(10-31-2026 01:20 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (10-31-2026 10:37 AM)AllTideUp Wrote: (10-31-2026 08:56 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote: I would be hesitant to do anything with UAB. They're just a few years removed from getting literally annihilated by Alabama...does the ACC want to risk that happening again, perhaps as UAB becomes a more realistic competitor to Tuscaloosa? This AAU thing is nice feather in their cap, but their place in the State of Alabama pecking order is unlikely to change.
(10-31-2026 09:21 AM)Gemofthehills Wrote: UAB had to fight Tuscaloosa for staking claim to the med school. Everything UAB does is or seems to be a fight with Tuscaloosa.
It's an interesting perspective that people have.
Everything negative that happens to UAB can be laid squarely at the feet of the oppressive and short-sighted UA Board of Trustees. Everything positive is the result of great work by people at UAB because apparently the BOT takes super long vacations.
What a world.
I don't claim to be privy to the inner workings of anything in the State of Alabama, but this dynamic has been much reported on.
The narrative that "Tuscaloosa almost killed UAB football" centers on a decades-long power dynamic within the University of Alabama System Board of Trustees, which is historically dominated by University of Alabama (Tuscaloosa) alumni.
While the official reason given for shutting down the UAB program in 2014 was a financial review claiming football was unsustainable, UAB fans, boosters, and local politicians widely attribute the move to a calculated campaign by powerful system trustees fiercely loyal to the Tuscaloosa campus.
The core factors that fueled this conflict include:
1. The UA System Board Structure
Unlike most university systems, UAB does not have its own independent board of trustees. It is governed by the University of Alabama System Board, which also oversees the Tuscaloosa and Huntsville campuses. At the time of the shutdown, 13 of the 15 board members held degrees from the Tuscaloosa campus. UAB supporters argued that this created an inherent conflict of interest, where the board actively suppressed UAB’s growth to ensure the Alabama Crimson Tide faced zero in-state branding or resource competition.
2. The Paul Bryant Jr. vs. Gene Bartow Vendetta
The most prominent figure at the heart of the "Tuscaloosa conspiracy" was Paul Bryant Jr.—a powerful UA trustee and the son of legendary Crimson Tide coach Paul "Bear" Bryant.
The friction traces back to 1991, when UAB's legendary basketball coach and athletic founder, Gene Bartow, wrote a letter to the NCAA alleging that Alabama’s football program under Bear Bryant had committed recruiting violations. UAB advocates firmly believe that Bryant Jr. made it his personal mission to starve and eventually dismantle UAB’s athletic program as retribution for tarnishing his father's legacy.
3. Systemic Obstruction of UAB Growth
UAB boosters points to a historical pattern of the board vetoing or killing projects that would make UAB football successful:
• The Jimbo Fisher Veto (2006): UAB had a fully executed agreement to hire Jimbo Fisher (then a highly sought-after LSU offensive coordinator) as their head coach. The UA Board of Trustees took the unprecedented step of vetoing the hire. Fisher went to Florida State instead, where he won a national championship.
• Blocking Facilities: The board consistently rejected or delayed plans for UAB to build an on-campus stadium or a football operations center.
• The Turf Incident: When a local business offered to upgrade UAB's aging, flood-prone practice fields with new turf completely free of charge, a powerful UA trustee stepped in to kill the donation.
4. The 2014 "Execution" and Rebirth
In late 2014, UAB President Ray Watts shocked the college football world by announcing the immediate termination of the football program, citing a commissioned financial report. However, leaked public relations documents later revealed that the university had been planning the shutdown for months and purposefully delayed the announcement to avoid public backlash and player boycotts.
The strategy backfired. The decision sparked national outrage, massive campus protests, and an unprecedented fundraising blitz. The Birmingham community and boosters rallied to raise over $27 million in less than a year, forcing President Watts and the board to reverse the decision. UAB football officially returned to the field in 2017 under coach Bill Clark, eventually earning multiple conference titles and moving into their own downtown venue, Protective Stadium.
Now, all of that is just stuff I read on the internet, and it's certainly possible that Tuscaloosa supporters and Board Members never cared one whit about UAB one way or the other. But there was a LOT of smoke around this one.
Yes, I've heard it all before.
1. UAB has never had an independent Board of Trustees and despite that reality has consistently been a strong institution with incredible medical research. UA's medical school was relocated out of Tuscaloosa to Birmingham decades ago and ultimately UAB was the institution built around its growth...UAB didn't become independent until 1969. There's an inextricable connection between the universities. I think someone mentioned the medical college being founded in Mobile and that's correct. It was moved out of Mobile to Tuscaloosa in 1920, however. In 1945, it was moved to Birmingham.
Alabama is not a super wealthy state and has to be smart with its resources. UAB was effectively created to house the medical school and the research arm for medicine in the state. The only other medical school in the state is housed at USA(South Alabama). I think if the BOT really wanted to screw UAB and keep it down, it would have spent the last several decades building a medical school in Tuscaloosa rather than making the one in Birmingham one of the best in the country.
2, 3, and 4. Bartow did a lot of great things for UAB, but if you or I were Paul Bryant Jr then we would probably despise the guy too. Bear Bryant died in 1982 so what purpose Bartow had in making enemies in Tuscaloosa nearly a decade after one of the state's great icons died is a mystery to me.
With that said, Bryant Jr has never been king potentate. If he really wanted to starve UAB then he probably would have had a lot easier time in 1991 rather than waiting more than 2 decades to persuade Ray Watts to kill it. This is assuming he had the power to do so. He's very influential, no doubt, but just because some people have an idea they're being conspired against doesn't make it true. After all, the same UAB advocates that make such a claim also said Ray Watts should be fired. Well, let's think that through. Who hired Ray Watts? The Board. Who would need to fire Ray Watts? The Board. Who would appoint Ray Watts' replacement? The Board.
Point being, if there was indeed a conspiracy to kill UAB football then I don't see how it could have been circumvented assuming these UAB "advocates" understood how these politics worked. Keep in mind, UAB's football foundation wasn't established until 2014...that's pretty late to the party. Fundraising arms college football 101 and the school just didn't take it seriously. Your own copied analysis said it was an unprecedented fundraising blitz. UAB has committed to football in more recent years, however, but has a history of mismanaging the program. Some leaders believed that if the program simply existed, it would be successful. That's just not how it works and again...limited resources.
UAB's original stadium proposal depended on the UA System guaranteeing a loan in order to fund the project. That money didn't exist unless UAB wanted to pull it from their general funds and again, the school exists to be a medical research institution. That wouldn't have been responsible. They had a plan to raise the funds assuming much higher than normal attendance and premium seating sales. It wasn't realistic.
None of what I'm saying should be construed as an attack on UAB or its supporters. I have family that works at UAB and I've been to a fair number of UAB games even though I wouldn't describe myself as a "fan." My point is simply that the narrative exists that the UA Board wants to hurt UAB and while it's fine to nitpick a decision here and there, the idea the Board is out to hurt one of the most important institutions in the state rings quite hollow to me.
I have plenty of criticisms for my own favorite institution, BTW. Their money-grubbing has annoyed me ever since I was a student, but that doesn't mean they're Bond villains.