RE: Why did not WOSU go the Indy route?
Money, scheduling, recruiting.
The Pac-12 held a lot of money. Disbanding it, which is what going independent would have done, meant returning assets to the other ten departing schools. That would have meant the loss of $200M ($100M of that from the expiring Rose Bowl contract) used to cushion the last two years of transition from autonomy to "group of" for the two schools.
Scheduling as an independent proved extremely expensive, as neither school is much of a draw. They were shelling out something like $1.25M per home game. It would have been worse if they walked away from Pac-12 Enterprises (Pac-12 Networks) which they needed to be able to produce games to have any media coverage.
They could have probably joined the WCC as full members, except football and Oregon State baseball (Gonzaga likely would have stayed put, and I doubt SU or DU would have been invited). This would have required a one time entry fee, but eliminated to associate fees and given them access to NCAA credits, although they would have had to surrender a much larger amount of credits in the legacy Pac-12. This would no doubt have been the logical path had football independence been chosen.
But that is unlikely for Washington State who are hemorrhaging cash to this day, would have almost certainly joined the Mountain West in all sports. They almost did so, which probably triggered the Pac-12 to relaunch prematurely before the 7th and 8th schools were lined up and a media partner agreement was in place. (I am convinced the "coup" attempt against the MWC was triggered early before any negotiations with media companies like CBS, FOX or ESPN had been explored, before any bowl games had been secured, and before any negotiations with Memphis had been done, and before even UNLV had been convinced --which they never were-- was because WSU was about to bail out of the project). Oregon State alone could not have pulled off football independence on their own.
The choices were really "merge" with the MWC (under the Pac-12 banner) or relaunch the Pac-12. Oregon State's Matt Barnes and San Diego State's AD and President led the charge for the latter giving us what we have today.
Had they chosen the merger path, very likely you have had a Pac-12 of 14 members in football (Hawaii football only and still in the Big West) and 14 in Basketball (Gonzaga almost certainly still would have joined). All other additions by both conferences would not have happened (no GCU, NIU, UTEP, NDSU, UC Davis or Texas State). Likely neither Gould (vetoed by the MWC schools) nor Navarez (vetoed by OSU, WSU, SDSU) would be the commissioner.
But I think the path we went down happened because Oregon State and San Deigo State are desperate to get into A4 and they felt they could control their destiny by selecting the membership. Even possibly force inclusion in the A4 as a 5th conference, and also maintain the premier bowls and get "half" A4 media revenues. None of that proved true, as the new model was coming into place and they were working under the assumptions of the old model.
So here we are.
|