Quote:If Marshall comes back, I predict NIU comes back eventually after another failed 'we're too good for the MAC' try fails
Thing is tho, it's not like NIU is new to the MAC (been here since before this century), and it's not like they have a lot of $$. They don't. They had those two top-G5 years
(one went to NY bowls of course; other was undefeated but then whipped in CCG by BGSU + another top-G5 in bowl after; to be fair QB Lynch was semi-partially-injured late season). But how much you're better than your conference outside of having High G5 $$ is being an Ohio State/Oregon/prev-Mich within your conference comparatively. So let's look at their years since COVID, also within the MAC itself as a key.
(2018) 8-6 [6-2]: Tough OOC Schedule, beat Buffalo in MCCG game by 1pt. Whipped by 10-3 UAB in bowl but earlier in season beat 7-6 G5 @BYU
(2019) 5-7 [4-4]: Lost to @Vandy by less than losing to BallState, but Vandy was Horrible P4/P5 until 2024, when paying players got leverage
(2021) 9-5 [6-2]: Lost close bowl game to Coastal Carolina, upper SunBelt team, who was 10-2 going in; although CoastCarolina only beat @Buff by 3 early in season
(2022) 3-9 [2-6]: Only lost to @Kentucky by 8 and @Vanderbilt by 10; but only beat Eastern Illinois by 7
(2023) 7-6 [5-3]: Was 6-6 beating @BostColl in OT but losing to FCS; lost to Tulsa by only 8; beat fellow 6-6 team ArkState by 2pts in bowl
(2024) 8-5 [4-4]: Upset ND! But .500 in the MAC, and lost to Buffalo in OT week after. Close games all around; beat Fresno in bowl in 2OTs
(2025) 3-9 [2-6]: Had some close games, but one was they only beat FCS Holy Cross by 2pts.
I don't see how they could say "we're better than the MAC". Toledo has and has had a better position to say that these days. Best NIU could do is ride off their 2 awesome years and talk said smack for a limited time -- which started in 2012, stayed good tho after 2013 until 2015; then when the 2016 year set in it'd be no-talk (under .500). It was a stretch of time, as if 2012-2015 would be how they'd be for another 10 years. :)
Quote:I don't see why Marshall would come to the MAC tho. To me the MAC is even w/ the SunBelt so it'd be a lateral move.
I don't think they'd Want to out of vision and quality-of-conference. Because, yeah, it's lateral. The only thing I can think they hypothetically kinda wanting to and open for it, would be if they have issues with SunBelt, and it also on-the-side being greater travel costs for thier Athletic Dept VS being the MAC since it's mostly closer, and felt comfortable here before.