bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,992
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3774
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
NFL reminds teams Harris, Wright ineligible to sign in 2026 - Kiffin strikes again
|
|
| 09-17-2026 11:14 PM |
|
jimrtex
All American

Posts: 4,849
Joined: Aug 2021
Reputation: 653
I Root For: Houston, Tulsa, Colorado
Location:
|
RE: NFL reminds teams Harris, Wright ineligible to sign in 2026 - Kiffin strikes again
(09-17-2026 11:14 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: https://www.espn.com/nfl/story/_/id/4996...-sign-2026
So now these kids are caught in the crossfire between Kiffin and, well, basically everyone else? How many enemies can one man make?
SEC and NCAA could lose an antitrust lawsuit over this.
How many $$$ did Harris and Wright receive as so-called professionals? How much did they receive as student athletes at Mississippi?
Did they attempt to return to college after the NCAA and SEC changed the eligibility rules at the last minute?
What are the defenses against an antitrust lawsuit:
(1) Collective bargaining agreement;
(2) Legislation;
(3) Rule of reason.
Do (1) and (2) apply.
Is the NCAA/SEC rule the least restrictive rule against "professionals" playing in college?
|
|
| 09-18-2026 05:50 AM |
|
Dr Dawgma III
Hark the Sound

Posts: 26,119
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2775
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
|
RE: NFL reminds teams Harris, Wright ineligible to sign in 2026 - Kiffin strikes again
Finalize rosters earlier than a day before the season starts
|
|
| 09-18-2026 07:36 AM |
|
bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,954
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: NFL reminds teams Harris, Wright ineligible to sign in 2026 - Kiffin strikes again
(09-18-2026 05:50 AM)jimrtex Wrote: (09-17-2026 11:14 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: https://www.espn.com/nfl/story/_/id/4996...-sign-2026
So now these kids are caught in the crossfire between Kiffin and, well, basically everyone else? How many enemies can one man make?
SEC and NCAA could lose an antitrust lawsuit over this.
How many $$$ did Harris and Wright receive as so-called professionals? How much did they receive as student athletes at Mississippi?
Did they attempt to return to college after the NCAA and SEC changed the eligibility rules at the last minute?
What are the defenses against an antitrust lawsuit:
(1) Collective bargaining agreement;
(2) Legislation;
(3) Rule of reason.
Do (1) and (2) apply.
Is the NCAA/SEC rule the least restrictive rule against "professionals" playing in college?
Sounds like they have a win against somebody, NCAA or NFL or both.
|
|
| 09-18-2026 07:49 AM |
|
johnbragg
Five Minute Google Expert

Posts: 19,638
Joined: Dec 2011
Reputation: 1371
I Root For: St Johns
Location:
|
RE: NFL reminds teams Harris, Wright ineligible to sign in 2026 - Kiffin strikes again
Can anyone explain the NFL's logic to me here?
I'm sure this is CBA-compliant, which short-circuits antitrust cases, but what is the business logic of not letting the Packers or Eagles or Jaguars sign these guys to their practice squads or as a midseason replacement if someone gets hurt?
it's not circumventing the draft, they went through the draft process.
It's not protecting the college game, these guys aren't on a college roster. You can make a case for the NFL protecting their de facto developmental league, you don't want the Houston Texans signing away the Texas Longhorn's star player in October even if he is a 23 year old who went undrafted this spring and unsigned in training camp. But again, these guys aren't playing for LSU.
IS the argument just the inertia of "we have these rules, we have rules for a reason, the rules are going to be followed until we change them via the rulemaking process we have"?
|
|
| 09-18-2026 08:22 AM |
|
georgia_tech_swagger
Res publica non dominetur

Posts: 52,992
Joined: Feb 2002
Reputation: 2417
I Root For: GT, USCU, FU, WYO
Location: Upstate, SC
  
|
RE: NFL reminds teams Harris, Wright ineligible to sign in 2026 - Kiffin strikes again
(09-17-2026 11:14 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: https://www.espn.com/nfl/story/_/id/4996...-sign-2026
So now these kids are caught in the crossfire between Kiffin and, well, basically everyone else? How many enemies can one man make?
Zxavian Harris. From Canton, MS. Been at Ole Miss since he left HS. Major: Multi-disciplinary Studies.
Dae'Quan Wright. From Perry, GA. Went to Virginia Tech '22 to '23. Then transferred to Ole Miss '24 to '25. Major: Multi-disciplinary Studies.
So they both cashed checks as hired guns for four years and did just about eff all nothing academically as you can see by the major. So, I have NO SYMPATHY whatsoever for them. If they are soon destitute and cutting car dealership commercials for rent money the lesson isn't "awllll the NFL and NCAA screwed these poor young boys". The lesson is instead "these young men have failed themselves, have been failed by Ole Miss, failed by their parents, failed by Lane Kiffin, and failed by the NCAA, and have squandered the greatest gift they've been given so far in their life. Maybe they should have put in some damn effort in the classroom too. There were FOUR backstops to instill responsibility and make prudent decisions in your long term self-interest. All four couldn't give a flying **** about anything other than the what next year's deal with their agent will be."
I will fill my schadenfreude cup up over these coming decades with what I suspect will be a never ending river of similar stories at most of the major football factories.
|
|
| 09-18-2026 08:24 AM |
|
bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,954
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: NFL reminds teams Harris, Wright ineligible to sign in 2026 - Kiffin strikes again
(09-18-2026 08:24 AM)georgia_tech_swagger Wrote: (09-17-2026 11:14 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: https://www.espn.com/nfl/story/_/id/4996...-sign-2026
So now these kids are caught in the crossfire between Kiffin and, well, basically everyone else? How many enemies can one man make?
Zxavian Harris. From Canton, MS. Been at Ole Miss since he left HS. Major: Multi-disciplinary Studies.
Dae'Quan Wright. From Perry, GA. Went to Virginia Tech '22 to '23. Then transferred to Ole Miss '24 to '25. Major: Multi-disciplinary Studies.
So they both cashed checks as hired guns for four years and did just about eff all nothing academically as you can see by the major. So, I have NO SYMPATHY whatsoever for them. If they are soon destitute and cutting car dealership commercials for rent money the lesson isn't "awllll the NFL and NCAA screwed these poor young boys". The lesson is instead "these young men have failed themselves, have been failed by Ole Miss, failed by their parents, failed by Lane Kiffin, and failed by the NCAA, and have squandered the greatest gift they've been given so far in their life. Maybe they should have put in some damn effort in the classroom too. There were FOUR backstops to instill responsibility and make prudent decisions in your long term self-interest. All four couldn't give a flying **** about anything other than the what next year's deal with their agent will be."
I will fill my schadenfreude cup up over these coming decades with what I suspect will be a never ending river of similar stories at most of the major football factories.
That's not the point. The point is that both the NCAA and NFL are banning them, putting them in a no man's land. They should be eligible for one or the other.
|
|
| 09-18-2026 08:27 AM |
|
georgia_tech_swagger
Res publica non dominetur

Posts: 52,992
Joined: Feb 2002
Reputation: 2417
I Root For: GT, USCU, FU, WYO
Location: Upstate, SC
  
|
RE: NFL reminds teams Harris, Wright ineligible to sign in 2026 - Kiffin strikes again
(09-18-2026 08:27 AM)bullet Wrote: (09-18-2026 08:24 AM)georgia_tech_swagger Wrote: (09-17-2026 11:14 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: https://www.espn.com/nfl/story/_/id/4996...-sign-2026
So now these kids are caught in the crossfire between Kiffin and, well, basically everyone else? How many enemies can one man make?
Zxavian Harris. From Canton, MS. Been at Ole Miss since he left HS. Major: Multi-disciplinary Studies.
Dae'Quan Wright. From Perry, GA. Went to Virginia Tech '22 to '23. Then transferred to Ole Miss '24 to '25. Major: Multi-disciplinary Studies.
So they both cashed checks as hired guns for four years and did just about eff all nothing academically as you can see by the major. So, I have NO SYMPATHY whatsoever for them. If they are soon destitute and cutting car dealership commercials for rent money the lesson isn't "awllll the NFL and NCAA screwed these poor young boys". The lesson is instead "these young men have failed themselves, have been failed by Ole Miss, failed by their parents, failed by Lane Kiffin, and failed by the NCAA, and have squandered the greatest gift they've been given so far in their life. Maybe they should have put in some damn effort in the classroom too. There were FOUR backstops to instill responsibility and make prudent decisions in your long term self-interest. All four couldn't give a flying **** about anything other than the what next year's deal with their agent will be."
I will fill my schadenfreude cup up over these coming decades with what I suspect will be a never ending river of similar stories at most of the major football factories.
That's not the point. The point is that both the NCAA and NFL are banning them, putting them in a no man's land. They should be eligible for one or the other.
They have to first PICK one of the other and not treat this as a game of duck duck goose. They ran out their eligibility clock and tried the NFL. They couldn't hack it. So then they tried to be a college player again using the cute 5th year ruling. If they want to be on a NFL roster, they're going to have to first GET THE **** OFF A COLLEGE ROSTER and stay off it. It's perfectly reasonable to stiff arm them both until it is clear they are no longer trying to play football in Oxford. And you don't just red carpet them to roll back in ... they have to wait to the next round just like everybody else.
|
|
| 09-18-2026 08:31 AM |
|
bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,954
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: NFL reminds teams Harris, Wright ineligible to sign in 2026 - Kiffin strikes again
(09-18-2026 08:31 AM)georgia_tech_swagger Wrote: (09-18-2026 08:27 AM)bullet Wrote: (09-18-2026 08:24 AM)georgia_tech_swagger Wrote: (09-17-2026 11:14 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: https://www.espn.com/nfl/story/_/id/4996...-sign-2026
So now these kids are caught in the crossfire between Kiffin and, well, basically everyone else? How many enemies can one man make?
Zxavian Harris. From Canton, MS. Been at Ole Miss since he left HS. Major: Multi-disciplinary Studies.
Dae'Quan Wright. From Perry, GA. Went to Virginia Tech '22 to '23. Then transferred to Ole Miss '24 to '25. Major: Multi-disciplinary Studies.
So they both cashed checks as hired guns for four years and did just about eff all nothing academically as you can see by the major. So, I have NO SYMPATHY whatsoever for them. If they are soon destitute and cutting car dealership commercials for rent money the lesson isn't "awllll the NFL and NCAA screwed these poor young boys". The lesson is instead "these young men have failed themselves, have been failed by Ole Miss, failed by their parents, failed by Lane Kiffin, and failed by the NCAA, and have squandered the greatest gift they've been given so far in their life. Maybe they should have put in some damn effort in the classroom too. There were FOUR backstops to instill responsibility and make prudent decisions in your long term self-interest. All four couldn't give a flying **** about anything other than the what next year's deal with their agent will be."
I will fill my schadenfreude cup up over these coming decades with what I suspect will be a never ending river of similar stories at most of the major football factories.
That's not the point. The point is that both the NCAA and NFL are banning them, putting them in a no man's land. They should be eligible for one or the other.
They have to first PICK one of the other and not treat this as a game of duck duck goose. They ran out their eligibility clock and tried the NFL. They couldn't hack it. So then they tried to be a college player again using the cute 5th year ruling. If they want to be on a NFL roster, they're going to have to first GET THE **** OFF A COLLEGE ROSTER and stay off it. It's perfectly reasonable to stiff arm them both until it is clear they are no longer trying to play football in Oxford. And you don't just red carpet them to roll back in ... they have to wait to the next round just like everybody else.
They never got on a college roster.
|
|
| 09-18-2026 08:36 AM |
|
georgia_tech_swagger
Res publica non dominetur

Posts: 52,992
Joined: Feb 2002
Reputation: 2417
I Root For: GT, USCU, FU, WYO
Location: Upstate, SC
  
|
RE: NFL reminds teams Harris, Wright ineligible to sign in 2026 - Kiffin strikes again
(09-18-2026 08:36 AM)bullet Wrote: (09-18-2026 08:31 AM)georgia_tech_swagger Wrote: (09-18-2026 08:27 AM)bullet Wrote: (09-18-2026 08:24 AM)georgia_tech_swagger Wrote: (09-17-2026 11:14 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: https://www.espn.com/nfl/story/_/id/4996...-sign-2026
So now these kids are caught in the crossfire between Kiffin and, well, basically everyone else? How many enemies can one man make?
Zxavian Harris. From Canton, MS. Been at Ole Miss since he left HS. Major: Multi-disciplinary Studies.
Dae'Quan Wright. From Perry, GA. Went to Virginia Tech '22 to '23. Then transferred to Ole Miss '24 to '25. Major: Multi-disciplinary Studies.
So they both cashed checks as hired guns for four years and did just about eff all nothing academically as you can see by the major. So, I have NO SYMPATHY whatsoever for them. If they are soon destitute and cutting car dealership commercials for rent money the lesson isn't "awllll the NFL and NCAA screwed these poor young boys". The lesson is instead "these young men have failed themselves, have been failed by Ole Miss, failed by their parents, failed by Lane Kiffin, and failed by the NCAA, and have squandered the greatest gift they've been given so far in their life. Maybe they should have put in some damn effort in the classroom too. There were FOUR backstops to instill responsibility and make prudent decisions in your long term self-interest. All four couldn't give a flying **** about anything other than the what next year's deal with their agent will be."
I will fill my schadenfreude cup up over these coming decades with what I suspect will be a never ending river of similar stories at most of the major football factories.
That's not the point. The point is that both the NCAA and NFL are banning them, putting them in a no man's land. They should be eligible for one or the other.
They have to first PICK one of the other and not treat this as a game of duck duck goose. They ran out their eligibility clock and tried the NFL. They couldn't hack it. So then they tried to be a college player again using the cute 5th year ruling. If they want to be on a NFL roster, they're going to have to first GET THE **** OFF A COLLEGE ROSTER and stay off it. It's perfectly reasonable to stiff arm them both until it is clear they are no longer trying to play football in Oxford. And you don't just red carpet them to roll back in ... they have to wait to the next round just like everybody else.
They never got on a college roster.
But that was exactly what they tried to do and would have done if LSU wouldn't be kicked out of the SEC for doing it. Have Sugar Daddy Lane sprinkle some NIL bag men all over it and make it all better, as usual.
|
|
| 09-18-2026 08:54 AM |
|
johnbragg
Five Minute Google Expert

Posts: 19,638
Joined: Dec 2011
Reputation: 1371
I Root For: St Johns
Location:
|
RE: NFL reminds teams Harris, Wright ineligible to sign in 2026 - Kiffin strikes again
(09-18-2026 08:54 AM)georgia_tech_swagger Wrote: (09-18-2026 08:36 AM)bullet Wrote: (09-18-2026 08:31 AM)georgia_tech_swagger Wrote: (09-18-2026 08:27 AM)bullet Wrote: (09-18-2026 08:24 AM)georgia_tech_swagger Wrote: Zxavian Harris. From Canton, MS. Been at Ole Miss since he left HS. Major: Multi-disciplinary Studies.
Dae'Quan Wright. From Perry, GA. Went to Virginia Tech '22 to '23. Then transferred to Ole Miss '24 to '25. Major: Multi-disciplinary Studies.
So they both cashed checks as hired guns for four years and did just about eff all nothing academically as you can see by the major. So, I have NO SYMPATHY whatsoever for them. If they are soon destitute and cutting car dealership commercials for rent money the lesson isn't "awllll the NFL and NCAA screwed these poor young boys". The lesson is instead "these young men have failed themselves, have been failed by Ole Miss, failed by their parents, failed by Lane Kiffin, and failed by the NCAA, and have squandered the greatest gift they've been given so far in their life. Maybe they should have put in some damn effort in the classroom too. There were FOUR backstops to instill responsibility and make prudent decisions in your long term self-interest. All four couldn't give a flying **** about anything other than the what next year's deal with their agent will be."
I will fill my schadenfreude cup up over these coming decades with what I suspect will be a never ending river of similar stories at most of the major football factories.
That's not the point. The point is that both the NCAA and NFL are banning them, putting them in a no man's land. They should be eligible for one or the other.
They have to first PICK one of the other and not treat this as a game of duck duck goose. They ran out their eligibility clock and tried the NFL. They couldn't hack it. So then they tried to be a college player again using the cute 5th year ruling. If they want to be on a NFL roster, they're going to have to first GET THE **** OFF A COLLEGE ROSTER and stay off it. It's perfectly reasonable to stiff arm them both until it is clear they are no longer trying to play football in Oxford. And you don't just red carpet them to roll back in ... they have to wait to the next round just like everybody else.
They never got on a college roster.
But that was exactly what they tried to do and would have done if LSU wouldn't be kicked out of the SEC for doing it. Have Sugar Daddy Lane sprinkle some NIL bag men all over it and make it all better, as usual.
But I'm not sure why the NFL sees that as their problem, though.
On the other hand, the NFL doesn't see themselves as missing much, or they'd have been drafted, or claimed on waivers when they got cut.
|
|
| 09-18-2026 09:12 AM |
|
Dr Dawgma III
Hark the Sound

Posts: 26,119
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2775
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
|
RE: NFL reminds teams Harris, Wright ineligible to sign in 2026 - Kiffin strikes again
Up-and-coming underclassmen playing by the well established rules and in danger of losing valuable time on the field should sue these rejects if they ever get cleared.
(This post was last modified: 09-18-2026 09:44 AM by Dr Dawgma III.)
|
|
| 09-18-2026 09:44 AM |
|
Scoochpooch1
Heisman

Posts: 5,781
Joined: May 2017
Reputation: 255
I Root For: P4
Location:
|
RE: NFL reminds teams Harris, Wright ineligible to sign in 2026 - Kiffin strikes again
(09-18-2026 08:22 AM)johnbragg Wrote: Can anyone explain the NFL's logic to me here?
I'm sure this is CBA-compliant, which short-circuits antitrust cases, but what is the business logic of not letting the Packers or Eagles or Jaguars sign these guys to their practice squads or as a midseason replacement if someone gets hurt?
it's not circumventing the draft, they went through the draft process.
It's not protecting the college game, these guys aren't on a college roster. You can make a case for the NFL protecting their de facto developmental league, you don't want the Houston Texans signing away the Texas Longhorn's star player in October even if he is a 23 year old who went undrafted this spring and unsigned in training camp. But again, these guys aren't playing for LSU.
IS the argument just the inertia of "we have these rules, we have rules for a reason, the rules are going to be followed until we change them via the rulemaking process we have"?
They are playing games and the NFL doesnt like that.
|
|
| 09-18-2026 01:17 PM |
|
Scoochpooch1
Heisman

Posts: 5,781
Joined: May 2017
Reputation: 255
I Root For: P4
Location:
|
RE: NFL reminds teams Harris, Wright ineligible to sign in 2026 - Kiffin strikes again
(09-18-2026 08:27 AM)bullet Wrote: (09-18-2026 08:24 AM)georgia_tech_swagger Wrote: (09-17-2026 11:14 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: https://www.espn.com/nfl/story/_/id/4996...-sign-2026
So now these kids are caught in the crossfire between Kiffin and, well, basically everyone else? How many enemies can one man make?
Zxavian Harris. From Canton, MS. Been at Ole Miss since he left HS. Major: Multi-disciplinary Studies.
Dae'Quan Wright. From Perry, GA. Went to Virginia Tech '22 to '23. Then transferred to Ole Miss '24 to '25. Major: Multi-disciplinary Studies.
So they both cashed checks as hired guns for four years and did just about eff all nothing academically as you can see by the major. So, I have NO SYMPATHY whatsoever for them. If they are soon destitute and cutting car dealership commercials for rent money the lesson isn't "awllll the NFL and NCAA screwed these poor young boys". The lesson is instead "these young men have failed themselves, have been failed by Ole Miss, failed by their parents, failed by Lane Kiffin, and failed by the NCAA, and have squandered the greatest gift they've been given so far in their life. Maybe they should have put in some damn effort in the classroom too. There were FOUR backstops to instill responsibility and make prudent decisions in your long term self-interest. All four couldn't give a flying **** about anything other than the what next year's deal with their agent will be."
I will fill my schadenfreude cup up over these coming decades with what I suspect will be a never ending river of similar stories at most of the major football factories.
That's not the point. The point is that both the NCAA and NFL are banning them, putting them in a no man's land. They should be eligible for one or the other.
CFL/Arena/Europe, options exist if they really love football.
|
|
| 09-18-2026 01:19 PM |
|
bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,992
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3774
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: NFL reminds teams Harris, Wright ineligible to sign in 2026 - Kiffin strikes again
(09-18-2026 01:17 PM)Scoochpooch1 Wrote: (09-18-2026 08:22 AM)johnbragg Wrote: Can anyone explain the NFL's logic to me here?
I'm sure this is CBA-compliant, which short-circuits antitrust cases, but what is the business logic of not letting the Packers or Eagles or Jaguars sign these guys to their practice squads or as a midseason replacement if someone gets hurt?
it's not circumventing the draft, they went through the draft process.
It's not protecting the college game, these guys aren't on a college roster. You can make a case for the NFL protecting their de facto developmental league, you don't want the Houston Texans signing away the Texas Longhorn's star player in October even if he is a 23 year old who went undrafted this spring and unsigned in training camp. But again, these guys aren't playing for LSU.
IS the argument just the inertia of "we have these rules, we have rules for a reason, the rules are going to be followed until we change them via the rulemaking process we have"?
They are playing games and the NFL doesnt like that.
I think it's the NFL + NFLPA working together to figure out how to handle an admittedly weird situation. If these 2 kids end up on an NFL roster next week or next month, then that means that they took roster spots from kids who didn't try to pretend they were still in college for the past month or 2. The NFL is about 10% through the regular season already, and the NFLPA has every reason to desire to know at some point who is/isn't an "NFL player" in 2026. Presumably, there's something in the Collective Bargaining Agreement that can be applied to the current situation.
As always, Kiffen didn't care about anybody but himself, and he screwed these 2 kids out of a chance at catching on with at least a practice squad for 2026.
|
|
| 09-18-2026 01:28 PM |
|
Just Joe
1st String

Posts: 1,885
Joined: Oct 2020
Reputation: 400
I Root For: Bama
Location:
|
RE: NFL reminds teams Harris, Wright ineligible to sign in 2026 - Kiffin strikes again
(09-18-2026 01:28 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (09-18-2026 01:17 PM)Scoochpooch1 Wrote: (09-18-2026 08:22 AM)johnbragg Wrote: Can anyone explain the NFL's logic to me here?
I'm sure this is CBA-compliant, which short-circuits antitrust cases, but what is the business logic of not letting the Packers or Eagles or Jaguars sign these guys to their practice squads or as a midseason replacement if someone gets hurt?
it's not circumventing the draft, they went through the draft process.
It's not protecting the college game, these guys aren't on a college roster. You can make a case for the NFL protecting their de facto developmental league, you don't want the Houston Texans signing away the Texas Longhorn's star player in October even if he is a 23 year old who went undrafted this spring and unsigned in training camp. But again, these guys aren't playing for LSU.
IS the argument just the inertia of "we have these rules, we have rules for a reason, the rules are going to be followed until we change them via the rulemaking process we have"?
They are playing games and the NFL doesnt like that.
I think it's the NFL + NFLPA working together to figure out how to handle an admittedly weird situation. If these 2 kids end up on an NFL roster next week or next month, then that means that they took roster spots from kids who didn't try to pretend they were still in college for the past month or 2. The NFL is about 10% through the regular season already, and the NFLPA has every reason to desire to know at some point who is/isn't an "NFL player" in 2026. Presumably, there's something in the Collective Bargaining Agreement that can be applied to the current situation.
As always, Kiffen didn't care about anybody but himself, and he screwed these 2 kids out of a chance at catching on with at least a practice squad for 2026.
No he doesn't and yes he did, but neither of these guys is particularly a kid and both knew what they were risking, both by trying to float between the NFL and CFB and getting in bed with Shady Lane, having spent years with him at Ole Miss ending with him leaving them high and dry in the CFP nine months ago. Frog/scorpion thing.
|
|
| 09-18-2026 02:29 PM |
|
quo vadis
Legend

Posts: 56,035
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
|
RE: NFL reminds teams Harris, Wright ineligible to sign in 2026 - Kiffin strikes again
(09-18-2026 01:28 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (09-18-2026 01:17 PM)Scoochpooch1 Wrote: (09-18-2026 08:22 AM)johnbragg Wrote: Can anyone explain the NFL's logic to me here?
I'm sure this is CBA-compliant, which short-circuits antitrust cases, but what is the business logic of not letting the Packers or Eagles or Jaguars sign these guys to their practice squads or as a midseason replacement if someone gets hurt?
it's not circumventing the draft, they went through the draft process.
It's not protecting the college game, these guys aren't on a college roster. You can make a case for the NFL protecting their de facto developmental league, you don't want the Houston Texans signing away the Texas Longhorn's star player in October even if he is a 23 year old who went undrafted this spring and unsigned in training camp. But again, these guys aren't playing for LSU.
IS the argument just the inertia of "we have these rules, we have rules for a reason, the rules are going to be followed until we change them via the rulemaking process we have"?
They are playing games and the NFL doesnt like that.
I think it's the NFL + NFLPA working together to figure out how to handle an admittedly weird situation. If these 2 kids end up on an NFL roster next week or next month, then that means that they took roster spots from kids who didn't try to pretend they were still in college for the past month or 2. The NFL is about 10% through the regular season already, and the NFLPA has every reason to desire to know at some point who is/isn't an "NFL player" in 2026. Presumably, there's something in the Collective Bargaining Agreement that can be applied to the current situation.
As always, Kiffen didn't care about anybody but himself, and he screwed these 2 kids out of a chance at catching on with at least a practice squad for 2026.
Well first, IMO Kiffin is supposed to care only for himself (and the LSU program), that's his job.
Second, these "kids" are 22, and I am not sure what opportunities Kiffin screwed them out of. These guys were undrafted and then waived in training camp. That doesn't exactly seem to indicate that they had all kinds of valuable NFL opportunities that risking going back to college denied them. Heck, if the NFL valued them, they would have been drafted, and not been waived in training camp.
In the end, Kiffin offered them a possible opportunity, and they decided to try and take it rather than hang around waiting for a practice squad chance that may well never have come. Their choice, their consequences, IMO. I think in all likelihood, they wouldn't be in the NFL now anyway. They simply were judged to not be good enough.
That said, I think this problem is far from settled. There is IMO a class of player like these two, who are not good enough for the NFL but who could be valuable to a college team, and they will keep filing lawsuits arguing that college eligibility rules are invalid, and I suspect they could well end up winning in a definitive court.
(This post was last modified: 09-18-2026 05:04 PM by quo vadis.)
|
|
| 09-18-2026 05:03 PM |
|
jimrtex
All American

Posts: 4,849
Joined: Aug 2021
Reputation: 653
I Root For: Houston, Tulsa, Colorado
Location:
|
RE: NFL reminds teams Harris, Wright ineligible to sign in 2026 - Kiffin strikes again
(09-18-2026 05:03 PM)quo vadis Wrote: (09-18-2026 01:28 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (09-18-2026 01:17 PM)Scoochpooch1 Wrote: (09-18-2026 08:22 AM)johnbragg Wrote: Can anyone explain the NFL's logic to me here?
I'm sure this is CBA-compliant, which short-circuits antitrust cases, but what is the business logic of not letting the Packers or Eagles or Jaguars sign these guys to their practice squads or as a midseason replacement if someone gets hurt?
it's not circumventing the draft, they went through the draft process.
It's not protecting the college game, these guys aren't on a college roster. You can make a case for the NFL protecting their de facto developmental league, you don't want the Houston Texans signing away the Texas Longhorn's star player in October even if he is a 23 year old who went undrafted this spring and unsigned in training camp. But again, these guys aren't playing for LSU.
IS the argument just the inertia of "we have these rules, we have rules for a reason, the rules are going to be followed until we change them via the rulemaking process we have"?
They are playing games and the NFL doesnt like that.
I think it's the NFL + NFLPA working together to figure out how to handle an admittedly weird situation. If these 2 kids end up on an NFL roster next week or next month, then that means that they took roster spots from kids who didn't try to pretend they were still in college for the past month or 2. The NFL is about 10% through the regular season already, and the NFLPA has every reason to desire to know at some point who is/isn't an "NFL player" in 2026. Presumably, there's something in the Collective Bargaining Agreement that can be applied to the current situation.
As always, Kiffen didn't care about anybody but himself, and he screwed these 2 kids out of a chance at catching on with at least a practice squad for 2026.
Well first, IMO Kiffin is supposed to care only for himself (and the LSU program), that's his job.
Second, these "kids" are 22, and I am not sure what opportunities Kiffin screwed them out of. These guys were undrafted and then waived in training camp. That doesn't exactly seem to indicate that they had all kinds of valuable NFL opportunities that risking going back to college denied them. Heck, if the NFL valued them, they would have been drafted, and not been waived in training camp.
In the end, Kiffin offered them a possible opportunity, and they decided to try and take it rather than hang around waiting for a practice squad chance that may well never have come. Their choice, their consequences, IMO. I think in all likelihood, they wouldn't be in the NFL now anyway. They simply were judged to not be good enough.
That said, I think this problem is far from settled. There is IMO a class of player like these two, who are not good enough for the NFL but who could be valuable to a college team, and they will keep filing lawsuits arguing that college eligibility rules are invalid, and I suspect they could well end up winning in a definitive court.
Xyzzy Harris had a tryout with the Green Bay Packers this week (prior to the NFL memo). The lawyer for Harris and Wright, Ryan Downton, has promised a lawsuit in the next week.
|
|
| 09-19-2026 08:12 PM |
|
The Beaver
Heisman

Posts: 7,389
Joined: Apr 2024
Reputation: 960
I Root For: Penn State
Location:
|
RE: NFL reminds teams Harris, Wright ineligible to sign in 2026 - Kiffin strikes again
(09-18-2026 01:28 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (09-18-2026 01:17 PM)Scoochpooch1 Wrote: (09-18-2026 08:22 AM)johnbragg Wrote: Can anyone explain the NFL's logic to me here?
I'm sure this is CBA-compliant, which short-circuits antitrust cases, but what is the business logic of not letting the Packers or Eagles or Jaguars sign these guys to their practice squads or as a midseason replacement if someone gets hurt?
it's not circumventing the draft, they went through the draft process.
It's not protecting the college game, these guys aren't on a college roster. You can make a case for the NFL protecting their de facto developmental league, you don't want the Houston Texans signing away the Texas Longhorn's star player in October even if he is a 23 year old who went undrafted this spring and unsigned in training camp. But again, these guys aren't playing for LSU.
IS the argument just the inertia of "we have these rules, we have rules for a reason, the rules are going to be followed until we change them via the rulemaking process we have"?
They are playing games and the NFL doesnt like that.
I think it's the NFL + NFLPA working together to figure out how to handle an admittedly weird situation. If these 2 kids end up on an NFL roster next week or next month, then that means that they took roster spots from kids who didn't try to pretend they were still in college for the past month or 2. The NFL is about 10% through the regular season already, and the NFLPA has every reason to desire to know at some point who is/isn't an "NFL player" in 2026. Presumably, there's something in the Collective Bargaining Agreement that can be applied to the current situation.
As always, Kiffen didn't care about anybody but himself, and he screwed these 2 kids out of a chance at catching on with at least a practice squad for 2026.
They never played in an NFL game, I think he didn't think it was a big deal and from wgat I've heard he wasn't the only one courting "washouts." If you ask me its everyone else screwing them over.
|
|
| 09-19-2026 08:59 PM |
|