Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Poll: What is the most important factor for new American membership
This poll is closed.
Amount of Revenue Sharing/NIL 42.11% 16 42.11%
Winning tradition 36.84% 14 36.84%
Attendance 2.63% 1 2.63%
Academics 7.89% 3 7.89%
Other 10.53% 4 10.53%
Total 38 vote(s) 100%
* You voted for this item. [Show Results]

Post Reply 
Most important factor for new American addition
Author Message
msu35 Offline
Observing Reality
*

Posts: 21,642
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2234
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
Post: #141
RE: Most important factor for new American addition
(10-07-2026 02:18 PM)shere khan Wrote:  
(10-07-2026 01:05 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(10-07-2026 12:59 PM)shere khan Wrote:  
(10-07-2026 11:41 AM)msu35 Wrote:  
(10-07-2026 11:12 AM)shere khan Wrote:  You really need to seek help

Of course you would feel compelled to defend the trolls and self-soothe, but I appreciate your dedication to self-identification.

Point stands

If you were a tenth as competent at self awareness as you are misireably incompetent diagnosing others you would be moderately tolerable.

Seek help
07-coffee3

Considering your penchant for glazing Tulane and USF while engaging in over-the-top self-hating histrionics, and lack of any substantive commentary that withstands even cursory scrutiny, it's safe to discard anything you write. Keep proving that the narcissistic injuries drive your ship, Cuck Khan.

More proof

Meds are your friend

...and you lack the cognitive ability to even counter, further validating me, but thanks for the middle-school level analysis.  Extra credit for not mentioning my mom.
10-07-2026 02:29 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
shere khan Offline
Southerner
*

Posts: 76,749
Joined: Mar 2004
Reputation: 10828
I Root For: Memphis
Location: Russia
Post: #142
RE: Most important factor for new American addition
(10-07-2026 02:29 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(10-07-2026 02:18 PM)shere khan Wrote:  
(10-07-2026 01:05 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(10-07-2026 12:59 PM)shere khan Wrote:  
(10-07-2026 11:41 AM)msu35 Wrote:  Of course you would feel compelled to defend the trolls and self-soothe, but I appreciate your dedication to self-identification.

Point stands

If you were a tenth as competent at self awareness as you are misireably incompetent diagnosing others you would be moderately tolerable.

Seek help
07-coffee3

Considering your penchant for glazing Tulane and USF while engaging in over-the-top self-hating histrionics, and lack of any substantive commentary that withstands even cursory scrutiny, it's safe to discard anything you write. Keep proving that the narcissistic injuries drive your ship, Cuck Khan.

More proof

Meds are your friend

...and you lack the cognitive ability to even counter, further validating me, but thanks for the middle-school level analysis.  Extra credit for not mentioning my mom.

03-lmfao

You have a screw loose. No joke.

Keep going
10-07-2026 03:05 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
msu35 Offline
Observing Reality
*

Posts: 21,642
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2234
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
Post: #143
RE: Most important factor for new American addition
(10-07-2026 03:05 PM)shere khan Wrote:  
(10-07-2026 02:29 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(10-07-2026 02:18 PM)shere khan Wrote:  
(10-07-2026 01:05 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(10-07-2026 12:59 PM)shere khan Wrote:  Point stands

If you were a tenth as competent at self awareness as you are misireably incompetent diagnosing others you would be moderately tolerable.

Seek help
07-coffee3

Considering your penchant for glazing Tulane and USF while engaging in over-the-top self-hating histrionics, and lack of any substantive commentary that withstands even cursory scrutiny, it's safe to discard anything you write. Keep proving that the narcissistic injuries drive your ship, Cuck Khan.

More proof

Meds are your friend

...and you lack the cognitive ability to even counter, further validating me, but thanks for the middle-school level analysis.  Extra credit for not mentioning my mom.

03-lmfao

You have a screw loose. No joke.

Keep going

Still waiting for a substantive counter-argument. Please, take all the time you need, but your default self-created echo chamber doesn't make a point, nor does it disprove your glaring lack of maturity and substance.
10-07-2026 03:15 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Tiger1983 Offline
BBA
*

Posts: 41,589
Joined: Apr 2006
Reputation: 2987
I Root For: Tigers - GTG!
Location: The enemy’s lair

DonatorsDonatorsDonators
Post: #144
RE: Most important factor for new American addition
Please cease from squabbling and instead, if one wishes, contribute to the thread topic. Otherwise, the thread has lost its purpose and will be treated as such.
10-08-2026 06:45 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Ourland Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 10,318
Joined: Apr 2017
Reputation: 990
I Root For: The Rice Owls
Location: Galveston
Post: #145
RE: Most important factor for new American addition
Most important factors, in as close an order as possible...

1. Market / population center
2. Budget / revenue sharing etc.
3. Facilities
4. Fan support / alumni engagement
5. Brand
6. Current on - field / court success
10-08-2026 07:17 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
ultraviolet Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,435
Joined: Jan 2004
Reputation: 519
I Root For: ECU
Location:
Post: #146
RE: Most important factor for new American addition
(10-08-2026 07:17 AM)Ourland Wrote:  Most important factors, in as close an order as possible...

1. Market / population center
2. Budget / revenue sharing etc.
3. Facilities
4. Fan support / alumni engagement
5. Brand
6. Current on - field / court success

That's a pretty good list.
10-08-2026 12:50 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Tiger1983 Offline
BBA
*

Posts: 41,589
Joined: Apr 2006
Reputation: 2987
I Root For: Tigers - GTG!
Location: The enemy’s lair

DonatorsDonatorsDonators
Post: #147
RE: Most important factor for new American addition
Why is market size/population the most important factor?
10-08-2026 01:17 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
SFLFB Offline
Special Teams
*

Posts: 847
Joined: Sep 2023
Reputation: 245
I Root For: USF
Location:
Post: #148
RE: Most important factor for new American addition
(10-08-2026 07:17 AM)Ourland Wrote:  Most important factors, in as close an order as possible...

1. Market / population center
2. Budget / revenue sharing etc.
3. Facilities
4. Fan support / alumni engagement
5. Brand
6. Current on - field / court success

Good list, I differ a tad in order. I'd put those factors in this order:

1. Budget / Revenue Sharing (self explanatory)
2. Fan support / alumni engagement (NIL + ticket sales)
3. Market / population center (regional + growth prospects)
4. Brand (kind of supports #2 + #3)
5. Facilities
6. Current on field/court success
10-08-2026 01:22 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
msu35 Offline
Observing Reality
*

Posts: 21,642
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2234
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
Post: #149
RE: Most important factor for new American addition
(10-08-2026 01:22 PM)SFLFB Wrote:  
(10-08-2026 07:17 AM)Ourland Wrote:  Most important factors, in as close an order as possible...

1. Market / population center
2. Budget / revenue sharing etc.
3. Facilities
4. Fan support / alumni engagement
5. Brand
6. Current on - field / court success

Good list, I differ a tad in order. I'd put those factors in this order:

1. Budget / Revenue Sharing (self explanatory)
2. Fan support / alumni engagement (NIL + ticket sales)
3. Market / population center (regional + growth prospects)
4. Brand (kind of supports #2 + #3)
5. Facilities
6. Current on field/court success

1) A financially healthy institution and athletic department. Conferences want turnkey solutions that can easily and quickly scale, not future charity cases and bottom feeders crushed by debt at the jump.

2) Market and brand. This is the primary revenue driver for the people calling the shots (e.g. ESPN) and is the most important factor once the financial filter is cleared.

3) Corporate, donor, and fan/alumni support directly contributes to points 1, 2, 4, and 5.

4) Facilities enhance points 1, 2, and 3. The snob factor prevalent in academia places this above point 5.

5) Success on the field or court, which enhances points 1, 2, and 3. Realistically the most volatile of the group.

Do it right and you have multiple feedback loops creating compounding value. Do it wrong and you eventually spend yourself into oblivion, creating a negative feedback loop, even if it's a catastrophic collapse or a slow slide into the abyss. Ultimately, the bar is higher than it's ever been for the G6.
10-08-2026 02:42 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
surrealpirate Online
GDP
*

Posts: 1,338
Joined: Dec 2003
Reputation: 199
I Root For: ECU
Location: The Western Front
Post: #150
RE: Most important factor for new American addition
(10-08-2026 01:17 PM)Tiger1983 Wrote:  Why is market size/population the most important factor?

I know you weren't asking me, but it shouldn't be the most important factor IMO. Budget/NIL, winning tradition, and passionate fanbase would roughly be the order I would put them in.

Large markets with a ton of pro sports will never have much interest in college teams at our level (or any level) unfortunately and that directly relates to the amount of money that the mouse will be willing to pay us come contract renewal time.

Give me a Boise/JMU type over a large market team that draws crickets on gameday, gets minimal coverage by their local media, and has little to no fans on message boards like these. All those factors point to low interest, low brand awareness, and therefore zero value towards our next contract.
(This post was last modified: 10-09-2026 11:34 AM by surrealpirate.)
10-09-2026 11:33 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
msu35 Offline
Observing Reality
*

Posts: 21,642
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2234
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
Post: #151
RE: Most important factor for new American addition
(10-09-2026 11:33 AM)surrealpirate Wrote:  
(10-08-2026 01:17 PM)Tiger1983 Wrote:  Why is market size/population the most important factor?

I know you weren't asking me, but it shouldn't be the most important factor IMO. Budget/NIL, winning tradition, and passionate fanbase would roughly be the order I would put them in.

Large markets with a ton of pro sports will never have much interest in college teams at our level (or any level) unfortunately and that directly relates to the amount of money that the mouse will be willing to pay us come contract renewal time.

Give me a Boise/JMU type over a large market team that draws crickets on gameday, gets minimal coverage by their local media, and has little to no fans on message boards like these. All those factors point to low interest, low brand awareness, and therefore zero value towards our next contract.

Of course. A large market is no good if you're in a hyper-saturated pro sports region with minimal mind share -- an afterthought at best. Conversely, the inverse is true. What good is deep penetration into a market the size of a postage stamp? As with all things in life, it depends. Ideally you want schools in top 50 markets who command a large or majority share of that market. Shades of gray, with some grays brighter than others.
10-09-2026 12:10 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Tiger1983 Offline
BBA
*

Posts: 41,589
Joined: Apr 2006
Reputation: 2987
I Root For: Tigers - GTG!
Location: The enemy’s lair

DonatorsDonatorsDonators
Post: #152
RE: Most important factor for new American addition
(10-09-2026 11:33 AM)surrealpirate Wrote:  
(10-08-2026 01:17 PM)Tiger1983 Wrote:  Why is market size/population the most important factor?

I know you weren't asking me, but it shouldn't be the most important factor IMO. Budget/NIL, winning tradition, and passionate fanbase would roughly be the order I would put them in.

Large markets with a ton of pro sports will never have much interest in college teams at our level (or any level) unfortunately and that directly relates to the amount of money that the mouse will be willing to pay us come contract renewal time.

Give me a Boise/JMU type over a large market team that draws crickets on gameday, gets minimal coverage by their local media, and has little to no fans on message boards like these. All those factors point to low interest, low brand awareness, and therefore zero value towards our next contract.

IMO, market size/population only matters for its contribution to the budget and especially revenue share.

The SEC, for example, generally resides in low populated areas and yet commands sizable media money.
(This post was last modified: 10-09-2026 05:01 PM by Tiger1983.)
10-09-2026 04:58 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
msu35 Offline
Observing Reality
*

Posts: 21,642
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2234
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
Post: #153
RE: Most important factor for new American addition
(10-09-2026 04:58 PM)Tiger1983 Wrote:  
(10-09-2026 11:33 AM)surrealpirate Wrote:  
(10-08-2026 01:17 PM)Tiger1983 Wrote:  Why is market size/population the most important factor?

I know you weren't asking me, but it shouldn't be the most important factor IMO. Budget/NIL, winning tradition, and passionate fanbase would roughly be the order I would put them in.

Large markets with a ton of pro sports will never have much interest in college teams at our level (or any level) unfortunately and that directly relates to the amount of money that the mouse will be willing to pay us come contract renewal time.

Give me a Boise/JMU type over a large market team that draws crickets on gameday, gets minimal coverage by their local media, and has little to no fans on message boards like these. All those factors point to low interest, low brand awareness, and therefore zero value towards our next contract.

IMO, market size/population only matters for its contribution to the budget and especially revenue share.

The SEC, for example, generally resides in low populated areas and yet commands sizable media money.

Is that your takeaway? I guess one would have to completely ignore how it works when your membership constitutes large land-grant universities and state flagships. We're not talking about tiny podunk schools, and your omissions conveniently skirt the exact reasons why those programs are juggernauts. Hope that clarifies.
10-09-2026 05:08 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
panama Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 31,470
Joined: May 2009
Reputation: 653
I Root For: Georgia STATE
Location: East Atlanta Village
Post: #154
RE: Most important factor for new American addition
(10-09-2026 04:58 PM)Tiger1983 Wrote:  
(10-09-2026 11:33 AM)surrealpirate Wrote:  
(10-08-2026 01:17 PM)Tiger1983 Wrote:  Why is market size/population the most important factor?

I know you weren't asking me, but it shouldn't be the most important factor IMO. Budget/NIL, winning tradition, and passionate fanbase would roughly be the order I would put them in.

Large markets with a ton of pro sports will never have much interest in college teams at our level (or any level) unfortunately and that directly relates to the amount of money that the mouse will be willing to pay us come contract renewal time.

Give me a Boise/JMU type over a large market team that draws crickets on gameday, gets minimal coverage by their local media, and has little to no fans on message boards like these. All those factors point to low interest, low brand awareness, and therefore zero value towards our next contract.

IMO, market size/population only matters for its contribution to the budget and especially revenue share.

The SEC, for example, generally resides in low populated areas and yet commands sizable media money.
SEC's market is their entire state....

Sent from my SM-S948U using Tapatalk
10-09-2026 10:22 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Tiger1983 Offline
BBA
*

Posts: 41,589
Joined: Apr 2006
Reputation: 2987
I Root For: Tigers - GTG!
Location: The enemy’s lair

DonatorsDonatorsDonators
Post: #155
RE: Most important factor for new American addition
(10-09-2026 10:22 PM)panama Wrote:  
(10-09-2026 04:58 PM)Tiger1983 Wrote:  
(10-09-2026 11:33 AM)surrealpirate Wrote:  
(10-08-2026 01:17 PM)Tiger1983 Wrote:  Why is market size/population the most important factor?

I know you weren't asking me, but it shouldn't be the most important factor IMO. Budget/NIL, winning tradition, and passionate fanbase would roughly be the order I would put them in.

Large markets with a ton of pro sports will never have much interest in college teams at our level (or any level) unfortunately and that directly relates to the amount of money that the mouse will be willing to pay us come contract renewal time.

Give me a Boise/JMU type over a large market team that draws crickets on gameday, gets minimal coverage by their local media, and has little to no fans on message boards like these. All those factors point to low interest, low brand awareness, and therefore zero value towards our next contract.

IMO, market size/population only matters for its contribution to the budget and especially revenue share.

The SEC, for example, generally resides in low populated areas and yet commands sizable media money.
SEC's market is their entire state....

Sent from my SM-S948U using Tapatalk

Because a critical mass of them have built a following over generations by winning.

Winning is what matters ultimately to build a large fan base and these days those with the most NIL/Revenue sharing are in the best position to win. Hence, NIL/Revenue is the most (not only) factor for sustainable success.
10-10-2026 04:14 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
voss749 Offline
Special Teams
*

Posts: 742
Joined: May 2012
Reputation: 29
I Root For: FAU
Location:
Post: #156
RE: Most important factor for new American addition
(09-28-2026 09:12 AM)goliath74 Wrote:  
(09-27-2026 10:36 PM)shere khan Wrote:  
(09-27-2026 09:48 PM)goliath74 Wrote:  
(09-27-2026 08:28 PM)ATTALLABLAZE Wrote:  Food. It’s all about the food and good food courses.

Nah, I think it is all about scantily clad women.

Right. Hookers and blow
07-coffee3

So, that's what ails you?


Wouldnt FIU have all of that covered?
10-10-2026 07:19 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
AAC.TV.Talk Offline
Bench Warmer
*

Posts: 117
Joined: May 2025
Reputation: 66
I Root For: A-A-C! A-A-C!
Location:
Post: #157
RE: Most important factor for new American addition
(10-02-2026 12:31 PM)AAC.TV.Talk Wrote:  
(09-30-2026 03:17 PM)FAU Connoisseur! Wrote:  I think snacks are the most important factor for new American additions.

Not a bad idea.

I voted for NIL/Rev Share as representative of "Commitment to Invest."

The other two factors which are top three but weren't in the poll:
Institutional fit
Brand value

Both of those have various factors contributing. For institutional fit, the 15 schools in the American are not identical, but the majority look alike. And where aspects of the fit are a mismatch, the weight in money and brand explain why.
ECU is not a city school like the majority, but clearly willing to spend for success and had a reputation as a giant killer back in the day -- a day that was more recent in 2011-12 timeframe of selecting the Pirates.
The academies are a better institutional fit with their other sports in the Patriot League, but as football national brands, they get in.

There is no single most important factor, but the balance of these three things makes the decision.

So how close was everybody?
The conference release upon announcing our future addition JMU laid it out for us:
Institutional and academic alignment;
Competitive strength and trajectory;
Institutional investment;
Financial sustainability and member value;
Brand, media value, fan engagement;
Geography and operational fit.

That was the order they were listed, without saying that was in priority order.

My three were half of the "textbook" answer.

The full paragraph:
Quote:Following a formal written application from James Madison University, the American conducted a deliberate and comprehensive due diligence process to evaluate the institution, its alignment with the American and the long-term value of the relationship. The evaluation considered six primary areas: institutional and academic alignment; competitive strength and trajectory; institutional investment; financial sustainability and member value; brand, media value, fan engagement; and geography and operational fit. The conference used multiple sources of analysis, including a quantitative media-value study examining market characteristics, audience performance, fan engagement, competitive performance and other value drivers.

https://theamerican.org/news/2026/10/12/...rsity.aspx
10-28-2026 03:19 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Ourland Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 10,318
Joined: Apr 2017
Reputation: 990
I Root For: The Rice Owls
Location: Galveston
Post: #158
RE: Most important factor for new American addition
If there are no competitive programs in big markets, then it makes perfect sense to add the the school with the most well-funded athletics department. We really strengthened ourselves by taking JMU.

If I had to guess, we want Air Force, but I think they're locked to the MWC, unless Pernetti can pull a rabbit from a hat. That leaves Miami Ohio. I read an article several months back that said that they have a healthy NIL and direct revenue aparatus for a mid-major. I wonder if anyone knows if there's truth to that. If I'm not mistaken, their football payroll approaches $10 million or so now...
(This post was last modified: 10-28-2026 05:40 PM by Ourland.)
10-28-2026 04:29 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Bang Burger Online
Bench Warmer
*

Posts: 159
Joined: Aug 2006
Reputation: 4
I Root For: Victory
Location: Bethel, NY
Post: #159
RE: Most important factor for new American addition
College Insider just released their Mid-Major Top 25 preseason poll. This is the closest to a real mid-major poll (coaches vote similar to the AP coaches poll and its been around for almost 30 years).

https://collegeinsider.com/mens-mid-major-top-25
10-29-2026 01:03 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
msu35 Offline
Observing Reality
*

Posts: 21,642
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2234
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
Post: #160
RE: Most important factor for new American addition
(10-29-2026 01:03 PM)Bang Burger Wrote:  College Insider just released their Mid-Major Top 25 preseason poll. This is the closest to a real mid-major poll (coaches vote similar to the AP coaches poll and its been around for almost 30 years).

https://collegeinsider.com/mens-mid-major-top-25

That was one of the most hilarious posts I've read in a long time. Did you read the fine print? Where is the AAC, PAC-12, or MWC?

Quote:NOTE: The Mid-Major Poll is made up of teams from the following conferences: America East, Atlantic Sun, Big Sky, Big South, Big West, Coastal Athletic, Conference USA, Horizon, Ivy, Metro, Mid-American, Mid-Eastern, Missouri Valley, Northeast, Ohio Valley, Patriot, Southern, Southland, Southwestern, Summit, Sun Belt, United Athletic, West Coast.

03-lmfao
10-29-2026 01:06 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.