Certainly, going 0–7 is a legitimate reason to move on from the current head coach. Ultimately, the head coach is responsible for the team's results. However, I have several questions about the overall state of the program that deserve consideration.
1. What shape was the program in before Harley took over?
The January 28, 2026, interview with Coach Thomas Hammock on Frazier's Corner was certainly unusual, especially considering he left just 20 days later.
Frazier's Corner Interview With Thomas Hammock
What was happening behind the scenes, and how much of the program's current problems predated Harley being name head coach?
Remember NIU went 3 - 9 in 2025. Were we on an upward or downward trajectory?
2. Why have two offensive coordinators?
Having two offensive coordinators raises questions about leadership, responsibility, and accountability. Could this arrangement have created confusion for players and other staff members and negatively affected the offense?
3. Does the team have enough talent to compete in the Mountain West?
There have been complaints on this board about the number of FCS transfers brought in through the transfer portal. Were these players good enough to compete at the Mountain West level? While the team certainly has some talented players, there are also noticeable weaknesses. What is the true talent level of this roster?
4. Would another head coach achieve significantly better results with this roster?
Some coaches might do better, but how much better given they would have started after February 28, 2026? Could another coach realistically take this team to a bowl game by winning six or more games, or would the result be one to three wins? If a new coach produced only one to three wins, would this board be calling for another coaching change? I suspect it would.
5. Is Harley fully responsible?
Harley took over a team that was not his. He may have had input on the defensive side, but he inherited players he had not recruited. If the roster lacks Mountain West-level talent, how realistic was it to expect him to turn things around quickly? Would Hammock have had a better season?
6. Were there other viable candidates available when the interim coach was named on February 18?
Naming an interim coach at that point presented a difficult situation. Given that most other coaching positions had already been filled, were there genuinely qualified candidates available who could have done a better job under those circumstances?
7. Did we address the 2025 issues in 2026?
We brought in an additional offensive coordinator and quarterback to address the 2025 offensive issues. While improved, many other issues throughout the team popped up.
My point is not that going 0–7 is acceptable. It isn't. The head coach must be held accountable for the results. However, before concluding that replacing the coach will solve all of this team's problems, we should also examine the roster, the coaching structure, the circumstances surrounding the transition, and the overall condition of the program.
Does NIU have the resources to quickly improve the team through the transfer portal? What is the turnaround time to make NIU competitive? What other areas do you think need to be addressed?