tf8693
All American

Posts: 2,902
Joined: Jul 2023
Reputation: 333
I Root For: Notre Dame
Location:
|
RE: Football Association of Independent Schools Idea
(10-25-2026 03:24 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (10-25-2026 12:06 PM)tf8693 Wrote: (10-23-2026 07:56 PM)random asian guy Wrote: I posted this idea before but since it was reported that Miami is considering the independence option, perhaps we can revisit this idea.
Think about these facts:
1. The current PCSA bill requires at least three years of independence.
2. Four ACC schools allegedly considers a PE-funded structure outside of a traditional conference. (https://x.com/burgessev/status/2108248449393037787)
3. The settlement terms between FSU/Clemson and the ACC let ACC schools (at least six members) leave the ACC to join a “single sport league, conference or other association.”
4. Conference championship games are going away (less incentive of belonging to a conference)
So what I can envision is an association of independent schools only for football.
They would play other independent schools in that association (and there will be at least six of them if the ACC schools get out using the above exit clause), but there would be no rules forcing them to. They could schedule anyone they want.
Perhaps the association would negotiate the collective media deal for them, with the money split based on the contribution each member makes.
This would be only for football so they would continue playing basketball and other sports in their current conference. That's the big advantage compared to going completely independent. Technically, ND could join this “association of independents” for football. And perhaps some B12 schools may try to join too.
Again, I don’t know whether it will happen, but it’s the type of idea schools like Miami and FSU would explore as a fallback option in my view.
To try to answer some of your questions, if this happens (and that's a big if) . . .
Would Notre Dame join? Probably not. Definitely not if this entity were recognized as a conference. I think the 24-team CFP field will be the final nail in the coffin of the *ND can be forced into a football conference* idea. And the ND-NBC deal has stood the test of time. Sure, there's always going to be some controversy over who is left out of the CFP But ND's fan base is a bit different in that regard. A majority, or at least a very vocal minority, of ND fans consistently maintained that a 7-5 ND team wasn't *good enough* for a bowl bid in the era of 80-plus bowl bids That same group will say the same thing if there's even an arguable case to keep ND out of a 24-team CFP field. With that in mind, all of the possibilities that could *force* ND into a conference have already been met. Under those circumstances, ND has no interest in joining ANY football conference. Not sure why some people have so much difficulty understanding that. You don't have to agree with it to accept and acknowledge it
Will ND play members of this group? The short answer is, it depends. Some here have said it would only last three years. I'm not sure I agree. If PCSA passes, and the cap is at 20 members, the de facto cap for the P2 becomes 18. Both conferences will leave a spot for ND *just in case*, and neither will expand to an odd number of members. That means there will be only two spots available in the P2 if the PCSA passes and the cap remains at 20 (admittedly a big if). If Clemson joins this group, ND has an upcoming series with Clemson, so ND would play them ND also would play Florida State and Miami if they joined depending on availability in their schedule. Anyone else? Probably not, unless either: (a) it would count against ND's ACC obligation; or (b) ND needed to fill spots in its schedule.
Will Big XII members join? Remember, there is no similar provision for the Big XII, so this probably depends on them making satisfactory arrangements for basketball and olympic sports. Assuming that to be taken care of, I can see this idea appealing to Cody Campbell (maybe I'm wrong about that), so Texas Tech is a possibility if he has enough pull there. And if the *Utah to the ACC* rumors that permeate this board are credited, Utah has to be considered a possibility as well. Big XII schools that have an ACC rival, such as West Virginia (Pitt), Cincinnati (Louisville), TCU (SMU), and UCF (if South Florida joins the ACC) may also be possibilities if their rival school joins.
Can’t comment on the others, but TCU allowed Dykes to convince them to drop SMU once the game turned into a difficult matchup after SMU moved up to the ACC.
Consider the following:
SMU won 15 in a row from 1072 to 1986. They were ahead 34-28-7.
Since SMU came back in 1989, TCU leads the series, 26-9. After 2025, the series ended bc Dykes was afraid of the competition. I would say that no school would ever run from their “rival” in such a cowardly fashion, but USC just did so with ND for much the same reason.
Some of these Admins need to grow a spine and quit letting the football coaches water down their schedules to Cignetti-like levels of weak sauce.
Anyway, it doesn’t matter. Baylor is TCU’s greatest rival. 122 meetings, a very even split of 61-54-7, and each school’s longest win streak is only 8 games. No 15 in a row domination like SMU had over those inept TCU squads during the Pony Express days.
Since you brought it up (sorta) . . .
During the Ted Tollner era (yes, I'm aware he was at USC for only four years, but the USC teams from that timeframe tend to run together, in my mind at least, so I usually refer to it as the *Ted Tollner era* for shorthand), ND won 11 in a row against USC, and 13 games unbeaten (ND won every year from 83 to 93, the 94 game was a tie, then ND won again in 95 before USC finally broke the streak in 96). Yet back then there was never any talk of ending the series. Even Gerry Faust got into the act, winning three straight against USC from 83 to 85. True, USC was still in the Pac-10 back then, but that was also the timeframe where the Pac-10 champ beating the Big Ten champ in the Rose Bowl was in the *death and taxes* category.
|
|