Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)


Post Reply 
Stop Playing P4 for a chance at the CFP?
Author Message
BRtransplant Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 2,298
Joined: Nov 2011
Reputation: 64
I Root For: La Tech
Location:
Post: #41
RE: Stop Playing P4 for a chance at the CFP?
(09-22-2026 08:45 AM)islandTROYtrojan Wrote:  
(09-22-2026 08:12 AM)Dukes_Royals Wrote:  
(09-22-2026 07:19 AM)islandTROYtrojan Wrote:  Does anyone truly believe that a G6 team will ever go past the first round in the P4's CFP show? Essentially the G6 team in the CFP is the G6 champion since we resist the idea of a G6 championship game due to fear of further relegation from the P4. As our good friends the Borg would say, "Resistance is futile". P4 leagues are changing their scheduling to eliminate G6 games and will soon play none at all. We have to accept the reality. The P4 runs the show, sets the rules, and decides who they will allow to be actors in the show. The G6 spot in the CFP is just throwing us a bone that we will continue to choke on. The CFP has never been my goal for any season as it would be just one more game we will not win. Give me a bowl game any day where we would at least stand a chance.

Did you already forget 2024 where Boise State had a bye in the first round? Sure it was based on being one of the 4 highest ranked conference champions but they played in the second round. Pretty sure that team would have beat plenty of first round opponents especially playing in Boise.

And it was a 3 point game mid-way into the 3rd quarter with Penn State in the second round.

It will take a lot to compete with teams who have substantially different resources but it has always been that way. The CFP is way better than competing against some G6 or run around P4.
No. Did not forget them. They did not play in the first round so the second was basically their first game and they lost by 17. My point continues to be that the CFP is strictly for the P4. It always will be regardless of how many Boise-type teams we have. People want to hold on to the illusion that this whole thing is somehow equitable when its sole design is to relegate the G6. We are an afterthought in this whole process. You are correct in the resources comment...a level of resources none of us will ever have. It is like a penniless man walking into a Tiffany store just to have a look. What I do not get is why out of 10 D1 conferences, 4 dictate everything. We have given away our power and the NCAA is run by the P4 as well. JMU like others deserve to be rewarded for great seasons but, for what, to be pummeled by a team you nor any other G6 team could compete against due to the differences in resources you mentioned. Why even aspire to the CFP? The result will always be the same. Money makes the difference.

Accepting reality comes hard for most people, but NIL spending and relaxed transfer rules have changed college football forever. Whatever dreams of grandeur one has had about their school's bright future are futile at this point. The P2 have seen to it.
09-22-2026 09:29 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
BRtransplant Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 2,298
Joined: Nov 2011
Reputation: 64
I Root For: La Tech
Location:
Post: #42
RE: Stop Playing P4 for a chance at the CFP?
(09-22-2026 08:45 AM)islandTROYtrojan Wrote:  
(09-22-2026 08:12 AM)Dukes_Royals Wrote:  
(09-22-2026 07:19 AM)islandTROYtrojan Wrote:  Does anyone truly believe that a G6 team will ever go past the first round in the P4's CFP show? Essentially the G6 team in the CFP is the G6 champion since we resist the idea of a G6 championship game due to fear of further relegation from the P4. As our good friends the Borg would say, "Resistance is futile". P4 leagues are changing their scheduling to eliminate G6 games and will soon play none at all. We have to accept the reality. The P4 runs the show, sets the rules, and decides who they will allow to be actors in the show. The G6 spot in the CFP is just throwing us a bone that we will continue to choke on. The CFP has never been my goal for any season as it would be just one more game we will not win. Give me a bowl game any day where we would at least stand a chance.

Did you already forget 2024 where Boise State had a bye in the first round? Sure it was based on being one of the 4 highest ranked conference champions but they played in the second round. Pretty sure that team would have beat plenty of first round opponents especially playing in Boise.

And it was a 3 point game mid-way into the 3rd quarter with Penn State in the second round.

It will take a lot to compete with teams who have substantially different resources but it has always been that way. The CFP is way better than competing against some G6 or run around P4.
No. Did not forget them. They did not play in the first round so the second was basically their first game and they lost by 17. My point continues to be that the CFP is strictly for the P4. It always will be regardless of how many Boise-type teams we have. People want to hold on to the illusion that this whole thing is somehow equitable when its sole design is to relegate the G6. We are an afterthought in this whole process. You are correct in the resources comment...a level of resources none of us will ever have. It is like a penniless man walking into a Tiffany store just to have a look. What I do not get is why out of 10 D1 conferences, 4 dictate everything. We have given away our power and the NCAA is run by the P4 as well. JMU like others deserve to be rewarded for great seasons but, for what, to be pummeled by a team you nor any other G6 team could compete against due to the differences in resources you mentioned. Why even aspire to the CFP? The result will always be the same. Money makes the difference.

Accepting reality comes hard for most people, but NIL spending and relaxed transfer rules have changed college football forever. Whatever dreams of grandeur one has had about their school's bright future are futile at this point. The P2 have seen to it.
09-22-2026 09:29 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
WinstonTheWolf Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,842
Joined: Sep 2009
Reputation: 230
I Root For: Arkansas State
Location:
Post: #43
RE: Stop Playing P4 for a chance at the CFP?
(09-22-2026 09:29 AM)BRtransplant Wrote:  
(09-22-2026 08:45 AM)islandTROYtrojan Wrote:  
(09-22-2026 08:12 AM)Dukes_Royals Wrote:  
(09-22-2026 07:19 AM)islandTROYtrojan Wrote:  Does anyone truly believe that a G6 team will ever go past the first round in the P4's CFP show? Essentially the G6 team in the CFP is the G6 champion since we resist the idea of a G6 championship game due to fear of further relegation from the P4. As our good friends the Borg would say, "Resistance is futile". P4 leagues are changing their scheduling to eliminate G6 games and will soon play none at all. We have to accept the reality. The P4 runs the show, sets the rules, and decides who they will allow to be actors in the show. The G6 spot in the CFP is just throwing us a bone that we will continue to choke on. The CFP has never been my goal for any season as it would be just one more game we will not win. Give me a bowl game any day where we would at least stand a chance.

Did you already forget 2024 where Boise State had a bye in the first round? Sure it was based on being one of the 4 highest ranked conference champions but they played in the second round. Pretty sure that team would have beat plenty of first round opponents especially playing in Boise.

And it was a 3 point game mid-way into the 3rd quarter with Penn State in the second round.

It will take a lot to compete with teams who have substantially different resources but it has always been that way. The CFP is way better than competing against some G6 or run around P4.
No. Did not forget them. They did not play in the first round so the second was basically their first game and they lost by 17. My point continues to be that the CFP is strictly for the P4. It always will be regardless of how many Boise-type teams we have. People want to hold on to the illusion that this whole thing is somehow equitable when its sole design is to relegate the G6. We are an afterthought in this whole process. You are correct in the resources comment...a level of resources none of us will ever have. It is like a penniless man walking into a Tiffany store just to have a look. What I do not get is why out of 10 D1 conferences, 4 dictate everything. We have given away our power and the NCAA is run by the P4 as well. JMU like others deserve to be rewarded for great seasons but, for what, to be pummeled by a team you nor any other G6 team could compete against due to the differences in resources you mentioned. Why even aspire to the CFP? The result will always be the same. Money makes the difference.

Accepting reality comes hard for most people, but NIL spending and relaxed transfer rules have changed college football forever. Whatever dreams of grandeur one has had about their school's bright future are futile at this point. The P2 have seen to it.

Spot on. TV money and greed have led to this. College/University presidents should be ashamed at what they have succumbed to. It is far from collegiate. They too are whores.
09-22-2026 12:43 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
DawgNBama Offline
RL/ Radio lover
*

Posts: 10,006
Joined: Sep 2002
Reputation: 651
I Root For: 'Vallo, Troy, UGA
Location: US
Post: #44
RE: Stop Playing P4 for a chance at the CFP?
(09-20-2026 05:26 AM)Herd6993 Wrote:  
(09-20-2026 01:55 AM)BDKJMU Wrote:  G6 vs P4 this season (not sure if totally accurate): 3-60. Wins:
-UMASS over Rutgers
-Tulsa over Ok St
-*W Mich over Michigan (we all know W Mich won that game).

3-60 is worse than FCS used to do vs FBS.


It will continue this way as long as NIL is in play. You just can't continue to lose your best players in your conference every year and compete with schools that are taking those players, already have 5 star recruits, and returning all-Americans.

I mean think about it. Marshall discovers a kicker from Ireland (Lorcan Quinn), brings him over, develops him and he turns into one of the best kickers in the country. Alabama poaches him, but is he kicking FG's or extra points? Nope, just kickoffs. They have another stud to do that. NIL and 105 Scholarship limit has allowed the P-4 to stockpile the talent that would normally play G-5.

This is why you grow your NIL. Hate to say it, but this is the new norm for college athletics. 03-banghead
09-24-2026 10:29 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
WinstonTheWolf Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,842
Joined: Sep 2009
Reputation: 230
I Root For: Arkansas State
Location:
Post: #45
RE: Stop Playing P4 for a chance at the CFP?
(09-24-2026 10:29 PM)DawgNBama Wrote:  
(09-20-2026 05:26 AM)Herd6993 Wrote:  
(09-20-2026 01:55 AM)BDKJMU Wrote:  G6 vs P4 this season (not sure if totally accurate): 3-60. Wins:
-UMASS over Rutgers
-Tulsa over Ok St
-*W Mich over Michigan (we all know W Mich won that game).

3-60 is worse than FCS used to do vs FBS.


It will continue this way as long as NIL is in play. You just can't continue to lose your best players in your conference every year and compete with schools that are taking those players, already have 5 star recruits, and returning all-Americans.

I mean think about it. Marshall discovers a kicker from Ireland (Lorcan Quinn), brings him over, develops him and he turns into one of the best kickers in the country. Alabama poaches him, but is he kicking FG's or extra points? Nope, just kickoffs. They have another stud to do that. NIL and 105 Scholarship limit has allowed the P-4 to stockpile the talent that would normally play G-5.

This is why you grow your NIL. Hate to say it, but this is the new norm for college athletics. 03-banghead

Get to work on that 30 million so you can NOT seriously compete for a championship like Arkansas.
09-25-2026 07:56 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Pounce FTW Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,673
Joined: May 2012
Reputation: 389
I Root For: Georgia State + Mercer
Location: NJ
Post: #46
RE: Stop Playing P4 for a chance at the CFP?
(09-22-2026 08:45 AM)islandTROYtrojan Wrote:  No. Did not forget them. They did not play in the first round so the second was basically their first game and they lost by 17. My point continues to be that the CFP is strictly for the P4. It always will be regardless of how many Boise-type teams we have. People want to hold on to the illusion that this whole thing is somehow equitable when its sole design is to relegate the G6. We are an afterthought in this whole process. You are correct in the resources comment...a level of resources none of us will ever have. It is like a penniless man walking into a Tiffany store just to have a look. What I do not get is why out of 10 D1 conferences, 4 dictate everything. We have given away our power and the NCAA is run by the P4 as well. JMU like others deserve to be rewarded for great seasons but, for what, to be pummeled by a team you nor any other G6 team could compete against due to the differences in resources you mentioned. Why even aspire to the CFP? The result will always be the same. Money makes the difference.

I largely agree with your assessment of the G6's place in the CFP, but I can't tell if you're saying you'd rather just not be connected to it at all. I hope we always maintain some presence in it even if the odds are overwhelming. It's honestly not that different from the situation in March, just a different set of numbers you're working with. You kind of nailed it in saying that the CFP rep is essentially the G6 champion. If folks want to formalize some sort of #1 G6 vs. #2 G6 championship, I'd be great with that as an addition. As far as playoff access goes, if the current setup is as good as it gets from here on out, I won't be too upset. (I would LOVE for an expanded playoff to offer more opportunities to G6s...although I know that tournament bloat with power leagues only might be what pushes me into dissatisfaction with the playoff.)
09-25-2026 03:20 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
islandTROYtrojan Online
2nd String
*

Posts: 369
Joined: May 2026
Reputation: 69
I Root For: Troy and the SBC
Location: Key West/Montgomery
Post: #47
RE: Stop Playing P4 for a chance at the CFP?
(09-25-2026 03:20 PM)Pounce FTW Wrote:  
(09-22-2026 08:45 AM)islandTROYtrojan Wrote:  No. Did not forget them. They did not play in the first round so the second was basically their first game and they lost by 17. My point continues to be that the CFP is strictly for the P4. It always will be regardless of how many Boise-type teams we have. People want to hold on to the illusion that this whole thing is somehow equitable when its sole design is to relegate the G6. We are an afterthought in this whole process. You are correct in the resources comment...a level of resources none of us will ever have. It is like a penniless man walking into a Tiffany store just to have a look. What I do not get is why out of 10 D1 conferences, 4 dictate everything. We have given away our power and the NCAA is run by the P4 as well. JMU like others deserve to be rewarded for great seasons but, for what, to be pummeled by a team you nor any other G6 team could compete against due to the differences in resources you mentioned. Why even aspire to the CFP? The result will always be the same. Money makes the difference.

I largely agree with your assessment of the G6's place in the CFP, but I can't tell if you're saying you'd rather just not be connected to it at all. I hope we always maintain some presence in it even if the odds are overwhelming. It's honestly not that different from the situation in March, just a different set of numbers you're working with. You kind of nailed it in saying that the CFP rep is essentially the G6 champion. If folks want to formalize some sort of #1 G6 vs. #2 G6 championship, I'd be great with that as an addition. As far as playoff access goes, if the current setup is as good as it gets from here on out, I won't be too upset. (I would LOVE for an expanded playoff to offer more opportunities to G6s...although I know that tournament bloat with power leagues only might be what pushes me into dissatisfaction with the playoff.)
We should stay connected as there is some value in the hope a G6 team will somehow miraculously actually be a factor in the CFP and the goal and excitement to a G6 team in reaching the CFP. But the P4, especially the SEC and 10, have contrived to have this as their show. They have set aside multiple slots for their teams from each conference to get a spot and still have only one for all of the G6. Even in a proposed 24 team CFP, the P4 with 68 teams gets 23 slots whereas the G6 with 69 teams gets 1. There is something not right here.
You can also add the SOS metric having more weight with P4 schools scheduling less, and soon few to any, G6 schools; this stacks the deck even more.
(This post was last modified: 09-25-2026 04:15 PM by islandTROYtrojan.)
09-25-2026 03:42 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.