(09-17-2026 07:42 AM)quo vadis Wrote: (09-16-2026 09:04 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: I stand by the Bob Davie comment. To do what he did at UNM takes excellent coaching. The last few years he dropped off but to win nine games there was unheard of at the time. Also he followed Lou freaking Holtz which is an impossible task. ND fans should cut him some slack after some of the miserable coaches they’ve had since lol
I mean, he inherited a Lou Holtz team that was 8-3 in 1996. He went 35-25 at ND in five seasons, two of which were losing seasons. His record was just about identical to Ty Willingham and Charlie Weis, and a little better than Gerry Faust. Those are all failed coaches IMO.
At New Mexico, he went 35-64. Maybe that is great at NM, but it's still not any good IMO. He did have the two good seasons, going 7-6 and 9-4, but all the others were losers. He finished 3-9, 3-9 and 2-10. I mean come on. New Mexico went 9-4 last year so those two in the middle were not miracle years.
IMO it is pretty amazing that he was able to be an HC for a total of 13 years at two schools with his records.
Ah, the Lack of Nuance King at it again.
Davie had two losing records at ND, 5-7 and 5-6. This day and age, the 5-6 would be 6-6 with a gimme game subbed in. But let's just say "losing records" so you can make them sound worse than they were.
By comparison, Charlie Weis had a 3-9 (!!!) record. At NOTRE DAME. And it was his THIRD season there! That is objectively a much worse coaching performance.
Willingham was fired prematurely—and coincidently had the same win percentage at ND as Davie—but he also wasn't first in line to be offered the job. I recall a severe drop off in defensive performance after Davie left. Blowouts left and right to B1G teams like Michigan and Ohio State. Don't recall blowouts during Davie's tenure. Even Kelly was getting embarrassed during marquee games.
Just to provide some grounded research, let's look at each coach's worst losses at ND:
Davie - Oregon State 41-9, Michigan State 45-23, and LSU 27-9
Willingham - Michigan 38-0, FSU 37-0, Southern Cal 45-14
Weis - Michigan 38-0, Southern Cal 38-0, and LSU 41-14
Bruh. I was surprised to see Davie actually had a consistently better offense than those "gurus"!
• • •
As to UNM, I already said the last three years there was a significant drop-off in his production, but if you look up to his 9-win season, it was solid improvement.
In 2016, New Mexico's pistol/triple-option attack was legitimately exceptional: #1 nationally in rushing at 350 yards/game, with two 1,000-yard rushers and a school-record 48 rushing TDs. After the first 3-9 season, DeBesse was fired and went onto Ga Southern and won 10 games. Looked like a pressure on Davie decision that didn't work out well after 2017 fell flat.