This article is one that makes me want to root for a Space X mobile network success. The people tearing the idea apart are so smug and cocky about it.
“This ranks as one of the top three dumbest ideas in my four decades of being in this industry," said Earl Lum, the founder of analyst company EJL Wireless Research”
Ouch. He may be right, or he may be wrong. I don’t know. He may just hate Elon Musk. Or he may be an expert in all things wireless that I knows a lot of things few outside that industry really know. I have no way to tell.
Some others cited in the article have questions, some are more optimistic regarding the talent within Space X to innovate solutions.
However, for those that know something about wireless, most of this criticism launched at him is about small cell, or femtocell service that would be provided by Starlink receivers. They would be like wireless hotspots for cell phones in the surrounding area. Apart from that, the idea is that people’s phones would be on a direct satellite connection
That would be fine for small groups and individuals in rural areas as it would provide good indoor coverage that a satellite to phone connection cannot provide. So if he is planning a mobile service aimed mostly at his own Starlink customers who are overwhelmingly in rural areas, I can see it working well for the roughly 3 million subscribers that fit that description. In cities, I see validity in the criticisms. Perhaps existing Starlink customers and customers in rural areas are all that will be marketed to- at first.
And that’s what excites me. He has a viable plan to get at least some mobile customers at launch (if that happens), but it’s fun to think about what innovative solutions may be lying in wait for when the kinks are worked out or a never seen before technical solution emerges and proves these “analysts” wrong. He may have a different type of network in the works apart from everything being discussed.
https://www.lightreading.com/5g/small-ce...won-t-work
Although I am the epitome of the ideal customer for Starlink service, I have stuck with the less than ideal solution I have for now. It was slow to be rolled out to my locale and I lost some interest in it over that time. It also sucks power at a high rate, which I really don’t want as a solar user.