025 07:33 AM)Crayton Wrote: Washington defeated Illinois and grabs the... wait! We've got a steal! A 12-1 Georgia Tech is now the most likely ACC Champion, bumping Miami to at large status, and stealing the Big Ten's 3rd bid.
An 11-2 USF is still the most likely G5 representative. The non-American contenders are still hovering around the #20-#25 range. But remember, that is an average, Strength of Schedule/Record depends a lot on how well other teams do.
This week Oklahoma-Tennessee is an elimination game, as is USC-Nebraska and ISU-ASU.
Nice to see UVa hanging around with a very slim chance in this CFP discussion. It’s fascinating that the ‘Hoos have no realistic shot as an at large selection…7-1 record with a painfully close loss at NC State, but weak SOS and weakening game-control. The closing schedule gets harder (at 5-2 Cal, 5-2 Wake, at 4-3 Duke & Hokies rivalry.
The discussion of CFP expansion with AQs will gain support in the (currently unlikely) scenario where UVa
1. finishes the regular season at 11-1,
2. loses a close ACC Championship Game,
3. misses the playoffs
It’s similar to the SMU versus Alabama debate from last year…except that unlike SMU, UVa has no opportunity to make its case other than to win every game. Yes, Virginia is actually relevant again in football.
USF: SOS thus far 41, remaining 97
Tulane: SOS 64, remaining 78
Boise St: SOS 57, remaining 93
Virginia current SOS: 95, remaining: 67
Memphis: SOS 116: remaining: 77
Virginia would have no better than the 4th best SOS if they were in the g5 this year. That's comparatively much worse than SMU, I think that their pre-CCG SOS was still higher than any g5's last year at least.
They've managed to get by with several VERY close wins against a schedule that's quite a bit weaker than even SMU's very easy schedule last year (#75 going into the ACC CCG). It's one thing for Alabama to squeak by with a close win against a very talented but struggling USC, but to balance that with 4 wins against teams that are still ranked. It's quite another for UVA to squeak out 4 straight games, 3 of those in OT and one a 2 pt home win over WSU. It's ok to struggle SOMETIMES, but if you struggle every time regardless of the competition then it appears that you're more lucky than good.
UVA is also different from SMU of 2024 in that they do at least have a quality win against a ranked Louisville. SMU didn't beat anybody last season. That probably would have gotten UVA in the CFP even with a CCG loss using the 2024 rules, but now that SOS is taken into account...I'd guess no. There are lots of scenarios where one or even both of the M2 get in multiple teams this season, 9 ranked teams between the 2 of them provides lots of opportunity for most to get some quality wins, but UVA probably needs to win the ACC to get in. But Texas Tech, BYU, Miami or GT could all easily get in even with a CCG loss. BYU and GT b/c they had only one loss, Miami b/c they've had lots of quality wins and a quality overall schedule, and Tech b/c their one loss thus far was about as close as you can get with their starting QB hurt (presuming that he's back and healthy for the CCG ofc) and they've otherwise looked borderline dominant.
The comparison to G5 SOS is weak and nonsensical because in this scenario (i.e., UVa’s second loss comes in the CCG) UVa will also be playing a top 10 team in its final game. G5 conferences don’t have that opportunity. The final SOS (assuming they lose the CCG after an 11-1 regular season) will be better than any G5. The CCG is a defacto SOS builder for the ACC. Simply put, the CFP Committee makes its final selection after the CCG. IMHO, this is the reason why the CFP Committee has correctly not heavily penalized teams with a 13th data point for a “quality loss” during the CCG.
With regards to “lucky” versus “good”, UVa is actually 3-1 in close games. The ‘Hoos lost a very close game at NC State when the QB made a couple of critical bone-headed plays in the fourth quarter. In other words, luck balances out over the season. If UVa continues playing one-score games they won’t finish the regular season 11-1. The real problem for UVa is the SOS relative the W/L record. FSU’s season turning into a dumpster fire is emblematic of this issue, especially given that FSU solidly beat Alabama.
(This post was last modified: 10-30-2025 07:59 PM by Wahoowa84.)
A couple upsets in the ACC mean that Louisville (not Georgia Tech) is now the most likely conference champion. Miami? Still clinging to an at large spot; too bad the simulation doesn't include the Cristobal choke quotient.
North Texas (!) is now the forerunner for the G5 spot. They passed their last big test before the American Championship. JMU is within striking distance of 2-loss American champs not named USF as well as near 3-loss ACC champs SMU/Duke. San Diego State likely needs those teams to have 1 additional loss to pass them.
Oregon finally reclaims a playoff spot. Though honestly they should have had it the last two weeks as well, as I continue to refine my presentation.
As the number of contenders dwindled, teams will start appearing in multiple locations in the grid.
(This post was last modified: 11-04-2025 06:06 PM by Crayton.)
(10-26-2025 07:33 AM)Crayton Wrote: Washington defeated Illinois and grabs the... wait! We've got a steal! A 12-1 Georgia Tech is now the most likely ACC Champion, bumping Miami to at large status, and stealing the Big Ten's 3rd bid.
An 11-2 USF is still the most likely G5 representative. The non-American contenders are still hovering around the #20-#25 range. But remember, that is an average, Strength of Schedule/Record depends a lot on how well other teams do.
This week Oklahoma-Tennessee is an elimination game, as is USC-Nebraska and ISU-ASU.
Nice to see UVa hanging around with a very slim chance in this CFP discussion. It’s fascinating that the ‘Hoos have no realistic shot as an at large selection…7-1 record with a painfully close loss at NC State, but weak SOS and weakening game-control. The closing schedule gets harder (at 5-2 Cal, 5-2 Wake, at 4-3 Duke & Hokies rivalry.
The discussion of CFP expansion with AQs will gain support in the (currently unlikely) scenario where UVa
1. finishes the regular season at 11-1,
2. loses a close ACC Championship Game,
3. misses the playoffs
It’s similar to the SMU versus Alabama debate from last year…except that unlike SMU, UVa has no opportunity to make its case other than to win every game. Yes, Virginia is actually relevant again in football.
USF: SOS thus far 41, remaining 97
Tulane: SOS 64, remaining 78
Boise St: SOS 57, remaining 93
Virginia current SOS: 95, remaining: 67
Memphis: SOS 116: remaining: 77
Virginia would have no better than the 4th best SOS if they were in the g5 this year. That's comparatively much worse than SMU, I think that their pre-CCG SOS was still higher than any g5's last year at least.
They've managed to get by with several VERY close wins against a schedule that's quite a bit weaker than even SMU's very easy schedule last year (#75 going into the ACC CCG). It's one thing for Alabama to squeak by with a close win against a very talented but struggling USC, but to balance that with 4 wins against teams that are still ranked. It's quite another for UVA to squeak out 4 straight games, 3 of those in OT and one a 2 pt home win over WSU. It's ok to struggle SOMETIMES, but if you struggle every time regardless of the competition then it appears that you're more lucky than good.
UVA is also different from SMU of 2024 in that they do at least have a quality win against a ranked Louisville. SMU didn't beat anybody last season. That probably would have gotten UVA in the CFP even with a CCG loss using the 2024 rules, but now that SOS is taken into account...I'd guess no. There are lots of scenarios where one or even both of the M2 get in multiple teams this season, 9 ranked teams between the 2 of them provides lots of opportunity for most to get some quality wins, but UVA probably needs to win the ACC to get in. But Texas Tech, BYU, Miami or GT could all easily get in even with a CCG loss. BYU and GT b/c they had only one loss, Miami b/c they've had lots of quality wins and a quality overall schedule, and Tech b/c their one loss thus far was about as close as you can get with their starting QB hurt (presuming that he's back and healthy for the CCG ofc) and they've otherwise looked borderline dominant.
The comparison to G5 SOS is weak and nonsensical because in this scenario (i.e., UVa’s second loss comes in the CCG) UVa will also be playing a top 10 team in its final game. G5 conferences don’t have that opportunity. The final SOS (assuming they lose the CCG after an 11-1 regular season) will be better than any G5. The CCG is a defacto SOS builder for the ACC. Simply put, the CFP Committee makes its final selection after the CCG. IMHO, this is the reason why the CFP Committee has correctly not heavily penalized teams with a 13th data point for a “quality loss” during the CCG.
With regards to “lucky” versus “good”, UVa is actually 3-1 in close games. The ‘Hoos lost a very close game at NC State when the QB made a couple of critical bone-headed plays in the fourth quarter. In other words, luck balances out over the season. If UVa continues playing one-score games they won’t finish the regular season 11-1. The real problem for UVa is the SOS relative the W/L record. FSU’s season turning into a dumpster fire is emblematic of this issue, especially given that FSU solidly beat Alabama.
Not likely now. The American CCG could be ranked v ranked, while UVA could very well be facing an unranked foe now in the CCG. Additionally, 4 tossup games with only 1 loss could mean that you've overcome a very difficult schedule if you're Alabama with a pinch of luck going 3-1 in very close games, or it could mean that you're not very good but got very lucky with an easy schedule if you're Virginia and also got lucky by going 3-1 in very close games.
(This post was last modified: 11-02-2025 09:56 AM by bryanw1995.)
(10-30-2025 04:16 PM)cubucks Wrote: Oregon at 10-2 is a lock imo. Their sos for the rest of the season is currently #18 according to Massey and ESPN has them at #12.
What if Alabama has 2 losses and they are FSU and Auburn? Those would be considered bad losses, right? Does sos trump bad losses in this situation? I'd personally still have them in the playoff...I think?
IMO, any SEC or B1G teams with two losses will make the playoffs. Especially any with a modicum of a brand name (translation, both Oregon and Alabama at 10-2 are locks IMO).
Sadly for the SEC, it will have fewer of those despite being once again the best conference and thus far more of a meatgrinder. Heck, Georgia could easily lose to Mississippi State this week.
(This post was last modified: 11-02-2025 10:50 AM by quo vadis.)