(07-14-2026 07:01 PM)Ourland Wrote: A conference's members can all trend upward while still beating one another. I know you aren't telling me that a conference can't collectively improve "as a whole," right?
Evidence of it can be seen in out-of-conference wins, national rankings, and bowl victories. It's the reason that those metrics are still important. They help show which conferences are improving, and which that are not.
Am I really explaining this?
Your continued projection is highly revealing of your insecurities. Nevertheless, I took the liberty of bold-facing your closing question for emphasis. You're right to question that. No, you aren't explaining it.
You initially claimed that the conference being "wide open" was the causal factor that would enhance our ability to obtain a CFP bid this season. You exclusively cited the historical bottom of the conference rising up and a collection of "new" contenders was signal of a stronger league. Now you're pivoting to requiring strong OOC performance that's orthogonal to the real-world performance of the very teams that have the most continuity. Not only did you shift goalposts, your suggestion flies against the statistical reality.
You're relying on phantom OOC wins and bowl games to claim that the bottom tier is rising and strengthening the AAC by cannibalizing the top. Where is the evidence or coherent model to support this? Looking at the real-world performance data, the bottom-tier programs aren't typically winning the necessary marquee games required to move the needle. These are the teams that have been the least affected by the chaos in our league; and overwhelmingly, these schools are the schools padding their "W" column the most against lower-tier schools -- even Silverfield was notorious for this to cite one example, and the Tigers aren't even bottom tier.
Zooming out to macro conference metrics doesn't hide the fact that internal parity can simply be a lower ceiling, not a rising floor. Parity born from everyone being awful looks identical to parity born from everyone being elite. The way one differentiates this is by accumulating high-profile OOC wins, otherwise it suggests the former; and you still haven't modeled how the teams with the most stability in the league will magically beat the class of team that typically blows them out.
Don't forget that intra-conference play is still a zero-sum calculation; and teams taking losses can hurt the overall metrics if the bottom reaches parity without a massive and
unprecedented shift in OOC performance league-wide. You can't math your way out of a closed system just by zooming out to cover your tracks. Where is your evidence that this will occur since you're "educating" the board?
Bottom line, your argument that a "wide open" conference is somehow going to elevate the conference's broader standings on a national scale -- even when factoring your current goalpost shift -- is incoherent. Frankly, the concept that the AAC is even "wide open" to begin with could be argued against. Irrespective, chaos doesn't suggest that the AAC's standing as the best G6 football conference is improved. Your blind faith and magical thinking is duly noted.
Score Coog: -8.