WhidbeyWolf
1st String

Posts: 1,596
Joined: Jul 2025
Reputation: 242
I Root For: Wolfpack
Location: Olympic Shadow
|
RE: Georgetown and UAB to the AAU
(11-02-2026 01:06 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote: (11-02-2026 08:15 AM)tf8693 Wrote: (11-01-2026 04:55 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote: (11-01-2026 10:54 AM)tf8693 Wrote: (10-29-2026 03:36 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: The State of Georgia already has 2. Virginia is underrepresented with only 1, VT is probably ahead of all 3 of those you listed, but as the AAU is primarily a lobbying institution rather than just a Gentleman's Club of Ivory Tower Nerds, there are other considerations.
ie, What other States have 0 AAU members, and what would the top AAU candidates be from those States? Alabama was the 2nd most populous without an AAU member school at all. Who is next?
South Carolina (5.5m)
Kentucky (4.6m)
Oklahoma (4.1m)
Arkansas (3.1m)
There are a bunch of others, but they're all at or near the bottom of the US rank of population by State. I'm unsure of the best privates in any of those States, but the Flagships don't exactly scream "AAU candidate", and are likely ranked lower than dozens of others that would add a 2nd or 3rd in a current AAU State. I think that Clemson is probably the best AAU candidate in any of those States, at least their Academics are overall very good, but their Research spending is pretty low and is still behind many others like FSU, VT, NC St, etc etc that would add additional schools in current AAU States. Could Clemson join the AAU, or South Carolina, before Georgia, NC St, VT, and FSU? Possibly. More likely, none of those listed are even on the radar for now, though I'm not privy to who actually was under discussion this round. I'd love to hear from someone who knows, however.
Georgetown as an AAU addition is, with apologies to Patrick Ewing, a Slam Dunk.
I don't have inside information, but I have noticed a trend since I started paying attention to the AAU. Much as people here like to hate on USNWR rankings, recently the school that ranked highest in USNWR rankings among non-AAU members was added to the AAU in relatively short order. When I first started paying attention, Dartmouth ranked highest in USNWR rankings among non-AAU members. Dartmouth then got AAU membership, leaving Notre Dame as the highest-ranked non-AAU member in USNWR rankings. Notre Dame then received AAU membership, leaving Georgetown as the highest-ranked school in the USNWR rankings that was not an AAU member. Now Georgetown has received AAU membership. If you're curious, Boston College is now the highest-ranked school in the USNWR rankings that is not currently an AAU member.
As far as Georgetown being a slam dunk as an AAU member, they certainly are qualified academically. But at least arguably, there was an anti-Catholic bias in the AAU Catholic U. was a charter member of the AAU, but left when the focus shifted from undergraduate education to research. Thereafter, there was a gap of several years where there were no Catholic members until Notre Dame was inducted.
As for UAB and DavidSt, I seem to recall that he once said that UAB would receive AAU membership before either Alabama or Auburn. So props to him on that call. But tbf, he throws out so many wild predictions that there probably is a greater likelihood of some of them coming true than of none of them coming true.
Unfortunately for BC, private universities from Boston are an overrepresented group in the AAU. Harvard, MIT, BU, Brandeis and Tufts provide more than enough lobbying members. If the AAU goes for a small private, with religious affiliation (Baptist affiliated Divinity School), plus research focused and US News-style academic heft…then Wake Forest is a more likely candidate.
Has geography ever been a consideration in AAU membership, other than maybe the fact that public flagships generally seem to have an advantage in gaining membership? As Bryan pointed out, there are several states that are completely unrepresented in the AAU, although most of those states are on the lower end in terms of population.
As I see it, Wake Forest could have two disadvantages. First, only two religiously affiliated schools in the AAU, and both of those (Notre Dame and Georgetown) are Catholic. Second, if NC State gets into the AAU (not a slam dunk but certainly not impossible either), and geography is a consideration, one could also make the argument that North Carolina is overrepresented if Wake Forest is also added.
The AAU is a political organization…that’s why it’s headquartered in Washington DC.
Geography and public v private have always been paramount AAU considerations. If you divide the US into four quadrants (Northeast, South, Midwest and West) and classify current AAU membership, the Northeast is slightly overrepresented while the South is belatedly catching-up. Georgetown, UAB, GWU, Miami and USF are all recent additions that have helped strengthen the South’s (Mason-Dixon line south & west until Texas) contingency. It’s also not a coincidence that a public school is admitted along with a private…maintaining the organization’s relative 50/50 membership split.
Regarding religious affiliation, I’d argue that Brandeis University is the most prominent AAU member that embodies that criteria. Having strong religious heritage (whether Roman Catholic, Jewish, Baptist, etc.) doesn’t preclude universities from excelling in academic research and graduate education…conflict only occurs if religious beliefs override academic pursuits.
Would that explain why unc was put on SACS probation, but it didn't affect their AAU?
|
|