Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
New 2027 US News academic rankings are out
Author Message
SFLFB Offline
Special Teams
*

Posts: 836
Joined: Sep 2023
Reputation: 245
I Root For: USF
Location:
Post: #101
RE: New 2027 US News academic rankings are out
(09-24-2026 05:11 AM)XLance Wrote:  
(09-23-2026 02:10 PM)sigke Wrote:  
(09-23-2026 01:30 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(09-23-2026 01:20 PM)sigke Wrote:  
(09-23-2026 01:01 PM)BirdstheWord Wrote:  Never say never. The ACC added Louisville in 2014 when their ranking was 160. It's now 179.

The rumor is that if the ACC gets raided, they want to become what the Magnolia League was envisioned to be... a southern version of the Ivy League.

If they go for an academic first league, then it's doubtful they will let in a school below the top 100, unless they ranked very well in another respected list, like the Forbes list and Wall Street Journal list.

This rumor is coming from where? Because the current rumor is two of the "Magnolia" schools are two of the most likely to leave and there's going to be six non-southern schools plus ND and Louisville.

Obviously, if the ACC moves to focus on being more of an academic school, they won't be the "Magnolia League" because they will have non-southern schools. But they apparently want to be more academic moving forward, esp if they they get raided.

There are even articles written about it, including the so called "Stanford Plan" which says that Stanford is suggesting that the ACC focus on trying to replace the schools that leave for the SEC and B1G with top academic FBS schools in the west & mid-west (if not each time zone), so they become more of a nationally academic focused power conference and less of an East Coast conference.

Rice & Tulane would be a prime targets in the Central Time Zone.

The timezone option is why we are starting to hear people talk about Utah or Colorado joining the ACC (I doubt that happens, but there is some talk online)

There's also talk about the ACC adding Army & Navy as football only schools.

All of which would follow the idea of the ACC rebranding themselves as an "Academics First Power Conference."

The article I read about the "Stanford Plan" says that the ACC knows if they lose their top football brands, there is no way they can replace their athletic & TV value. So instead, they would replace them by prioritizing academic value instead.

Whether it happens or not, who knows. But it makes sense if the ACC is raided and loses Clemson, Miami, FSU, GT, plus two others.

Link for the referenced "Stanford Plan"?

Sigh, it's another Jim Williams post. I wouldn't put too much stock in it outside of "it's another idea". There's no meaningful evidence that Stanford has this as a plan at all, only that they're a research anchor in what could become a meaningful academic conference. The post is quoted below, with a link to the X post.

Quote:Stanford’s Plan Could Save the ACC—and Make It Stronger After Losses of key members

If the ACC loses Florida State, North Carolina and Clemson, the easy assumption is that the conference becomes a diminished football property. That outcome is possible—but it is not inevitable.

A different path begins with Stanford, Duke, Cal, Pitt, Virginia, Georgia Tech, Miami, NC State, Virginia Tech and the rest of the league’s research-heavy core. Instead of trying to outspend the SEC and Big Ten in a football arms race, the ACC could become the nation’s leading coast-to-coast conference for academics, innovation, major markets and broad-based athletics.

Football would remain important. It just would no longer be the only way the league creates value.

The Stanford plan starts with what remains
Even without Florida State, Clemson and North Carolina, the conference would retain a strong institutional base.

Duke, Stanford, Cal, Virginia, Pitt, Georgia Tech, Miami, NC State, Virginia Tech, Boston College, Wake Forest, Louisville and SMU are not a collection of leftovers. They include elite private universities, major public research institutions, medical centers, engineering schools, technology hubs and recognizable national athletics brands.

Stanford and Cal provide Silicon Valley and Bay Area access. Duke, NC State and Wake Forest connect the league to the Research Triangle. Georgia Tech brings Atlanta’s technology and corporate economy. Pitt is a major research and medical center in Pittsburgh. Miami gives the conference an international gateway and one of the most important recruiting and event markets in college sports.

The ACC already proved it was willing to think beyond traditional geography when it added Stanford, Cal and SMU. Those schools joined at discounted media shares, helping create additional revenue and a performance-based funding pool for incumbent members. Stanford and Cal initially received 30 percent of a normal ACC share, while SMU agreed to forgo its broadcast-media share for nine years.espn
That was the first stage. The next stage could be building an academic-and-media platform that produces value well beyond Saturday football.

Add USF, Rice and UConn
The best eastern additions would be USF, Rice and UConn.
USF brings Tampa Bay, a large and growing Florida market, AAU membership, a major public research profile, health-care connections and a large alumni base. It also gives the league a second Florida presence that complements Miami rather than competes with it.

Rice is a smaller athletics brand, but it may be the cleanest academic fit available in Texas. The Houston private university brings AAU status, engineering, space, energy and medical-research ties, plus direct access to the Houston corporate market. Rice and SMU would give the conference an affluent, high-end Texas pairing in Houston and Dallas.

UConn adds a flagship public university, a valuable basketball brand, New England presence and the Hartford/New York media corridor. Its men’s and women’s basketball programs also give any future league a dependable national-event property in a sports calendar increasingly built around streaming windows and tournament inventory.

The best Western choices
The strongest Western targets are San Diego State, Oregon State and Washington State.

San Diego State makes sense because it now carries R1 research status, sits in a major Southern California market and offers access to San Diego’s defense, biotech, tourism and cross-border business economy. SDSU officially received Carnegie R1 classification in 2025.sdsu

Oregon State is an R1 university with land-, sea-, space- and sun-grant designations, making it especially valuable for climate, ocean, forestry, food and environmental research.business.oregonstate

Washington State would add another serious research institution, Pacific Northwest reach and strength in agriculture, veterinary medicine, food systems and applied science. Together with Stanford, Cal, Oregon State and San Diego State, those schools create a practical Pacific scheduling and research division instead of leaving the Bay Area schools isolated.

A second expansion tier could include Tulane, which offers AAU status, New Orleans, medical research and Gulf Coast climate expertise, or UNLV, which brings Las Vegas, Allegiant Stadium and major-event infrastructure. Tulane is the cleaner institutional fit; UNLV is the stronger sports-business and championship-event play.

The real money is beyond football
The Stanford plan would not pretend that a conference can simply pool university endowments or redirect research grants into athletics. It cannot. Research funding is awarded to institutions, faculty and projects, while endowment dollars are normally restricted by donor purpose.

The smarter model is a league-supported research and innovation consortium.
The conference could create a shared office to help member schools build multi-campus bids for federal grants, foundation support and corporate research contracts. It could connect Stanford and Cal’s technology networks with Georgia Tech, Duke, Pitt, Rice, USF, Miami, NC State and Virginia Tech in fields such as artificial intelligence, cybersecurity, health care, sports medicine, climate resilience, energy, aerospace and advanced manufacturing.

That approach could generate more research opportunities, corporate partnerships, student internships, startup investment and intellectual-property development. The financial benefit would largely flow to the universities themselves—not directly into the ACC office—but it makes league membership more valuable and harder to walk away from.

Stanford’s 2024 research expenditures totaled about $1.64 billion, including more than $1 billion in federal support. That shows the scale of the academic economy compared with even major football-media payments.ncsesdata.nsf
A better long-term conference

The ACC’s ESPN agreement runs through 2036, giving the league a period of stability while it rethinks its post-2036 model. The original Stanford-Cal-SMU expansion was expected to generate roughly $600 million in added media-rights revenue over the remaining life of the deal, or about $50 million annually.newsobserver

A rebuilt league would still sell football, basketball and championship events. But it could also sell something the SEC and Big Ten cannot easily duplicate: a national alliance of research universities in Silicon Valley, Boston, Pittsburgh, Washington’s orbit, the Research Triangle, Atlanta, Miami, Tampa, Dallas, Houston and Southern California.

Losing Florida State, North Carolina and Clemson would hurt. There is no reason to minimize it.

But the Stanford plan offers a credible alternative: build a conference that wins with elite academics, research capacity, affluent markets, innovation partnerships, destination events, basketball inventory and broad-based sports—not simply by chasing the next football payout.

https://x.com/JWMediaDC/status/2101330236054860261?s=20
09-24-2026 08:08 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,873
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #102
RE: New 2027 US News academic rankings are out
(09-24-2026 05:07 AM)HP-TBDPITL Wrote:  
(09-23-2026 02:15 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(09-23-2026 01:59 PM)HP-TBDPITL Wrote:  
(09-23-2026 01:29 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(09-23-2026 01:20 PM)sigke Wrote:  The rumor is that if the ACC gets raided, they want to become what the Magnolia League was envisioned to be... a southern version of the Ivy League.

If they go for an academic first league, then it's doubtful they will let in a school below the top 100, unless they ranked very well in another respected list, like the Forbes list and Wall Street Journal list.

When Maryland announced that they were leaving in November 2012, UVa’s President initially advocated for UConn. The next day Clemson and FSU both communicated their preference of Louisville. Within a few days, Louisville was offered the spot.

Academics are important to the ACC, but football and money carry more weight in an athletics conference.

Well...West Virginia wasnt even considered because of its academics. Also I believe UConn's has gotten better since that happened-so UConn and Louisville weren't as far apart as they are now.

Louisville had just built their new Coliseum-so they started raking in money from non basketball events and had sold naming rights.
West Virginia had just moved to the Big 12 so they weren't in a position to move again. And WVU beat out UL for the Big 12 slot.

WVU went to the Big 12 because the ACC wasnt an option for them. If the ACC was an option-they would have joined the ACC.

WVU moved to the Big 12 in 2012. Louisville tried very hard, but the Big 12 couldn't find an acceptable #12 and wasn't willing to go to 11.

The ACC didn't decide to expand to 14 until 2013. And then after Maryland left, added Louisville in 2014.

So the ACC was not an option in 2012. But you make it sound like they were "rejected" in favor of other schools which is not true. The ACC just wasn't expanding in 2012 and WVU wasn't moving in 2014.
09-24-2026 08:37 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
HouCat Offline
2nd String
*

Posts: 388
Joined: Nov 2023
Reputation: 41
I Root For: Texas State
Location: Bayou City
Post: #103
RE: New 2027 US News academic rankings are out
(09-22-2026 01:24 PM)SFLFB Wrote:  All Other Ranking Categories 2027 Best Colleges Ranking Factor Weights
Indicator

2027 Weight for Schools With Usable SAT/ACT

Graduation rates 16%
First-year retention rates 5%
Graduation rate performance 10%
Pell graduation rates 5.5%
Pell graduation performance 5.5%
College grads earning more than a high school grad 5%
Earnings by major 5%
Peer assessment 20%
Financial resources 8%
Faculty salaries 8%
Full-time faculty 3%
Student-faculty ratio 4%
Standardized tests 5%

Quote:Peer assessment: This is a measure of how a school is regarded by top administrators at other institutions and accounts for qualitative attributes of schools that may not be fully captured by the other ranking factors. A school's peer assessment score is calculated from the weighted, rolling average of ratings on academic quality it received by presidents, provosts and deans of admissions – or officials in equivalent positions – at institutions submitting a peer assessment survey administered by U.S. News. Schools in National Universities and National Liberal Arts Colleges once again incorporated a two-year average, while all schools in Regional Universities and Regional Colleges categories were newly scored based on a weighted, three-year rolling average due to fewer ratings per year reported within these smaller categories.

Each survey respondent was asked to rate the overall academic quality of peer schools' undergraduate academic programs on a 5-point scale: outstanding (5), strong (4), good (3), adequate (2) or marginal (1). For example, schools in the National Universities ranking could only rate other schools in the National Universities ranking. Respondents who didn't know enough about a school to evaluate it fairly were asked to mark "don't know" or leave it blank, neither of which counted for or against a school's score.

U.S. News collected the most recent data by administering peer assessment surveys to schools in spring and summer 2026. Of the 4,405 academics who were sent questionnaires, 30.8% responded. The peer assessment response rate in the most recent year for National Universities was 41% and for National Liberal Arts Colleges was 47%.

The two highest and lowest ratings schools received each year were trimmed to minimize the effect of outliers. Schools that received fewer than 10 cumulative ratings after trimming were alternatively assigned a peer assessment value equaling the lowest qualifying score in their ranking. These alternative values were only needed for the smaller regional categories.

Whether a school submitted a peer assessment survey or statistical survey had no impact on the average peer score it received from other schools. However, schools that didn't respond to U.S. News' statistical survey who submitted peer surveys had their ratings of other schools excluded from the computations.

How USN&WR came to be the measuring stick for colleges blows my mind.

The biggest single factor (20%) is based on what others think of you.

Not graduation rates, not quality of education, not student life etc.
09-24-2026 08:49 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,873
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #104
RE: New 2027 US News academic rankings are out
(09-24-2026 08:49 AM)HouCat Wrote:  
(09-22-2026 01:24 PM)SFLFB Wrote:  All Other Ranking Categories 2027 Best Colleges Ranking Factor Weights
Indicator

2027 Weight for Schools With Usable SAT/ACT

Graduation rates 16%
First-year retention rates 5%
Graduation rate performance 10%
Pell graduation rates 5.5%
Pell graduation performance 5.5%
College grads earning more than a high school grad 5%
Earnings by major 5%
Peer assessment 20%
Financial resources 8%
Faculty salaries 8%
Full-time faculty 3%
Student-faculty ratio 4%
Standardized tests 5%

Quote:Peer assessment: This is a measure of how a school is regarded by top administrators at other institutions and accounts for qualitative attributes of schools that may not be fully captured by the other ranking factors. A school's peer assessment score is calculated from the weighted, rolling average of ratings on academic quality it received by presidents, provosts and deans of admissions – or officials in equivalent positions – at institutions submitting a peer assessment survey administered by U.S. News. Schools in National Universities and National Liberal Arts Colleges once again incorporated a two-year average, while all schools in Regional Universities and Regional Colleges categories were newly scored based on a weighted, three-year rolling average due to fewer ratings per year reported within these smaller categories.

Each survey respondent was asked to rate the overall academic quality of peer schools' undergraduate academic programs on a 5-point scale: outstanding (5), strong (4), good (3), adequate (2) or marginal (1). For example, schools in the National Universities ranking could only rate other schools in the National Universities ranking. Respondents who didn't know enough about a school to evaluate it fairly were asked to mark "don't know" or leave it blank, neither of which counted for or against a school's score.

U.S. News collected the most recent data by administering peer assessment surveys to schools in spring and summer 2026. Of the 4,405 academics who were sent questionnaires, 30.8% responded. The peer assessment response rate in the most recent year for National Universities was 41% and for National Liberal Arts Colleges was 47%.

The two highest and lowest ratings schools received each year were trimmed to minimize the effect of outliers. Schools that received fewer than 10 cumulative ratings after trimming were alternatively assigned a peer assessment value equaling the lowest qualifying score in their ranking. These alternative values were only needed for the smaller regional categories.

Whether a school submitted a peer assessment survey or statistical survey had no impact on the average peer score it received from other schools. However, schools that didn't respond to U.S. News' statistical survey who submitted peer surveys had their ratings of other schools excluded from the computations.

How USN&WR came to be the measuring stick for colleges blows my mind.

The biggest single factor (20%) is based on what others think of you.

Not graduation rates, not quality of education, not student life etc.

Sounds like college football with its polls and committees!
09-24-2026 09:24 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Gitanole Offline
Barista
*

Posts: 13,916
Joined: May 2016
Reputation: 2818
I Root For: Florida State
Location: Speared Turf
Post: #105
RE: New 2027 US News academic rankings are out
(09-24-2026 08:49 AM)HouCat Wrote:  
(09-22-2026 01:24 PM)SFLFB Wrote:  All Other Ranking Categories 2027 Best Colleges Ranking Factor Weights
Indicator

2027 Weight for Schools With Usable SAT/ACT

Graduation rates 16%
First-year retention rates 5%
Graduation rate performance 10%
Pell graduation rates 5.5%
Pell graduation performance 5.5%
College grads earning more than a high school grad 5%
Earnings by major 5%
Peer assessment 20%
Financial resources 8%
Faculty salaries 8%
Full-time faculty 3%
Student-faculty ratio 4%
Standardized tests 5%

Quote:Peer assessment: This is a measure of how a school is regarded by top administrators at other institutions and accounts for qualitative attributes of schools that may not be fully captured by the other ranking factors. A school's peer assessment score is calculated from the weighted, rolling average of ratings on academic quality it received by presidents, provosts and deans of admissions – or officials in equivalent positions – at institutions submitting a peer assessment survey administered by U.S. News. Schools in National Universities and National Liberal Arts Colleges once again incorporated a two-year average, while all schools in Regional Universities and Regional Colleges categories were newly scored based on a weighted, three-year rolling average due to fewer ratings per year reported within these smaller categories.

Each survey respondent was asked to rate the overall academic quality of peer schools' undergraduate academic programs on a 5-point scale: outstanding (5), strong (4), good (3), adequate (2) or marginal (1). For example, schools in the National Universities ranking could only rate other schools in the National Universities ranking. Respondents who didn't know enough about a school to evaluate it fairly were asked to mark "don't know" or leave it blank, neither of which counted for or against a school's score.

U.S. News collected the most recent data by administering peer assessment surveys to schools in spring and summer 2026. Of the 4,405 academics who were sent questionnaires, 30.8% responded. The peer assessment response rate in the most recent year for National Universities was 41% and for National Liberal Arts Colleges was 47%.

The two highest and lowest ratings schools received each year were trimmed to minimize the effect of outliers. Schools that received fewer than 10 cumulative ratings after trimming were alternatively assigned a peer assessment value equaling the lowest qualifying score in their ranking. These alternative values were only needed for the smaller regional categories.

Whether a school submitted a peer assessment survey or statistical survey had no impact on the average peer score it received from other schools. However, schools that didn't respond to U.S. News' statistical survey who submitted peer surveys had their ratings of other schools excluded from the computations.

How USN&WR came to be the measuring stick for colleges blows my mind.

The biggest single factor (20%) is based on what others think of you.

Not graduation rates, not quality of education, not student life etc.

All of those are still factored in. Institutional reputation has much to do with the professional currency of a degree.

Reputation is built over time as the result of breaking new research, graduating capable professionals, winning support via grants, and so on. Invent an Internet, as Stanford and UCLA did, and yes, it tends to give your institution a reputation boost. Things like that don’t happen every day.

US News enjoys high credibility because US News led the way in taking a consumer reporting approach to higher education choices. It was hardly a project university leaders were asking them to undertake. US News argued that for the same reasons journalists provide independent reviews of cars, entertainment, home appliances and restaurants, it makes sense to review educational services.

US News then invested the time, money, and personnel into crafting metrics, sending out surveys, and tallying data in order to provide this service for young scholars making choices. US News has also adapted its metrics over time. You will notice a variety of categories—public, specialized, liberal arts, tech, value for money—based on the various priorities consumers may have.

Other rankings exist, but most lists are comparatively lazy affairs generated by a small staff. US News, by contrast, works as the Consumer Reports or Rotten Tomatoes of higher education. It enjoys the credibility it does because it has always been structured as a systematic, year-long investigative project, with appropriate resources allotted to it.

When the project began, university leaders objected to the entire premise, saying you can’t rank research institutions like you can coffee makers. Since then they have come to appreciate the engagement of the public with the realities of what institutions, in all their facets, try to do.

Today, as we know, university leaders are proud to tout their US News wins. Like preeminence designations, AAU memberships and everything else of the sort, a high US News ranking is not everything. But it is something. A feather in the cap.

And, as every researcher knows, quantifiable measures are worth having.

___
(This post was last modified: 09-24-2026 10:21 AM by Gitanole.)
09-24-2026 09:50 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Frank the Tank Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 23,551
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3294
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
Post: #106
RE: New 2027 US News academic rankings are out
(09-24-2026 08:49 AM)HouCat Wrote:  
(09-22-2026 01:24 PM)SFLFB Wrote:  All Other Ranking Categories 2027 Best Colleges Ranking Factor Weights
Indicator

2027 Weight for Schools With Usable SAT/ACT

Graduation rates 16%
First-year retention rates 5%
Graduation rate performance 10%
Pell graduation rates 5.5%
Pell graduation performance 5.5%
College grads earning more than a high school grad 5%
Earnings by major 5%
Peer assessment 20%
Financial resources 8%
Faculty salaries 8%
Full-time faculty 3%
Student-faculty ratio 4%
Standardized tests 5%

Quote:Peer assessment: This is a measure of how a school is regarded by top administrators at other institutions and accounts for qualitative attributes of schools that may not be fully captured by the other ranking factors. A school's peer assessment score is calculated from the weighted, rolling average of ratings on academic quality it received by presidents, provosts and deans of admissions – or officials in equivalent positions – at institutions submitting a peer assessment survey administered by U.S. News. Schools in National Universities and National Liberal Arts Colleges once again incorporated a two-year average, while all schools in Regional Universities and Regional Colleges categories were newly scored based on a weighted, three-year rolling average due to fewer ratings per year reported within these smaller categories.

Each survey respondent was asked to rate the overall academic quality of peer schools' undergraduate academic programs on a 5-point scale: outstanding (5), strong (4), good (3), adequate (2) or marginal (1). For example, schools in the National Universities ranking could only rate other schools in the National Universities ranking. Respondents who didn't know enough about a school to evaluate it fairly were asked to mark "don't know" or leave it blank, neither of which counted for or against a school's score.

U.S. News collected the most recent data by administering peer assessment surveys to schools in spring and summer 2026. Of the 4,405 academics who were sent questionnaires, 30.8% responded. The peer assessment response rate in the most recent year for National Universities was 41% and for National Liberal Arts Colleges was 47%.

The two highest and lowest ratings schools received each year were trimmed to minimize the effect of outliers. Schools that received fewer than 10 cumulative ratings after trimming were alternatively assigned a peer assessment value equaling the lowest qualifying score in their ranking. These alternative values were only needed for the smaller regional categories.

Whether a school submitted a peer assessment survey or statistical survey had no impact on the average peer score it received from other schools. However, schools that didn't respond to U.S. News' statistical survey who submitted peer surveys had their ratings of other schools excluded from the computations.

How USN&WR came to be the measuring stick for colleges blows my mind.

The biggest single factor (20%) is based on what others think of you.

Not graduation rates, not quality of education, not student life etc.

Here’s what is probably an unpopular answer for the masses: that subjective peer assessment factor is actually *why* the US News rankings get taken the most seriously because that is what makes the rankings actually make sense in the real world. Why is someone paying $100,000 per year for a Harvard degree? Because when a resume from a Harvard grad comes across your desk, you don’t need a measure of student life or graduation rates or anything to tell you about the education of that person. I know that there are always some snarky counterintuitive people out there on the Internet that will claim that they’d rather hire someone from Northwest Arkansas Technical Institute than a Harvard grad, but for 99.9% of the world, the instant and unintentional reaction that they will have in their mind is, “This person is *really* smart.” They will be able to walk into any interview for the rest of their lives and the assumption is that they’re a really smart person based on where they attended college, which is completely about perception.

In higher education more than anywhere else, perception *is* reality. What other people think of a school’s brand is actually most impactful factor of them all as to admissions rates and ability to having pricing power with tuition.

People critique the peer assessment because it’s subjective, some individual responses look really wacky (not unlike looking at individual AP voter ballots), and it’s hard to know whether a university president filled it out or some grad assistant. It’s a messy *process*. However, not unlike the free market, the aggregate outcome ends up tracking pretty well with how society overall views these schools where there is a “wisdom of crowds” element. A single member picked out of that that crowd might be an idiot, but the collective view of the crowd overall is often quite right.

In essence, I believe that peer assessment factor is exactly the secret sauce as to why the US News rankings get taken more seriously. Look at the recent Time college rankings where they’re using just a blunt force methodology based on public data. It’s an interesting list, but Harvey Mudd is a top 5 school higher than places like Princeton and Yale while the Fashion Institute of Technology higher than Amherst and UT-Austin. That’s great that it has surprising and quirky outcomes to spur discussion… but as a parent with 2 kids applying to college right now as we speak, those other rankings have pretty much zero relation to how difficult a school is to get into as of now. In contrast, the US News top 25 is pretty much an accurate representation of the hardest schools to get into in America. We can quibble about whether a school is ranked #19 versus #24, but if you look at the US News rankings in tiers - top 20, top 50, top 75, top 100 - they’re pretty close to reality when it comes to selectivity within those tiers. There are always outliers, but overall, the rankings “make sense” in real life.

When we talk about the “best college” ranks, if we are provided with truth serum, what most people really think is “best” deep down inside is “Who is most selective?” I’m not saying that this is how it should be and maybe there are ROI measurement that are actually more useful for most families, but by and large, if you’re the type of person or family that pays attention to these rankings in the first place, their value generally tracks with, “Is School A actually harder to get into than School B?” The US News rankings are generally a good reflection of which schools are most selective (once again if you look at it in tiers versus if a school is ranked 2 spots higher than the other).

There are other rankings that attempt to focus on ROI or how much a school actually advances an incoming student from freshman year to senior year, like the Time and WSJ rankings. That’s all fine and there are some interesting data points that can be gleaned from them or uncover some schools that provide value that aren’t at the top of mind for a lot of people. It’s just that those might be “best value” or “best ROI” rankings… but it’s hard for people to take them seriously when they try to call themselves the “best” rankings.

In contrast, US News rankings are largely trying to measure prestige… and the fact of the matter is that deep down, that is what most people really want in those rankings. Schools don’t want to just say that their graduation rate is great or they have a high ROI for each degree. They want all of that to translate into *prestige* and that’s simply much more of a mix of subjective factors on top of objective factors.
09-24-2026 10:12 AM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Frank the Tank Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 23,551
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3294
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
Post: #107
RE: New 2027 US News academic rankings are out
(09-24-2026 09:50 AM)Gitanole Wrote:  
(09-24-2026 08:49 AM)HouCat Wrote:  
(09-22-2026 01:24 PM)SFLFB Wrote:  All Other Ranking Categories 2027 Best Colleges Ranking Factor Weights
Indicator

2027 Weight for Schools With Usable SAT/ACT

Graduation rates 16%
First-year retention rates 5%
Graduation rate performance 10%
Pell graduation rates 5.5%
Pell graduation performance 5.5%
College grads earning more than a high school grad 5%
Earnings by major 5%
Peer assessment 20%
Financial resources 8%
Faculty salaries 8%
Full-time faculty 3%
Student-faculty ratio 4%
Standardized tests 5%

Quote:Peer assessment: This is a measure of how a school is regarded by top administrators at other institutions and accounts for qualitative attributes of schools that may not be fully captured by the other ranking factors. A school's peer assessment score is calculated from the weighted, rolling average of ratings on academic quality it received by presidents, provosts and deans of admissions – or officials in equivalent positions – at institutions submitting a peer assessment survey administered by U.S. News. Schools in National Universities and National Liberal Arts Colleges once again incorporated a two-year average, while all schools in Regional Universities and Regional Colleges categories were newly scored based on a weighted, three-year rolling average due to fewer ratings per year reported within these smaller categories.

Each survey respondent was asked to rate the overall academic quality of peer schools' undergraduate academic programs on a 5-point scale: outstanding (5), strong (4), good (3), adequate (2) or marginal (1). For example, schools in the National Universities ranking could only rate other schools in the National Universities ranking. Respondents who didn't know enough about a school to evaluate it fairly were asked to mark "don't know" or leave it blank, neither of which counted for or against a school's score.

U.S. News collected the most recent data by administering peer assessment surveys to schools in spring and summer 2026. Of the 4,405 academics who were sent questionnaires, 30.8% responded. The peer assessment response rate in the most recent year for National Universities was 41% and for National Liberal Arts Colleges was 47%.

The two highest and lowest ratings schools received each year were trimmed to minimize the effect of outliers. Schools that received fewer than 10 cumulative ratings after trimming were alternatively assigned a peer assessment value equaling the lowest qualifying score in their ranking. These alternative values were only needed for the smaller regional categories.

Whether a school submitted a peer assessment survey or statistical survey had no impact on the average peer score it received from other schools. However, schools that didn't respond to U.S. News' statistical survey who submitted peer surveys had their ratings of other schools excluded from the computations.

How USN&WR came to be the measuring stick for colleges blows my mind.

The biggest single factor (20%) is based on what others think of you.

Not graduation rates, not quality of education, not student life etc.

All of those are still factored in. Institutional reputation has much to do with the professional currency of a degree.

Reputation is built over time as the result of breaking new research, graduating capable professionals, winning support via grants, and so on. Invent an Internet, as Stanford and UCLA did, and yes, it tends to give your institution a reputation boost. Things like that don’t happen every day.

US News enjoys high credibility because US News led the way in taking a consumer reporting approach to higher education choices. It was hardly a project university leaders were asking them to undertake. US News argued that for the same reasons journalists provide independent reviews of cars, entertainment, home appliances and restaurants, it makes sense to review educational services.

US News then invested the time, money, and personnel into crafting metrics, sending out surveys, and rallying data in order to provide this service for young scholars making choices. US News has also adapted its metrics over time. You will notice a variety of categories—public, specialized, liberal arts, tech, value for money—based on the various priorities consumers may have.

Other rankings exist, but most lists are comparatively lazy affairs generated by a small staff. US News, by contrast, works as the Consumer Reports or Rotten Tomatoes of higher education. It enjoys the credibility it does because it has always been structured as a systematic, year-long investigative project, with appropriate resources allotted to it.

When the project began, university leaders objected to the entire premise, saying you can’t rank research institutions like you can coffee makers. Since then they have come to appreciate the engagement of the public with the realities of what institutions strive to do, in all its facets.

Today, university leaders are proud to tout US News wins. Like preeminence designations, AAU memberships and the like, a high US News ranking is not everything, but it is something. It’s a feather in the cap. And, as every researcher knows, quantifiable measures are worth having.

___

Granted, I do think most university administrators hate the US News rankings, but are resigned to the fact that they have to live with them and consumers take them seriously. Even beyond the consumer-facing side, for anyone that thinks “rankings don’t matter”, note that financial institutions will actually take the US News rankings into account for the bond ratings and credit ratings of colleges because there’s a very strong correlation (and sometimes direct causation) between rising and falling in the rankings with rising and falling in applications, enrollment, yield, and net tuition revenue (e.g. a lower-ranked school is generally going to need to provide higher levels of merit aid or other tuition discounts to better or sometimes any students and that drives down net tuition revenue, which is a very bad thing if you’re trying to balance your budget and/or obtain a loan). The borrowing costs for a school can go up significantly if they drop in the US News rankings.

And look - this isn’t crazy. A lot of people are going to spend close to or more than six figures on college even if it’s just in-state costs for a public flagship. The most expensive private colleges will cost over $400,000 over the course of 4 years. What used to be the equivalent of buying a car for each kid is now the equivalent of buying a house for each kid when it comes to college costs.

So, I do tend to push back on some of these administrators that complain about the rankings. Subjective platitudes about “fit and feel” are fine and I totally agree that every kid needs to be comfortable in their college environment to be happy and successful, but when people are spending this much for college, it’s pretty natural to want to know where a college ranks in comparison to others. I mean, people will research what’s the best washing machine or printer or hundreds of other items that will cost much less than just a couple of days of tuition and fees at a lot of universities… so college leaders are quite naive that the marketplace shouldn’t be creating rankings for what will be the largest purchase (and multiple purchases with multiple kids) in their lives besides maybe their house. People are going to want some validation for the massive amounts that they have to spend for college whether administrators like those rankings or not.
09-24-2026 10:33 AM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quo vadis Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 56,023
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
Post: #108
RE: New 2027 US News academic rankings are out
Looks like USF slipped from #91 to #100.

Hopefully we can rebound upwards.
(This post was last modified: 09-24-2026 10:44 AM by quo vadis.)
09-24-2026 10:36 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Wahoowa84 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,436
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 1176
I Root For: UVa
Location:
Post: #109
RE: New 2027 US News academic rankings are out
(09-24-2026 08:08 AM)SFLFB Wrote:  
(09-24-2026 05:11 AM)XLance Wrote:  
(09-23-2026 02:10 PM)sigke Wrote:  
(09-23-2026 01:30 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(09-23-2026 01:20 PM)sigke Wrote:  The rumor is that if the ACC gets raided, they want to become what the Magnolia League was envisioned to be... a southern version of the Ivy League.

If they go for an academic first league, then it's doubtful they will let in a school below the top 100, unless they ranked very well in another respected list, like the Forbes list and Wall Street Journal list.

This rumor is coming from where? Because the current rumor is two of the "Magnolia" schools are two of the most likely to leave and there's going to be six non-southern schools plus ND and Louisville.

Obviously, if the ACC moves to focus on being more of an academic school, they won't be the "Magnolia League" because they will have non-southern schools. But they apparently want to be more academic moving forward, esp if they they get raided.

There are even articles written about it, including the so called "Stanford Plan" which says that Stanford is suggesting that the ACC focus on trying to replace the schools that leave for the SEC and B1G with top academic FBS schools in the west & mid-west (if not each time zone), so they become more of a nationally academic focused power conference and less of an East Coast conference.

Rice & Tulane would be a prime targets in the Central Time Zone.

The timezone option is why we are starting to hear people talk about Utah or Colorado joining the ACC (I doubt that happens, but there is some talk online)

There's also talk about the ACC adding Army & Navy as football only schools.

All of which would follow the idea of the ACC rebranding themselves as an "Academics First Power Conference."

The article I read about the "Stanford Plan" says that the ACC knows if they lose their top football brands, there is no way they can replace their athletic & TV value. So instead, they would replace them by prioritizing academic value instead.

Whether it happens or not, who knows. But it makes sense if the ACC is raided and loses Clemson, Miami, FSU, GT, plus two others.

Link for the referenced "Stanford Plan"?

Sigh, it's another Jim Williams post. I wouldn't put too much stock in it outside of "it's another idea". There's no meaningful evidence that Stanford has this as a plan at all, only that they're a research anchor in what could become a meaningful academic conference. The post is quoted below, with a link to the X post.

Quote:Stanford’s Plan Could Save the ACC—and Make It Stronger After Losses of key members

If the ACC loses Florida State, North Carolina and Clemson, the easy assumption is that the conference becomes a diminished football property. That outcome is possible—but it is not inevitable.

A different path begins with Stanford, Duke, Cal, Pitt, Virginia, Georgia Tech, Miami, NC State, Virginia Tech and the rest of the league’s research-heavy core. Instead of trying to outspend the SEC and Big Ten in a football arms race, the ACC could become the nation’s leading coast-to-coast conference for academics, innovation, major markets and broad-based athletics.

Football would remain important. It just would no longer be the only way the league creates value.

The Stanford plan starts with what remains
Even without Florida State, Clemson and North Carolina, the conference would retain a strong institutional base.

Duke, Stanford, Cal, Virginia, Pitt, Georgia Tech, Miami, NC State, Virginia Tech, Boston College, Wake Forest, Louisville and SMU are not a collection of leftovers. They include elite private universities, major public research institutions, medical centers, engineering schools, technology hubs and recognizable national athletics brands.

Stanford and Cal provide Silicon Valley and Bay Area access. Duke, NC State and Wake Forest connect the league to the Research Triangle. Georgia Tech brings Atlanta’s technology and corporate economy. Pitt is a major research and medical center in Pittsburgh. Miami gives the conference an international gateway and one of the most important recruiting and event markets in college sports.

The ACC already proved it was willing to think beyond traditional geography when it added Stanford, Cal and SMU. Those schools joined at discounted media shares, helping create additional revenue and a performance-based funding pool for incumbent members. Stanford and Cal initially received 30 percent of a normal ACC share, while SMU agreed to forgo its broadcast-media share for nine years.espn
That was the first stage. The next stage could be building an academic-and-media platform that produces value well beyond Saturday football.

Add USF, Rice and UConn
The best eastern additions would be USF, Rice and UConn.
USF brings Tampa Bay, a large and growing Florida market, AAU membership, a major public research profile, health-care connections and a large alumni base. It also gives the league a second Florida presence that complements Miami rather than competes with it.

Rice is a smaller athletics brand, but it may be the cleanest academic fit available in Texas. The Houston private university brings AAU status, engineering, space, energy and medical-research ties, plus direct access to the Houston corporate market. Rice and SMU would give the conference an affluent, high-end Texas pairing in Houston and Dallas.

UConn adds a flagship public university, a valuable basketball brand, New England presence and the Hartford/New York media corridor. Its men’s and women’s basketball programs also give any future league a dependable national-event property in a sports calendar increasingly built around streaming windows and tournament inventory.

The best Western choices
The strongest Western targets are San Diego State, Oregon State and Washington State.

San Diego State makes sense because it now carries R1 research status, sits in a major Southern California market and offers access to San Diego’s defense, biotech, tourism and cross-border business economy. SDSU officially received Carnegie R1 classification in 2025.sdsu

Oregon State is an R1 university with land-, sea-, space- and sun-grant designations, making it especially valuable for climate, ocean, forestry, food and environmental research.business.oregonstate

Washington State would add another serious research institution, Pacific Northwest reach and strength in agriculture, veterinary medicine, food systems and applied science. Together with Stanford, Cal, Oregon State and San Diego State, those schools create a practical Pacific scheduling and research division instead of leaving the Bay Area schools isolated.

A second expansion tier could include Tulane, which offers AAU status, New Orleans, medical research and Gulf Coast climate expertise, or UNLV, which brings Las Vegas, Allegiant Stadium and major-event infrastructure. Tulane is the cleaner institutional fit; UNLV is the stronger sports-business and championship-event play.

The real money is beyond football
The Stanford plan would not pretend that a conference can simply pool university endowments or redirect research grants into athletics. It cannot. Research funding is awarded to institutions, faculty and projects, while endowment dollars are normally restricted by donor purpose.

The smarter model is a league-supported research and innovation consortium.
The conference could create a shared office to help member schools build multi-campus bids for federal grants, foundation support and corporate research contracts. It could connect Stanford and Cal’s technology networks with Georgia Tech, Duke, Pitt, Rice, USF, Miami, NC State and Virginia Tech in fields such as artificial intelligence, cybersecurity, health care, sports medicine, climate resilience, energy, aerospace and advanced manufacturing.

That approach could generate more research opportunities, corporate partnerships, student internships, startup investment and intellectual-property development. The financial benefit would largely flow to the universities themselves—not directly into the ACC office—but it makes league membership more valuable and harder to walk away from.

Stanford’s 2024 research expenditures totaled about $1.64 billion, including more than $1 billion in federal support. That shows the scale of the academic economy compared with even major football-media payments.ncsesdata.nsf
A better long-term conference

The ACC’s ESPN agreement runs through 2036, giving the league a period of stability while it rethinks its post-2036 model. The original Stanford-Cal-SMU expansion was expected to generate roughly $600 million in added media-rights revenue over the remaining life of the deal, or about $50 million annually.newsobserver

A rebuilt league would still sell football, basketball and championship events. But it could also sell something the SEC and Big Ten cannot easily duplicate: a national alliance of research universities in Silicon Valley, Boston, Pittsburgh, Washington’s orbit, the Research Triangle, Atlanta, Miami, Tampa, Dallas, Houston and Southern California.

Losing Florida State, North Carolina and Clemson would hurt. There is no reason to minimize it.

But the Stanford plan offers a credible alternative: build a conference that wins with elite academics, research capacity, affluent markets, innovation partnerships, destination events, basketball inventory and broad-based sports—not simply by chasing the next football payout.

https://x.com/JWMediaDC/status/2101330236054860261?s=20


Jim Williams is a sports media writer who graduated from USF.

To simplify Jim Williams' agenda: he believes that if FSU and Clemson move to the SEC, USF should be #1 in the ACC's backfill options.

Calling this the "Stanford Plan" is just Jim Williams' marketing approach. First, there is no material benefit from creating a "research consortium" that requires athletics membership. Second, Rice is not a serious top-level backfill candidate from the G6 (they're not investing sufficiently in athletics, especially football, and it's not due to the lack of resources). Third, the suggestion that Stanford is suggesting UNLV and SDSU as ACC backfills due to being research heavyweights is nonsensical.
09-24-2026 10:49 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
whittx Offline
All American
*

Posts: 2,908
Joined: Apr 2016
Reputation: 129
I Root For: FSU, Bport,Corn
Location:
Post: #110
RE: New 2027 US News academic rankings are out
And then there's the underrated America East:

Binghamton - 73
NJIT - 85
UNH - 109
UAlbany - 121
Vermont -133
UMBC -137
UMass Lowell - 148
UNH - 262
Bryant - 8 (Regional University North)
09-24-2026 11:10 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
jrj84105 Online
All American
*

Posts: 3,185
Joined: Jan 2013
Reputation: 352
I Root For: Utes
Location:
Post: #111
RE: New 2027 US News academic rankings are out
(09-24-2026 10:12 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(09-24-2026 08:49 AM)HouCat Wrote:  
(09-22-2026 01:24 PM)SFLFB Wrote:  All Other Ranking Categories 2027 Best Colleges Ranking Factor Weights
Indicator

2027 Weight for Schools With Usable SAT/ACT

Graduation rates 16%
First-year retention rates 5%
Graduation rate performance 10%
Pell graduation rates 5.5%
Pell graduation performance 5.5%
College grads earning more than a high school grad 5%
Earnings by major 5%
Peer assessment 20%
Financial resources 8%
Faculty salaries 8%
Full-time faculty 3%
Student-faculty ratio 4%
Standardized tests 5%

Quote:Peer assessment: This is a measure of how a school is regarded by top administrators at other institutions and accounts for qualitative attributes of schools that may not be fully captured by the other ranking factors. A school's peer assessment score is calculated from the weighted, rolling average of ratings on academic quality it received by presidents, provosts and deans of admissions – or officials in equivalent positions – at institutions submitting a peer assessment survey administered by U.S. News. Schools in National Universities and National Liberal Arts Colleges once again incorporated a two-year average, while all schools in Regional Universities and Regional Colleges categories were newly scored based on a weighted, three-year rolling average due to fewer ratings per year reported within these smaller categories.

Each survey respondent was asked to rate the overall academic quality of peer schools' undergraduate academic programs on a 5-point scale: outstanding (5), strong (4), good (3), adequate (2) or marginal (1). For example, schools in the National Universities ranking could only rate other schools in the National Universities ranking. Respondents who didn't know enough about a school to evaluate it fairly were asked to mark "don't know" or leave it blank, neither of which counted for or against a school's score.

U.S. News collected the most recent data by administering peer assessment surveys to schools in spring and summer 2026. Of the 4,405 academics who were sent questionnaires, 30.8% responded. The peer assessment response rate in the most recent year for National Universities was 41% and for National Liberal Arts Colleges was 47%.

The two highest and lowest ratings schools received each year were trimmed to minimize the effect of outliers. Schools that received fewer than 10 cumulative ratings after trimming were alternatively assigned a peer assessment value equaling the lowest qualifying score in their ranking. These alternative values were only needed for the smaller regional categories.

Whether a school submitted a peer assessment survey or statistical survey had no impact on the average peer score it received from other schools. However, schools that didn't respond to U.S. News' statistical survey who submitted peer surveys had their ratings of other schools excluded from the computations.

How USN&WR came to be the measuring stick for colleges blows my mind.

The biggest single factor (20%) is based on what others think of you.

Not graduation rates, not quality of education, not student life etc.

Here’s what is probably an unpopular answer for the masses: that subjective peer assessment factor is actually *why* the US News rankings get taken the most seriously because that is what makes the rankings actually make sense in the real world. Why is someone paying $100,000 per year for a Harvard degree? Because when a resume from a Harvard grad comes across your desk, you don’t need a measure of student life or graduation rates or anything to tell you about the education of that person. I know that there are always some snarky counterintuitive people out there on the Internet that will claim that they’d rather hire someone from Northwest Arkansas Technical Institute than a Harvard grad, but for 99.9% of the world, the instant and unintentional reaction that they will have in their mind is, “This person is *really* smart.” They will be able to walk into any interview for the rest of their lives and the assumption is that they’re a really smart person based on where they attended college, which is completely about perception.

In higher education more than anywhere else, perception *is* reality. What other people think of a school’s brand is actually most impactful factor of them all as to admissions rates and ability to having pricing power with tuition.

People critique the peer assessment because it’s subjective, some individual responses look really wacky (not unlike looking at individual AP voter ballots), and it’s hard to know whether a university president filled it out or some grad assistant. It’s a messy *process*. However, not unlike the free market, the aggregate outcome ends up tracking pretty well with how society overall views these schools where there is a “wisdom of crowds” element. A single member picked out of that that crowd might be an idiot, but the collective view of the crowd overall is often quite right.

In essence, I believe that peer assessment factor is exactly the secret sauce as to why the US News rankings get taken more seriously. Look at the recent Time college rankings where they’re using just a blunt force methodology based on public data. It’s an interesting list, but Harvey Mudd is a top 5 school higher than places like Princeton and Yale while the Fashion Institute of Technology higher than Amherst and UT-Austin. That’s great that it has surprising and quirky outcomes to spur discussion… but as a parent with 2 kids applying to college right now as we speak, those other rankings have pretty much zero relation to how difficult a school is to get into as of now. In contrast, the US News top 25 is pretty much an accurate representation of the hardest schools to get into in America. We can quibble about whether a school is ranked #19 versus #24, but if you look at the US News rankings in tiers - top 20, top 50, top 75, top 100 - they’re pretty close to reality when it comes to selectivity within those tiers. There are always outliers, but overall, the rankings “make sense” in real life.

When we talk about the “best college” ranks, if we are provided with truth serum, what most people really think is “best” deep down inside is “Who is most selective?” I’m not saying that this is how it should be and maybe there are ROI measurement that are actually more useful for most families, but by and large, if you’re the type of person or family that pays attention to these rankings in the first place, their value generally tracks with, “Is School A actually harder to get into than School B?” The US News rankings are generally a good reflection of which schools are most selective (once again if you look at it in tiers versus if a school is ranked 2 spots higher than the other).

There are other rankings that attempt to focus on ROI or how much a school actually advances an incoming student from freshman year to senior year, like the Time and WSJ rankings. That’s all fine and there are some interesting data points that can be gleaned from them or uncover some schools that provide value that aren’t at the top of mind for a lot of people. It’s just that those might be “best value” or “best ROI” rankings… but it’s hard for people to take them seriously when they try to call themselves the “best” rankings.

In contrast, US News rankings are largely trying to measure prestige…

But the peer assessment is being performed by university officials who are increasingly competing for students with each other and have an incentive to nuke competitors. If it were being filled out by semi-objective third parties in hiring positions it might be meaningful.
09-24-2026 11:45 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Wahoowa84 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,436
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 1176
I Root For: UVa
Location:
Post: #112
RE: New 2027 US News academic rankings are out
(09-24-2026 10:33 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(09-24-2026 09:50 AM)Gitanole Wrote:  
(09-24-2026 08:49 AM)HouCat Wrote:  
(09-22-2026 01:24 PM)SFLFB Wrote:  All Other Ranking Categories 2027 Best Colleges Ranking Factor Weights
Indicator

2027 Weight for Schools With Usable SAT/ACT

Graduation rates 16%
First-year retention rates 5%
Graduation rate performance 10%
Pell graduation rates 5.5%
Pell graduation performance 5.5%
College grads earning more than a high school grad 5%
Earnings by major 5%
Peer assessment 20%
Financial resources 8%
Faculty salaries 8%
Full-time faculty 3%
Student-faculty ratio 4%
Standardized tests 5%

Quote:Peer assessment: This is a measure of how a school is regarded by top administrators at other institutions and accounts for qualitative attributes of schools that may not be fully captured by the other ranking factors. A school's peer assessment score is calculated from the weighted, rolling average of ratings on academic quality it received by presidents, provosts and deans of admissions – or officials in equivalent positions – at institutions submitting a peer assessment survey administered by U.S. News. Schools in National Universities and National Liberal Arts Colleges once again incorporated a two-year average, while all schools in Regional Universities and Regional Colleges categories were newly scored based on a weighted, three-year rolling average due to fewer ratings per year reported within these smaller categories.

Each survey respondent was asked to rate the overall academic quality of peer schools' undergraduate academic programs on a 5-point scale: outstanding (5), strong (4), good (3), adequate (2) or marginal (1). For example, schools in the National Universities ranking could only rate other schools in the National Universities ranking. Respondents who didn't know enough about a school to evaluate it fairly were asked to mark "don't know" or leave it blank, neither of which counted for or against a school's score.

U.S. News collected the most recent data by administering peer assessment surveys to schools in spring and summer 2026. Of the 4,405 academics who were sent questionnaires, 30.8% responded. The peer assessment response rate in the most recent year for National Universities was 41% and for National Liberal Arts Colleges was 47%.

The two highest and lowest ratings schools received each year were trimmed to minimize the effect of outliers. Schools that received fewer than 10 cumulative ratings after trimming were alternatively assigned a peer assessment value equaling the lowest qualifying score in their ranking. These alternative values were only needed for the smaller regional categories.

Whether a school submitted a peer assessment survey or statistical survey had no impact on the average peer score it received from other schools. However, schools that didn't respond to U.S. News' statistical survey who submitted peer surveys had their ratings of other schools excluded from the computations.

How USN&WR came to be the measuring stick for colleges blows my mind.

The biggest single factor (20%) is based on what others think of you.

Not graduation rates, not quality of education, not student life etc.

All of those are still factored in. Institutional reputation has much to do with the professional currency of a degree.

Reputation is built over time as the result of breaking new research, graduating capable professionals, winning support via grants, and so on. Invent an Internet, as Stanford and UCLA did, and yes, it tends to give your institution a reputation boost. Things like that don’t happen every day.

US News enjoys high credibility because US News led the way in taking a consumer reporting approach to higher education choices. It was hardly a project university leaders were asking them to undertake. US News argued that for the same reasons journalists provide independent reviews of cars, entertainment, home appliances and restaurants, it makes sense to review educational services.

US News then invested the time, money, and personnel into crafting metrics, sending out surveys, and rallying data in order to provide this service for young scholars making choices. US News has also adapted its metrics over time. You will notice a variety of categories—public, specialized, liberal arts, tech, value for money—based on the various priorities consumers may have.

Other rankings exist, but most lists are comparatively lazy affairs generated by a small staff. US News, by contrast, works as the Consumer Reports or Rotten Tomatoes of higher education. It enjoys the credibility it does because it has always been structured as a systematic, year-long investigative project, with appropriate resources allotted to it.

When the project began, university leaders objected to the entire premise, saying you can’t rank research institutions like you can coffee makers. Since then they have come to appreciate the engagement of the public with the realities of what institutions strive to do, in all its facets.

Today, university leaders are proud to tout US News wins. Like preeminence designations, AAU memberships and the like, a high US News ranking is not everything, but it is something. It’s a feather in the cap. And, as every researcher knows, quantifiable measures are worth having.

___

Granted, I do think most university administrators hate the US News rankings, but are resigned to the fact that they have to live with them and consumers take them seriously. Even beyond the consumer-facing side, for anyone that thinks “rankings don’t matter”, note that financial institutions will actually take the US News rankings into account for the bond ratings and credit ratings of colleges because there’s a very strong correlation (and sometimes direct causation) between rising and falling in the rankings with rising and falling in applications, enrollment, yield, and net tuition revenue (e.g. a lower-ranked school is generally going to need to provide higher levels of merit aid or other tuition discounts to better or sometimes any students and that drives down net tuition revenue, which is a very bad thing if you’re trying to balance your budget and/or obtain a loan). The borrowing costs for a school can go up significantly if they drop in the US News rankings.

And look - this isn’t crazy. A lot of people are going to spend close to or more than six figures on college even if it’s just in-state costs for a public flagship. The most expensive private colleges will cost over $400,000 over the course of 4 years. What used to be the equivalent of buying a car for each kid is now the equivalent of buying a house for each kid when it comes to college costs.

So, I do tend to push back on some of these administrators that complain about the rankings. Subjective platitudes about “fit and feel” are fine and I totally agree that every kid needs to be comfortable in their college environment to be happy and successful, but when people are spending this much for college, it’s pretty natural to want to know where a college ranks in comparison to others. I mean, people will research what’s the best washing machine or printer or hundreds of other items that will cost much less than just a couple of days of tuition and fees at a lot of universities… so college leaders are quite naive that the marketplace shouldn’t be creating rankings for what will be the largest purchase (and multiple purchases with multiple kids) in their lives besides maybe their house. People are going to want some validation for the massive amounts that they have to spend for college whether administrators like those rankings or not.

Consumer demand has definitely led to a supply-side change in attitude by universities. University administrators dislike of oversimplification is mitigated by the positive macro-marketing benefit from having their institution publicized amongst peers.

It seems that over time universities are actually encouraging US News to rank their schools. US News now has about 400 "national universities" ranked, that's double the size from 40+ years ago when it started. For example, UVa has consistently been a top 5 ranked public university. Yet in the 1980s it was ranked in the mid teens; now the top 5 publics are ranked in the mid 20s. Elite private universities were the first jump on the bandwagon...and they dominate the very top of the rankings. Then as the framework for classifying universities became more transparent, the Lehighs and Villanovas got serious about the value of this marketing tool. Now a lot more publics recognize that advocating to be ranked by US News is a worthwhile exercise.
09-24-2026 11:47 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Frank the Tank Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 23,551
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3294
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
Post: #113
RE: New 2027 US News academic rankings are out
(09-24-2026 11:45 AM)jrj84105 Wrote:  
(09-24-2026 10:12 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(09-24-2026 08:49 AM)HouCat Wrote:  
(09-22-2026 01:24 PM)SFLFB Wrote:  All Other Ranking Categories 2027 Best Colleges Ranking Factor Weights
Indicator

2027 Weight for Schools With Usable SAT/ACT

Graduation rates 16%
First-year retention rates 5%
Graduation rate performance 10%
Pell graduation rates 5.5%
Pell graduation performance 5.5%
College grads earning more than a high school grad 5%
Earnings by major 5%
Peer assessment 20%
Financial resources 8%
Faculty salaries 8%
Full-time faculty 3%
Student-faculty ratio 4%
Standardized tests 5%

Quote:Peer assessment: This is a measure of how a school is regarded by top administrators at other institutions and accounts for qualitative attributes of schools that may not be fully captured by the other ranking factors. A school's peer assessment score is calculated from the weighted, rolling average of ratings on academic quality it received by presidents, provosts and deans of admissions – or officials in equivalent positions – at institutions submitting a peer assessment survey administered by U.S. News. Schools in National Universities and National Liberal Arts Colleges once again incorporated a two-year average, while all schools in Regional Universities and Regional Colleges categories were newly scored based on a weighted, three-year rolling average due to fewer ratings per year reported within these smaller categories.

Each survey respondent was asked to rate the overall academic quality of peer schools' undergraduate academic programs on a 5-point scale: outstanding (5), strong (4), good (3), adequate (2) or marginal (1). For example, schools in the National Universities ranking could only rate other schools in the National Universities ranking. Respondents who didn't know enough about a school to evaluate it fairly were asked to mark "don't know" or leave it blank, neither of which counted for or against a school's score.

U.S. News collected the most recent data by administering peer assessment surveys to schools in spring and summer 2026. Of the 4,405 academics who were sent questionnaires, 30.8% responded. The peer assessment response rate in the most recent year for National Universities was 41% and for National Liberal Arts Colleges was 47%.

The two highest and lowest ratings schools received each year were trimmed to minimize the effect of outliers. Schools that received fewer than 10 cumulative ratings after trimming were alternatively assigned a peer assessment value equaling the lowest qualifying score in their ranking. These alternative values were only needed for the smaller regional categories.

Whether a school submitted a peer assessment survey or statistical survey had no impact on the average peer score it received from other schools. However, schools that didn't respond to U.S. News' statistical survey who submitted peer surveys had their ratings of other schools excluded from the computations.

How USN&WR came to be the measuring stick for colleges blows my mind.

The biggest single factor (20%) is based on what others think of you.

Not graduation rates, not quality of education, not student life etc.

Here’s what is probably an unpopular answer for the masses: that subjective peer assessment factor is actually *why* the US News rankings get taken the most seriously because that is what makes the rankings actually make sense in the real world. Why is someone paying $100,000 per year for a Harvard degree? Because when a resume from a Harvard grad comes across your desk, you don’t need a measure of student life or graduation rates or anything to tell you about the education of that person. I know that there are always some snarky counterintuitive people out there on the Internet that will claim that they’d rather hire someone from Northwest Arkansas Technical Institute than a Harvard grad, but for 99.9% of the world, the instant and unintentional reaction that they will have in their mind is, “This person is *really* smart.” They will be able to walk into any interview for the rest of their lives and the assumption is that they’re a really smart person based on where they attended college, which is completely about perception.

In higher education more than anywhere else, perception *is* reality. What other people think of a school’s brand is actually most impactful factor of them all as to admissions rates and ability to having pricing power with tuition.

People critique the peer assessment because it’s subjective, some individual responses look really wacky (not unlike looking at individual AP voter ballots), and it’s hard to know whether a university president filled it out or some grad assistant. It’s a messy *process*. However, not unlike the free market, the aggregate outcome ends up tracking pretty well with how society overall views these schools where there is a “wisdom of crowds” element. A single member picked out of that that crowd might be an idiot, but the collective view of the crowd overall is often quite right.

In essence, I believe that peer assessment factor is exactly the secret sauce as to why the US News rankings get taken more seriously. Look at the recent Time college rankings where they’re using just a blunt force methodology based on public data. It’s an interesting list, but Harvey Mudd is a top 5 school higher than places like Princeton and Yale while the Fashion Institute of Technology higher than Amherst and UT-Austin. That’s great that it has surprising and quirky outcomes to spur discussion… but as a parent with 2 kids applying to college right now as we speak, those other rankings have pretty much zero relation to how difficult a school is to get into as of now. In contrast, the US News top 25 is pretty much an accurate representation of the hardest schools to get into in America. We can quibble about whether a school is ranked #19 versus #24, but if you look at the US News rankings in tiers - top 20, top 50, top 75, top 100 - they’re pretty close to reality when it comes to selectivity within those tiers. There are always outliers, but overall, the rankings “make sense” in real life.

When we talk about the “best college” ranks, if we are provided with truth serum, what most people really think is “best” deep down inside is “Who is most selective?” I’m not saying that this is how it should be and maybe there are ROI measurement that are actually more useful for most families, but by and large, if you’re the type of person or family that pays attention to these rankings in the first place, their value generally tracks with, “Is School A actually harder to get into than School B?” The US News rankings are generally a good reflection of which schools are most selective (once again if you look at it in tiers versus if a school is ranked 2 spots higher than the other).

There are other rankings that attempt to focus on ROI or how much a school actually advances an incoming student from freshman year to senior year, like the Time and WSJ rankings. That’s all fine and there are some interesting data points that can be gleaned from them or uncover some schools that provide value that aren’t at the top of mind for a lot of people. It’s just that those might be “best value” or “best ROI” rankings… but it’s hard for people to take them seriously when they try to call themselves the “best” rankings.

In contrast, US News rankings are largely trying to measure prestige…

But the peer assessment is being performed by university officials who are increasingly competing for students with each other and have an incentive to nuke competitors. If it were being filled out by semi-objective third parties in hiring positions it might be meaningful.

Like I’ve said, there might be individual surveys where this occurs. Hence my statement that you can pick out an individual in the crowd that’s an idiot (or in this case answering the survey in bad faith). However, US News simply has a very large sample size and if people want truth serum, the overall peer assessment *does* track pretty well with the overall prestige of universities. We’re not getting wacky or disingenuous results when all of that is taken in the aggregate. That’s what I mean that no one likes the *process* of these surveys because it seems like people can write them out in an attempt to game the system in the way that you’ve suggested, but the outcome of the survey ends up being the closest to real life because, once again, perception *is* reality in higher education prestige.

I do think there have been some attempts at getting employer surveys. I think people have found that it’s a bit difficult particularly for overall schools. It might work better for specific majors or industries: accounting, for instance, has a pretty standard nationalized way of looking at schools, but other industries or employers may be almost entirely looking at college hiring based on location.
09-24-2026 12:00 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Online
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,945
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #114
RE: New 2027 US News academic rankings are out
(09-24-2026 05:11 AM)XLance Wrote:  
(09-23-2026 02:10 PM)sigke Wrote:  
(09-23-2026 01:30 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(09-23-2026 01:20 PM)sigke Wrote:  
(09-23-2026 01:01 PM)BirdstheWord Wrote:  Never say never. The ACC added Louisville in 2014 when their ranking was 160. It's now 179.

The rumor is that if the ACC gets raided, they want to become what the Magnolia League was envisioned to be... a southern version of the Ivy League.

If they go for an academic first league, then it's doubtful they will let in a school below the top 100, unless they ranked very well in another respected list, like the Forbes list and Wall Street Journal list.

This rumor is coming from where? Because the current rumor is two of the "Magnolia" schools are two of the most likely to leave and there's going to be six non-southern schools plus ND and Louisville.

Obviously, if the ACC moves to focus on being more of an academic school, they won't be the "Magnolia League" because they will have non-southern schools. But they apparently want to be more academic moving forward, esp if they they get raided.

There are even articles written about it, including the so called "Stanford Plan" which says that Stanford is suggesting that the ACC focus on trying to replace the schools that leave for the SEC and B1G with top academic FBS schools in the west & mid-west (if not each time zone), so they become more of a nationally academic focused power conference and less of an East Coast conference.

Rice & Tulane would be a prime targets in the Central Time Zone.

The timezone option is why we are starting to hear people talk about Utah or Colorado joining the ACC (I doubt that happens, but there is some talk online)

There's also talk about the ACC adding Army & Navy as football only schools.

All of which would follow the idea of the ACC rebranding themselves as an "Academics First Power Conference."

The article I read about the "Stanford Plan" says that the ACC knows if they lose their top football brands, there is no way they can replace their athletic & TV value. So instead, they would replace them by prioritizing academic value instead.

Whether it happens or not, who knows. But it makes sense if the ACC is raided and loses Clemson, Miami, FSU, GT, plus two others.

Link for the referenced "Stanford Plan"?

http://www.gregFlugaur.com

edit: dang, looks like it was Jim Williams. I was close though!
(This post was last modified: 09-24-2026 12:06 PM by bryanw1995.)
09-24-2026 12:02 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Frank the Tank Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 23,551
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3294
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
Post: #115
RE: New 2027 US News academic rankings are out
(09-24-2026 12:02 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(09-24-2026 05:11 AM)XLance Wrote:  
(09-23-2026 02:10 PM)sigke Wrote:  
(09-23-2026 01:30 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(09-23-2026 01:20 PM)sigke Wrote:  The rumor is that if the ACC gets raided, they want to become what the Magnolia League was envisioned to be... a southern version of the Ivy League.

If they go for an academic first league, then it's doubtful they will let in a school below the top 100, unless they ranked very well in another respected list, like the Forbes list and Wall Street Journal list.

This rumor is coming from where? Because the current rumor is two of the "Magnolia" schools are two of the most likely to leave and there's going to be six non-southern schools plus ND and Louisville.

Obviously, if the ACC moves to focus on being more of an academic school, they won't be the "Magnolia League" because they will have non-southern schools. But they apparently want to be more academic moving forward, esp if they they get raided.

There are even articles written about it, including the so called "Stanford Plan" which says that Stanford is suggesting that the ACC focus on trying to replace the schools that leave for the SEC and B1G with top academic FBS schools in the west & mid-west (if not each time zone), so they become more of a nationally academic focused power conference and less of an East Coast conference.

Rice & Tulane would be a prime targets in the Central Time Zone.

The timezone option is why we are starting to hear people talk about Utah or Colorado joining the ACC (I doubt that happens, but there is some talk online)

There's also talk about the ACC adding Army & Navy as football only schools.

All of which would follow the idea of the ACC rebranding themselves as an "Academics First Power Conference."

The article I read about the "Stanford Plan" says that the ACC knows if they lose their top football brands, there is no way they can replace their athletic & TV value. So instead, they would replace them by prioritizing academic value instead.

Whether it happens or not, who knows. But it makes sense if the ACC is raided and loses Clemson, Miami, FSU, GT, plus two others.

Link for the referenced "Stanford Plan"?

http://www.gregFlugaur.com

edit: dang, looks like it was Jim Williams. I was close though!

Ha! Yes - Jim Williams is like the Dude or Flugaur with just a little more subtlety (but no less biased).

Everyone should listen to the latest College Football Enquirer podcast. Dellenger (an actual real reporter with real sources) talk about the call Cody Campbell and other supporters of the PCSA had early on with a lot of different college leaders. One of the people on that call was Condoleezza Rice representing Stanford and she specifically called out that they did not like the expansion and realignment restrictions of the bill at all. That is certainly not due to some type of hope of a “Stanford Plan” or Magnolia League, but rather Stanford’s outright goal is to get into the Big Ten.
09-24-2026 12:16 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Garden_KC Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,000
Joined: Jan 2023
Reputation: 142
I Root For: Landscaping
Location:
Post: #116
RE: New 2027 US News academic rankings are out
(09-24-2026 12:16 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(09-24-2026 12:02 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(09-24-2026 05:11 AM)XLance Wrote:  
(09-23-2026 02:10 PM)sigke Wrote:  
(09-23-2026 01:30 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  This rumor is coming from where? Because the current rumor is two of the "Magnolia" schools are two of the most likely to leave and there's going to be six non-southern schools plus ND and Louisville.

Obviously, if the ACC moves to focus on being more of an academic school, they won't be the "Magnolia League" because they will have non-southern schools. But they apparently want to be more academic moving forward, esp if they they get raided.

There are even articles written about it, including the so called "Stanford Plan" which says that Stanford is suggesting that the ACC focus on trying to replace the schools that leave for the SEC and B1G with top academic FBS schools in the west & mid-west (if not each time zone), so they become more of a nationally academic focused power conference and less of an East Coast conference.

Rice & Tulane would be a prime targets in the Central Time Zone.

The timezone option is why we are starting to hear people talk about Utah or Colorado joining the ACC (I doubt that happens, but there is some talk online)

There's also talk about the ACC adding Army & Navy as football only schools.

All of which would follow the idea of the ACC rebranding themselves as an "Academics First Power Conference."

The article I read about the "Stanford Plan" says that the ACC knows if they lose their top football brands, there is no way they can replace their athletic & TV value. So instead, they would replace them by prioritizing academic value instead.

Whether it happens or not, who knows. But it makes sense if the ACC is raided and loses Clemson, Miami, FSU, GT, plus two others.

Link for the referenced "Stanford Plan"?

http://www.gregFlugaur.com

edit: dang, looks like it was Jim Williams. I was close though!

Ha! Yes - Jim Williams is like the Dude or Flugaur with just a little more subtlety (but no less biased).

Everyone should listen to the latest College Football Enquirer podcast. Dellenger (an actual real reporter with real sources) talk about the call Cody Campbell and other supporters of the PCSA had early on with a lot of different college leaders. One of the people on that call was Condoleezza Rice representing Stanford and she specifically called out that they did not like the expansion and realignment restrictions of the bill at all. That is certainly not due to some type of hope of a “Stanford Plan” or Magnolia League, but rather Stanford’s outright goal is to get into the Big Ten.

I watched a tailgating/game day video recently on Stanford/Cal.

Cal feels like going to a mid tier ACC game.

Stanford feels like attending a Navy/Army game.

They are lucky to be where they are at IMO.
09-24-2026 12:29 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13521
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #117
RE: New 2027 US News academic rankings are out
(09-24-2026 12:16 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(09-24-2026 12:02 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(09-24-2026 05:11 AM)XLance Wrote:  
(09-23-2026 02:10 PM)sigke Wrote:  
(09-23-2026 01:30 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  This rumor is coming from where? Because the current rumor is two of the "Magnolia" schools are two of the most likely to leave and there's going to be six non-southern schools plus ND and Louisville.

Obviously, if the ACC moves to focus on being more of an academic school, they won't be the "Magnolia League" because they will have non-southern schools. But they apparently want to be more academic moving forward, esp if they they get raided.

There are even articles written about it, including the so called "Stanford Plan" which says that Stanford is suggesting that the ACC focus on trying to replace the schools that leave for the SEC and B1G with top academic FBS schools in the west & mid-west (if not each time zone), so they become more of a nationally academic focused power conference and less of an East Coast conference.

Rice & Tulane would be a prime targets in the Central Time Zone.

The timezone option is why we are starting to hear people talk about Utah or Colorado joining the ACC (I doubt that happens, but there is some talk online)

There's also talk about the ACC adding Army & Navy as football only schools.

All of which would follow the idea of the ACC rebranding themselves as an "Academics First Power Conference."

The article I read about the "Stanford Plan" says that the ACC knows if they lose their top football brands, there is no way they can replace their athletic & TV value. So instead, they would replace them by prioritizing academic value instead.

Whether it happens or not, who knows. But it makes sense if the ACC is raided and loses Clemson, Miami, FSU, GT, plus two others.

Link for the referenced "Stanford Plan"?

http://www.gregFlugaur.com

edit: dang, looks like it was Jim Williams. I was close though!

Ha! Yes - Jim Williams is like the Dude or Flugaur with just a little more subtlety (but no less biased).

Everyone should listen to the latest College Football Enquirer podcast. Dellenger (an actual real reporter with real sources) talk about the call Cody Campbell and other supporters of the PCSA had early on with a lot of different college leaders. One of the people on that call was Condoleezza Rice representing Stanford and she specifically called out that they did not like the expansion and realignment restrictions of the bill at all. That is certainly not due to some type of hope of a “Stanford Plan” or Magnolia League, but rather Stanford’s outright goal is to get into the Big Ten.

I'd rather see a listing on the ARWU. USN&WR is not ranking what most think it is ranking.

Now to the point I want to make in your reply Frank. It seems pretty clear to me that the Big Ten and SEC will tolerate some things each does not particularly love about the PCSA in order to get the exemption. Then in 5 or 6 years we'll have court cases against the cap both for our own reasons and for because of situations like Stanford's. The only quip I'd make about Stanford is that with them it isn't so much of an expectation to be in the Big Ten as it may be that they see it as their "Right" to be in the Big Ten.

If the SEC adds under the cap North Carolina and Virginia, the desire of Clemson, FSU, and Miami to be a part of one of our conferences isn't going to be going away. So, there will be at least a handful or more of a coalition that's wants that cap either expanded or eliminated. Adding California, Colorado, Stanford and Kansas to that list is quite plausible. If you look at things which could happen in the short run, sewing up at least North Carolina for the SEC, likely with Virginia, and possibly Duke, and at least tying Notre Dame into the Big Ten solves a lot of each conference's short-term objectives. Clearing those out of the way then will permit a more focused and organized handling of the rest at a later time if the ability to do so presents itself through a modification or elimination of the cap. I think the Big Ten and SEC will be quite content to manage the now and let a pressure build which they don't push for, and should it result in opening opportunities each can and would likely add again, and if it doesn't happen both will be quite content with what they have. The pressure against that opportunity will be the survivability of the ACC and Big 12 vs the desires of that handful or so of schools to leave. It will be an interesting fight, but not our fight.
(This post was last modified: 09-24-2026 01:11 PM by JRsec.)
09-24-2026 12:47 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Frank the Tank Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 23,551
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3294
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
Post: #118
RE: New 2027 US News academic rankings are out
(09-24-2026 12:29 PM)Garden_KC Wrote:  
(09-24-2026 12:16 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(09-24-2026 12:02 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(09-24-2026 05:11 AM)XLance Wrote:  
(09-23-2026 02:10 PM)sigke Wrote:  Obviously, if the ACC moves to focus on being more of an academic school, they won't be the "Magnolia League" because they will have non-southern schools. But they apparently want to be more academic moving forward, esp if they they get raided.

There are even articles written about it, including the so called "Stanford Plan" which says that Stanford is suggesting that the ACC focus on trying to replace the schools that leave for the SEC and B1G with top academic FBS schools in the west & mid-west (if not each time zone), so they become more of a nationally academic focused power conference and less of an East Coast conference.

Rice & Tulane would be a prime targets in the Central Time Zone.

The timezone option is why we are starting to hear people talk about Utah or Colorado joining the ACC (I doubt that happens, but there is some talk online)

There's also talk about the ACC adding Army & Navy as football only schools.

All of which would follow the idea of the ACC rebranding themselves as an "Academics First Power Conference."

The article I read about the "Stanford Plan" says that the ACC knows if they lose their top football brands, there is no way they can replace their athletic & TV value. So instead, they would replace them by prioritizing academic value instead.

Whether it happens or not, who knows. But it makes sense if the ACC is raided and loses Clemson, Miami, FSU, GT, plus two others.

Link for the referenced "Stanford Plan"?

http://www.gregFlugaur.com

edit: dang, looks like it was Jim Williams. I was close though!

Ha! Yes - Jim Williams is like the Dude or Flugaur with just a little more subtlety (but no less biased).

Everyone should listen to the latest College Football Enquirer podcast. Dellenger (an actual real reporter with real sources) talk about the call Cody Campbell and other supporters of the PCSA had early on with a lot of different college leaders. One of the people on that call was Condoleezza Rice representing Stanford and she specifically called out that they did not like the expansion and realignment restrictions of the bill at all. That is certainly not due to some type of hope of a “Stanford Plan” or Magnolia League, but rather Stanford’s outright goal is to get into the Big Ten.

I watched a tailgating/game day video recently on Stanford/Cal.

Cal feels like going to a mid tier ACC game.

Stanford feels like attending a Navy/Army game.

They are lucky to be where they are at IMO.

Lucky to be respectively the hardest public school to get into the country (Cal) and hardest school overall to get into the country (Stanford) with both being directly located in most important tech innovation region on the planet? Every school would love that “luck”.
09-24-2026 12:50 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
HP-TBDPITL Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,527
Joined: Jun 2010
Reputation: 250
I Root For: College Sports
Location:
Post: #119
RE: New 2027 US News academic rankings are out
(09-24-2026 08:37 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(09-24-2026 05:07 AM)HP-TBDPITL Wrote:  
(09-23-2026 02:15 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(09-23-2026 01:59 PM)HP-TBDPITL Wrote:  
(09-23-2026 01:29 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  When Maryland announced that they were leaving in November 2012, UVa’s President initially advocated for UConn. The next day Clemson and FSU both communicated their preference of Louisville. Within a few days, Louisville was offered the spot.

Academics are important to the ACC, but football and money carry more weight in an athletics conference.

Well...West Virginia wasnt even considered because of its academics. Also I believe UConn's has gotten better since that happened-so UConn and Louisville weren't as far apart as they are now.

Louisville had just built their new Coliseum-so they started raking in money from non basketball events and had sold naming rights.
West Virginia had just moved to the Big 12 so they weren't in a position to move again. And WVU beat out UL for the Big 12 slot.

WVU went to the Big 12 because the ACC wasnt an option for them. If the ACC was an option-they would have joined the ACC.

WVU moved to the Big 12 in 2012. Louisville tried very hard, but the Big 12 couldn't find an acceptable #12 and wasn't willing to go to 11.

The ACC didn't decide to expand to 14 until 2013. And then after Maryland left, added Louisville in 2014.

So the ACC was not an option in 2012. But you make it sound like they were "rejected" in favor of other schools which is not true. The ACC just wasn't expanding in 2012 and WVU wasn't moving in 2014.

You are too focused on Louisville. Pitt and Syracuse were accepted into the ACC in Sept 2011. WVU was accepted into the Big 12 in Oct 2011. As I said, WVU went to the Big 12 because the ACC "wasnt an option."
09-24-2026 01:09 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,873
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #120
RE: New 2027 US News academic rankings are out
(09-24-2026 01:09 PM)HP-TBDPITL Wrote:  
(09-24-2026 08:37 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(09-24-2026 05:07 AM)HP-TBDPITL Wrote:  
(09-23-2026 02:15 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(09-23-2026 01:59 PM)HP-TBDPITL Wrote:  Well...West Virginia wasnt even considered because of its academics. Also I believe UConn's has gotten better since that happened-so UConn and Louisville weren't as far apart as they are now.

Louisville had just built their new Coliseum-so they started raking in money from non basketball events and had sold naming rights.
West Virginia had just moved to the Big 12 so they weren't in a position to move again. And WVU beat out UL for the Big 12 slot.

WVU went to the Big 12 because the ACC wasnt an option for them. If the ACC was an option-they would have joined the ACC.

WVU moved to the Big 12 in 2012. Louisville tried very hard, but the Big 12 couldn't find an acceptable #12 and wasn't willing to go to 11.

The ACC didn't decide to expand to 14 until 2013. And then after Maryland left, added Louisville in 2014.

So the ACC was not an option in 2012. But you make it sound like they were "rejected" in favor of other schools which is not true. The ACC just wasn't expanding in 2012 and WVU wasn't moving in 2014.

You are too focused on Louisville. Pitt and Syracuse were accepted into the ACC in Sept 2011. WVU was accepted into the Big 12 in Oct 2011. As I said, WVU went to the Big 12 because the ACC "wasnt an option."

You're correct about those dates. I had forgotten that WVU moved early. Missouri announced for the SEC AFTER the ACC announced SU and Pitt.

Syracuse was actually chosen before Virginia Tech but politics left them behind. The ACC did choose Pitt over WVU.
(This post was last modified: 09-24-2026 01:17 PM by bullet.)
09-24-2026 01:17 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.