![]() |
|
Why did not WOSU go the Indy route? - Printable Version +- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com) +-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html) +--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html) +---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html) +---- Thread: Why did not WOSU go the Indy route? (/thread-1029781.html) Pages: 1 2 |
Why did not WOSU go the Indy route? - Garrettabc - 06-21-2026 08:57 AM I'm sure it's more work, but could not they have scheduled football, basketball and Olympic sports games with their former PAC buddies, the MWC and others? RE: Why did not WOSU go the Indy route? - PlayBall! - 06-21-2026 09:54 AM Because the PAC still had value. Not as much of it left, though, if they had not just merged with the MW instead of paying all those lawyers, etc. RE: Why did not WOSU go the Indy route? - Garden_KC - 06-21-2026 10:08 AM Thankfully not for UC-Davis, Grand Canyon, UTEP, North Dakota St. & Northern Illinois. RE: Why did not WOSU go the Indy route? - Garrettabc - 06-21-2026 10:16 AM (06-21-2026 09:54 AM)PlayBall! Wrote: Because the PAC still had value. Not as much of it left, though, if they had not just merged with the MW instead of paying all those lawyers, etc. They could have continued to call themselves the PAC2 or whatever, correct? RE: Why did not WOSU go the Indy route? - Usajags - 06-21-2026 10:37 AM The PAC had to exist for them to collect the $250 mil in exit fees from all the other schools. If you want to know why they didn’t join the MW of go Indy, that is why. RE: Why did not WOSU go the Indy route? - chargeradio - 06-21-2026 10:46 AM (06-21-2026 10:37 AM)Usajags Wrote: The PAC had to exist for them to collect the $250 mil in exit fees from all the other schools. If you want to know why they didn’t join the MW of go Indy, that is why.The Pac-12 could have invited the entire Mountain West, but the Pac-12 had to be the surviving entity to collect the monies left behind by the departing ten schools. The moment you try to cut a Wyoming or San Jose State loose, the Pac-12 triggered the poaching fees that led to the legal battle (which I guess is still technically ongoing, but about to wrap up). RE: Why did not WOSU go the Indy route? - Garrettabc - 06-21-2026 11:14 AM (06-21-2026 10:37 AM)Usajags Wrote: The PAC had to exist for them to collect the $250 mil in exit fees from all the other schools. If you want to know why they didn’t join the MW of go Indy, that is why. Right, but they could have been a conference of 2 or even applied for a waiver, correct? RE: Why did not WOSU go the Indy route? - UIWElite2 - 06-21-2026 11:25 AM (06-21-2026 11:14 AM)Garrettabc Wrote:(06-21-2026 10:37 AM)Usajags Wrote: The PAC had to exist for them to collect the $250 mil in exit fees from all the other schools. If you want to know why they didn’t join the MW of go Indy, that is why. They had 2 years to get compliant. No, they could not have been a conference of two, and the Pac 12 didn’t have autobids in 2024-25 and 2025-26. At least in major sports. RE: Why did not WOSU go the Indy route? - SoCalBobcat78 - 06-21-2026 11:41 AM (06-21-2026 08:57 AM)Garrettabc Wrote: I'm sure it's more work, but could not they have scheduled football, basketball and Olympic sports games with their former PAC buddies, the MWC and others? Are you suggesting that they should have gone independent in all sports or just football? The other thing, besides the hundreds of millions of dollars they would lose, who is going to fly up to Corvalis and Pullman to play an independent OSU and an independent WSU? RE: Why did not WOSU go the Indy route? - Garrettabc - 06-21-2026 11:56 AM (06-21-2026 11:41 AM)SoCalBobcat78 Wrote:(06-21-2026 08:57 AM)Garrettabc Wrote: I'm sure it's more work, but could not they have scheduled football, basketball and Olympic sports games with their former PAC buddies, the MWC and others? All sports. Are you saying that the only way anyone would play them is if others just had to? RE: Why did not WOSU go the Indy route? - Stugray2 - 06-21-2026 12:16 PM Money, scheduling, recruiting. The Pac-12 held a lot of money. Disbanding it, which is what going independent would have done, meant returning assets to the other ten departing schools. That would have meant the loss of $200M ($100M of that from the expiring Rose Bowl contract) used to cushion the last two years of transition from autonomy to "group of" for the two schools. Scheduling as an independent proved extremely expensive, as neither school is much of a draw. They were shelling out something like $1.25M per home game. It would have been worse if they walked away from Pac-12 Enterprises (Pac-12 Networks) which they needed to be able to produce games to have any media coverage. They could have probably joined the WCC as full members, except football and Oregon State baseball (Gonzaga likely would have stayed put, and I doubt SU or DU would have been invited). This would have required a one time entry fee, but eliminated to associate fees and given them access to NCAA credits, although they would have had to surrender a much larger amount of credits in the legacy Pac-12. This would no doubt have been the logical path had football independence been chosen. But that is unlikely for Washington State who are hemorrhaging cash to this day, would have almost certainly joined the Mountain West in all sports. They almost did so, which probably triggered the Pac-12 to relaunch prematurely before the 7th and 8th schools were lined up and a media partner agreement was in place. (I am convinced the "coup" attempt against the MWC was triggered early before any negotiations with media companies like CBS, FOX or ESPN had been explored, before any bowl games had been secured, and before any negotiations with Memphis had been done, and before even UNLV had been convinced --which they never were-- was because WSU was about to bail out of the project). Oregon State alone could not have pulled off football independence on their own. The choices were really "merge" with the MWC (under the Pac-12 banner) or relaunch the Pac-12. Oregon State's Matt Barnes and San Diego State's AD and President led the charge for the latter giving us what we have today. Had they chosen the merger path, very likely you have had a Pac-12 of 14 members in football (Hawaii football only and still in the Big West) and 14 in Basketball (Gonzaga almost certainly still would have joined). All other additions by both conferences would not have happened (no GCU, NIU, UTEP, NDSU, UC Davis or Texas State). Likely neither Gould (vetoed by the MWC schools) nor Navarez (vetoed by OSU, WSU, SDSU) would be the commissioner. But I think the path we went down happened because Oregon State and San Deigo State are desperate to get into A4 and they felt they could control their destiny by selecting the membership. Even possibly force inclusion in the A4 as a 5th conference, and also maintain the premier bowls and get "half" A4 media revenues. None of that proved true, as the new model was coming into place and they were working under the assumptions of the old model. So here we are. RE: Why did not WOSU go the Indy route? - SoCalBobcat78 - 06-21-2026 12:39 PM (06-21-2026 11:56 AM)Garrettabc Wrote:(06-21-2026 11:41 AM)SoCalBobcat78 Wrote:(06-21-2026 08:57 AM)Garrettabc Wrote: I'm sure it's more work, but could not they have scheduled football, basketball and Olympic sports games with their former PAC buddies, the MWC and others? A school has to be in a conference for the auto-bid that comes with being a member of an NCAA conference for Olympic sports. Scheduling is so much easier in a conference. The other ten Pac-12 schools that left the conference wanted Oregon State and Washington State to go independent, so they could keep all of the basketball tournament units to themselves. All of the other conference money as well. The University of Idaho dropped down to the Big Sky and FCS rather than attempt another run as an independent. Moscow, Idaho, where the University of Idaho is located, is just seven miles from Pullman, Washington, where WSU is located. In these locations you need to be in a conference. Only Notre Dame can pull off an independent schedule in football, and they need the ACC to schedule games. Oregon State went independent in baseball the past two years and it was rough scheduling and probably cost them the chance to host a regional site for baseball this season. I would also add that besides the $250 million that was at stake keeping the Pac-12 alive, they will also be able to utilize the Pac-12 Enterprises with a conference. Going forward, they were able to negotiate an additional $1.8 million annually for the next three seasons for CFP revenue or a total of $5.4 million for three years. As an independent, that was never going to happen. RE: Why did not WOSU go the Indy route? - PicksUp - 06-21-2026 01:01 PM I do not think they would have ever seriously considered independence in Olympic Sports. RE: Why did not WOSU go the Indy route? - HawaiiMongoose - 06-21-2026 01:48 PM WOSU could have distributed all of the settlement money paid by the departing Pac members to themselves, negotiated a reverse merger with the WCC to give their Olympic sports a secure home, and committed to football independence. That would have removed any threat to the MWC, opening the door to a long-term scheduling agreement to give them each a few late-season football games against top MWC teams, while otherwise loading up their football schedules with P4 opponents. That strategy would have done far more to position them to eventually return to a power conference than the half-baked and enormously expensive Pac rebuild they chose to pursue. RE: Why did not WOSU go the Indy route? - UTEPDallas - 06-21-2026 01:55 PM Independence was never an option for the two left behind schools especially Wazzu. Based on its location, an independent Wazzu would inevitably met the fate of its neighbor Idaho. That’s the last thing the Wazzu decision makers wanted to face. RE: Why did not WOSU go the Indy route? - AssKickingChicken - 06-21-2026 01:56 PM OSU was an independent in baseball the last two seasons. RE: Why did not WOSU go the Indy route? - The Beaver - 06-21-2026 02:01 PM There are all sorts of football reasons not to do it but I'll just throw out NCAA basketball credits and say that that alone is reason enough. RE: Why did not WOSU go the Indy route? - PicksUp - 06-21-2026 02:31 PM BYU was able to sort of pull off football independence from 2011-2022. They played 55 total games vs the P5. That is an average of 4.5 per year. They had an easier time scheduling with annual games vs Boise State, Utah State and Utah. What does Washington State have, Washington and Oregon State every year? Not sure how old PAC schools would be willing to play them. I only see a couple games vs Arizona and Washington in future schedules. They could try to load non-conference with P4 schools even now in the MW. RE: Why did not WOSU go the Indy route? - UTEPDallas - 06-21-2026 03:10 PM (06-21-2026 02:31 PM)PicksUp Wrote: BYU was able to sort of pull off football independence from 2011-2022. They played 55 total games vs the P5. That is an average of 4.5 per year. They had an easier time scheduling with annual games vs Boise State, Utah State and Utah. What does Washington State have, Washington and Oregon State every year? Not sure how old PAC schools would be willing to play them. I only see a couple games vs Arizona and Washington in future schedules. They could try to load non-conference with P4 schools even now in the MW. I can see Oregon State being able to schedule some P4 schools in the future but not Washington State. Their remote location is a dealbreaker for most P4 schools. I can see schools like Nevada, Wyoming and North Dakota State on future schedules, even UTEP UNM and NMSU but I don’t see the appeal if you’re a C-USA, AAC or Sun Belt school. RE: Why did not WOSU go the Indy route? - The Beaver - 06-21-2026 03:28 PM (06-21-2026 03:10 PM)UTEPDallas Wrote:They can do one off away games, just like other G6 teams. There is no keeping power stature for them, if they ever actually had it to begin with.(06-21-2026 02:31 PM)PicksUp Wrote: BYU was able to sort of pull off football independence from 2011-2022. They played 55 total games vs the P5. That is an average of 4.5 per year. They had an easier time scheduling with annual games vs Boise State, Utah State and Utah. What does Washington State have, Washington and Oregon State every year? Not sure how old PAC schools would be willing to play them. I only see a couple games vs Arizona and Washington in future schedules. They could try to load non-conference with P4 schools even now in the MW. |