(01-11-2018 12:44 PM)Seahawkhoops Wrote:  

(01-11-2018 11:47 AM)Gary Miller Wrote:  

(01-11-2018 09:02 AM)Seahawkhoops Wrote:  

(01-10-2018 07:15 PM)Seahawk2010 Wrote:  [quote='Seahawkhoops' pid='14978397' dateline='1515620858']
On a roster of 14, State has 5 people left from last year they are 11-5

Thats like comparing apples to oranges.

It's not. Both rosters had significant turnover and lose a majority of the key contributors. One has a winning record, one doesn't(not even close)

UNCW has 3 players that played significant minutes in NCAA basketball prior to this season. Cacok, Talley, and Bryan(played 3 minutes against UVA). So that's 3 of their normal 8 man rotation.

NC State has 6 players of their 8 man rotation that have played significant minutes in NCAA basketball. 3 of which who have played/started for teams that made the Sweet 16. (A.Freeman, L. Freeman, and Abu) Dorn was Freshman POY in the CUSA, Yurtseven was a 5 star recruit. Beverly and Batts were 4 start recruits.

That is "comparing apples to oranges"

So you are counting NCAA minutes for State guys that plated elsewhere, but not counting minutes for UNCW guys that played elsewhere? Seems to be the definition of inconsistent

No, I am simply counting "significant" playing time at any D-1 NCAA Basketball Program prior to this season. So with NC State, I'm counting L. Freeman, Abu, Yurtseven, Dorn(NCSU/UNCC), A. Freeman(Baylor), Hunt (NCAT). 6/8 with 2 4 star Freshman.

UNCW I am counting Cacok, Talley, and Bryan. Fornes played sparingly but had mostly DNPs in games that mattered. Yes, Ty Taylor(Wichita State) and Kalina(UT-Chattanooga) transferred from D-1 programs. Taylor played 154 minutes and Kalina played 14 minutes in their one season before transferring. I don't consider that "significant." So that's 3/8, with 2 2 star freshman.