(09-25-2026 12:02 PM)JRsec Wrote: (09-25-2026 11:46 AM)The Beaver Wrote: (09-25-2026 10:37 AM)bullet Wrote: (09-25-2026 09:54 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (09-24-2026 04:37 PM)JRsec Wrote: If the SEC wanted to add a football school, then Miami is the more logical choice since it gets them stronger ratings in the weakest part of their Florida market penetration. The overlap between FSU and UF is significant though both get a higher total % than Miami.
The SEC has 1 major basketball brand, Kentucky. We have a lot of strong programs which are getting stronger, but they don't carry the must-see brand of Duke, North Carolina, or Kansas. Kentucky needs a big brand rival in conference. UNC provides that, Duke provides that, or Kansas provides that. The conference wants Flagships with national branding if they can get them.
This x 1000.
BRANDS.
UNC is the best combination of Brand, Academics, dominates own large State, you name it. Everyone else had better bring something, and something big and valuable, if they want consideration. The football Brands of Miami, Clemson, or FSU? That works. The mammoth Duke mbb brand + their intense rivalry with UNC + T1 Academics? That could work. Kansas? Sure, maybe, they created basketball and their rivalry with Missouri is awesome. I get so caught up in the weeds talking about other schools, but with this 19 cap looking more likely as time goes on, it just gets awfully hard to see how a school like Colorado, VT, GT or UVA that doesn't have that huge national Brand can turf out one of those listed above.
There aren't that many schools with a shot even at 20. FSU, Miami, Clemson and North Carolina are locks. Probably UVA (presidents like them and get enough money from the bigger brands to take a "loss leader"). The final one would be Notre Dame if they decided to take the last helicopter out of Saigon. Assuming they wouldn't, then a few schools have a shot-Stanford, Kansas, Virginia Tech, North Carolina St. I don't see Duke getting in at 20. The SEC and Big Ten don't need another Vanderbilt or Northwestern even if basketball is great. So that's only 4 besides the 6 obvious candidates.
Now if conferences were able to and did decide to go beyond 20, then there are a whole lot of schools. But I think they would likely stop at 20.
The interesting thing to me about 20 is the SEC cannot protect all relevant areas. I still think the Big Ten holds a slot for Notre Dame, but could see a one off 19th add of whichever great southern school isn't added. Whether thats FSU, Miami, UNC or Clemson. If the SEC chooses all of them, which I doubt, Miami and Clemson are both of questionable utility, only then does it start making sense for the Big Ten to do nothing.
Bear in mind, there's been zero give on the 19 member limit so far and I don't think that gets changed in, at least, the senate version of the bill.
I also don't think 19 is likely to be changed at this time in the process. So, what's your point. Whether the SEC takes North Carolina and Virginia, or North Carolina and Duke and whether the third is Virginia, Duke or Miami the SEC has effectively taken all they need to take in the SE. Personally, I see UNC & UVa with Duke in some capacity. Duke and the SEC have a very large money donor in common and if Duke was going to be left behind, he might get involved. If a football brand is required, and I don't think it will be, Miami makes the most sense for the reasons I stated. But at 19 if the Big Ten holds that slot for Notre Dame (who will likely be looking around if the academic schools leave the ACC) then expansion to the Southeast by the Big Ten in any capacity is dead. That leaves the SEC the ability to use its remaining 3 slots as it deems best with no thought whatsoever at this juncture to having to defend brand. And on the ESPN vs FOX front, a reload of 4 schools should N.D. indeed decide to affiliate with the Big Ten would give ESPN a chance to add up to 5 schools to reach 19. I think ESPN might have designs on holding the #1 most viewed of the P4 and the #3 most viewed by rebuilding the ACC with the best they can take from the Big 12. What I can't remember right now is whether the limit on how many you could take from one conference was actually an amendment or in the original wording of the PCSA. That of course could impact things a bit if it still is there and is passed.
UNC and Duke is a natural combo for lots of reasons and I think, all things being equal, is the one UNC would prefer as they move. I see UVA as a necessity from the SEC's standpoint. The state of VA is too large to ignore and there are other positive aspects of UVA at that.
I don't think the Senate is working to change the 19 school cap, but I think there's a chance the House negotiations will address it. There are a handful of reasons I see it this way. One, we've seen the Senate address some of their hardline positions such as the 5 year independence requirement. Latest I heard was that it was down to 3 years and the requirement would altogether disappear after 6 years time. This sort of provision is to make short term movement costly, obviously. It disincentivizes it before we come up on the time period when major contracts are open around the country. Even with the 19 school cap, the 3 year independence rule seems to be in place as currently constituted.
Now maybe that sort of provision is not removed in the House, but I could see the 19 school cap as a negotiating point. First of all, 19 is an odd number and you'd think if we're going to have a cap that it would be an even number just to make everyone's life a little more workable. Now, if your league wants to have 10 conference games then 19 is just fine, but if anyone wants to stick with 9 league games then 19 is impossible. Maybe the Senate set the number at 19 with the anticipation that the House would work the number up, but they'll have little ability to work it up significantly or when it goes back to the Senate...no dice.
A second key reason is because most of the programs that stand to lose out on P2 access with a cap of 19 reside in high population states and states that are very much divided when it comes to party representation. The House bill will have to be bipartisan just like the Senate as the GOP majority is not massive. It will need heavy support in states like FL, GA, NC, VA, and TX. Now maybe if Stanford is serious about getting into the P2 they can beat the drums with CA representatives and I'm sure they have strong connections in DC anyway. Point being, support for any House bill will have to come from a lot of angles.
It makes a lot of sense that the SEC and Big Ten would be fine with a cap as it does lock in their advantages in a very real way. To get them both on the same page here, I could see movement towards a higher cap. Not much higher mind you, but something with an even number. The Big Ten stands to gain if they can slide Notre Dame into that 19th spot, but that would be their only real move. Does ND really want to move if the ACC isn't losing a bunch of schools though? I think that's a fair question. The SEC doesn't want the Big Ten to gain a foothold in the Southeast, no, but I don't think they want an odd number of schools or the codified inability to double down in FL.
Duke having a partial membership makes some sense, but their inclusion from a football standpoint also does what UNC and UVA's does...a program that won't be super competitive on the regular...one that adds content, but is not a threat to overall structure...one that adds intangibles in other areas. I'm not sure that granting Duke 5 or 6 games, for instance, does anything positive. They'll struggle economically by trying to be independent in that sport which doesn't really serve the SEC's interests. Not that the SEC is looking for another powerhouse, but being saddled to a weaker Duke program just to have someone in that 19th slot, I don't really see the advantage. Basketball wise, it's slam dunk. See what I did there?
But I think if Duke is coming aboard, it's as a full member because I think the cap would go to 20. In that scenario, the SEC can grab Miami and keep that market out of the hands of the Big Ten while also double dipping in FL. Miami is also AAU...something Florida State is not. Nothing against FSU as I would prefer to have both them and Clemson in the league, if there are a small number of spots available for the foreseeable future then we have to be more careful.
Those 4 schools represent a very strong set of additions....UNC, Duke, UVA, and Miami.
Once the ACC loses 4 key members such as these then perhaps Notre Dame is a little more motivated to go to the P2. Regardless of which arrangement they prefer, if the cap is at 20 then Notre Dame can basically choose their running mate. Perhaps it is indeed Stanford? ND and Stanford into the Big Ten. Neither push for anything beyond 20 as the cap has done its job. The ACC has not been decimated. The Big 12 will lose schools to the ACC, but not a ton of them. Both the SEC and Big Ten have grown market share while also creating workable, practical alignments. Their advantages are locked in, but the other Power leagues are not suffering mightily because of it.
The ACC and Big 12 can also move to 20 if they like. There's a delicate balance here of movement and call ups that help a lot of constituencies.
The ACC becomes:
USF, Florida State, Georgia Tech, Clemson, NC State, Wake Forest, Virginia Tech, Louisville, Cincinnati, West Virginia, Pittsburgh, Syracuse, Boston College, California, Arizona, Arizona State, Utah, Colorado, Kansas, SMU
The Big 12 becomes:
UConn, UCF, East Carolina, Texas Tech, TCU, Baylor, Houston, Oklahoma State, Kansas State, Iowa State, Memphis, Tulane, Washington State, Oregon State, San Diego State, Fresno State, Boise State, BYU, Colorado State, UNLV
CA politicians get Stanford into the P2, California's future is secure, San Diego State and Fresno State are elevated...they're happy.
VA politicians get UVA into the P2 without harming Virginia Tech's long term standing...they're happy.
NC politicians get UNC and Duke into the P2 without harming NC State and Wake Forest's long term standing, East Carolina is elevated...they're happy.
FL politicians get Miami into the P2 and they also get USF elevated...they're happy.
GA politicians...status quo
SC politicians...status quo
WA politicians get Washington State elevated again...they're happy
OR politicians get Oregon State elevated again...they're happy
NV politicians get UNLV elevated...they're happy
TX politicians get a slightly more TX-centric version of the Big 12 as far as the power base goes...they're happy
LA politicians get Tulane elevated...they're happy
TN politicians get Memphis elevated...they're happy.
CO politicians get Colorado State elevated...they're happy
ID politicians get Boise State elevated...they're happy
CT politicians get UConn elevated...they're happy
ESPN is super pleased because they've enhanced the value of the SEC and enhanced the value of the ACC while also gaining the ability to monetize its conference network in a brand new way. Plenty of opportunity for crossover matchups between the leagues that are regional while simultaneously stretching all the leagues into numerous new markets.