bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,964
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3765
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: US College closures are expected to soar - bloomberg
(12-04-2024 10:53 AM)JRsec Wrote: (12-04-2024 10:45 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (12-04-2024 12:58 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (12-03-2024 07:02 PM)DawgNBama Wrote: (12-03-2024 03:19 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: The number of colleges that close each year is poised to significantly increase as schools contend with a slowdown in prospective students. That’s the finding of a new working paper published by the Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia, where researchers created predictive models of schools’ financial distress using metrics like enrollment and staffing patterns, sources of revenue and liquidity data. They overlayed those models with simulations to estimate the likely increase of future closures.
Under the worst-case scenario which assumes a one-time 15% drop in prospective students — known as the “demographic cliff” — 80 additional colleges would shut, impacting more than 100,000 students and 20,880 staff members. If that student decline was spread out over five years, annual closures would tick up by 4.6 schools, the report shows.
“These simulations point to the precarious potential situation facing postsecondary education in the coming years, especially if the demographic cliff materializes in a moderate to severe fashion,” according to the report, authored by Robert Kelchen, a professor at the University of Tennessee and a visiting scholar at the Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia, along with Dubravka Ritter and Douglas Webber, Fed researchers.
“While some of these estimated increases might seem small at the national level, they would be significant for the handful of localities predicted to experience college closures in a given year,” the report said.
Yikes.
I am reminded of schools like SMU and Alabama, schools that benefit disproportionately from outstanding Athletics. But that works in FCS, D2 and D3 also, right? Anybody who wants to know why so many schools subsidize Athletics, this is exhibit A. They want to keep the doors open.
This is a deep subject for me, and I have done quite a bit of personal research on it. First, and foremost, JRsec is correct. To a degree, some of these small schools have been preparing for this occurrence/storm. Others have not, and have met the fate of the grasshopper in winter, and have not survived!!
For the ones that have survived, there are.more storms to come, and that is why they must innovate and overcome. I always keep coming back to a conundrum that Bullet posted awhile back questioning why 4 year schools have a higher tuition than 2 year schools. Some of it is because some 4 year schools are private, and therefore, more tuition dependent as opposed to being a state-funded university or college. Another reason why four year colleges have a higher tuition than two year colleges is that four year colleges go more in-depth on subjects lightly touched on in two year colleges.
But my question is this, what is the justification for charging freshmen & sophomores more in tuition at a four year college/university than what a local two year junior college would charge for basically the same thing?? Are you being charged more for a "brand??" And is it justified??
Yes, people are absolutely charged more for a brand. YMMV as to whether it’s justified or worth it for each individual situation, but top employers have a list of “target schools” for hiring and that is heavily based on brands. If you look at the elite sectors of society - Wall Street, Silicon Valley, DC, and Hollywood - they are disproportionately taking people from the most elite colleges. Sure, there is a very wide range of colleges that can give you a normal middle class lifestyle if that’s all that you’re looking for, but those aiming for the very top generally get what they pay for in terms of branding.
Also, I think people conflate wanting lower costs for college (which everyone wants) with finding the *cheapest* possible place for college. The cheapest in-person options - community colleges - are actually atrophying students worse than anyone. They have been getting absolutely pummeled on enrollment even worse than the 4-year directional schools.
“Value” or “bang for the buck” is really what people are looking for with college costs and that’s why most public flagships and flagship equivalents (e.g. Purdue, Auburn, Texas A&M, Michigan State, etc.) have largely thrived in a terrible overall environment for student enrollment that’s about the get even worse. Think shopping at Costco instead of the Dollar Store or buying a Toyota as opposed to a Yugo. That’s the mentality of people looking at college options.
It makes sense if you take a step back and look at who is most likely going to continue to seek out college educations. The typical middle to upper middle class suburban towns aren’t going to stop sending their kids to college. I have kids that will be applying to college in a couple of years at the start of the enrollment cliff and the zeal to get into top colleges is more competitive than ever and rising every year. Those aren’t the families dropping out of the college seeking race or looking at simply the cheapest possible college option, but rather the lower income and lower educated groups in society that were on the margins on whether they’d attend college before. The pool of college-going students is going to be smaller but wealthier relative to those that don’t attend college, which are the types of conditions that increase the importance of branding and reputation.
Ironically, the best way to fix the situation is to continue doing controversial things like busing migrants to states with shrinking populations. I know, I know, that's not the type of discussions we have here, but strictly from a "we want our population to grow long term instead of shrink" perspective, more people from any source is better than fewer people from any source. And more people means more kids, which means more college applicants, which means fewer schools are closing. Not saying it's the "right" solution, and I'm certainly not trying to get into a political discussion here at all, but I do wonder if States with a severe money crunch and a shrinking population might not start asking for an influx of new people eventually.
Of course, it's probably not a bad thing if the most horribly mismanaged schools close. The well funded and well run schools are not in any danger, regardless of location.
That line of thinking as it pertains to college enrollment takes 60 years to be impactful. The average college graduate from immigrant lineage occurs in the family's third generation. Immigration is not immediately impactful on enrollment. Of all of the immigrant ethnicities this is true with the exception of Asians which will produce a college graduate by the second generation.
The crises facing colleges and eventually tertiary state schools will be well underway as in multiple decades before any help from immigration occurs. This slide takes a deeper plunge by 2036 when the largest private donor sector becomes statistically irrelevant.
Good point. So, long term, States like Florida, Texas, Arizona and California seem likely to disproportionately benefit from illegal immigration, while admittedly covering extensive costs from it in the interim. Perhaps not a fair trade if you started it today in, say, Chicago with a "we're open for all your immigrant buses" sign b/c it takes decades to filter down, but the border States have already had those decades. For whatever reason, NM has not benefited from this very much, presumably b/c El Paso, Tucson, Phoenix, San Antonio and SoCal get most of the immigrants b/c it's easier to hide in their larger populations.
Kinda makes me wonder about the long term prospects of schools like UArizona, ASU and SDSU. The Texas schools are already thriving with 2 in the P2 and 5 in the M2, plus various smaller entities eyeballing moves within the g5...could we see the Arizonas and SDSU make similar moves in the future? ASU to the P2, SDSU to replace ASU? One Arizona to each of the P2? The South in general is benefiting enormously from net migration, but the Arizonas are getting net internal and net EXTERNAL migration. It's worth watching that in the medium term, despite their distant geography to the SEC and mostly-distant geography to the B1G, though they are very close to LA.
|
|