Leaving aside the question of how to define a ‘super conference’, I think
P2 expansion to 20—24 is plausible and perhaps already in the cards.
First, we have objective evidence. Lawmakers don’t push for amendments to bills when P2 conferences have made it clear to all interested parties they will never, ever expand. And no one who believes the P2 is maxed out screams bloody murder when asked to raise or forego a supposedly unnecessary conference cap. Ergo: the door is open to expansion. Everyone with a stake knows it.
Second: anything that boosts media revenues is money in the bank. Why
wouldn’t you enhance the reach of your content? Playoff formats don’t materially alter this equation, as post-season games are just another revenue stream. If more viewers tune in to your conference games
during the season, so much the better.
Third: regular rivalry games work better in-conference. With the new 9/10 ‘power’ scheduling requirements, it makes sense for schools like Georgia, UF, Kentucky, and South Carolina to want to get Georgia Tech, Florida State and Miami, Louisville, Clemson and a North Carolina school or two under the tent. (Similar factors enter the picture with Penn State and Maryland regarding Virginia and other regional schools, or with the B1G’s western members and the 4C schools.) These are big-revenue games your conference members play anyway. Make them in-conference games and your league ‘owns’ the rivalry and garners all the media revenues. What’s more: league members who now have these games as part of their normal conference rotation are free to schedule more intriguing OOC matchups. All those teams cutting games with ND right now? They can put the Irish back on the schedule.
So no, the P2 conferences are not done bulking up. That’s what the evidence indicates. There’s still money to be made. Existing pressures still have everyone interested in that.