UofMemphis
Official MT.org Ambassador of Smack

Posts: 49,759
Joined: Mar 2004
Reputation: 1239
I Root For: Univ of Memphis
Location: Memphis (Berclair)
|
RE: G6 Top Ten Poll
(11-11-2026 10:34 PM)Gemofthehills Wrote: (11-11-2026 09:09 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote: Let’s talk about some of the garbage programs you folks keep voting for:
2. New Mexico — their best OOC win is against a bottom half of the MAC team, CMU. The rest of those wins are an FCS beat down, NMSU, and a bunch of wins against a severely weakened MWC slate
4. Liberty— they didn’t schedule a single A4 and their best OOC win is a toss up between a pair of 3 win squads CCU and Ball St. The rest is padding from a weak C-USA.
7. North Dakota St — there are hard schedules and there are soft schedules. What we have here is a cool whip schedule. No A4; fellow FCS transitioner Sac St, still FCS Fordham, a 9th MWC OOC game, and then the 1 OOC game of note—Jacksonville St. That win looks noteworthy on the surface until you see how weak their schedule is too. They’ve still managed to lose 2 games.
8. JMU — Again, no A4 opponents. Liberty is a decent win and San Diego St looked better prior to falling into the middle of the pack on the Pac 12.
Again, I think too many folks are voting and making 2 fatal flaws—
looking simply at wins and losses without factoring in who took losses from the A4 and wins from FCS.
Acting as if having the same record in all 6 conferences means the same thing. They don’t—some are a head and shoulders above the others.
Left these garbage programs
1 Boise St who has a South Dakota win and Memphis who has win over Ark St and a bunch of weak PAC schools
3 North Texas Has the Houston Christian and UNLV who has the win against winless Akron then weak AC conference games
5 Memphis look above not much
6 La Tech did beat NW State and an Army team with zero OOC wins, only wins in weak AC. Rest is weak conference game wins
9 UTSA Has win against UTRGV and Tx St who had to get into league to look better and then weak conference games
10 Ohio has the JaX State win and lost to middle of the road SBC South Alabama then weak conference games.
People are giving too much credit to Boise for having the best brand name.
Your details didnt give much of a reason to agree with your opinion after looking at the others you left out.
Memphis had Arkansas back out on us this season and Miss State next season...not much we can do to control that. we were lucky to get Boise and UNLV the same season considering we had to move stuff around.
|
|
| 11-13-2026 02:04 PM |
|
Gemofthehills
Heisman

Posts: 5,184
Joined: Jan 2005
Reputation: 343
I Root For: JSU
Location:
|
RE: G6 Top Ten Poll
(11-13-2026 02:04 PM)UofMemphis Wrote: (11-11-2026 10:34 PM)Gemofthehills Wrote: (11-11-2026 09:09 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote: Let’s talk about some of the garbage programs you folks keep voting for:
2. New Mexico — their best OOC win is against a bottom half of the MAC team, CMU. The rest of those wins are an FCS beat down, NMSU, and a bunch of wins against a severely weakened MWC slate
4. Liberty— they didn’t schedule a single A4 and their best OOC win is a toss up between a pair of 3 win squads CCU and Ball St. The rest is padding from a weak C-USA.
7. North Dakota St — there are hard schedules and there are soft schedules. What we have here is a cool whip schedule. No A4; fellow FCS transitioner Sac St, still FCS Fordham, a 9th MWC OOC game, and then the 1 OOC game of note—Jacksonville St. That win looks noteworthy on the surface until you see how weak their schedule is too. They’ve still managed to lose 2 games.
8. JMU — Again, no A4 opponents. Liberty is a decent win and San Diego St looked better prior to falling into the middle of the pack on the Pac 12.
Again, I think too many folks are voting and making 2 fatal flaws—
looking simply at wins and losses without factoring in who took losses from the A4 and wins from FCS.
Acting as if having the same record in all 6 conferences means the same thing. They don’t—some are a head and shoulders above the others.
Left these garbage programs
1 Boise St who has a South Dakota win and Memphis who has win over Ark St and a bunch of weak PAC schools
3 North Texas Has the Houston Christian and UNLV who has the win against winless Akron then weak AC conference games
5 Memphis look above not much
6 La Tech did beat NW State and an Army team with zero OOC wins, only wins in weak AC. Rest is weak conference game wins
9 UTSA Has win against UTRGV and Tx St who had to get into league to look better and then weak conference games
10 Ohio has the JaX State win and lost to middle of the road SBC South Alabama then weak conference games.
People are giving too much credit to Boise for having the best brand name.
Your details didnt give much of a reason to agree with your opinion after looking at the others you left out.
Memphis had Arkansas back out on us this season and Miss State next season...not much we can do to control that. we were lucky to get Boise and UNLV the same season considering we had to move stuff around.
If memory is correct, I think a few teams had P2 and M2 schools back out. Not much you can do but find any team available.
|
|
| 11-13-2026 04:22 PM |
|
TrojanCampaign
Heisman

Posts: 6,093
Joined: Sep 2011
Reputation: 335
I Root For: USC, AAMU,
Location: Huntsville
|
RE: G6 Top Ten Poll
(11-12-2026 08:42 AM)Gemofthehills Wrote: Trying sell anyone on this team or that team has a tougher schedule in G6 is laughable. Very few teams are even above the average G6 team this year and very few of those are playing each other. No big P2 or M2 win, which is causing the degrading having a good loss debate. Just several teams about as good as the other one.
Are you trying to tell me that a 4-5 PAC-12 team is not a national championship contender? It's unfair because they have such a tough schedule man. Utah State had to play Colorado State AND Fresno State!
As I have brought up several times these metrics are bogus. Like how people were bragging about Utah State nearly beating ranked Washington early in the season.
Meanwhile Washingtons wins are :
Washington State
Utah State
Eastern Washington
Purdue
Nebraska
Pounding your chest about losing to a bunch of Big 10/12 teams this season has been so strange.
|
|
| 11-13-2026 04:26 PM |
|
DavidSt
Legend

Posts: 27,080
Joined: Dec 2013
Reputation: 1157
I Root For: ATU, P7
Location:
|
RE: G6 Top Ten Poll
(11-13-2026 09:19 AM)Bobcat2013 Wrote: (11-12-2026 10:40 PM)DavidSt Wrote: Boise State nearly lost to South Dakota as they were trailing themBoise was winning a majority of the game and won by 14..., Fresno State who lost to last place Utah State and almost lost to Texas StateUtah State is tied for 2nd in the PAC and Fresno hasn't played TXST yet. Boise State only wins of note is Western michigan, but their game against Michigan was a fluke and MemphisYou wanna dog teams for "nearly lost" but don't wanna give credit to them for almost beating Oregon?. Memphis blow out by Tulane and Tulane got blow out by UTSA makes Boise State's win looked bad.
NDSU's losses are two tough teams in the MWC in UNLV and New Mexico, UNLV has been getting dog walked but they did beat Jacksonville State and Air force. They also beat 6-3 Wyoming. That wyoming team got handled by a bad PAC team in CSU
New mexico lost to Oklahoma in a close game [/b] again here you wanna give credit for a close lose for one team but not another, but beat NDSU. They still have to play 7-2 Air Force, 6-3 Wyoming and 5-4 UNLV.
PAC 12 left a lot on the table because would Boise State lose to NDSU, Air Force, Wyoming, UNLV and New Mexico? I could say yes. [b]New Mexico might get it done vs Boise, I doubt the rest would.
I am A Boise State fan, but I don't think they are good this year. If they between 2000 and 2012 teams? They would beat Oregon. Utah State is a garbage team and one of those that should have been left behind.
|
|
| 11-13-2026 05:43 PM |
|
WesternDave
All American

Posts: 2,704
Joined: Jul 2020
Reputation: 80
I Root For: WMU
Location:
|
RE: G6 Top Ten Poll
(11-12-2026 10:40 PM)DavidSt Wrote: Boise State nearly lost to South Dakota as they were trailing them, Fresno State who lost to last place Utah State and almost lost to Texas State. Boise State only wins of note is Western michigan, but their game against Michigan was a fluke and Memphis. Memphis blow out by Tulane and Tulane got blow out by UTSA makes Boise State's win looked bad.
NDSU's losses are two tough teams in the MWC in UNLV and New Mexico, but they did beat Jacksonville State and Air force. They also beat 6-3 Wyoming.
New mexico lost to Oklahoma in a close game, but beat NDSU. They still have to play 7-2 Air Force, 6-3 Wyoming and 5-4 UNLV.
PAC 12 left a lot on the table because would Boise State lose to NDSU, Air Force, Wyoming, UNLV and New Mexico? I could say yes.
WMUs win over Michigan was not a fluke because Michigan State did the exact same thing to them last weekend.
(This post was last modified: 11-14-2026 12:22 AM by WesternDave.)
|
|
| 11-14-2026 12:19 AM |
|
Memphis Yankee
Hall of Famer

Posts: 15,390
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 1943
I Root For: Memphis
Location: Lake Mills, WI
|
RE: G6 Top Ten Poll
(11-12-2026 10:53 AM)Gemofthehills Wrote: (11-12-2026 08:48 AM)Bobcat2013 Wrote: (11-11-2026 10:57 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (11-11-2026 10:34 PM)Gemofthehills Wrote: (11-11-2026 09:09 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote: Let’s talk about some of the garbage programs you folks keep voting for:
2. New Mexico — their best OOC win is against a bottom half of the MAC team, CMU. The rest of those wins are an FCS beat down, NMSU, and a bunch of wins against a severely weakened MWC slate
4. Liberty— they didn’t schedule a single A4 and their best OOC win is a toss up between a pair of 3 win squads CCU and Ball St. The rest is padding from a weak C-USA.
7. North Dakota St — there are hard schedules and there are soft schedules. What we have here is a cool whip schedule. No A4; fellow FCS transitioner Sac St, still FCS Fordham, a 9th MWC OOC game, and then the 1 OOC game of note—Jacksonville St. That win looks noteworthy on the surface until you see how weak their schedule is too. They’ve still managed to lose 2 games.
8. JMU — Again, no A4 opponents. Liberty is a decent win and San Diego St looked better prior to falling into the middle of the pack on the Pac 12.
Again, I think too many folks are voting and making 2 fatal flaws—
looking simply at wins and losses without factoring in who took losses from the A4 and wins from FCS.
Acting as if having the same record in all 6 conferences means the same thing. They don’t—some are a head and shoulders above the others.
Left these garbage programs
1 Boise St who has a South Dakota win and Memphis who has win over Ark St and a bunch of weak PAC schools
3 North Texas Has the Houston Christian and UNLV who has the win against winless Akron then weak AC conference games
5 Memphis look above not much
6 La Tech did beat NW State and an Army team with zero OOC wins, only wins in weak AC. Rest is weak conference game wins
9 UTSA Has win against UTRGV and Tx St who had to get into league to look better and then weak conference games
10 Ohio has the JaX State win and lost to middle of the road SBC South Alabama then weak conference games.
People are giving too much credit to Boise for having the best brand name.
Your details didnt give much of a reason to agree with your opinion after looking at the others you left out.
FYI, MC has the Pac 12 ranked as the strongest g6 conference right now.
He knows, he's just trying to cope with the fact that CUSA is arguably the worst conference.
No I dont know and neither does anyone. CUSA is arguably the worst or you could argue the best. Not much to separate any of the leagues. I would not have CUSA at the top if looking at the entire conference teams. Probably a battle this year with MWC and AC. Neither are head and heels above the others on the playing field.
I would argue CUSA is the worst. You have two teams undefeated in conference that haven't gotten a quality win. Liberty came the closest losing to JMU 21-13. Jax State lost to NDSU 33-7. Of the conferences ten teams, seven are under .500 in conference/overall. Of the three teams above .500 not one has a quality win. You had three marquee games out of conference with, JMU, NDSU, and Ohio, but lost all three games. From what I could see the conferences best win is MTSU 5-4 over Marshall 5-4.
|
|
| 11-14-2026 07:03 AM |
|
Gemofthehills
Heisman

Posts: 5,184
Joined: Jan 2005
Reputation: 343
I Root For: JSU
Location:
|
RE: G6 Top Ten Poll
(11-14-2026 07:03 AM)Memphis Yankee Wrote: (11-12-2026 10:53 AM)Gemofthehills Wrote: (11-12-2026 08:48 AM)Bobcat2013 Wrote: (11-11-2026 10:57 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (11-11-2026 10:34 PM)Gemofthehills Wrote: Left these garbage programs
1 Boise St who has a South Dakota win and Memphis who has win over Ark St and a bunch of weak PAC schools
3 North Texas Has the Houston Christian and UNLV who has the win against winless Akron then weak AC conference games
5 Memphis look above not much
6 La Tech did beat NW State and an Army team with zero OOC wins, only wins in weak AC. Rest is weak conference game wins
9 UTSA Has win against UTRGV and Tx St who had to get into league to look better and then weak conference games
10 Ohio has the JaX State win and lost to middle of the road SBC South Alabama then weak conference games.
People are giving too much credit to Boise for having the best brand name.
Your details didnt give much of a reason to agree with your opinion after looking at the others you left out.
FYI, MC has the Pac 12 ranked as the strongest g6 conference right now.
He knows, he's just trying to cope with the fact that CUSA is arguably the worst conference.
No I dont know and neither does anyone. CUSA is arguably the worst or you could argue the best. Not much to separate any of the leagues. I would not have CUSA at the top if looking at the entire conference teams. Probably a battle this year with MWC and AC. Neither are head and heels above the others on the playing field.
I would argue CUSA is the worst. You have two teams undefeated in conference that haven't gotten a quality win. Liberty came the closest losing to JMU 21-13. Jax State lost to NDSU 33-7. Of the conferences ten teams, seven are under .500 in conference/overall. Of the three teams above .500 not one has a quality win. You had three marquee games out of conference with, JMU, NDSU, and Ohio, but lost all three games. From what I could see the conferences best win is MTSU 5-4 over Marshall 5-4.
JaX State has a win over SBC East leading GaSo.
AC has the big wins over? UNLV who is 5-4 middle of the road MWC team, Tx State a 5-4 guess they are top level PAC, OK St is your big win but its by a team not even being mentioned in CFP debate. Appears AC is in the running with CUSA.
AC loss its big games to Boise St, La Tech, Air Force ULaLa, App St X2, Toledo, UCONN WMU and of course The Citadel (FCS).
Dont see any FCS losses on CUSA resume.
|
|
| 11-14-2026 07:58 AM |
|
ken d
Hall of Famer

Posts: 21,310
Joined: Dec 2013
Reputation: 2032
I Root For: college sports
Location: Raleigh
|
RE: G6 Top Ten Poll
(11-14-2026 07:58 AM)Gemofthehills Wrote: (11-14-2026 07:03 AM)Memphis Yankee Wrote: (11-12-2026 10:53 AM)Gemofthehills Wrote: (11-12-2026 08:48 AM)Bobcat2013 Wrote: (11-11-2026 10:57 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: FYI, MC has the Pac 12 ranked as the strongest g6 conference right now.
He knows, he's just trying to cope with the fact that CUSA is arguably the worst conference.
No I dont know and neither does anyone. CUSA is arguably the worst or you could argue the best. Not much to separate any of the leagues. I would not have CUSA at the top if looking at the entire conference teams. Probably a battle this year with MWC and AC. Neither are head and heels above the others on the playing field.
I would argue CUSA is the worst. You have two teams undefeated in conference that haven't gotten a quality win. Liberty came the closest losing to JMU 21-13. Jax State lost to NDSU 33-7. Of the conferences ten teams, seven are under .500 in conference/overall. Of the three teams above .500 not one has a quality win. You had three marquee games out of conference with, JMU, NDSU, and Ohio, but lost all three games. From what I could see the conferences best win is MTSU 5-4 over Marshall 5-4.
JaX State has a win over SBC East leading GaSo. Which is also 5-4 (middle of the road). You can't have it both ways.
AC has the big wins over? UNLV who is 5-4 middle of the road MWC team, Tx State a 5-4 guess they are top level PAC, OK St is your big win but its by a team not even being mentioned in CFP debate. Appears AC is in the running with CUSA.
AC loss its big games to Boise St, La Tech, Air Force ULaLa, App St X2, Toledo, UCONN WMU and of course The Citadel (FCS).
Dont see any FCS losses on CUSA resume.
|
|
| 11-14-2026 08:19 AM |
|
Gemofthehills
Heisman

Posts: 5,184
Joined: Jan 2005
Reputation: 343
I Root For: JSU
Location:
|
RE: G6 Top Ten Poll
(11-14-2026 08:19 AM)ken d Wrote: (11-14-2026 07:58 AM)Gemofthehills Wrote: (11-14-2026 07:03 AM)Memphis Yankee Wrote: (11-12-2026 10:53 AM)Gemofthehills Wrote: (11-12-2026 08:48 AM)Bobcat2013 Wrote: He knows, he's just trying to cope with the fact that CUSA is arguably the worst conference.
No I dont know and neither does anyone. CUSA is arguably the worst or you could argue the best. Not much to separate any of the leagues. I would not have CUSA at the top if looking at the entire conference teams. Probably a battle this year with MWC and AC. Neither are head and heels above the others on the playing field.
I would argue CUSA is the worst. You have two teams undefeated in conference that haven't gotten a quality win. Liberty came the closest losing to JMU 21-13. Jax State lost to NDSU 33-7. Of the conferences ten teams, seven are under .500 in conference/overall. Of the three teams above .500 not one has a quality win. You had three marquee games out of conference with, JMU, NDSU, and Ohio, but lost all three games. From what I could see the conferences best win is MTSU 5-4 over Marshall 5-4.
JaX State has a win over SBC East leading GaSo. Which is also 5-4 (middle of the road). You can't have it both ways.
AC has the big wins over? UNLV who is 5-4 middle of the road MWC team, Tx State a 5-4 guess they are top level PAC, OK St is your big win but its by a team not even being mentioned in CFP debate. Appears AC is in the running with CUSA.
AC loss its big games to Boise St, La Tech, Air Force ULaLa, App St X2, Toledo, UCONN WMU and of course The Citadel (FCS).
Dont see any FCS losses on CUSA resume.
Not having it both ways, GaSo is at the top of the SBC East while UNLV is in the middle of the MWC. Two of GaSo losses are to M2 schools while all of UNLVs losses are to G6 schools. Both teams losses to G6 teams have been to good G6 teams.
|
|
| 11-14-2026 08:39 AM |
|
Gemofthehills
Heisman

Posts: 5,184
Joined: Jan 2005
Reputation: 343
I Root For: JSU
Location:
|
RE: G6 Top Ten Poll
(11-13-2026 05:43 PM)DavidSt Wrote: (11-13-2026 09:19 AM)Bobcat2013 Wrote: (11-12-2026 10:40 PM)DavidSt Wrote: Boise State nearly lost to South Dakota as they were trailing themBoise was winning a majority of the game and won by 14..., Fresno State who lost to last place Utah State and almost lost to Texas StateUtah State is tied for 2nd in the PAC and Fresno hasn't played TXST yet. Boise State only wins of note is Western michigan, but their game against Michigan was a fluke and MemphisYou wanna dog teams for "nearly lost" but don't wanna give credit to them for almost beating Oregon?. Memphis blow out by Tulane and Tulane got blow out by UTSA makes Boise State's win looked bad.
NDSU's losses are two tough teams in the MWC in UNLV and New Mexico, UNLV has been getting dog walked but they did beat Jacksonville State and Air force. They also beat 6-3 Wyoming. That wyoming team got handled by a bad PAC team in CSU
New mexico lost to Oklahoma in a close game [/b] again here you wanna give credit for a close lose for one team but not another, but beat NDSU. They still have to play 7-2 Air Force, 6-3 Wyoming and 5-4 UNLV.
PAC 12 left a lot on the table because would Boise State lose to NDSU, Air Force, Wyoming, UNLV and New Mexico? I could say yes. [b]New Mexico might get it done vs Boise, I doubt the rest would.
I am A Boise State fan, but I don't think they are good this year. If they between 2000 and 2012 teams? They would beat Oregon. Utah State is a garbage team and one of those that should have been left behind.
Boise St is as good as any of the top level G6 teams. Agree not as good as the 2000 or 2012 teams but as good as this years slate.
(This post was last modified: 11-14-2026 08:43 AM by Gemofthehills.)
|
|
| 11-14-2026 08:42 AM |
|
Memphis Yankee
Hall of Famer

Posts: 15,390
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 1943
I Root For: Memphis
Location: Lake Mills, WI
|
RE: G6 Top Ten Poll
(11-14-2026 07:58 AM)Gemofthehills Wrote: (11-14-2026 07:03 AM)Memphis Yankee Wrote: (11-12-2026 10:53 AM)Gemofthehills Wrote: (11-12-2026 08:48 AM)Bobcat2013 Wrote: (11-11-2026 10:57 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: FYI, MC has the Pac 12 ranked as the strongest g6 conference right now.
He knows, he's just trying to cope with the fact that CUSA is arguably the worst conference.
No I dont know and neither does anyone. CUSA is arguably the worst or you could argue the best. Not much to separate any of the leagues. I would not have CUSA at the top if looking at the entire conference teams. Probably a battle this year with MWC and AC. Neither are head and heels above the others on the playing field.
I would argue CUSA is the worst. You have two teams undefeated in conference that haven't gotten a quality win. Liberty came the closest losing to JMU 21-13. Jax State lost to NDSU 33-7. Of the conferences ten teams, seven are under .500 in conference/overall. Of the three teams above .500 not one has a quality win. You had three marquee games out of conference with, JMU, NDSU, and Ohio, but lost all three games. From what I could see the conferences best win is MTSU 5-4 over Marshall 5-4.
JaX State has a win over SBC East leading GaSo.
AC has the big wins over? UNLV who is 5-4 middle of the road MWC team, Tx State a 5-4 guess they are top level PAC, OK St is your big win but its by a team not even being mentioned in CFP debate. Appears AC is in the running with CUSA.
AC loss its big games to Boise St, La Tech, Air Force ULaLa, App St X2, Toledo, UCONN WMU and of course The Citadel (FCS).
Dont see any FCS losses on CUSA resume.
Are you honestly trying to compare CUSA to the American? Our 10th place team USF has a 6-4 record. Compare that to your 10th place team Sam Houston who's 1-8 averaging 9.4 points a game in conference. Half your conference is at 3-6 overall or worse. 70% of your conference has an overall record of 21-42. It's going to be tough sledding making a case for a team from CUSA getting to the CFP.
|
|
| 11-14-2026 09:12 AM |
|
Gemofthehills
Heisman

Posts: 5,184
Joined: Jan 2005
Reputation: 343
I Root For: JSU
Location:
|
RE: G6 Top Ten Poll
(11-14-2026 09:12 AM)Memphis Yankee Wrote: (11-14-2026 07:58 AM)Gemofthehills Wrote: (11-14-2026 07:03 AM)Memphis Yankee Wrote: (11-12-2026 10:53 AM)Gemofthehills Wrote: (11-12-2026 08:48 AM)Bobcat2013 Wrote: He knows, he's just trying to cope with the fact that CUSA is arguably the worst conference.
No I dont know and neither does anyone. CUSA is arguably the worst or you could argue the best. Not much to separate any of the leagues. I would not have CUSA at the top if looking at the entire conference teams. Probably a battle this year with MWC and AC. Neither are head and heels above the others on the playing field.
I would argue CUSA is the worst. You have two teams undefeated in conference that haven't gotten a quality win. Liberty came the closest losing to JMU 21-13. Jax State lost to NDSU 33-7. Of the conferences ten teams, seven are under .500 in conference/overall. Of the three teams above .500 not one has a quality win. You had three marquee games out of conference with, JMU, NDSU, and Ohio, but lost all three games. From what I could see the conferences best win is MTSU 5-4 over Marshall 5-4.
JaX State has a win over SBC East leading GaSo.
AC has the big wins over? UNLV who is 5-4 middle of the road MWC team, Tx State a 5-4 guess they are top level PAC, OK St is your big win but its by a team not even being mentioned in CFP debate. Appears AC is in the running with CUSA.
AC loss its big games to Boise St, La Tech, Air Force ULaLa, App St X2, Toledo, UCONN WMU and of course The Citadel (FCS).
Dont see any FCS losses on CUSA resume.
Are you honestly trying to compare CUSA to the American? Our 10th place team USF has a 6-4 record. Compare that to your 10th place team Sam Houston who's 1-8 averaging 5.2 points a game in conference. Half your conference is at 3-6 overall or worse. 70% of your conference has an overall record of 21-42. It's going to be tough sledding making a case for a team from CUSA getting to the CFP.
Your last place team has one win against Houston Christian. And average diff versus conference mates is 14 while Sam Houston stayed within 6 of a middle level AC team Tulsa. Sam is averaging losing by 21 in CUSA.
Hope your not really believing AC is better than CUSA?
|
|
| 11-14-2026 09:34 AM |
|
bill dazzle
Craft beer and urban living enthusiast

Posts: 18,679
Joined: Aug 2016
Reputation: 2041
I Root For: Vanderbilt
Location: Nashville
|
RE: G6 Top Ten Poll
(11-14-2026 09:34 AM)Gemofthehills Wrote: (11-14-2026 09:12 AM)Memphis Yankee Wrote: (11-14-2026 07:58 AM)Gemofthehills Wrote: (11-14-2026 07:03 AM)Memphis Yankee Wrote: (11-12-2026 10:53 AM)Gemofthehills Wrote: No I dont know and neither does anyone. CUSA is arguably the worst or you could argue the best. Not much to separate any of the leagues. I would not have CUSA at the top if looking at the entire conference teams. Probably a battle this year with MWC and AC. Neither are head and heels above the others on the playing field.
I would argue CUSA is the worst. You have two teams undefeated in conference that haven't gotten a quality win. Liberty came the closest losing to JMU 21-13. Jax State lost to NDSU 33-7. Of the conferences ten teams, seven are under .500 in conference/overall. Of the three teams above .500 not one has a quality win. You had three marquee games out of conference with, JMU, NDSU, and Ohio, but lost all three games. From what I could see the conferences best win is MTSU 5-4 over Marshall 5-4.
JaX State has a win over SBC East leading GaSo.
AC has the big wins over? UNLV who is 5-4 middle of the road MWC team, Tx State a 5-4 guess they are top level PAC, OK St is your big win but its by a team not even being mentioned in CFP debate. Appears AC is in the running with CUSA.
AC loss its big games to Boise St, La Tech, Air Force ULaLa, App St X2, Toledo, UCONN WMU and of course The Citadel (FCS).
Dont see any FCS losses on CUSA resume.
Are you honestly trying to compare CUSA to the American? Our 10th place team USF has a 6-4 record. Compare that to your 10th place team Sam Houston who's 1-8 averaging 5.2 points a game in conference. Half your conference is at 3-6 overall or worse. 70% of your conference has an overall record of 21-42. It's going to be tough sledding making a case for a team from CUSA getting to the CFP.
Your last place team has one win against Houston Christian. And average diff versus conference mates is 14 while Sam Houston stayed within 6 of a middle level AC team Tulsa. Sam is averaging losing by 21 in CUSA.
Hope your not really believing AC is better than CUSA?
My father watches lots of C-USA and American games (I sometimes watch with him during the week, as I live with my elderly parents Tue-Friday to assist them). We follow/cheer for Memphis and Middle Tennessee State. MTSU plays Liberty today and I plan to watch some of that game.
All this to say ...
Based on what I've seen this season, Gem, the American is better than C-USA. The differential is not dramatic — but it's noticeable.
I want both C-USA and the American to do well so as to indirectly benefit MTSU and Memphis, respectively. So I would hope that I'm not too biased when I note the AC is "better" (very subjective term, no doubt) than C-USA. I'm neither "pro" nor "anti" either league (in a general sense).
Obviously, this is just my opinion.
(This post was last modified: 11-14-2026 10:29 AM by bill dazzle.)
|
|
| 11-14-2026 10:28 AM |
|
Gemofthehills
Heisman

Posts: 5,184
Joined: Jan 2005
Reputation: 343
I Root For: JSU
Location:
|
RE: G6 Top Ten Poll
(11-14-2026 10:28 AM)bill dazzle Wrote: (11-14-2026 09:34 AM)Gemofthehills Wrote: (11-14-2026 09:12 AM)Memphis Yankee Wrote: (11-14-2026 07:58 AM)Gemofthehills Wrote: (11-14-2026 07:03 AM)Memphis Yankee Wrote: I would argue CUSA is the worst. You have two teams undefeated in conference that haven't gotten a quality win. Liberty came the closest losing to JMU 21-13. Jax State lost to NDSU 33-7. Of the conferences ten teams, seven are under .500 in conference/overall. Of the three teams above .500 not one has a quality win. You had three marquee games out of conference with, JMU, NDSU, and Ohio, but lost all three games. From what I could see the conferences best win is MTSU 5-4 over Marshall 5-4.
JaX State has a win over SBC East leading GaSo.
AC has the big wins over? UNLV who is 5-4 middle of the road MWC team, Tx State a 5-4 guess they are top level PAC, OK St is your big win but its by a team not even being mentioned in CFP debate. Appears AC is in the running with CUSA.
AC loss its big games to Boise St, La Tech, Air Force ULaLa, App St X2, Toledo, UCONN WMU and of course The Citadel (FCS).
Dont see any FCS losses on CUSA resume.
Are you honestly trying to compare CUSA to the American? Our 10th place team USF has a 6-4 record. Compare that to your 10th place team Sam Houston who's 1-8 averaging 5.2 points a game in conference. Half your conference is at 3-6 overall or worse. 70% of your conference has an overall record of 21-42. It's going to be tough sledding making a case for a team from CUSA getting to the CFP.
Your last place team has one win against Houston Christian. And average diff versus conference mates is 14 while Sam Houston stayed within 6 of a middle level AC team Tulsa. Sam is averaging losing by 21 in CUSA.
Hope your not really believing AC is better than CUSA?
My father watches lots of C-USA and American games (I sometimes watch with him during the week, as I live with my elderly parents Tue-Friday to assist them). We follow/cheer for Memphis and Middle Tennessee State. MTSU plays Liberty today and I plan to watch some of that game.
All this to say ...
Based on what I've seen this season, Gem, the American is better than C-USA. The differential is not dramatic — but it's noticeable.
I want both C-USA and the American to do well so as to indirectly benefit MTSU and Memphis, respectively. So I would hope that I'm not too biased when I note the AC is "better" (very subjective term, no doubt) than C-USA. I'm neither "pro" nor "anti" either league (in a general sense).
Obviously, this is just my opinion.

I dont disagree with you. Just hard to understand how any fan of any G6 conference can dog the other when the delta of difference isnt real wide. The top teams arent much different either and those are the only ones which matter in the CFP world.
Hell none look great this year and a bad team can lose any game. Not saying the tops are bad but none are even in the G6 great level.
|
|
| 11-14-2026 10:36 AM |
|
billybobby777
The REAL BillyBobby

Posts: 14,636
Joined: May 2013
Reputation: 755
I Root For: ECU, Army
Location: Houston dont sleepon
|
RE: G6 Top Ten Poll
(11-14-2026 10:28 AM)bill dazzle Wrote: (11-14-2026 09:34 AM)Gemofthehills Wrote: (11-14-2026 09:12 AM)Memphis Yankee Wrote: (11-14-2026 07:58 AM)Gemofthehills Wrote: (11-14-2026 07:03 AM)Memphis Yankee Wrote: I would argue CUSA is the worst. You have two teams undefeated in conference that haven't gotten a quality win. Liberty came the closest losing to JMU 21-13. Jax State lost to NDSU 33-7. Of the conferences ten teams, seven are under .500 in conference/overall. Of the three teams above .500 not one has a quality win. You had three marquee games out of conference with, JMU, NDSU, and Ohio, but lost all three games. From what I could see the conferences best win is MTSU 5-4 over Marshall 5-4.
JaX State has a win over SBC East leading GaSo.
AC has the big wins over? UNLV who is 5-4 middle of the road MWC team, Tx State a 5-4 guess they are top level PAC, OK St is your big win but its by a team not even being mentioned in CFP debate. Appears AC is in the running with CUSA.
AC loss its big games to Boise St, La Tech, Air Force ULaLa, App St X2, Toledo, UCONN WMU and of course The Citadel (FCS).
Dont see any FCS losses on CUSA resume.
Are you honestly trying to compare CUSA to the American? Our 10th place team USF has a 6-4 record. Compare that to your 10th place team Sam Houston who's 1-8 averaging 5.2 points a game in conference. Half your conference is at 3-6 overall or worse. 70% of your conference has an overall record of 21-42. It's going to be tough sledding making a case for a team from CUSA getting to the CFP.
Your last place team has one win against Houston Christian. And average diff versus conference mates is 14 while Sam Houston stayed within 6 of a middle level AC team Tulsa. Sam is averaging losing by 21 in CUSA.
Hope your not really believing AC is better than CUSA?
My father watches lots of C-USA and American games (I sometimes watch with him during the week, as I live with my elderly parents Tue-Friday to assist them). We follow/cheer for Memphis and Middle Tennessee State. MTSU plays Liberty today and I plan to watch some of that game.
All this to say ...
Based on what I've seen this season, Gem, the American is better than C-USA. The differential is not dramatic — but it's noticeable.
I want both C-USA and the American to do well so as to indirectly benefit MTSU and Memphis, respectively. So I would hope that I'm not too biased when I note the AC is "better" (very subjective term, no doubt) than C-USA. I'm neither "pro" nor "anti" either league (in a general sense).
Obviously, this is just my opinion.

AC may be down this year but still way above CUSA. And the MAC and SB. If you want to argue the PAC or even MWC those are closer (Boise and the 7 dwarfs) but take away some truly horrible teams at the bottom such as Charlotte, Rice, Temple and Tulane and such and the AC is the best of the G6.
|
|
| 11-14-2026 10:38 AM |
|
PicksUp
All American

Posts: 3,619
Joined: Mar 2018
Reputation: 287
I Root For: UTEP, Texas
Location:
|
RE: G6 Top Ten Poll
(11-14-2026 10:36 AM)Gemofthehills Wrote: (11-14-2026 10:28 AM)bill dazzle Wrote: (11-14-2026 09:34 AM)Gemofthehills Wrote: (11-14-2026 09:12 AM)Memphis Yankee Wrote: (11-14-2026 07:58 AM)Gemofthehills Wrote: JaX State has a win over SBC East leading GaSo.
AC has the big wins over? UNLV who is 5-4 middle of the road MWC team, Tx State a 5-4 guess they are top level PAC, OK St is your big win but its by a team not even being mentioned in CFP debate. Appears AC is in the running with CUSA.
AC loss its big games to Boise St, La Tech, Air Force ULaLa, App St X2, Toledo, UCONN WMU and of course The Citadel (FCS).
Dont see any FCS losses on CUSA resume.
Are you honestly trying to compare CUSA to the American? Our 10th place team USF has a 6-4 record. Compare that to your 10th place team Sam Houston who's 1-8 averaging 5.2 points a game in conference. Half your conference is at 3-6 overall or worse. 70% of your conference has an overall record of 21-42. It's going to be tough sledding making a case for a team from CUSA getting to the CFP.
Your last place team has one win against Houston Christian. And average diff versus conference mates is 14 while Sam Houston stayed within 6 of a middle level AC team Tulsa. Sam is averaging losing by 21 in CUSA.
Hope your not really believing AC is better than CUSA?
My father watches lots of C-USA and American games (I sometimes watch with him during the week, as I live with my elderly parents Tue-Friday to assist them). We follow/cheer for Memphis and Middle Tennessee State. MTSU plays Liberty today and I plan to watch some of that game.
All this to say ...
Based on what I've seen this season, Gem, the American is better than C-USA. The differential is not dramatic — but it's noticeable.
I want both C-USA and the American to do well so as to indirectly benefit MTSU and Memphis, respectively. So I would hope that I'm not too biased when I note the AC is "better" (very subjective term, no doubt) than C-USA. I'm neither "pro" nor "anti" either league (in a general sense).
Obviously, this is just my opinion.

I dont disagree with you. Just hard to understand how any fan of any G6 conference can dog the other when the delta of difference isnt real wide. The top teams arent much different either and those are the only ones which matter in the CFP world.
Hell none look great this year and a bad team can lose any game. Not saying the tops are bad but none are even in the G6 great level.
There’s dozens of data points this year to make a distinction. There are hundreds over the past few years. Do you think we should just ignore the few data points we have?
|
|
| 11-14-2026 12:03 PM |
|
bill dazzle
Craft beer and urban living enthusiast

Posts: 18,679
Joined: Aug 2016
Reputation: 2041
I Root For: Vanderbilt
Location: Nashville
|
RE: G6 Top Ten Poll
(11-14-2026 10:36 AM)Gemofthehills Wrote: (11-14-2026 10:28 AM)bill dazzle Wrote: (11-14-2026 09:34 AM)Gemofthehills Wrote: (11-14-2026 09:12 AM)Memphis Yankee Wrote: (11-14-2026 07:58 AM)Gemofthehills Wrote: JaX State has a win over SBC East leading GaSo.
AC has the big wins over? UNLV who is 5-4 middle of the road MWC team, Tx State a 5-4 guess they are top level PAC, OK St is your big win but its by a team not even being mentioned in CFP debate. Appears AC is in the running with CUSA.
AC loss its big games to Boise St, La Tech, Air Force ULaLa, App St X2, Toledo, UCONN WMU and of course The Citadel (FCS).
Dont see any FCS losses on CUSA resume.
Are you honestly trying to compare CUSA to the American? Our 10th place team USF has a 6-4 record. Compare that to your 10th place team Sam Houston who's 1-8 averaging 5.2 points a game in conference. Half your conference is at 3-6 overall or worse. 70% of your conference has an overall record of 21-42. It's going to be tough sledding making a case for a team from CUSA getting to the CFP.
Your last place team has one win against Houston Christian. And average diff versus conference mates is 14 while Sam Houston stayed within 6 of a middle level AC team Tulsa. Sam is averaging losing by 21 in CUSA.
Hope your not really believing AC is better than CUSA?
My father watches lots of C-USA and American games (I sometimes watch with him during the week, as I live with my elderly parents Tue-Friday to assist them). We follow/cheer for Memphis and Middle Tennessee State. MTSU plays Liberty today and I plan to watch some of that game.
All this to say ...
Based on what I've seen this season, Gem, the American is better than C-USA. The differential is not dramatic — but it's noticeable.
I want both C-USA and the American to do well so as to indirectly benefit MTSU and Memphis, respectively. So I would hope that I'm not too biased when I note the AC is "better" (very subjective term, no doubt) than C-USA. I'm neither "pro" nor "anti" either league (in a general sense).
Obviously, this is just my opinion.

I dont disagree with you. Just hard to understand how any fan of any G6 conference can dog the other when the delta of difference isnt real wide. The top teams arent much different either and those are the only ones which matter in the CFP world.
Hell none look great this year and a bad team can lose any game. Not saying the tops are bad but none are even in the G6 great level.
The American and the PAC are perceived in a general sense, and understandably so, IMO as more "sexy," than the other four G conferences, Gem. And we all know this perception is based on budgets, name recognition, basketball, academics, etc. As such, the AC and the PAC in football are often given more credit than is due for what specifically happens on the field. That's how the "differential" is created.
I agree that the six G leagues look reasonably equal on the field this year.
I like the look of the C-USA teams collectively. Respectable.
(This post was last modified: 11-14-2026 01:46 PM by bill dazzle.)
|
|
| 11-14-2026 12:49 PM |
|
Bobcat2013
Heisman

Posts: 5,772
Joined: May 2013
Reputation: 326
I Root For: Texas State
Location:
|
RE: G6 Top Ten Poll
(11-14-2026 10:36 AM)Gemofthehills Wrote: (11-14-2026 10:28 AM)bill dazzle Wrote: (11-14-2026 09:34 AM)Gemofthehills Wrote: (11-14-2026 09:12 AM)Memphis Yankee Wrote: (11-14-2026 07:58 AM)Gemofthehills Wrote: JaX State has a win over SBC East leading GaSo.
AC has the big wins over? UNLV who is 5-4 middle of the road MWC team, Tx State a 5-4 guess they are top level PAC, OK St is your big win but its by a team not even being mentioned in CFP debate. Appears AC is in the running with CUSA.
AC loss its big games to Boise St, La Tech, Air Force ULaLa, App St X2, Toledo, UCONN WMU and of course The Citadel (FCS).
Dont see any FCS losses on CUSA resume.
Are you honestly trying to compare CUSA to the American? Our 10th place team USF has a 6-4 record. Compare that to your 10th place team Sam Houston who's 1-8 averaging 5.2 points a game in conference. Half your conference is at 3-6 overall or worse. 70% of your conference has an overall record of 21-42. It's going to be tough sledding making a case for a team from CUSA getting to the CFP.
Your last place team has one win against Houston Christian. And average diff versus conference mates is 14 while Sam Houston stayed within 6 of a middle level AC team Tulsa. Sam is averaging losing by 21 in CUSA.
Hope your not really believing AC is better than CUSA?
My father watches lots of C-USA and American games (I sometimes watch with him during the week, as I live with my elderly parents Tue-Friday to assist them). We follow/cheer for Memphis and Middle Tennessee State. MTSU plays Liberty today and I plan to watch some of that game.
All this to say ...
Based on what I've seen this season, Gem, the American is better than C-USA. The differential is not dramatic — but it's noticeable.
I want both C-USA and the American to do well so as to indirectly benefit MTSU and Memphis, respectively. So I would hope that I'm not too biased when I note the AC is "better" (very subjective term, no doubt) than C-USA. I'm neither "pro" nor "anti" either league (in a general sense).
Obviously, this is just my opinion.

I dont disagree with you. Just hard to understand how any fan of any G6 conference can dog the other when the delta of difference isnt real wide. The top teams arent much different either and those are the only ones which matter in the CFP world.
Hell none look great this year and a bad team can lose any game. Not saying the tops are bad but none are even in the G6 great level.
Because the difference is pretty obvious. I get how one could squint and make things look how they want them to look though. You're squinting so hard that your eyes are closed and you've fallen asleep and are in some dream reality.
|
|
| 11-14-2026 02:34 PM |
|
SoCalBobcat78
Heisman

Posts: 5,265
Joined: Jan 2014
Reputation: 556
I Root For: TXST, UCLA, CBU
Location:
|
RE: G6 Top Ten Poll
(11-11-2026 10:34 PM)Gemofthehills Wrote: People are giving too much credit to Boise for having the best brand name.
You keep trying to poke holes in the Boise State season and it is going nowhere. The human polls think they are currently the best G6 school. The computer polls think they are the best G6 team. Boise State beat an 8-2 Memphis team by 18 points. Boise State beat Western Michigan (7-3) on the road 32-7. WMU should be 8-2. They had one game stolen from them at Michigan. Boise State lost to a ranked Oregon team on the road 34-27, a game that was tied in the middle of the fourth quarter. They beat Fresno State on the road in front of a stadium record 43,000 fans. Fresno is not an easy place to win at. They are passing all of the tests to this point.
Do they have a good brand? Yes, Boise State currently holds the active streak of 29 consecutive winning seasons (dating back to 1998), which ranks as the longest active streak in the nation in Division I FBS and the third-longest streak in FBS history. They were just in the playoffs two years ago. They have street cred with voters because they have a history of success in football.
Boise State and Liberty own the longest current winning streaks between G6 schools at 8. But Liberty has not beat a team with a winning record. They did not play a power conference school. There are differences between conferences. They are not all alike and it is fairly obvious that the PAC and the American are the two best G6 conferences, which is verified by Sagarin and Massey.
|
|
| 11-14-2026 03:16 PM |
|
memphistiger89
Heisman

Posts: 7,798
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 551
I Root For: Memphis Tigers
Location:
|
RE: G6 Top Ten Poll
(11-11-2026 10:31 PM)Just Joe Wrote: (11-11-2026 09:09 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote: Let’s talk about some of the garbage programs you folks keep voting for:
2. New Mexico — their best OOC win is against a bottom half of the MAC team, CMU. The rest of those wins are an FCS beat down, NMSU, and a bunch of wins against a severely weakened MWC slate
4. Liberty— they didn’t schedule a single A4 and their best OOC win is a toss up between a pair of 3 win squads CCU and Ball St. The rest is padding from a weak C-USA.
7. North Dakota St — there are hard schedules and there are soft schedules. What we have here is a cool whip schedule. No A4; fellow FCS transitioner Sac St, still FCS Fordham, a 9th MWC OOC game, and then the 1 OOC game of note—Jacksonville St. That win looks noteworthy on the surface until you see how weak their schedule is too. They’ve still managed to lose 2 games.
8. JMU — Again, no A4 opponents. Liberty is a decent win and San Diego St looked better prior to falling into the middle of the pack on the Pac 12.
Again, I think too many folks are voting and making 2 fatal flaws—
looking simply at wins and losses without factoring in who took losses from the A4 and wins from FCS.
Acting as if having the same record in all 6 conferences means the same thing. They don’t—some are a head and shoulders above the others.
Waaay too judgmental and nitpicky IMO. You’d be hard pressed to find any G6 that meet as high a standard as you’re seeking.
And records matter at this level regardless of competition unless someone has a truly impressive win like the year Cincinnati beat Notre Dame. Most of these G6 schedules are trash this year just varying degrees of trash. If someone is winning, good for them.
And with P4 conferences making rules that their members have to schedule at least 10 teams from P4 conferences, the G6 teams will have trashier schedules moving forward. Freeze them out then talk about how they don’t play anybody. That is definitely the playbook. What do you think the over/under is on how many years before the G6 is completely shut out of the playoffs? I’ve loved college sports for 50 years but my interest wanes with every passing season.
|
|
| 11-14-2026 03:54 PM |
|