(07-03-2026 07:50 PM)Carsonpop Wrote: (07-03-2026 09:43 AM)JMUNation Wrote: When we look at a map of the SBC, the membership makes a lot of sense. Adding ECU, S. Florida, Memphis and one other top tier G6 in the region while dropping ULM and Georgia St. would put the SBC at the top of G6 and allow us to split into two 8 team divisions. I like the grouping of schools we have and see a lot of potential for the conference. It will come down to leadership.
ULM isn’t going anywhere, but I understand you JMU folks are so full of yourself, just go on and join the Big Ten like you think you deserve or replace Florida St in ACC, good riddance! If anyone thinks LaTech is ******, just read most JMU responses, never have I seen a fan base as arrogant as most of them….
I am not full of myself nor do I see JMU as the end all be all of college athletics. I have watched college athletics evolve over many decades and want to see the SBC be at the top of the food chain. The rivalries in this conference can grow if a strong membership can be maintained. The fan interest will grow if rivalries are maintained. Programs need to be well funded and have a strong donor base. I have not seen that with ULM and Ga. State is worse. Maybe you can enlighten me. Maybe you can change my mind. I participate in this forum because I want to learn about the ins and outs of the schools in the SBC not because I want to bash the weak ones.
I sincerely like being a part of the SBC. I have lived long enough to watch schools jump from conference to conference and not elevate their program. Fellow state school ODU is a perfect example. Mens basketball at ODU use to be able to go head to head with some of the best teams in the country. Today mens basketball there is as bad as it has ever been. The jumping around of conferences has brought them back to the SBC and has not elevated their athletics to the top of the food chain.
Here is a snapshot of their conference affiliation: Became D1 in 1976 and joined the ECAC South, which changed its name to the CAA in 1985. ODU joined the SBC in 1982 and CAA again in 1990 then CUSA and now SBC again. That’s five conferences in fifty years of D1. For comparison, JMU became D1 in 1976 joining the ECAC South/CAA then moving to the SBC in 2022. Two conferences in its D1 history so JMU is not a school that has jumped around historically.
The rivalries were terrific in the CAA. Unfortunately, it was a mix of schools who played football and many who did not. Many schools came and left over the years because of football. Some schools who didn’t play football moved to conferences they felt would elevate their basketball programs. With the exception of moving from FCS to FBS in football, the change in conference affiliation hasn’t elevated programs(football or basketball). Most are worse off. At best, they are about the same. Many have come back to their original conference partners like La Tech is doing this year.
I would like to see JMU have a long run in the SBC. I am happy to see us back in a conference with ODU(for a third time) plus finally in one with Marshall, Georgia Southern and App State. As ODU has experienced, the grass is rarely greener. You can’t grow rivalries when schools move around constantly. The stability of membership is one of the main reasons why the SEC and Big 10 are at the top of the food chain.
JMU hasn’t moved conferences historically so you guys might be stuck with us and what you perceive as our arrogance. I personally don’t believe constantly switching conferences is the way to elevate a program. We left the CAA because we moved to FBS. ECU and Navy left for football too. ODU left the CAA the second time because of FBS.
Sorry for the long post but I wanted to enlighten our new conference partners on our history in hopes that you will see us as a long term member not a program stopping by for a cup of coffee. There will always be posturing of Presidents but a move won’t take place unless the money warrants it. The SBC has so much potential. The regional footprint is perfect for elevating rivalries and rivalries are what makes games meaningful.