Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
Bring back the BCS rankings instead of arbitrary CFP rankings
Author Message
C2__ Online
Caltex2
*

Posts: 24,292
Joined: Feb 2008
Reputation: 609
I Root For: Houston, PVAMU
Location: League City, TX
Post: #1
Bring back the BCS rankings instead of arbitrary CFP rankings
Leave the fate of teams in the hands of the computers and take man (aside from the polls) out of it. Now that we have a playoff this is the best way to do it.
11-01-2026 05:01 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Advertisement


Fighting Muskie Offline
Senior Chief Realignmentologist
*

Posts: 15,084
Joined: Sep 2016
Reputation: 1214
I Root For: Bishop Sycamore
Location: Secret Lair
Post: #2
RE: Bring back the BCS rankings instead of arbitrary CFP rankings
I prefer the old BCS formula—there’s far more components involved to be easily tampered with the way the committee can.
11-02-2026 07:18 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quo vadis Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 56,029
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
Post: #3
RE: Bring back the BCS rankings instead of arbitrary CFP rankings
I like the BCS formula over the CFP rankings as well.

And, I especially like that another aspect of the BCS was that there were no auto-bids for anyone regarding who played in the two-team playoff. IMO, that should be the case with the 12-team playoff as well.

Everyone should have the same clause that ND now has - if you are ranked in the top 12, you get in. If not, then not.
11-02-2026 07:28 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
thrill_house Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,126
Joined: Apr 2021
Reputation: 177
I Root For: Anti-CFP
Location:
Post: #4
RE: Bring back the BCS rankings instead of arbitrary CFP rankings
Accurate computer formulas that have been tested and are used because of their historical accuracy, yes.

BCS computers? No.
11-02-2026 08:19 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
BirdHawkEagle Away
All American
*

Posts: 3,244
Joined: Jun 2026
Reputation: 303
I Root For: UTK, MTSU, UMCP, USMA
Location:
Post: #5
RE: Bring back the BCS rankings instead of arbitrary CFP rankings
(11-02-2026 08:19 PM)thrill_house Wrote:  Accurate computer formulas that have been tested and are used because of their historical accuracy, yes.

BCS computers? No.

What's wrong with BCS computers?

I'd trust those things more than I would some AI model running the show.

This whole AI obsession is going to get people killed.
11-02-2026 08:22 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,946
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #6
RE: Bring back the BCS rankings instead of arbitrary CFP rankings
(11-02-2026 08:22 PM)BirdHawkEagle Wrote:  
(11-02-2026 08:19 PM)thrill_house Wrote:  Accurate computer formulas that have been tested and are used because of their historical accuracy, yes.

BCS computers? No.

What's wrong with BCS computers?

I'd trust those things more than I would some AI model running the show.

This whole AI obsession is going to get people killed.

Those were systems who were willing to compromise their formulas to eliminate MOV as a factor.
11-02-2026 08:50 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Advertisement


Crayton Online
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,316
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
Post: #7
RE: Bring back the BCS rankings instead of arbitrary CFP rankings
(11-02-2026 08:19 PM)thrill_house Wrote:  Accurate computer formulas that have been tested and are used because of their historical accuracy, yes.

BCS computers? No.

Agreed. Some of those computers were B A D. And, as bullet notes, they were forbidden from using MOV, even if only using it as a basis for an SOR ranking.

The BCS Computers were ~somewhat know-able, but even better would be a single open-source algorithm. The “science” of ranking teams has come a long way since 1998.

The main goal of dropping the committee is dropping the opaqueness. And it doesn’t have to be the “perfect” ranking tool. The NFL uses SOS rather late in its ranking algorithm, but fans (and coaches and media personalities, etc) accept it BECAUSE it is public knowledge and not ‘too’ complicated.
11-03-2026 04:55 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
IWokeUpLikeThis Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 17,111
Joined: Jul 2014
Reputation: 2478
I Root For: NIU, Chicago St
Location:
Post: #8
RE: Bring back the BCS rankings instead of arbitrary CFP rankings
A committee is a complete waste of time and resources with a 24-team playoff. Let the BCS computers handle it. It was more fun (and transparent) anyway.
11-03-2026 04:57 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
BirdHawkEagle Away
All American
*

Posts: 3,244
Joined: Jun 2026
Reputation: 303
I Root For: UTK, MTSU, UMCP, USMA
Location:
Post: #9
RE: Bring back the BCS rankings instead of arbitrary CFP rankings
(11-03-2026 04:57 PM)IWokeUpLikeThis Wrote:  A committee is a complete waste of time and resources with a 24-team playoff. Let the BCS computers handle it. It was more fun (and transparent) anyway.

I agree.
11-03-2026 05:00 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Frank the Tank Online
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 23,554
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3294
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
Post: #10
RE: Bring back the BCS rankings instead of arbitrary CFP rankings
People have super selective amnesia on this issue and how much the BCS rankings were hated. The first time that the equivalent of a BCS ranking materially differs from the human ranking, it will get killed by the general public. Remember that the BCS ranking still had a human poll included as its largest factor.

The 24-team playoff will be so large that it essentially has become idiot proof. That is, any conceivable team that could possibly win the national championship is going to be included in that playoff (which isn’t even the case for the 12-team playoff à la the debate between Notre Dame and Miami being included last season).

I can’t stand the CFP committee… but any reliance on computer rankings directly determining the actual playoff field itself (and not merely informative as it is with the NCAA Tournament) would end up being misguided just as was the case with the BCS rankings. An “objective” computer ranking is still based on subjective human choices on what’s important for such ranking, so it’s not really any different than a human opinion.

We don’t have a closed system like the NFL where the playoff field can be determined entirely based on the actual games between teams. As a result, as annoying as it is, the human CFP committee is the best of a lot of bad options. As Churchill said about democracy, it’s the worst form of government… except for all of the others. Likewise, a human committee is the worst way to choose a playoff field… except for all of the others.
11-03-2026 06:42 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
IWokeUpLikeThis Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 17,111
Joined: Jul 2014
Reputation: 2478
I Root For: NIU, Chicago St
Location:
Post: #11
RE: Bring back the BCS rankings instead of arbitrary CFP rankings
(11-03-2026 06:42 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  People have super selective amnesia on this issue and how much the BCS rankings were hated. The first time that the equivalent of a BCS ranking materially differs from the human ranking, it will get killed by the general public. Remember that the BCS ranking still had a human poll included as its largest factor.

The 24-team playoff will be so large that it essentially has become idiot proof. That is, any conceivable team that could possibly win the national championship is going to be included in that playoff (which isn’t even the case for the 12-team playoff à la the debate between Notre Dame and Miami being included last season).

I can’t stand the CFP committee… but any reliance on computer rankings directly determining the actual playoff field itself (and not merely informative as it is with the NCAA Tournament) would end up being misguided just as was the case with the BCS rankings. An “objective” computer ranking is still based on subjective human choices on what’s important for such ranking, so it’s not really any different than a human opinion.

We don’t have a closed system like the NFL where the playoff field can be determined entirely based on the actual games between teams. As a result, as annoying as it is, the human CFP committee is the best of a lot of bad options. As Churchill said about democracy, it’s the worst form of government… except for all of the others. Likewise, a human committee is the worst way to choose a playoff field… except for all of the others.

The BCS Rankings being hated were a by-product of it being 2 teams. Yeah, they were hated on inane talk shows with goofy talking heads, but I always loved them. The BCS computers might have a bias for selective criteria, but they were still what best removed any human school/conference bias by a small selection of humans. Removing the later bias is much more important than removing the former bias.
11-03-2026 06:55 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Advertisement


Dr Dawgma III Offline
Hark the Sound
*

Posts: 26,100
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2774
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
Post: #12
RE: Bring back the BCS rankings instead of arbitrary CFP rankings
If you’re a G6 and you lose a G6 game, you’re probably not gonna win a natty. Just the way it is.

If you’re an A4 and you don’t win your conference, you get not guarantees. Sorry.

The season is still a form of ladder tournament.
11-03-2026 07:21 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
C2__ Online
Caltex2
*

Posts: 24,292
Joined: Feb 2008
Reputation: 609
I Root For: Houston, PVAMU
Location: League City, TX
Post: #13
RE: Bring back the BCS rankings instead of arbitrary CFP rankings
Texas at 8, Alabama at 6 (!) and Utah (!), LOL.
(This post was last modified: 11-03-2026 08:02 PM by C2__.)
11-03-2026 08:01 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,978
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3768
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #14
RE: Bring back the BCS rankings instead of arbitrary CFP rankings
(11-03-2026 04:55 PM)Crayton Wrote:  
(11-02-2026 08:19 PM)thrill_house Wrote:  Accurate computer formulas that have been tested and are used because of their historical accuracy, yes.

BCS computers? No.

Agreed. Some of those computers were B A D. And, as bullet notes, they were forbidden from using MOV, even if only using it as a basis for an SOR ranking.

The BCS Computers were ~somewhat know-able, but even better would be a single open-source algorithm. The “science” of ranking teams has come a long way since 1998.

The main goal of dropping the committee is dropping the opaqueness. And it doesn’t have to be the “perfect” ranking tool. The NFL uses SOS rather late in its ranking algorithm, but fans (and coaches and media personalities, etc) accept it BECAUSE it is public knowledge and not ‘too’ complicated.

The NFL also gives a playoff spot to every division champion. Salary cap. Draft. Competitive balance, teams in small markets like Buffalo and KC routinely dominate huge market teams like the Jets and Redskins, roughly akin to Southern Miss dominating Michigan in CFB.
11-03-2026 08:14 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,978
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3768
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #15
RE: Bring back the BCS rankings instead of arbitrary CFP rankings
(11-03-2026 04:57 PM)IWokeUpLikeThis Wrote:  A committee is a complete waste of time and resources with a 24-team playoff. Let the BCS computers handle it. It was more fun (and transparent) anyway.

Seems fair to me.
11-03-2026 08:14 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
GoBuckeyes1047 Online
All American
*

Posts: 3,082
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation: 302
I Root For: Ohio State
Location:
Post: #16
RE: Bring back the BCS rankings instead of arbitrary CFP rankings


It's worth noting that the coaches and AP polls will resemble closer to the CFP Committee next week so should be less variation.
(This post was last modified: 11-03-2026 09:02 PM by GoBuckeyes1047.)
11-03-2026 08:56 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Advertisement


PicksUp Online
All American
*

Posts: 3,616
Joined: Mar 2018
Reputation: 287
I Root For: UTEP, Texas
Location:
Post: #17
RE: Bring back the BCS rankings instead of arbitrary CFP rankings
(11-03-2026 06:42 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  People have super selective amnesia on this issue and how much the BCS rankings were hated. The first time that the equivalent of a BCS ranking materially differs from the human ranking, it will get killed by the general public. Remember that the BCS ranking still had a human poll included as its largest factor.

The 24-team playoff will be so large that it essentially has become idiot proof. That is, any conceivable team that could possibly win the national championship is going to be included in that playoff (which isn’t even the case for the 12-team playoff à la the debate between Notre Dame and Miami being included last season).

I can’t stand the CFP committee… but any reliance on computer rankings directly determining the actual playoff field itself (and not merely informative as it is with the NCAA Tournament) would end up being misguided just as was the case with the BCS rankings. An “objective” computer ranking is still based on subjective human choices on what’s important for such ranking, so it’s not really any different than a human opinion.

We don’t have a closed system like the NFL where the playoff field can be determined entirely based on the actual games between teams. As a result, as annoying as it is, the human CFP committee is the best of a lot of bad options. As Churchill said about democracy, it’s the worst form of government… except for all of the others. Likewise, a human committee is the worst way to choose a playoff field… except for all of the others.

I believe last year the BCS would have included Notre Dame and Alabama over Miami. The computers hated Miami. Source: X/Twitter and Reddit

Edit: If we included Tulane and James Madison. Miami was 11 and BYU was 12.
(This post was last modified: 11-03-2026 09:11 PM by PicksUp.)
11-03-2026 09:08 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,946
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #18
RE: Bring back the BCS rankings instead of arbitrary CFP rankings
(11-03-2026 08:56 PM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  

It's worth noting that the coaches and AP polls will resemble closer to the CFP Committee next week so should be less variation.

Its the same 25 teams, just a different order.
11-03-2026 09:09 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
GoBuckeyes1047 Online
All American
*

Posts: 3,082
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation: 302
I Root For: Ohio State
Location:
Post: #19
RE: Bring back the BCS rankings instead of arbitrary CFP rankings
I know it wouldn't make too much difference outside the ACC so far this season, but I think 4/4/4/4/1+7 would be beneficial for the 24 team CFP. Seeing how the committee is ranking 10 of the top 25 from the SEC, I think the rest of the P4 will want to have some guaranteed bids while still leaving plenty of at-large bids in the event a conference has a strong regular season (like the SEC is having so far).

Give teams an opportunity on the field to make the CFP and use ACC tiebreakers to break any ties (possibly use the 10 qualifying games for the conference race), and if you don't finish top 4 and the committee keeps you out, you had your opportunity to avoid the subjectivity of the committee. This also could open up the opportunity for the P4 to replace their CCGs with a play-in game on the 1st weekend to help maintain their revenue and monetize the conference race for the top 4 and maybe guarantee the top 3 or 4 champs a first round bye.
11-03-2026 09:42 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
C2__ Online
Caltex2
*

Posts: 24,292
Joined: Feb 2008
Reputation: 609
I Root For: Houston, PVAMU
Location: League City, TX
Post: #20
RE: Bring back the BCS rankings instead of arbitrary CFP rankings
(11-03-2026 09:09 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-03-2026 08:56 PM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  

It's worth noting that the coaches and AP polls will resemble closer to the CFP Committee next week so should be less variation.

Its the same 25 teams, just a different order.

What about a BCS that factors in MOV.
11-03-2026 09:48 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.