(Yesterday 01:29 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: (Yesterday 01:26 PM)bullet Wrote: (Yesterday 12:18 PM)Blust3 Wrote: (Yesterday 10:23 AM)bullet Wrote: (11-17-2026 02:14 PM)ThreeifbyLightning Wrote: Perhaps, but I think a) UNC is more interested in SEC and b) if SEC wants UVA and UNC they're probably going to win that battle over the BIG. FSU will never be considered on the grounds of academics. So, if these factors are true and let's just pretend it is for a moment it dilutes the premise of this. Left with Stanford, Cal, and Kansas, only Kansas gives you a new state/market plus an upper echelon program (MBB).
There's no way the BIG adds Cal or Stanford over Georgia Tech. It's the only other option on the table that's AAU, new state, new market, and new region. They could have already done it if they were going to.
FSU is academically equivalent to Nebraska, but with a lot better demographics.
That was 50 years ago. Right now, the academics ranking has jump from outside 150 to top 65. What hurts Florida State is her location. Not in a big city. Otherwise, B1G will add FSU in a heartbeat.
My point is that FSU is equivalent to an existing Big Ten member, so they are good enough.
100%
Kevin Warren told us Carolina, Miami, and FSU are on the table.
Georgia Tech and their 13% acceptance rate and drop-in-the-bucket-ATL-presence, however, are not.
Where is Kevin Warren now? He's no longer relevant to the discussion.
Look at what has gone on in the past. The Big Ten has only one non-AAU member, Nebraska who was AAU when it joined though the Big Ten realized it was likely to lose its status. Their medical school will be in their portfolio of credentials again when future AAU considerations are made and their likelihood of regaining that status is sound. Meanwhile FSU is behind quite a few schools for consideration, and the available spots are slim. I don't think they are an item on the Big Ten wish list. I could see them on FOX's wish list.
What has the SEC done? They have added the two most valuable programs from the Big 12, after adding their 4th most valuable program in A&M and a sound market add with Missouri which by itself added 6 million to the SEC footprint. Who paid for it? ESPN Why? They are practicing product placement for the enhancement of the value of all of their product being accumulated in the SEC.
I listen to the same voices telling me that ESPN won't consolidate the top product of the ACC into the SEC that once declared that Texas and Oklahoma would never leave the Big 12 and if Texas did leave it would never be for the SEC. And the same voices have been telling me for 14 years now that there's not enough value in the same thing happening to the ACC. This in the light of the declarations by the Mag 7, the desires of Cal and Stanford to be elsewhere. And now the push for Congressionally recommended caps to be raised or lifted.
The lack of comprehension here is over what the theory of product placement proves to be true. Valued brands when associated with other valued brands raises the value of all of the brands. In a retail store that means you place the most desirable brands next to each other. The interest in a consumer buying one while noticing the others and buying one of those as well is time proven. Well, in television viewing the same thing holds true when two brands are playing, and it doesn't seem to matter too much if one is well known for football and the other for basketball, as the random viewer recognizes both logos and names as being known for sports success and tunes in. If the fan is likely to be an avid fan of one sport or the other it might make a difference to them, but to Joe Blow from Idaho who doesn't care two brand names is all he/she sees.
Realignment follows the ability of schools to generate revenue. It is no accident that the Big Ten took 4 of the top 5 revenue producers from the PAC 12. Stanford was the fifth and may yet wind up in the Big Ten. Texas and Oklahoma represented 56% of the total value of the remaining Big 12 at the time of their departure and they were the #1 and #2 values for the conference when it was created. Texas A&M, Nebraska, Missouri, Kansas and Colorado were the next and 3 of those are gone. And I wouldn't be surprised if Kansas and Colorado are taken by the Big Ten or possibly the SEC for Kansas.
Last year the ACC's revenue leaders were Miami, Florida State, Clemson, Duke and North Carolina. They all make ESPN more money than they do now if they are placed with other brands. If/when the ACC does suffer a raid, these will be the targets with emphasis on new markets first and that emphasis coupled with the SEC's parameters might reach into Virginia though neither Virginia school is a viable candidate due to revenue generation. Being from a state of 9 million will be the appeal there.
The only things that will prevent further consolidation of brands among FBS college sports programs will be:
1. Congressional/Political action
2. The loss of interest in the sport they play.
The first hasn't gotten itself together on the issue and may or may not be interested in limiting size of competing conferences.
The second will remain as long as the NFL is popular as a sport. And as long as schools/states can afford to fund their top college sports schools for their facilities and athletics. So for the remainder of my life and that of a high percentage of those who post on this site it will remain viable.
The issue for the networks has been the constant accretion of the FCS programs seeking FBS status for increased revenue or to be noticed for their new associations. Every time the FBS grows so too does the desire of schools in the top conferences to separate from the one size fits all morass of the NCAA where there can't be a consensus on rules or governance because of the radically different conditions at the wealthiest institutions and the poorest ones.
I see the viable candidates for expansion into the SEC or Big Ten as being these:
Arizona, Arizona State, Colorado, Kansas, Utah from the Big 12
California, Clemson, Florida State, Georgia Tech, Miami, North Carolina, Pittsburgh, Stanford, Virginia from the ACC.
Whether the expansion is to 20 or 24 will depend upon who takes whom. If the SEC/ESPN take the Southern schools of their choice, the Big Ten will take the former PAC schools and likely Kansas. Then the expansion will be to 24. If the Big Ten/FOX land a couple of Southern schools the SEC will take 4 and we stop at 20.
Notre Dame will of course try to remain independent and unaffiliated. If successful maybe a B.Y.U. attempts the same. But the pressure simply to pick one will be there due to how scheduling is handled by the Big Ten and SEC who are already working on a scheduling agreement between the two of them.
If you move to 24 and rotate divisions in scheduling then there will be 11 conference games for each and the with the scheduling agreement it would account for all 12. Therein will reside the pressure upon Notre Dame's or Brigham Young's independence.
The point of product placement is to make all brands easy to find (in this case on the tube) and make it harder for those which would challenge them to be marketed as successfully. Whether the upper tier has 40 or 48 schools between these two conferences will determine if there are enough viable brands unclaimed to make a third conference possible for that tier. That too will be an unspoken part of the thinking going into size. If they want the process to be politically acceptable then going to 20 and leaving enough to form a viable third conference of 20 for an upper tier of 60 would be wise. If they don't have to please anyone politically and only have to meet the provisions laid out by the SCOTUS then 24 each and the elimination of all others is likely the more profitable route for them. Then the two conferences and their schools will have a voice in determining that the CFP is just theirs. And that concept is slowly emerging now. It had been unspoken of publicly and now is merely suggested, but likely the goal is to claim as much of that honeypot as they can.
Now none of this is what I would prefer, but it is how big business works.
What I would have preferred would have been a cap at 18. The SEC could have added South Florida and Kansas and let the ACC stand on its own and look for either 2 schools to promote plus Notre Dame or 1 school to promote plus Notre Dame. The Big Ten would have been done. The Big 12 could have picked up 3 and been done. I would have then hoped for the determination of the CFP entrants to have been each conference's champion and runner up. The runners up could have opened play at another conference's champion's home field. Then semifinals and finals could have been held at neutral sites bid out to the top bowls.
You see my hopes were modest changes and keep the P4 intact. But that's not going to happen. Now with a 24 team playoff the objective of the SEC and Big Ten and most particularly their network partners will be how to squeeze the most juice from their advantages. Because of that nothing is sacred to them but the objective to be what the SCOTUS has declared them to be, for profit businesses. And that means further consolidation with modifications along the way that will glean more and more of the 24 team playoff revenue for what will grow to be 2 conferences each in the hands of one network and those two networks while appearing to be rivals actually oddly intertwined through stock options.
And that Dawgma is how they will consolidate down to likely 48 schools, raise the value of those, trim the value of the rest, and through the expansion to 24 teams in a playoff make more money from all of them. Brand x 12 regular season games instead of 9 x the playoffs. Higher dollar return on advertising x a maximum number of high dollar games = greater profits.