bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,947
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: Levine: The Big Ten and SEC have no plans to expand in the near future
(09-27-2026 10:09 PM)AllTideUp Wrote: (09-25-2026 12:02 PM)JRsec Wrote: (09-25-2026 11:46 AM)The Beaver Wrote: (09-25-2026 10:37 AM)bullet Wrote: (09-25-2026 09:54 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote: This x 1000.
BRANDS.
UNC is the best combination of Brand, Academics, dominates own large State, you name it. Everyone else had better bring something, and something big and valuable, if they want consideration. The football Brands of Miami, Clemson, or FSU? That works. The mammoth Duke mbb brand + their intense rivalry with UNC + T1 Academics? That could work. Kansas? Sure, maybe, they created basketball and their rivalry with Missouri is awesome. I get so caught up in the weeds talking about other schools, but with this 19 cap looking more likely as time goes on, it just gets awfully hard to see how a school like Colorado, VT, GT or UVA that doesn't have that huge national Brand can turf out one of those listed above.
There aren't that many schools with a shot even at 20. FSU, Miami, Clemson and North Carolina are locks. Probably UVA (presidents like them and get enough money from the bigger brands to take a "loss leader"). The final one would be Notre Dame if they decided to take the last helicopter out of Saigon. Assuming they wouldn't, then a few schools have a shot-Stanford, Kansas, Virginia Tech, North Carolina St. I don't see Duke getting in at 20. The SEC and Big Ten don't need another Vanderbilt or Northwestern even if basketball is great. So that's only 4 besides the 6 obvious candidates.
Now if conferences were able to and did decide to go beyond 20, then there are a whole lot of schools. But I think they would likely stop at 20.
The interesting thing to me about 20 is the SEC cannot protect all relevant areas. I still think the Big Ten holds a slot for Notre Dame, but could see a one off 19th add of whichever great southern school isn't added. Whether thats FSU, Miami, UNC or Clemson. If the SEC chooses all of them, which I doubt, Miami and Clemson are both of questionable utility, only then does it start making sense for the Big Ten to do nothing.
Bear in mind, there's been zero give on the 19 member limit so far and I don't think that gets changed in, at least, the senate version of the bill.
I also don't think 19 is likely to be changed at this time in the process. So, what's your point. Whether the SEC takes North Carolina and Virginia, or North Carolina and Duke and whether the third is Virginia, Duke or Miami the SEC has effectively taken all they need to take in the SE. Personally, I see UNC & UVa with Duke in some capacity. Duke and the SEC have a very large money donor in common and if Duke was going to be left behind, he might get involved. If a football brand is required, and I don't think it will be, Miami makes the most sense for the reasons I stated. But at 19 if the Big Ten holds that slot for Notre Dame (who will likely be looking around if the academic schools leave the ACC) then expansion to the Southeast by the Big Ten in any capacity is dead. That leaves the SEC the ability to use its remaining 3 slots as it deems best with no thought whatsoever at this juncture to having to defend brand. And on the ESPN vs FOX front, a reload of 4 schools should N.D. indeed decide to affiliate with the Big Ten would give ESPN a chance to add up to 5 schools to reach 19. I think ESPN might have designs on holding the #1 most viewed of the P4 and the #3 most viewed by rebuilding the ACC with the best they can take from the Big 12. What I can't remember right now is whether the limit on how many you could take from one conference was actually an amendment or in the original wording of the PCSA. That of course could impact things a bit if it still is there and is passed.
UNC and Duke is a natural combo for lots of reasons and I think, all things being equal, is the one UNC would prefer as they move. I see UVA as a necessity from the SEC's standpoint. The state of VA is too large to ignore and there are other positive aspects of UVA at that.
I clipped your post just to respond to this one part. Why is UVA a necessity? How much money will they actually put in Crimson Tide coffers when they're winning 4-6 games per year for decades? VT would still control Virginia. If we are so anxious to get a Flagship AAU of a large and growing conference, why not go for Colorado instead of UVA? Or Miami, which is not a flagship but like Southern Cal is a huge draw as a private pseudo Flagship AAU in a critical region?
We get so many comments from old school SEC supporters about how important and/or critical UVA is, but I wonder if this isn't at least partly based upon the desire to add them for so long. Not unlike UNC, with the critical difference that UNC still makes financial sense in a modern era that rewards Brands financially far more than just "school XX is in a big State = cable $$". Presumably, UVA has had plenty of chances over the past few decades to join the SEC and decided that they liked the ACC better. They should have jumped when they had the chance because they're not getting a bunch of votes from the more Western SEC schools, and I'm still convinced that even the schools near Virginia will still end up leaning in a different direction once they see the financials.
|
|