Gitanole
Barista

Posts: 13,952
Joined: May 2016
Reputation: 2823
I Root For: Florida State
Location: Speared Turf
|
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(11-13-2026 09:35 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (11-13-2026 09:10 AM)domer1978 Wrote: (11-13-2026 12:27 AM)Transic_nyc Wrote: I wouldn't say never in this day and age. Who would have thought, two weeks ago, that 8 Senate seats would change from one party to another.
That said, there will be lots of pressure to amend the legislation again from representatives in states where several programs want to move between conferences. If I see moves to amend section 205 or a compensation cap on coaches, then I'll know that it has a chance of passing.
Any changes and it's DOA. The Senate would have to approve it all over again. And you know the house will want some changes.
I feel like that is what would need to happen. There probably isn’t time for a back and forth between the House and Senate. Either there are enough votes to push the bill through the House as-is or it can get stuck. I say this as someone that doesn’t personally like this bill, but thought that this would get through based on how much Senate support it had. The sheer margins of the changes in parties in the House and Senate were beyond expectations, though, so that is a large wrinkle.
We could get something more trimmed back. More “bare bones,” just the hits. Time exists to pass that.
The Senate bill has its porky aspects.
|
|
| 11-13-2026 03:08 PM |
|
AssKickingChicken
Heisman

Posts: 6,569
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation: 585
I Root For: Jax State
Location:
|
RE: Protect College Sports Act
The Senate passed a bill with pork?
I’m shocked.
|
|
| 11-13-2026 04:14 PM |
|
ouflak
2nd String

Posts: 317
Joined: Feb 2023
Reputation: 69
I Root For: University of Oklahoma
Location:
|
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(11-13-2026 03:08 PM)Gitanole Wrote: (11-13-2026 09:35 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (11-13-2026 09:10 AM)domer1978 Wrote: (11-13-2026 12:27 AM)Transic_nyc Wrote: I wouldn't say never in this day and age. Who would have thought, two weeks ago, that 8 Senate seats would change from one party to another.
That said, there will be lots of pressure to amend the legislation again from representatives in states where several programs want to move between conferences. If I see moves to amend section 205 or a compensation cap on coaches, then I'll know that it has a chance of passing.
Any changes and it's DOA. The Senate would have to approve it all over again. And you know the house will want some changes.
I feel like that is what would need to happen. There probably isn’t time for a back and forth between the House and Senate. Either there are enough votes to push the bill through the House as-is or it can get stuck. I say this as someone that doesn’t personally like this bill, but thought that this would get through based on how much Senate support it had. The sheer margins of the changes in parties in the House and Senate were beyond expectations, though, so that is a large wrinkle.
We could get something more trimmed back. More “bare bones,” just the hits. Time exists to pass that.
'Trimmed back' sure sounds like a lot more of a fundamental set of changes that just some amendments. I would think that would require even more back-and-forth between the House and the Senate. Let's say they get it down to something like ten pages - no NIL anything not even a mention, no exemptions of any kind, no transfer restrictions. And they get that passed and signed into law. Would that really satisfy the powers that are looking to maintain some stance of the antiquated antebellum amateurship model and looking to not have to otherwise follow the laws of the land? I don't know. 'Trimmed back' seems like it would quickly morph into something more like 'not-done-put-off-until-later-or-maybe-never' to me. Especially with so little lame-duck time left, and the perception that passing anything might look like giving the losing political party a going away victory. It certainly wouldn't be the first time that bills have been converted into token meaningless show piece legislation - and passed as such.
I guess we'd have to see the final product to judge it all.
|
|
| 11-13-2026 06:05 PM |
|
jimrtex
All American

Posts: 4,849
Joined: Aug 2021
Reputation: 653
I Root For: Houston, Tulsa, Colorado
Location:
|
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(11-11-2026 01:53 PM)ouflak Wrote: (11-11-2026 12:38 PM)jimrtex Wrote: (11-10-2026 09:59 PM)Gitanole Wrote: (11-10-2026 05:52 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (11-10-2026 03:48 PM)Gitanole Wrote: Athletes have rights. Rights matter.
When courts have decided. it has been because athletes were plaintiffs. They, as citizens holding rights, asked courts to decide.
The idea of a new category has been discussed in player organizations and among ADs, with lawyers advising.
If no new category is created by law, courts are on course—using existing law—simply to rule athletes employees. (See Dartmouth for precedent.[)
Some people really don’t want this, which is in part why the PCSA got as far as it did with the lawmakers it did. But the topic of a collective bargaining mechanism—whatever form it takes—appears to be back on the table for discussion.
(It would have been taken up as a topic in court anyway had the original PCSA passed. Athletes’ rights again: right to petition for redress of grievances, right to freedom of association.)
That's an awfully thin precedent b/c it came through the NLRB instead of a Federal District Court. Even in the unlikely event that it is eventually revived under a future Democratic administration, and even if the NLRB were to rule in favor of the palintiffs, it would still only apply to the Ivy League, or perhaps any others that are fully composed of private schools.
The issue isn't whether it's common sense or not that kids playing sports should be considered employees, the issue is that these extremely wealthy and powerful entities (aka the schools) don't want them to be considered employees, and most of the kids don't want it, either b/c right now they can get their NIL checks tax free and they can transfer any time they get benched, the coach gives them a dirty look, that Miami booster shows up with $2m in a bag, whatever.
It seems that this whole argument just extreme conservatives and extreme liberals shouting over each other rather than listening to the parties involved. The PCSA does a good job of simply ignoring the issue...let the kids and the schools do it if they want to in the future, but if they don't that's ok, too.
A thin precedent is nevertheless a precedent. It tells you how the law looks to people whose job it is to know the law.
The larger precedent is in the Allston and House cases. Athletes’ rights have been doing very well in court for some time now, and the NCAA has been getting shredded.
It is one reason the PCSA effort was mounted—to create a firewall against the traditional NCAA powers losing more ground.
All this, before we even consider how collective bargaining has long been the norm in pro leagues.
This is why I see it as a tossup whether sports legislation goes forward now. The inclination among many elected officials, especially but not only Democrats, is to sit out any involvement and let the courts continue to sort things out. The athletes are already doing fine there.
What sparks involvement is if enough people in the college sports sector do find legislation useful. That would likely need to include athletes at this point. If grass-roots interest in Congressional action is truly present, lawmakers have these wish lists to begin with in crafting new law.
In any case, athletes retain their rights. The burden of proof is on anyone claiming the ability to unilaterally set caps on revshare and NIL in the absence of negotiation with those whose options are capped. Legally, in the US, that is a difficult argument to make.
Odds are that collective bargaining of some sort is on the way. We will have employment and unions, or something that kinda sorta works like employees and unions.
We’ll see how things go.
__
The athletes agreed to the cap under the House Settlement. Incoming athletes agree to the settlement before they play.
Any and all top athletes opt out of the House Settlement. They could care less about some sliver of the revenues when they are set to rake in NIL. This was a major part of the motivation for the PCSA - to force all student athletes into that kind of agreement whether they wanted it or not, and kneecap their ability to go to the courts to do something about those lost fundamental rights mentioned in an earlier post above.
Your verb tenses are confusing.
The House Settlement is between student athletes and NCAA and P5(4) conferences.
The NCAA agreed to pay $1.8 billion to be distributed to student athletes, primarily football and men's basketball players, in exchange for an agreement not to sue the schools. Athletes were given an opportunity to opt out. If they did so, they will not receive any money. They are free to sue the NCAA, schools, etc.
Incoming student athletes are required to opt in, or they won't be rostered.
|
|
| 11-13-2026 09:38 PM |
|
Gitanole
Barista

Posts: 13,952
Joined: May 2016
Reputation: 2823
I Root For: Florida State
Location: Speared Turf
|
RE: Protect College Sports Act
Here is an example of why “something more trimmed back” and “bare bones, just the hits” may still come down the pipe.*
The A4 conferences look ready to take the wheel. If they do, they likely still require some special permissions from Congress under existing antitrust law.
They would need to enact revshare policies at the inter-conference level, for example, as the SEC recently proposed. That likely requires regulatory help at the national level.
Congress, lame-duck or incoming, can take this up. Affected athletes can be represented via House plaintiffs.
Thread
https://csnbbs.com/thread-1035934.html
----
(* 4 mixed metaphors in 1 sentence is anyway a personal record.)
(This post was last modified: 11-18-2026 11:58 PM by Gitanole.)
|
|
| 11-18-2026 12:18 PM |
|
FSBlueApocalypse
Water Engineer

Posts: 11
Joined: Mar 2019
Reputation: 22
I Root For: Seminoles
Location:
|
RE: Protect College Sports Act
|
|
| 11-18-2026 01:00 PM |
|
Gitanole
Barista

Posts: 13,952
Joined: May 2016
Reputation: 2823
I Root For: Florida State
Location: Speared Turf
|
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(11-18-2026 01:00 PM)FSBlueApocalypse Wrote: Probably not the kind of news schools want leaking out if they have any hope of PCSA passing
https://defector.com/emails-show-adminis...-from-pcsa
Wow. This is my first look at The Defector but the writers appear to have assembled a very detailed investigative report. Everything is based on bona fide source documents obtained via FOIA and the calendar dates are what they are. We get a glimpse at how some influential people at SEC schools are thinking.
This goes some way to answer a question many have wondered through this whole thing: who exactly is being protected in the Protect College Sports Act?
|
|
| 11-18-2026 01:14 PM |
|
JRsec
Super Moderator

Posts: 44,994
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13547
I Root For: SEC
Location:
|
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(11-18-2026 01:14 PM)Gitanole Wrote: (11-18-2026 01:00 PM)FSBlueApocalypse Wrote: Probably not the kind of news schools want leaking out if they have any hope of PCSA passing
https://defector.com/emails-show-adminis...-from-pcsa
Wow. This is my first look at The Defector but the writers appear to have assembled a very detailed investigative report. Everything is based on bona fide source documents obtained via FOIA and the calendar dates are what they are. We get a glimpse at how some influential people at SEC schools are thinking.
This goes some way to answer a question many have wondered through this whole thing: who exactly is being protected in the Protect College Sports Act?
Could you please provide a summary of what is contained in the article, attributed of course to the source. I don't care to have my email address captured for sale as I have very, very little spam. My suspicion is that large profitable schools would.be protected, but so too one outdated bureaucratic institution, the NCAA, which the sources may or may not indicate but they ultimately survive if the PCSA is passed.
|
|
| 11-18-2026 01:51 PM |
|
FSBlueApocalypse
Water Engineer

Posts: 11
Joined: Mar 2019
Reputation: 22
I Root For: Seminoles
Location:
|
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(11-18-2026 01:14 PM)Gitanole Wrote: (11-18-2026 01:00 PM)FSBlueApocalypse Wrote: Probably not the kind of news schools want leaking out if they have any hope of PCSA passing
https://defector.com/emails-show-adminis...-from-pcsa
Wow. This is my first look at The Defector but the writers appear to have assembled a very detailed investigative report. Everything is based on bona fide source documents obtained via FOIA and the calendar dates are what they are. We get a glimpse at how some influential people at SEC schools are thinking.
This goes some way to answer a question many have wondered through this whole thing: who exactly is being protected in the Protect College Sports Act?
Defector was started by a lot of ex-Deadspin staff who quit after the site got taken over by PE and turned into a content farm
|
|
| 11-18-2026 02:12 PM |
|
FSBlueApocalypse
Water Engineer

Posts: 11
Joined: Mar 2019
Reputation: 22
I Root For: Seminoles
Location:
|
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(11-18-2026 01:51 PM)JRsec Wrote: (11-18-2026 01:14 PM)Gitanole Wrote: (11-18-2026 01:00 PM)FSBlueApocalypse Wrote: Probably not the kind of news schools want leaking out if they have any hope of PCSA passing
https://defector.com/emails-show-adminis...-from-pcsa
Wow. This is my first look at The Defector but the writers appear to have assembled a very detailed investigative report. Everything is based on bona fide source documents obtained via FOIA and the calendar dates are what they are. We get a glimpse at how some influential people at SEC schools are thinking.
This goes some way to answer a question many have wondered through this whole thing: who exactly is being protected in the Protect College Sports Act?
Could you please provide a summary of what is contained in the article, attributed of course to the source. I don't care to have my email address captured for sale as I have very, very little spam. My suspicion is that large profitable schools would.be protected, but so too one outdated bureaucratic institution, the NCAA, which the sources may or may not indicate but they ultimately survive if the PCSA is passed.
OU President said in internal SEC email that one of the SEC's priorities in PCSA lobbying was stripping protections for scholarships/funding for non-revenue sports.
Big Ten also listed the provision staying int he bill as a "loss" internally
|
|
| 11-18-2026 04:46 PM |
|
The Beaver
Heisman

Posts: 7,384
Joined: Apr 2024
Reputation: 960
I Root For: Penn State
Location:
|
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(11-18-2026 01:51 PM)JRsec Wrote: (11-18-2026 01:14 PM)Gitanole Wrote: (11-18-2026 01:00 PM)FSBlueApocalypse Wrote: Probably not the kind of news schools want leaking out if they have any hope of PCSA passing
https://defector.com/emails-show-adminis...-from-pcsa
Wow. This is my first look at The Defector but the writers appear to have assembled a very detailed investigative report. Everything is based on bona fide source documents obtained via FOIA and the calendar dates are what they are. We get a glimpse at how some influential people at SEC schools are thinking.
This goes some way to answer a question many have wondered through this whole thing: who exactly is being protected in the Protect College Sports Act?
Could you please provide a summary of what is contained in the article, attributed of course to the source. I don't care to have my email address captured for sale as I have very, very little spam. My suspicion is that large profitable schools would.be protected, but so too one outdated bureaucratic institution, the NCAA, which the sources may or may not indicate but they ultimately survive if the PCSA is passed.
The article is free, you can just click the "no" X and continue reading without providing any information.
|
|
| 11-18-2026 04:48 PM |
|
bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,950
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(11-18-2026 04:46 PM)FSBlueApocalypse Wrote: (11-18-2026 01:51 PM)JRsec Wrote: (11-18-2026 01:14 PM)Gitanole Wrote: (11-18-2026 01:00 PM)FSBlueApocalypse Wrote: Probably not the kind of news schools want leaking out if they have any hope of PCSA passing
https://defector.com/emails-show-adminis...-from-pcsa
Wow. This is my first look at The Defector but the writers appear to have assembled a very detailed investigative report. Everything is based on bona fide source documents obtained via FOIA and the calendar dates are what they are. We get a glimpse at how some influential people at SEC schools are thinking.
This goes some way to answer a question many have wondered through this whole thing: who exactly is being protected in the Protect College Sports Act?
Could you please provide a summary of what is contained in the article, attributed of course to the source. I don't care to have my email address captured for sale as I have very, very little spam. My suspicion is that large profitable schools would.be protected, but so too one outdated bureaucratic institution, the NCAA, which the sources may or may not indicate but they ultimately survive if the PCSA is passed.
OU President said in internal SEC email that one of the SEC's priorities in PCSA lobbying was stripping protections for scholarships/funding for non-revenue sports.
Big Ten also listed the provision staying int he bill as a "loss" internally
Well it was changed to give them flexibility, not to reduce opportunities, but to reallocate. And that provision does go away after a certain number of years (9?).
|
|
| 11-18-2026 05:40 PM |
|
The Beaver
Heisman

Posts: 7,384
Joined: Apr 2024
Reputation: 960
I Root For: Penn State
Location:
|
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(11-18-2026 05:40 PM)bullet Wrote: (11-18-2026 04:46 PM)FSBlueApocalypse Wrote: (11-18-2026 01:51 PM)JRsec Wrote: (11-18-2026 01:14 PM)Gitanole Wrote: (11-18-2026 01:00 PM)FSBlueApocalypse Wrote: Probably not the kind of news schools want leaking out if they have any hope of PCSA passing
https://defector.com/emails-show-adminis...-from-pcsa
Wow. This is my first look at The Defector but the writers appear to have assembled a very detailed investigative report. Everything is based on bona fide source documents obtained via FOIA and the calendar dates are what they are. We get a glimpse at how some influential people at SEC schools are thinking.
This goes some way to answer a question many have wondered through this whole thing: who exactly is being protected in the Protect College Sports Act?
Could you please provide a summary of what is contained in the article, attributed of course to the source. I don't care to have my email address captured for sale as I have very, very little spam. My suspicion is that large profitable schools would.be protected, but so too one outdated bureaucratic institution, the NCAA, which the sources may or may not indicate but they ultimately survive if the PCSA is passed.
OU President said in internal SEC email that one of the SEC's priorities in PCSA lobbying was stripping protections for scholarships/funding for non-revenue sports.
Big Ten also listed the provision staying int he bill as a "loss" internally
Well it was changed to give them flexibility, not to reduce opportunities, but to reallocate. And that provision does go away after a certain number of years (9?).
Right now it is sort of a side-issue but locking in schools to their 2024/5 levels forever would be terrible policy. Even 9 years would be egregious were it not for the fact that the schools are asking for a massive giveaway of other peoples' rights at the same time. A much fairer proposal would be to mandate all P4 (equivalent) schools meet the 2025 median scholarships and then if the big spenders want to voluntarily keep spending they could. If little spenders want to continue not soending they are free to set their media payments, as a conference, below the legislation's covered conference numbers or move to a conference with lower media rights payments.
|
|
| 11-18-2026 06:44 PM |
|
bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,991
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3774
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(11-18-2026 12:18 PM)Gitanole Wrote: Here is an example of why “something more trimmed back” and “bare bones, just the hits” may still come down the pipe.*
The A4 conferences look ready to take the wheel. If they do, the conferences would likely still require some special permissions from Congress under existing antitrust law.
They will need something in order to enact revshare policies at the inter-conference level, for example, as the SEC has recently proposed.
Either Congress, lame-duck or incoming, could take this up. Affected athletes can be represented via House plaintiffs.
Thread
https://csnbbs.com/thread-1035934.html
(* 4 mixed metaphors in 1 sentence is anyway a personal record.)
Grats, I think mine is only 3.
|
|
| 11-18-2026 08:44 PM |
|
bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,991
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3774
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(11-18-2026 05:40 PM)bullet Wrote: (11-18-2026 04:46 PM)FSBlueApocalypse Wrote: (11-18-2026 01:51 PM)JRsec Wrote: (11-18-2026 01:14 PM)Gitanole Wrote: (11-18-2026 01:00 PM)FSBlueApocalypse Wrote: Probably not the kind of news schools want leaking out if they have any hope of PCSA passing
https://defector.com/emails-show-adminis...-from-pcsa
Wow. This is my first look at The Defector but the writers appear to have assembled a very detailed investigative report. Everything is based on bona fide source documents obtained via FOIA and the calendar dates are what they are. We get a glimpse at how some influential people at SEC schools are thinking.
This goes some way to answer a question many have wondered through this whole thing: who exactly is being protected in the Protect College Sports Act?
Could you please provide a summary of what is contained in the article, attributed of course to the source. I don't care to have my email address captured for sale as I have very, very little spam. My suspicion is that large profitable schools would.be protected, but so too one outdated bureaucratic institution, the NCAA, which the sources may or may not indicate but they ultimately survive if the PCSA is passed.
OU President said in internal SEC email that one of the SEC's priorities in PCSA lobbying was stripping protections for scholarships/funding for non-revenue sports.
Big Ten also listed the provision staying int he bill as a "loss" internally
Well it was changed to give them flexibility, not to reduce opportunities, but to reallocate. And that provision does go away after a certain number of years (9?).
I think that the desire to be able to make our own decisions about what sports we offer and what sports we don't is extremely reasonable. I also see it as a big selling point to Congress as something of huge value that we gave up in order to secure the antitrust protection.
Put another way, what's going to happen in the next 5 years sans Congressional action? It's no exaggeration to say that the average school probably cuts about 25% of its sports, and it cuts back in other non-revenue sports where it can, too. Forcing schools to hold the line for at least 9 years is a huge concession, and it's certainly reasonable for them to use that as a reason for Congress to get off their keisters and pass the PCSA.
|
|
| 11-18-2026 08:49 PM |
|
random asian guy
Heisman

Posts: 5,219
Joined: Aug 2014
Reputation: 652
I Root For: VT, Georgetown
Location: Suburban Hell
|
RE: Protect College Sports Act
The PCSA is not dead yet.
The GOP planns to take the bill to the floor in the first week of December. Looks like there will be some "changes"
We will see.
|
|
| Yesterday 12:35 PM |
|
Gitanole
Barista

Posts: 13,952
Joined: May 2016
Reputation: 2823
I Root For: Florida State
Location: Speared Turf
|
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(Yesterday 12:35 PM)random asian guy Wrote: The PCSA is not dead yet.
The GOP planns to take the bill to the floor in the first week of December. Looks like there will be some "changes"
We will see.

So much for all the sagacious declarations about the PCSA having to pass the House unaltered.
Thanks for sharing this.
We’ll need to wait for Mr. Dellenger’s full report, but—PSA—“our conference” from a Republican leader usually means just the lawmakers in his/her party. Democratic leaders refer to their own as “our caucus.” It’s a quirk of tradition.
The quote suggests that members of the outgoing majority party are not themselves yet on the same page.
This comes as no surprise to anyone who has been following the PCSA debate. Both PCSA support and PCSA skepticism have a way of cutting across partisan lines.
|
|
| Yesterday 01:43 PM |
|
Attackcoog
Moderator

Posts: 49,258
Joined: Oct 2011
Reputation: 3527
I Root For: Houston
Location:
|
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(Yesterday 12:35 PM)random asian guy Wrote: The PCSA is not dead yet.
The GOP planns to take the bill to the floor in the first week of December. Looks like there will be some "changes"
We will see.

Honestly, I suspect the schools (even the big ones) will end up getting behind this bill because any bill authored by the next Congress is likely to demand a much higher price from the schools in exchange for the highly coveted limited anti-trust exemption the current bill will grant the schools.
(This post was last modified: Yesterday 03:25 PM by Attackcoog.)
|
|
| Yesterday 03:24 PM |
|
bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,991
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3774
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(Yesterday 03:24 PM)Attackcoog Wrote: (Yesterday 12:35 PM)random asian guy Wrote: The PCSA is not dead yet.
The GOP planns to take the bill to the floor in the first week of December. Looks like there will be some "changes"
We will see.

Honestly, I suspect the schools (even the big ones) will end up getting behind this bill because any bill authored by the next Congress is likely to demand a much higher price from the schools in exchange for the highly coveted limited anti-trust exemption the current bill will grant the schools.
There's no way to know when or even if the next Congress will take up Sports Legislation. I suspect that it will be distracted with other things and no serious effort is even made to look at the issue until 2029. I wonder what LSU would get up to during time period? Or half the SEC, B1G, P4, etc etc etc? Likely nothing that most fans of college athletics would be very excited about.
I'm curious to see what the proposed changes are. Hopefully the House and Senate are actually talking about it now instead of the House just making changes and hoping for the best, as we are running out of time at this point.
Definitely a good sign that Scalise brought it up. I wonder how much of his interest is protecting LSU from their governorAdministration's apparent desire to force the SEC into kicking them out of the Conference? I was 50/50 when I heard about the basketball player that it was designed to prompt Congress to act.
|
|
| Yesterday 04:03 PM |
|
The Beaver
Heisman

Posts: 7,384
Joined: Apr 2024
Reputation: 960
I Root For: Penn State
Location:
|
RE: Protect College Sports Act
The current Republican conference has a number of ideological holdouts, including ones that can gum up the process due to their leadership positions. I'm just saying this as a warning the changes proposed might be very political in nature.
(This post was last modified: Yesterday 05:10 PM by The Beaver.)
|
|
| Yesterday 05:07 PM |
|