(09-07-2026 11:51 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: Urban Meyer was the best coach in Utah history and put them on the map. I’m not sure your obsession here but I am going to defer to the Utah fan when it comes to Whittingham’s time to go.
A lot of it comes down to people overrating the difficulty of being a HC in the state of Utah because the “it’s hard to win there” narrative is so strong.
People think that because it’s a very insular place and it’s hard to recruit outsiders there. But it’s also an insular place where locals don’t want to leave. Utah+LDS+Polynesian population base also produces a lot more talent than population indicates including “sneaky athletic” white guys and Poly guys who are often late bloomers and underrated as recruits. It’s hard to coach in the state of Utah and not look like you’re good at “developing talent”.
It also severely underestimates the Lavell Edwards coaching tree. There are so many quality coaches (including Whittingham, Sitake, Holmgren, Andy Reid, Steve Sarkisian, and all the people they influenced) that come from that tree who just want to be in Utah. The ability to find decent assistant coaches is an underrated advantage of head coaching in Utah. The floor for assistants is relatively high.
Also, prior to AD Jerry “we’re a basketball school” Pimm, Utah was pretty decent in football. There aren’t many comparable scenarios where schools shift the entire weight of their athletic department behind one sport and then change course and put their weight behind another.
There aren’t a lot of schools where a guy like Jim Fassel can’t win a game due to lack of AD support, then a guy like Ron McBride (Urban Meyer predecessor) can step in and start winning just because the AD decides it might be a good idea to fund football (also why there hasn’t been another Rick Majerus as priorities changed drastically).
Whittingham was about 0.5 wins per season better than the era before Utah decided to focus solely on basketball. It’s a return to an older standard rather than something completely new. (But don’t look for basketball to rekindle the Majerus years anytime soon.).
At least one of the Utah schools has been nationally relevant for 40+ years. Maybe it’s not so hard to build a winner in Utah? The assumption that it IS really hard is why people think KW is goated. He had a good run, but like a lot of that generation of coaches, the NIL era was not something he easily adapted to. Also, KW sort of leaned into that narrative and actively cultivated a reputation based on that assumption.