SFLFB
Special Teams

Posts: 847
Joined: Sep 2023
Reputation: 245
I Root For: USF
Location:
|
RE: People want in the American!
(09-25-2026 10:28 PM)Nugget49er Wrote: (09-25-2026 04:32 PM)Thewavefan Wrote: (09-25-2026 04:24 PM)Ned Low Wrote: (09-25-2026 04:16 PM)Thewavefan Wrote: No markets? No thanks. There is a reason why schools are beating down the doors to get in but we have to stay the course. If your market isn’t sizzling, we have no interest. Still has to sting that the best school the Sun Belt has is literally begging to join our conference. This shows everyone that the American is light years ahead of the Sun Belt and there is no room to debate it ever again.
What programs in what markets would you want to add to the conference? The fact is that even if we merged with the PAC, we would not be adding many huge markets. Corvailis, Pullman, Logan, Fort Collins, Boise, Fresno... none of these are in "huge" markets.
We could add Georgia State, FIU, Buffalo, etc... but those teams suck.
We should add the most competative programs possible, provided that they can increase the per-member distribution. If JMU (or Miami, UConn, App, etc) can do that, so be it.
Markets are literally all anyone cares about and maybe academics. If no program can bring in a new and exciting market then why do we need to add anyone at all? Boise might have had a few good years but with no market, they get left out of the Big 12 conversation every single time. We don’t want that. James Madison might be the best program in the Sun Belt but the American is big league football. They can’t compete with the programs here when it comes to money, athletics, having a brand. It would be like adding a junior college. At least with a market, they could grow but without a decent market that will not happen. Being the best school in the Sun Belt is the equivalent to being the best high school program in Montana. Nobody cares and they add zero value. No thanks.
I am kind of fascinated by the data on the enrollment cliff. If you do some googling, it is easy to find lots of information that isn't on sports message boards talking about the impact coming to colleges/universities. A baby born today will be college age in 2044, so no matter what happens tomorrow, universities have data on what is going to happen over the next 18 years or so, and it isn't good.
The general predictions of people studying the situation, and not aimed specifically at any one school, go like this. Land-grant flagships will be fine. Small private schools are screwed. Regional colleges in rural college towns face several problems. They often are the economy of their towns, and as enrollment declines, some businesses will close with none to replace them. Real estate, especially apartments, cannot fill vacancies, which drives down rent prices, which causes owners to begin to defer maintenance, and they may go under. Because there are not big corporations to offset these losses, the general attractiveness of this small-town college experience declines as each business is boarded up, which exacerbates the already bad situation. Layer on the more recent feeling that a college education is no longer a ticket to a good life, and this further cuts the enrollment numbers.
Large metro areas generally do not depend on schools to support their economy; they look to business to do that. Universities in these areas benefit from several advantages in a period of declining enrollment. Students will have more access to business partnerships for internships, research dollars, and local job opportunities. As prospective students compare colleges, a struggling small college town isn't going to be as attractive as it once was when it was vibrant and everything revolved around the campus. Those students who are making a return on investment calculation on their college investment may find staying at home and commuting their best option, or perhaps working full-time and going to school at night is the answer. Universities in small college towns are more likely to have students who move away from home when they enroll, and they do not have the local infrastructure or population to support as many non-traditional student options.
Now I know that some will take this information personally and want to defend their specific school. I get that, but again, these are general predictions of the future. I promise you that each of our universities, small or large, is looking at the data and trying to map out a plan to survive what cannot be controlled. Many schools are already seeing enrollment declines, and now there is a lot of talk about 3-year bachelor's degrees, which will both be attractive to students and further decrease total enrollment. More and more schools are already closing programs so they can refocus their resources on majors more attractive to students and their careers. There are going to be winners and losers, and it will take decades for this to play out.
So, to loop this back to conferences, the Commissioners, Chancellors, and Presidents are already spending every day planning for the long term, and trying to forecast who will best weather this inevitable contraction in the student population. They must be able to make an argument to the media giants who are signing long-term contracts. Schools hit hardest by the financial challenges are going to have the most difficulty supporting non-core activities. Will it be your school? My school? None of us know. These decisions will have to be made soon with imperfect information, and right now, The American is betting that big-market schools are better positioned--not simply for football success, but for thriving as an organization during these difficult decades.
Thanks for the detail here. A lot of it is pretty "general" and we'll see how it actually affects colleges/universities, but I think you're pretty accurate here. I do however wonder if this will even affect the larger, rural schools who are "second" in their state. Schools like Michigan State and Mississippi State, Iowa State, Purdue, etc. I think, and hope, they'll all be fine.
|
|