JRsec
Super Moderator

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13523
I Root For: SEC
Location:
|
RE: How Fox priorities could change realignment.
(07-06-2026 01:18 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (07-06-2026 12:39 PM)JRsec Wrote: (07-06-2026 11:46 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (07-06-2026 10:23 AM)JRsec Wrote: (07-06-2026 09:04 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: I largely agree with this here. Sure, ESPN and Fox have a lot of influence. They set the market for college sports rights, so what they are willing to pay for or not pay for is critical.
However, the notion that they will be covering potentially 9 figures worth of exit fees for ACC schools simply isn’t plausible. Wall Street has been punishing Disney’s stock for the past several years largely because everyone that understands the industry has been skeptical that ESPN can be transitioned from a basic cable business to a viable streaming business… and those are the “optimistic” ones. The rest of Wall Street just wants Disney to sell ESPN completely because they don’t believe that the business has any future at all. This question has been asked on EVERY Disney earnings call every quarter for several years. To the extent that investors want Disney to keep ESPN, they want to freeze rights fees in place: keep the NFL at all costs, play out the current NBA, SEC, CFP, and other contracts… but stop signing up anything else even if it means have wide gaps on the schedule.
Look at ESPN dropping most of its MLB rights at a national level to cut costs. It has been *really* glaring over the past couple of weeks where their sports lineup in July and August looks more like a TruTV sports lineup than the ESPN that we grew up with. Ultimately, investors don’t care - they’d rather have ESPN cut costs on anything that isn’t the NFL at this point.
These micro points about whether ESPN wants to protect market share on Florida or other markets is a classic missing the forest for the trees. Disney is the most *global* company out there. Sure, they like games involving Miami and Florida State, but it’s because they’re brands that they are paying a good price for right now. It’s not as if ESPN wanted to “lose” half of the country by not signing up the Big Ten or the brands that it has - this is a company that is essentially run by USC/UCLA people at the ground level. The leadership and culture at Disney is waaaay more Big Ten-coded than SEC-coded. However, the Big Ten got out of the ESPN price range and, as noted above, investors are caring much more about ESPN’s costs than they are about ESPN’s market share in any particular area. The SEC is a *great* deal for ESPN now as an undervalued contract until the 2030s, so of course they’re pounding it for all that it’s worth, but whether ESPN is willing to pay “market price” for anything other than the NFL and NBA (where you can’t just look at domestic ratings and need to look beyond at the international rights component that the NBA brings for global Disney+ streaming in a way that other US sports generally don’t) is an open question going forward.
We have seen them give up MLB rights due to costs where they now have barely any major sports programming for two months during the summer. ESPN didn’t give up Big Ten rights because of any principle or grand strategy to help the SEC, but rather straight up costs. ESPN would have loved to have the World Cup rights this summer, but Fox signed a longer-term contract.
Disney is essentially the definition of IP assets. They *own* Marvel. They *own* Star Wars. They *own* Pixar. These are the types of assets that Wall Street cares about when it comes to Disney deploying long-term strategies.
The NFL now owns a part of ESPN, so there’s a critical tie in place there. Everything else on ESPN, on the other hand, is a highly-paid rental. ESPN needs a critical mass of sports because it’s a sports network, but they’re still ultimately all rentals where, other than the NFL (which truly does determine survival or not for US sports programmers at scale), it’s all based on whether that rental price is worth it or not at a given time.
And lest anyone thinks that I’m just picking on ESPN and Disney here, it’s the same for everyone else, too. Fox and the Big Ten aren’t married, but rather in a business relationship that works for now. Other than the NFL, no other sports entity can delude themselves into thinking that they are so important that programmers won’t pass on them due to cost.
We'll see Frank. It's pretty clear to me that the focus of ESPN is not always the same as that of their adopted parent Disney. They've done quite a bit of sculpting of their rights holdings in 30 years. And the options available to them while owning both sets of right is a useful tool. Now your usual spiel about the NFL is your usual propaganda and had nothing to do with the post either. MLB, the NFL, pro sports in general had nothing to do with the post Bullet misrepresented. Besides the proof is in the pudding. The product ESPN has assembled is largely in what were the two best college sports markets in the nation, the Southeast and Southwest. Their ability to handle schools transitioning from one set of their rights holdings to another has been palpable and perhaps never so palpable as the acquisition of Texas and Oklahoma. If further consolidation occurs and it lowers their overhead and enhances the value of the group consolidating power they profit. So, barring Congressional action this is a wait and see. And to date Frank most of our wait and sees have gone pretty well for the SEC. NIL is the issue that revived the Big Ten. We'll see how long that goes without stipulations. There you go, I too can slip things into a conversation that weren't there either.
The NFL reference isn’t propaganda at all. Their *current* deal with CBS is worth more than the entire value of their parent company of Pararmount… and the NFL is exercising its option to renegotiate its rights fees early with each of its TV partners (including ESPN) this year. This will increase what everyone in the industry is paying the NFL *drastically*. You’re looking at this at a micro-level where how each college conference relates to each other matters to these media companies… but they are all dwarfed by the macro-level economics of having to both (a) pay way more for the NFL and (b) profits are still going down because additional streaming revenue isn’t compensating for the decline in linear cable subscription fees.
And this isn’t necessarily good for the Big Ten that’s going out to market within the next couple of years, either. Everyone is about to use all of their spare cash to keep their NFL rights and that’s going to be painful for each of these media partners. How much money each of these media companies will have left to spend on other sports is an open question. So, I’m not even stating this as a Big Ten fan because these macro-level issues can impact the B1G negatively, too.
In any event, my point is that when every major network, including ESPN, is about to have to pay several more *billion* dollars just to keep their current NFL rights, this notion that they care about Florida State so much that they will engage in all of these actions that you are stating stretches credulity. ESPN has given up the Big Ten and most of Major League Baseball due to high costs, both of which are far more important market-wise than a percentage of the State of Florida for college football. Besides the NFL, the costs are ultimately what matters above else and that goes for ESPN, Fox, NBC, and CBS, too.
Hence why everyone in sports wants more involvement from Amazon and Netflix wherever possible. It’s not an accident that the Big Ten wasn’t the one that shut down the USC-ND discussions with Netflix or NBC’s discussions with Amazon about the Big Ten Championship Game. The Big Ten could have immediately nixed all of those discussions… but they didn’t. It was Fox that did it because they’re the ones threatened by those much more profitable streamers. The Big Ten let the discussions play out (knowing full well that Fox wouldn’t ever agree to either scenario) because they want to start planting the seeds for the next media rights negotiations. They know that focusing on ESPN and Fox and other linear TV partners is fighting the last war. The SEC would be doing the same if they weren’t locked in with ESPN for so long, too. We’re all talking about fighting the last war in thinking that what ESPN and Fox want circa 2030 will mean anything compared to what Netflix and Amazon want.
Frank this is the college sports forum. You talk about the NFL a lot because you know that business. The comparisons with college football are more skewed than parallel, at least until pay for play, but how the two will corelate from here is yet to be seen. When I call the NFL propaganda, it is because you go to that analogy when you don't want to relate directly to the post at hand. It is your vehicle for reshaping the argument.
And to the crux of the argument you do present what ESPN spends on the NFL is an annually anticipated part of their budget. Ditto for the SEC. This isn't an either or proposition, but an annual expectation of both at the same time. And too is very true for FOX. FOX has the Big Ten in the budget already as a gestalt. They also have the NFL in their budget as a gestalt. Until they don't have enough for both key products the comparison you suggest would disfavor the college sports entity is spurious because something besides the SEC or Big Ten would be sacrificed first in order to hold onto the NFL because Saturday sponsorships are too valuable not to keep, just as Sunday and Monday night are too valuable not to keep. And face it, if the choice ever comes down to ESPN or FOX choosing between the Big Ten/SEC and the NFL then those companies are coughing up blood already.
They’re all directly intertwined and I would think that you, of all people on this forum, would see it. You can’t talk about how critical ESPN is to the SEC’s plans, including a supposed financial subsidization to move schools from the ACC to SEC, without talking about how ESPN and every other network’s costs for the NFL, which already dwarf everything else that they’re paying for, are likely going to rise by 50% or more within the next 12 months. The cable subscriber fees that ESPN receives are *directly* contingent upon them having the NFL - there is nothing else (not the SEC or NBA or anything else) that has that direct contractual and financial impact for the company. So, yes, the NFL has ESPN over a barrel that no one else does. We’re talking about ESPN, Fox, CBS and NBC having to pay a billion dollars or more per year *each* to the NFL just to keep what the rights that they have now above and beyond the billions per year that they’re already paying the NFL… and they truly have no choice. They have to do it.
And to be sure, I’m not a pessimist about the value of top tier college football. I think the Big Ten and SEC will ultimately be fine for now. However, I do believe that there are major risks. The economics of the linear TV networks simply won’t work much longer - declining profits year-over-year combined with rapidly rising costs for the NFL isn’t going to be sustainable. There’s frankly nothing more important for the college sports industry to understand more than what’s happening with NFL rights because they are poised to take literally $4-5 billion per year out of the sports rights system… and this is simply renegotiating current contracts as opposed to going out for bid. The companies coughing up blood isn’t too far away (which investors have known for a long time and why they keep hammering Disney’s stock price at this point).
Believe me - I personally don’t wish any of this is true, but when each major media company is going to have to send a check to the NFL each year that is larger than all of their other sports rights combined after this year, we have to acknowledge the broader implications. Just thinking that this is a pro sports issue that doesn’t impact college sports is the height of naïveté, particularly if so much of the argument is that ESPN will supposedly do “x”. This is the media business - pro sports and college sports are all in the same cost bucket.
The NFL cannot continue to exist without college football. There is no farm league for which they have to pay. College Football is, and will remain, an important part of their revenue plan.
Therefore, all of the anti-trust blathering, which I have had to listen to every time we have had realignment, the unlikely coordination of a Congressional response, and all of the "Oh we must consider the NFL" nonsense goes in one ear and out the other. The NFL has a vested interest in protecting college football as do the gambling houses, and as do the networks. I like the odds that life goes on for college football pretty much like it is with perhaps some tweaking of NIL in terms of narrowing what it can and can't be, but still with no limits.
So, until Chicken Little comes up with a novel concept about how College Football is going to fail, I'll remain a profound skeptic of this line of conversation. And you know what Frank, even if the NFL becomes an issue, which it won't, it will impact Northern College Football markets a lot more than Southern ones. But hey, you guys knock yourselves out with this line of conversation. It's still a month and half before serious football discussion begins, unless we have....another realignment move.
|
|