Ned Low
Heisman

Posts: 6,476
Joined: Nov 2010
Reputation: 561
I Root For: ECU
Location: Durham, NC
|
RE: Sunbelt Seeking To Increase Exit Fees
(06-23-2026 07:39 PM)Nugget49er Wrote: (06-23-2026 04:03 PM)Ned Low Wrote: (06-23-2026 03:32 PM)Nugget49er Wrote: (06-23-2026 12:06 PM)Ned Low Wrote: (06-23-2026 09:25 AM)Nugget49er Wrote: JMU seems like a fine program, but I have to agree with several here that it just doesn't fit the AC's metro model. Additionally, Ned Low seems like a rational guy, so it doesn't surprise me that, as an ECU fan, he would support the idea that we should ignore location/population.
As for my friends in the hills of NC, App fans are feeling down in the dumps these days about the trajectory of their football program. Like most of us, NIL and the Transfer Portal are screwing with their program when it comes to acquiring and keeping players and coaches. The days of selling history and tradition are sadly over, with players only caring about getting the bag and leasing a Range Rover. App cut other sports a few years ago to keep football funding as high as they could, but where do they go now? As a medium-sized teachers' college in the middle of nowhere their options will be limited. There is a whole thread on their message board discussing this.
![[Image: image.png?ex=6a3b61b7&is=6a3a103...eight=1168]](https://media.discordapp.net/attachments/813823064533368923/1516847121406492772/image.png?ex=6a3b61b7&is=6a3a1037&hm=4be81c6051e754573d5ab1d16428d8bb993d10b25f0d8388e64ab61732845edf&=&format=webp&quality=lossless&width=2784&height=1168)
Thank for the compliment and yes, I try to be rational at all times. I have been rational when I've supported the idea that JMU and APP should be added as well.
Why should they be added?
Competativeness: Both programs have been competative in the recent past and will be so again in the future, at least on par with the majority of American programs.
Money: Both programs travel well. That means higher ticket sales. I say this with all due respect but the fact is that Charlotte, Temple, Rice, FAU and UAB travel poorly. They don't sell tickets.
There's a reason that the SEC still leads in per-school revenue generation when compared to B10 members: fans of opposing teams buy tickets. More visting fans equals more money, stronger local economies and more fan engagement. It's more fun. People recognize this and want to participate, which means that more tickets are sold to your fanbase as well.
I would not be supportive of New Mexico as a candidate for this very reason: historically, their fans have not cared about football (although based on what I've seen that could be changing). Air Force would sell tickets based on brand alone. JMU and App would BRING fans.
App and JMU would add no less in terms of media revenue than other candidates would. They would absolutely sell more tickets.
I get why some Charlotte fans would not want App in particular. However, I think your minds would change when you saw the revenues generated by either member.
There is a very good chance that the American will be left untouched by this next round of realignment. I think that our conference needs to plan for this by making ourselves as competative and interesting as possible. This can be accomplished while generating as much money as possible for all of our members.
If the American expands in the future (which I think it will), the best programs need to be added.
Here's the thing: Charlotte plays App in multiple sports every year, and we expect that to continue. Adding them to the AC gets us nothing really. I assume ECU also plays them pretty often, so again, no big gain. I doubt most of the rest of our conference would ever see many traveling 'Neers because of distance and costs. My wife is a retired teacher, and while there is no more noble profession, fans who rely on teaching salaries are not often taking overnight trips to away games, especially if they need airfare to get there. App is predominantly a teachers' college, and many of their fans already do half a dozen away games every year, just driving to Boone to see their team, because they all work in Charlotte, Greensboro/Winston-Salem/High Point, or Raleigh/Durham because that's where the jobs are.
There isn't anything wrong with App, I just don't buy into the hype that they move the needle. Apparently, no other conferences do either, because they had 30 pretty good years of football until recently, and nobody took them but the Sun Belt.
I look at things this way: there are no "perfect" additions. If we're discussing expansion now, there are only so many possibilties.
That being said, who would you expand with and why?
I completely agree that there are no perfect additions, and if the AC (I really like AAC better) lost one, maybe two teams, our best move might be to stay where we are. ESPN will tell us what we are actually going to do.
Looking at my crystal ball, I think the end state will be the SEC and B1G picking up the teams they want from the ACC and Big 12 (Notre Dame, UNC-CH, Clemson, UVA, FSU, GA Tech, Miami, and Kansas), and casting off the teams they don't want (Rutgers, Northwestern, Vanderbilt, Purdue, and Mississippi State). This is when the Super 2 becomes its own league.
After this happens, Duke will wonder what the hell just happened and go to the Big East (football will need some place to play). The leftovers from the ACC and Big 12 will probably create a new merged conference, factoring in quality and location, but leave out quite a few of their current members, who will look to the PAC-12 and AAC for a home.
The new AAC/Big 12 combo conference may be the best of the P6, now P7, but their media dollars are going to be cut substantially, which means the coaching contracts, NIL deals, and facility bonds are going to bury them. I would expect that to result in equilibrium and the PAC-12, AAC, and New Conference to even out in a couple of quick years.
So, to answer your question, I think the AAC doesn't need to raid the Sun Belt because we are going to get schools we didn't expect, and that aren't happy to be with us. Just more joy in college sports.
I don't think that your prediction will come to fruitition but appreciate the answer.
I don't see realignment being this tumultuous. I think that it will be rather boring, at least when compared to the prediction you've made.
|
|