UTSA are clearly #1. The next 4 are so close to each other and are so uninspiring that I would refer to them as ##2-5. I understand that, normally, 4 weeks should be enough to separate teams but, this year, I just do not see it.
So, in my view:
1. UTSA
2-5. USF, Tulane, UNT, Tulsa (in no particular order)
6-9. Army, Memphis, FAU, UAB (in no particular order)
10. ECU
11. Navy
12. Rice
13. Temple
14. Charlotte
(09-28-2026 02:23 PM)SFLFB Wrote: After 4 games, most of the offseason player and coaching turnover dust should be settling. As we head into conference play, rank the American!
1. UTSA
2. UNT
3. Tulsa
4. USF
5. Tulane
6. Memphis
7. Army
8. ECU
9. FAU
10. Navy
11. Temple
12. UAB
13. Rice
14. Charlotte
Cool, with only three games played, Army and Navy have time to shake off more dust compared to everyone else!
(09-28-2026 02:32 PM)goliath74 Wrote: UTSA are clearly #1. The next 4 are so close to each other and are so uninspiring that I would refer to them as ##2-5. I understand that, normally, 4 weeks should be enough to separate teams but, this year, I just do not see it.
So, in my view:
1. UTSA
2-5. USF, Tulane, UNT, Tulsa (in no particular order) 6-9. Army, Memphis, FAU, UAB (in no particular order)
10. ECU
11. Navy
12. Rice
13. Temple
14. Charlotte
I like that ECU is under the radar. I know I'm biased but now that we have made the move to Emory Williams at QB, I think ECU is a different team. Defense is solid. Pirates would be 3-1 had Williams started from the get go. We're paying him about $1M to do a job, let him do it. It was a perfect time to make the move to him though (vs FCS Saturday to get his confidence up before a Bye and then Rice here in Greenville for homecoming). ECU has also been without their top 3 WRs, and should have all of them back moving forward. FWIW, Pirates are favored in all remaining games per ESPN FPI (including @UAB, vs Temple and vs FAU) except vs USF 50/50 game, @ Memphis 31%, and @ Army 35%.
1. UTSA
2. USF
3. Memphis
4. Tulane
5. ECU
6. Army
7. UAB
8. Tulsa
9. UNT
10. FAU
11. Navy
12. Temple
13. Rice
14. Charlotte
Most have played very different schedule to this point, and comparing each other is still difficult. At this point I think UTSA, Memphis, and maybe Tulsa are at the top. North Texas is probably a step behind those three, but could crash the party with a win at Tulsa. Thursday night’s game on ESPN will be must watch TV for every American Conference fan.
(09-28-2026 04:53 PM)Side.Show.Joe Wrote: Most have played very different schedule to this point, and comparing each other is still difficult. At this point I think UTSA, Memphis, and maybe Tulsa are at the top. North Texas is probably a step behind those three, but could crash the party with a win at Tulsa. Thursday night’s game on ESPN will be must watch TV for every American Conference fan.
I think you guys will beat Tulsa. Much of it depends on whether or not their QB returns. I haven't heard anything.
(09-28-2026 05:15 PM)Ourland Wrote: Memphis
USF
Army
UTSA
North Texas
Tulsa
FAU
Navy Tulane
ECU
Temple
UAB
Rice
Charlotte
Ouch.
And it’s probably true.
At least you aren't a Rice fan.
Seriously, the whole conference is "down" this season. There's parity throughout the conference in football. Memphis might be our best team, but even they aren't in the top 50. Tulsa is doing great. So is North Texas.
(This post was last modified: 09-28-2026 06:26 PM by Ourland.)
(09-28-2026 05:15 PM)Ourland Wrote: Memphis
USF
Army
UTSA
North Texas
Tulsa
FAU
Navy Tulane
ECU
Temple
UAB
Rice
Charlotte
Ouch.
And it’s probably true.
At least you aren't a Rice fan.
Seriously, the whole conference is "down" this season. There's parity throughout the conference in football. Memphis might be our best team, but even they aren't in the top 50. Tulsa is doing great. So is North Texas.
North Texas isn’t doing great. We needed to beat Texas State on the road. We have blown any chance at a playoff spot and reduced the American’s odds by losing.
(09-28-2026 05:15 PM)Ourland Wrote: Memphis
USF
Army
UTSA
North Texas
Tulsa
FAU
Navy Tulane
ECU
Temple
UAB
Rice
Charlotte
Ouch.
And it’s probably true.
At least you aren't a Rice fan.
Seriously, the whole conference is "down" this season. There's parity throughout the conference in football. Memphis might be our best team, but even they aren't in the top 50. Tulsa is doing great. So is North Texas.
North Texas isn’t doing great. We needed to beat Texas State on the road. We have blown any chance at a playoff spot and reduced the American’s odds by losing.
It's not the end of the world. Most teams lose in San Marcos. They're very hard to stop.
You guys should be feeling good. There's not much drop off from last season. You have some good coaches.
As for the CFP, it's not the American's year. I expect Memphis and USF to lose a couple games.
(09-28-2026 05:15 PM)Ourland Wrote: Memphis
USF
Army
UTSA
North Texas
Tulsa
FAU
Navy Tulane
ECU
Temple
UAB
Rice
Charlotte
Ouch.
And it’s probably true.
At least you aren't a Rice fan.
Seriously, the whole conference is "down" this season. There's parity throughout the conference in football. Memphis might be our best team, but even they aren't in the top 50. Tulsa is doing great. So is North Texas.
North Texas isn’t doing great. We needed to beat Texas State on the road. We have blown any chance at a playoff spot and reduced the American’s odds by losing.
It's not the end of the world. Most teams lose in San Marcos. They're very hard to stop.
You guys should be feeling good. There's not much drop off from last season. You have some good coaches.
As for the CFP, it's not the American's year. I expect Memphis and USF to lose a couple games.
Sadly I agree. I think Boise will probably take the spot this year.
The American top teams arent as good as they were last year and that was to be expected with losing so many coaches and top players.
I think it will be much better next year because I don’t think we will lose coaches making it a better chance to keep players.
Seriously, the whole conference is "down" this season. There's parity throughout the conference in football. Memphis might be our best team, but even they aren't in the top 50. Tulsa is doing great. So is North Texas.
North Texas isn’t doing great. We needed to beat Texas State on the road. We have blown any chance at a playoff spot and reduced the American’s odds by losing.
It's not the end of the world. Most teams lose in San Marcos. They're very hard to stop.
You guys should be feeling good. There's not much drop off from last season. You have some good coaches.
As for the CFP, it's not the American's year. I expect Memphis and USF to lose a couple games.
Sadly I agree. I think Boise will probably take the spot this year.
The American top teams arent as good as they were last year and that was to be expected with losing so many coaches and top players.
I think it will be much better next year because I don’t think we will lose coaches making it a better chance to keep players.
Even Army and Navy are struggling. Our top teams aren't very good this season, but next season should be better.
These are the most recent available futures odds to win the conference title (primarily from Kalshi prediction-market pricing as of ~September 28, 2026; sportsbook lines can vary slightly and move with results).
American odds are shown with approximate implied probability:
Where does Wichita slot in here .. as in ... where would it better for a school to not have a team than to be fielding one at all.... I think we are at least above Charlotte
(09-29-2026 11:44 AM)Stickboy46 Wrote: Where does Wichita slot in here .. as in ... where would it better for a school to not have a team than to be fielding one at all.... I think we are at least above Charlotte
I wouldn't be so sure. You had to drop football to begin with because it was simply that bad, and post-Marshall your basketball has been a net drag too with a near .500 conference record. Before you take a jab at Memphis, under Penny even with an historically bad season (worst in half a century) we're still nearly .700 in conference play. Make the tourney again before you start acting better than anyone here.
As we turn the page of a united front against outside conferences to beating up on one another, it is time for the American Athletic Avengers to enter Civil War and that time of year when one of the "New Additions" beat an "OG American" team:
1. UTSA - The Meep Meep Spider-Runners from SA may not be undefeated but losing at the real UT is nothing to be ashamed of.
2. South Florida - The South-ish Florida Hulks played down to this the Bowlers of Green, but have found a way to win every game and are the last undefeated team in the Conference.
3. Memphis - The Iron River Cats took one on the chin in the land of the Smurf Turf, but have taken care of business otherwise.
4. UNT - The Mean Green Falcon of North-ish Texas have looked up and down this season, but this week brings a chance to prove themselves against . . .
5. Tulsa - The Gold Plated Thors, the God of Thunder (not the God of Hammers). Still a lot of questions about how big a storm they can conjure, but for now 3-1 keeps them above the pack.
6. Tulane - The Nola Green Namor with losses to middle P4 teams and wins over lower G6 teams, the wave isn't as tall as it has been.
7. Army - Captain America's season is looking like it will include the Commander in Chief's Trophy this year.
8. ECU - The Eastern Carolina Deadpool may still have fight left, but it's hard to hear above the constant chatter.
(Return of the Aviary)
9. FAU - The Atlantic Florida Captain Citrus' loss in the Swamp week one continues to look better and better, but the seasons real tests come when the weather gets cooler.
10. Temple - The Daredevil the Hidden Temple continues to come up short in three straight games.
11. Rice - The R-Owl Photons (a.k.a. Monica Rambeau) appear to be on the outside looking in for a winning season once again, but like the most famous fictional alumnus at the Westview Anomaly. But how telling are losses @ND, WMU, and @Fresno when compared to . . .
12. UAB - Bammy Ant-Blazers who split the SunBelt Lousiana Classics, but went super sized to take down . . .
13. Navy - The Navy Nic Fury's drop another close one, is it an elaborate scheme or sign of real trouble.
14. Charlotte - The Metropolitan Carolina Green Goblins are just scary at this point.