(10-13-2026 04:00 PM)Ragu Wrote: (10-13-2026 03:46 PM)Volkmar Wrote: (10-13-2026 03:14 PM)Ragu Wrote: Miami OH probably makes sense next. Ohio is a big state so getting one of the schools there is logical
Yep, either UConn or Miami OH.
UConn doesnt make sense. Football only isn't valuable with them as it isn't a great football program
Besides, I think South Florida and UConn will be the first to be added to the acc
I know Miami OH is a good school and offered a lot of money. The American just has to see if they are more value added then Ohio or Toledo and get it right. I expect al 3 to leave the MAC down the line
Well, I asked AI to rank which schools would be a best fit for the American Conference in terms of athletics, academics, growth potential, market size, facilities, revenue sharing/NIL, geographic fit, cultural fit, winning tradition, and value added to a potential media deal. IOW, I threw pretty much everything into the soup that I could think of.
Without going into all the specifics, JMU stood out as a clear first choice. So we definitely did right in admitting them into our conference. Miami (Ohio) ranked as the best remaining full-membership fit, followed by UConn (with caveats) and Liberty.
It also said the American Conference, while JMU’s addition complicates scheduling, the league has stated it is not proactively seeking more members and prioritizes long-term brand/competitive value over pure entrance-fee money, but interest has come from Miami (OH), UConn, and Liberty.
This is long but here’s what it said about the other 3 schools…
1. Miami University (Ohio) — Strongest overall full-membership fit
• Athletics: Recent multi-sport success (multiple MAC title-game appearances in football; standout basketball seasons). Strong “Cradle of Coaches” tradition and aggressive roster/NIL investment (sources put combined football/men’s basketball spending in the high seven figures to low eight figures range).
• Academics: “Public Ivy” profile with solid national rankings, high graduation rates, and research activity that aligns with AAC peers (many R1/R2).
• Growth / market / facilities: Stable but ambitious enrollment; Ohio Valley/Cincinnati-Dayton market; major arena investment (~$242–281 million project).
• Revenue sharing/NIL: Demonstrated capacity and willingness to invest; offered a reported $30–40 million entrance package.
• Geographic / cultural fit: Strong Midwest addition that meshes with the existing footprint; public-university cultural match is excellent.
• Winning tradition / media value: Deep MAC history plus recent on-field relevance adds competitive depth and some regional media inventory without major dilution risks.
It is the clearest peer-style addition after JMU.
2. UConn — Highest brand/media ceiling, but practical fit issues
• Athletics: Elite men’s and women’s basketball brands (national-title pedigree); improving football (recent 9-win seasons and bowl success).
• Academics: Top public flagship with strong research and graduation metrics.
• Growth / market / facilities: Large enrollment (~25k+ undergrads at Storrs plus system campuses); Northeast media markets (Hartford/NY/Boston proximity); substantial recent capital spending and a large stadium (Rentschler Field ~36–40k). Athletics budget has been in the $100M+ range.
• Revenue sharing/NIL: High capacity.
• Geographic / cultural fit: Extends the Northeast footprint (alongside Temple/Army/Navy) but is a travel stretch for some members. Cultural fit as a public flagship is fine, but the historical full-membership departure (2019–20) and preference for football-only (keeping Olympic sports in the Big East) creates scheduling and integration friction. Some members have reportedly wanted reciprocal non-conference basketball games.
• Winning tradition / media value: Basketball brand is the biggest pure media asset among candidates and would enhance the conference’s national profile, especially around March. Football value is more incremental.
Best if the league is open to a football-only or hybrid arrangement; less clean as a full member.
3. Liberty — Resources and results, weaker cultural/market match
• Athletics: Football success (including a Fiesta Bowl appearance); regularly competitive in Conference USA basketball and other sports.
• Academics: Large private institution with broad program offerings (including professional schools); different mission emphasis.
• Growth / market / facilities: Very large enrollment; solid on-campus facilities (Williams Stadium ~25k, indoor practice, modern arenas). Financial resources are a clear strength.
• Revenue sharing/NIL: Capacity to meet or exceed AAC minimums.
• Geographic / cultural fit: Virginia location is reasonable, but the private evangelical identity is a poorer cultural match for a conference dominated by public universities. Market size (Lynchburg area) is more limited.
• Winning tradition / media value: Recent football visibility helps, but overall brand and media lift is more regional/niche than UConn or even Miami (OH).
Viable if the conference prioritizes enrollment size and cash over cultural alignment.