Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
Hypothetical for Cal
Author Message
bryanw1995 Online
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,945
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #41
RE: Hypothetical for Cal
(06-17-2026 04:44 AM)schmolik Wrote:  The Big Ten didn't just take USC, they also took UCLA.

The Big Ten didn't just take Oregon, they also took Washington.

Why would they just take Stanford and not Cal?

And why is it assumed Stanford is the better Bay Area school anyway? One's the flagship state school in the most populous state in the country and one's a snotty private school. It's not like the Big Ten doesn't have one (or two) already. And it's not like Stanford is blowing Cal away in sports these days.

I'll bite.

Stanford is Harvard academically and Texas athletically in everything but football. Cal is a homeless man's UCLA.

Stanford can get TV ratings when their team is good, as it was in the 2010s:

https://sicem365.com/s/13048/how-many-vi...am-attract

Check out those numbers. In the top 32 games average of all Pac 12 (non CCG) games for each school from 2013-2021, Stanford was a very strong #3:

USC: 2.87m avg
Oregon: 2.85m avg
Stanford: 2.66m avg
6 others ranging from 2.41m down to 1.42m
Cal: 1.37m avg

UCLA is the Athletic Flagship of California, at least in the sports that people care about and open their wallets for. Cal Berkeley, well, it was ahead of only 4 P5 schools from 2013-2021 in tv ratings.

It definitely doesn't hurt that Stanford has a longstanding rivalry with ND. It might not help much, but that's the type of school that Stanford is measured against. Cal is more like a West Coast version of UVA, top of the heap in Academics but not able to carry their own weight financially in the P2.

Advantage: Stanford
(This post was last modified: 06-17-2026 09:24 AM by bryanw1995.)
06-17-2026 08:29 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Online
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,945
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #42
RE: Hypothetical for Cal
(06-17-2026 06:20 AM)Sitting bull Wrote:  
(06-16-2026 11:51 AM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  Could Cal conceivably operate as an independent if Stanford, USC, and UCLA all committed to annual series?

I think they’d have no problems getting lengthy schedule deals with San Diego St, Fresno State, SJSU, Sac St, and potentially FBS UC Davis.

Filling out the rest of the schedule at that point would be pretty easy or at least manageable l.

I don’t think so. Given their football history and standing within academic circles, a steady diet of G6 opponents, even if regional, wouldn’t seem to hold much interest in Berkeley. At that point, I think Cal would be just fine with Ivy League opponents and a few past rivals, if that were even an option (probably not).

The ACC is not a bad home for the Bears in terms of associations other than the distance on most. The demise of the PAC 12 has really set back west coast FBS football. Everyone seems to have splintered in different directions, none of which make much sense.

People thought that the demise of the SWC would be damaging to Texas (State) football, but it's been quite the opposite. I suspect that the same will hold true in California. The 4 former Pac members will all up their football support, and new programs will also rise in the coming decades. What happens in Evanston, Columbus, Happy Valley, Miami, Atlanta, Virginia and the Research Triangle matters now to people in California, and that will likely be a very good thing for football in the State. It would actually be even better if they had a school in the Big 12 and SEC, too, though I'm not sure how likely either of those is today.
06-17-2026 08:35 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
USF_Bullsharks Offline
Special Teams
*

Posts: 936
Joined: May 2025
Reputation: 287
I Root For: USF
Location:
Post: #43
RE: Hypothetical for Cal
(06-17-2026 08:29 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(06-17-2026 04:44 AM)schmolik Wrote:  The Big Ten didn't just take USC, they also took UCLA.

The Big Ten didn't just take Oregon, they also took Washington.

Why would they just take Stanford and not Cal?

And why is it assumed Stanford is the better Bay Area school anyway? One's the flagship state school in the most populous state in the country and one's a snotty private school. It's not like the Big Ten doesn't have one (or two) already. And it's not like Stanford is blowing Cal away in sports these days.

I'll bite.

Stanford is Harvard academically and Texas athletically in everything but football. Cal is a homeless man's UCLA.

Stanford can get TV ratings when their team is good, as it was in the 2010s:

https://sicem365.com/s/13048/how-many-vi...am-attract

Chick out those numbers. In the top 32 games average of all Pac 12 (non CCG) games for each school from 2013-2021, Stanford was a very strong #3:

USC: 2.87m avg
Oregon: 2.85m avg
Stanford: 2.66m avg
6 others ranging from 2.41m down to 1.42m
Cal: 1.37m avg

UCLA is the Athletic Flagship of California, at least in the sports that people care about and open their wallets for. Cal Berkeley, well, it was ahead of only 4 P5 schools from 2013-2021 in tv ratings.

It definitely doesn't hurt that Stanford has a longstanding rivalry with ND. It might not help much, but that's the type of school that Stanford is measured against. Cal is more like a West Coast version of UVA, top of the heap in Academics but not able to carry their own weight financially in the P2.

Advantage: Stanford

Too add: Stanford's alumni. Cal is no slouch for alum status, and would probably be at the very top or near the top of wealthiest alumni in the B1G - but Stanford is silicon valley. Only counting Stanford's dropouts-turned-tech-founders would be richer than all of the B1G alumni combined. The networking, hiring, and political pull of Stanford-related individuals is top 3 in the country on par with Harvard and UPenn/Yale.

That said, I think if you take one you take both. But Stanford as an entity is head and shoulders above every school in the country except for maybe 1 or two schools.
06-17-2026 09:00 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
goofus Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,718
Joined: May 2013
Reputation: 304
I Root For: Iowa
Location: chicago suburbs
Post: #44
RE: Hypothetical for Cal
If you start with the assumption that Flor St, Miami, UNC and either Clemson or Virginia are invited to the P2 in the next expansion, it might make sense for the ACC and Big 12 to just declare a M2 truce and try to split the 2 M2 conferences geographicly.

ACC adds Cincy, WV, UCF, USF and UConn.

Big 12 adds Cal, Stan and SanDiego St.

New ACC (16/17)
NCSU, Duke, Wake, GT, SMU,
VT, Lou, Pitt, Cuse, BC,
Cincy, WV, UCF, USF, UConn,
Va or Clem,
ND-non football

New Big 12 (16)
Hou, Bay, TCU, TT,
Ok St, Kan, Kan St, Iowa St,
Col, Utah, Ariz, Ariz St, BYU
Cal, Stan, San Diego St

Of course it won't happen because of reasons already stated.
(This post was last modified: 06-17-2026 11:11 AM by goofus.)
06-17-2026 09:21 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
USF_Bullsharks Offline
Special Teams
*

Posts: 936
Joined: May 2025
Reputation: 287
I Root For: USF
Location:
Post: #45
RE: Hypothetical for Cal
(06-17-2026 09:21 AM)goofus Wrote:  If you start with the assumption that Flor St, Miami, UNC and either Clemson or Virginia are invited to the P2 in the next expansion, it might make sense for the ACC and Big 12 to just declare a M2 truce and try to split the 2 M2 conferences geographicly.

ACC adds Cincy, WV, UCF, USF and UConn.

Big 12 adds Cal, Stan and SanDiego St.

New ACC (16/17)
NCSU, Duke, Wake, GT, SMU,
VT, Lou, Pitt, Cuse, BC,
Cincy, WV, UCF, USF, UConn,
Va or Clem,
ND-non football

New Big 12 (16)
Hou, Bay, TCU, TT,
Ok St, Kan, Kan St, Iowa St,
Col, Utah, Ariz, Ariz St,
Cal, Stan,
BYU, San Diego St

Of course it won't happen because of reasons already stated.

Also do not think this would happen, but when looking at those conferences it sure makes a lot of sense. Wonder if ND would stay with it's ACC affiliation in that universe though.
06-17-2026 09:27 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Online
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,945
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #46
RE: Hypothetical for Cal
(06-17-2026 09:21 AM)goofus Wrote:  If you start with the assumption that Flor St, Miami, UNC and either Clemson or Virginia are invited to the P2 in the next expansion, it might make sense for the ACC and Big 12 to just declare a M2 truce and try to split the 2 M2 conferences geographicly.

ACC adds Cincy, WV, UCF, USF and UConn.

Big 12 adds Cal, Stan and SanDiego St.

New ACC (16/17)
NCSU, Duke, Wake, GT, SMU,
VT, Lou, Pitt, Cuse, BC,
Cincy, WV, UCF, USF, UConn,
Va or Clem,
ND-non football

New Big 12 (16)
Hou, Bay, TCU, TT,
Ok St, Kan, Kan St, Iowa St,
Col, Utah, Ariz, Ariz St,
Cal, Stan,
BYU, San Diego St

Of course it won't happen because of reasons already stated.

I don't think it would happen simply because it wouldn't be what's best for the ACC. The ACC would be better off with the duo of Cal and Stanford than with the trio of Cincinnati, WV and UConn. Why involve SDSU at all? It's possible that the Big 12 would look at SDSU as a UCF replacement in your scenario, though it's hard to imagine UCF joining a neutered ACC OR the Big 12 choosing SDSU over Memphis and their $200m++ FedEx cash infusion.

I suppose that it could happen if the ACC and Big 12 schools on your list clamored to switch places, but it's really hard to see any of them wanting to change in your hypothetical. Travel sucks, but status is more important than some student-athletes losing some sleep, according to the actions of University admins all over the country.
06-17-2026 09:42 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Frank the Tank Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 23,551
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3294
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
Post: #47
RE: Hypothetical for Cal
(06-17-2026 08:19 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(06-16-2026 05:30 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  If I were to wager, I think there’s a higher chance of either both Stanford and Cal ending up in the Big Ten or neither of them. Having only one of them end up in the Big Ten is unlikely.

I will reiterate what I’ve stated before that I don’t believe that Cal would willingly join a conference that has BYU and, to a lesser extent, Baylor due to core political and ideological reasons. The only way that they join the Big 12 is a total collapse of the ACC where the Big 12 is the absolute last life raft to retaining power conference status. Cal would never join the Big 12 proactively, though.

I guess that's why UCLA is in the B1G and Cal was stuck begging the ACC for any life raft at all after everyone but Stanford left them behind in 2023, huh? Perhaps you're right, though I think it more likely that the old Cal leadership felt as you do, while the new Cal leadership is going to ruthlessly act in it's own Athletic self-interest to gain entry to the B1G. If that means remaining in the ACC, going independent, joining their old Pac-mates in the Big 12, rejoining the Pac 12 even...whatever they deem to be the best move to ultimately get them into the B1G. And BYU or Baylor? If Cal was so determined to keep away from those guys, they'd have dropped fb to FCS and they'd still have their Olympics in the Pac.

Like I’ve said - if it was a matter of pure survival (“survival” in this case meaning power conference status), any school will do what it needs to do to retain it.

However, an ACC that still has, say, Georgia Tech, Wake Forest, Virginia Tech, SMU, Syracuse, Boston College and others that are more institutionally aligned with Cal is still likely going to be considered a power league (albeit weaker) and I completely believe that Cal would rather stay in that league compared to the Big 12. This is *Berkeley* we are talking about - it is above and beyond any other place on Earth in terms of campus activism. Cal and, for that matter, Stanford are totally unique institutions in the realm of P4 sports (and I mean that in a good way) - they can’t even be compared to, say, UCLA and Duke that are similar peers. Cal is the very best public university in the country academically with a very entrenched culture and Stanford is arguably the very best university in the country overall. So, yes, they have different standards for themselves because they are looked at as symbols and leaders for greater academia in a way that even the schools a few spots lower than them in the rankings aren’t looked at. They are the elite of the elite of the elite (and they want their athletics to reflect that, as well, so it’s not about downgrading to FCS or lower level leagues, either).
06-17-2026 10:01 AM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Frank the Tank Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 23,551
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3294
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
Post: #48
RE: Hypothetical for Cal
(06-17-2026 09:00 AM)USF_Bullsharks Wrote:  
(06-17-2026 08:29 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(06-17-2026 04:44 AM)schmolik Wrote:  The Big Ten didn't just take USC, they also took UCLA.

The Big Ten didn't just take Oregon, they also took Washington.

Why would they just take Stanford and not Cal?

And why is it assumed Stanford is the better Bay Area school anyway? One's the flagship state school in the most populous state in the country and one's a snotty private school. It's not like the Big Ten doesn't have one (or two) already. And it's not like Stanford is blowing Cal away in sports these days.

I'll bite.

Stanford is Harvard academically and Texas athletically in everything but football. Cal is a homeless man's UCLA.

Stanford can get TV ratings when their team is good, as it was in the 2010s:

https://sicem365.com/s/13048/how-many-vi...am-attract

Chick out those numbers. In the top 32 games average of all Pac 12 (non CCG) games for each school from 2013-2021, Stanford was a very strong #3:

USC: 2.87m avg
Oregon: 2.85m avg
Stanford: 2.66m avg
6 others ranging from 2.41m down to 1.42m
Cal: 1.37m avg

UCLA is the Athletic Flagship of California, at least in the sports that people care about and open their wallets for. Cal Berkeley, well, it was ahead of only 4 P5 schools from 2013-2021 in tv ratings.

It definitely doesn't hurt that Stanford has a longstanding rivalry with ND. It might not help much, but that's the type of school that Stanford is measured against. Cal is more like a West Coast version of UVA, top of the heap in Academics but not able to carry their own weight financially in the P2.

Advantage: Stanford

Too add: Stanford's alumni. Cal is no slouch for alum status, and would probably be at the very top or near the top of wealthiest alumni in the B1G - but Stanford is silicon valley. Only counting Stanford's dropouts-turned-tech-founders would be richer than all of the B1G alumni combined. The networking, hiring, and political pull of Stanford-related individuals is top 3 in the country on par with Harvard and UPenn/Yale.

That said, I think if you take one you take both. But Stanford as an entity is head and shoulders above every school in the country except for maybe 1 or two schools.

Among those Stanford’s alums is Phil Knight, too (who got his MBA there). He is also one of the largest donors to Stanford even taking into consideration that Stanford has an insanely wealthy alumni base. The donations may not be as flashy as the donations to Oregon, but they’re similarly large in scale.

The Stanford athletic department is also a machine for turning out Olympians (where they produce more Olympic medalists in a typical Summer Olympics than all of a handful of entire countries on the whole planet). Now, we can debate whether that’s meaningful in conference realignment that’s focused on football with a touch of men’s basketball, but it can’t be emphasized enough that Stanford is NOT an Ivy-like “we want good athletes that are really smart” athletic department, but rather truly getting the very best pure elite of the elite athletes (regardless of academics) across all Olympic sports and, as a result, needs competition that aligns with that top level. This isn’t Harvard - the Stanford objective is to create Olympians and national/world champions across their sports portfolio in a way that no other school does.
(This post was last modified: 06-17-2026 10:12 AM by Frank the Tank.)
06-17-2026 10:11 AM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Wahoowa84 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,436
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 1176
I Root For: UVa
Location:
Post: #49
RE: Hypothetical for Cal
(06-17-2026 08:29 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(06-17-2026 04:44 AM)schmolik Wrote:  The Big Ten didn't just take USC, they also took UCLA.

The Big Ten didn't just take Oregon, they also took Washington.

Why would they just take Stanford and not Cal?

And why is it assumed Stanford is the better Bay Area school anyway? One's the flagship state school in the most populous state in the country and one's a snotty private school. It's not like the Big Ten doesn't have one (or two) already. And it's not like Stanford is blowing Cal away in sports these days.

I'll bite.

Stanford is Harvard academically and Texas athletically in everything but football. Cal is a homeless man's UCLA.

Stanford can get TV ratings when their team is good, as it was in the 2010s:

https://sicem365.com/s/13048/how-many-vi...am-attract

Check out those numbers. In the top 32 games average of all Pac 12 (non CCG) games for each school from 2013-2021, Stanford was a very strong #3:

USC: 2.87m avg
Oregon: 2.85m avg
Stanford: 2.66m avg
6 others ranging from 2.41m down to 1.42m
Cal: 1.37m avg

UCLA is the Athletic Flagship of California, at least in the sports that people care about and open their wallets for. Cal Berkeley, well, it was ahead of only 4 P5 schools from 2013-2021 in tv ratings.

It definitely doesn't hurt that Stanford has a longstanding rivalry with ND. It might not help much, but that's the type of school that Stanford is measured against. Cal is more like a West Coast version of UVA, top of the heap in Academics but not able to carry their own weight financially in the P2.

Advantage: Stanford

On the flip side, Cal is actually adapting to the new era of athlete empowerment.

Their football recruiting is rebounding well. In the 2027 class, they’re #20 in latest 247Sports rankings, versus #50+ for Stanford. After Fernando Mendoza graduated and left for Indiana, they promptly flipped (from Oregon no less) the highly touted freshman Hawaiian QB. As a public university, they’ve also always been more accommodating towards transfers (Aaron Rodgers ??).

Per EADA reporting, athletic department expenditures are being maintained at comparable levels to UCLA (both were at $173M in FY2024-25). Cal already spent hundreds of millions to upgrade their football stadium…their leaders are committed to maintaining football at an elite competitive status. There’s a lot of athletic talent in the region and Cal has a lot of compelling attributes.

Finally, Cal is a rivalry team to the west coast contingent. Cal is not only Stanford’s main rival, it’s also USC’s most frequent football opponent (more games than against UCLA or Notre Dame). It’s UCLA’s second most frequent opponent, Washington’s third most frequent opponent, and in Oregon’s top five. College football thrives on rivalries…the value of all Pacific teams benefits from their inclusion.

If the B1G decides to expand with Stanford, then Cal is likely to be its partner.
06-17-2026 10:41 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
AztecEmpire Online
1st String
*

Posts: 1,079
Joined: May 2020
Reputation: 105
I Root For: SDSU
Location:
Post: #50
RE: Hypothetical for Cal
(06-17-2026 09:21 AM)goofus Wrote:  If you start with the assumption that Flor St, Miami, UNC and either Clemson or Virginia are invited to the P2 in the next expansion, it might make sense for the ACC and Big 12 to just declare a M2 truce and try to split the 2 M2 conferences geographicly.

ACC adds Cincy, WV, UCF, USF and UConn.

Big 12 adds Cal, Stan and SanDiego St.

New ACC (16/17)
NCSU, Duke, Wake, GT, SMU,
VT, Lou, Pitt, Cuse, BC,
Cincy, WV, UCF, USF, UConn,
Va or Clem,
ND-non football

New Big 12 (16)
Hou, Bay, TCU, TT,
Ok St, Kan, Kan St, Iowa St,
Col, Utah, Ariz, Ariz St, BYU
Cal, Stan, San Diego St

Of course it won't happen because of reasons already stated.

Memphis?
06-17-2026 11:31 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Fighting Muskie Offline
Senior Chief Realignmentologist
*

Posts: 15,080
Joined: Sep 2016
Reputation: 1214
I Root For: Bishop Sycamore
Location: Secret Lair
Post: #51
RE: Hypothetical for Cal
The problem with Cal is that folks on the West Coast don’t follow college sports on a per capita basis anywhere near the way they do in the South and the Midwest. You’re blue collar folks are following pro sports teams and don’t really have any strong connections to elite academic institutions like Cal, Stanford, Cal, and maybe to a lesser extent Washington, Colorado, Arizona, and Arizona State. (USC seems to be able to maintain a t-shirt fan basis when their good, but even then, there’s some truth behind the nickname University of Spoiled Children — the kids going to USC/Cal/Stanford/UCLA aren’t your average California teenagers, they come from money and/or out-of-state. )

I think that among the 4 California schools, Cal struggles the most with athletic support because in addition to the aforementioned reasons, they also heavily lean into the far left wing political ideology and to that crowd your popular sports represent some of their major negative buzz words — capitalism, patriarchy, etc. They simply don’t cultivate a campus culture that’s going to ravenously consume sports and are much more likely to champion the collapse of the whole system.
06-17-2026 02:08 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Frank the Tank Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 23,551
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3294
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
Post: #52
RE: Hypothetical for Cal
(06-17-2026 02:08 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  The problem with Cal is that folks on the West Coast don’t follow college sports on a per capita basis anywhere near the way they do in the South and the Midwest. You’re blue collar folks are following pro sports teams and don’t really have any strong connections to elite academic institutions like Cal, Stanford, Cal, and maybe to a lesser extent Washington, Colorado, Arizona, and Arizona State. (USC seems to be able to maintain a t-shirt fan basis when their good, but even then, there’s some truth behind the nickname University of Spoiled Children — the kids going to USC/Cal/Stanford/UCLA aren’t your average California teenagers, they come from money and/or out-of-state. )

I think that among the 4 California schools, Cal struggles the most with athletic support because in addition to the aforementioned reasons, they also heavily lean into the far left wing political ideology and to that crowd your popular sports represent some of their major negative buzz words — capitalism, patriarchy, etc. They simply don’t cultivate a campus culture that’s going to ravenously consume sports and are much more likely to champion the collapse of the whole system.

It’s more of what your comparison point is.

I agree that the Bay Area has less college sports fandom compared to the core Midwest and South.

However, I do think the Bay Area and the West Coast in general has better natural college sports fandom compared to the attempts to make the NYC-to-Boston corridor into a college sports area.

At the same time, the growth in college sports isn’t from just getting more Midwestern and Southern viewers (who are already largely tapped out), but rather those coastal viewers who are just straight up more valuable to media companies due to higher education and income levels. This is an audience that college sports need to cultivate if they want long-term growth. The wealth and affluence of the Bay Area and similar markets is a major feature as opposed to a bug - you’re not selling Teslas and Mercedes en masse in small rural college towns.

Finally, I think you’re projecting some personal political viewpoints onto your perception of Cal sports fandom. Once again, sure, Cal isn’t like Ohio State or Alabama. However, all of those political projections really don’t track with the reality. Cal is more like UVA or Maryland on the college sports fandom spectrum with fairweatherness but certainly not nonexistent - this isn’t some type of inherently anti-sports environment that you seem to have on your mind.
(This post was last modified: 06-17-2026 02:42 PM by Frank the Tank.)
06-17-2026 02:40 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,873
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #53
RE: Hypothetical for Cal
Well the NYC-Boston corridor was once the hotbed of college sports. It has 3 issues: 1) its all close to lots of major league sports; 2) its big time programs, de-emphasized and moved down--the Ivy League and schools like Holy Cross, NYU, LIU; and 3) it doesn't have the dominance of the big state university like you do in the rest of the country.

The major league limits you, but some schools, like Washington and Michigan, do very well surrounded by the pros. The lack of dominance of Enormous State U. with people tending to look down on ESU and preferring privates is a bigger problem than the major leagues, but could still be overcome. The biggest factor is habit and time. If the Ivy League had stayed up, I think there would be more interest. Instead, all that is left is Syracuse, Boston College, Army, and more recently, Buffalo, UMass and UConn.

The growth of gambling could be something that makes it possible to create a resurgence in interest in NY & New England.

I think there may be more potential for growth in the northeast than in California. There are serious sports fans in the northeast.
06-17-2026 03:09 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
USF_Bullsharks Offline
Special Teams
*

Posts: 936
Joined: May 2025
Reputation: 287
I Root For: USF
Location:
Post: #54
RE: Hypothetical for Cal
(06-17-2026 03:09 PM)bullet Wrote:  Well the NYC-Boston corridor was once the hotbed of college sports. It has 3 issues: 1) its all close to lots of major league sports; 2) its big time programs, de-emphasized and moved down--the Ivy League and schools like Holy Cross, NYU, LIU; and 3) it doesn't have the dominance of the big state university like you do in the rest of the country.

The major league limits you, but some schools, like Washington and Michigan, do very well surrounded by the pros. The lack of dominance of Enormous State U. with people tending to look down on ESU and preferring privates is a bigger problem than the major leagues, but could still be overcome. The biggest factor is habit and time. If the Ivy League had stayed up, I think there would be more interest. Instead, all that is left is Syracuse, Boston College, Army, and more recently, Buffalo, UMass and UConn.

The growth of gambling could be something that makes it possible to create a resurgence in interest in NY & New England.

I think there may be more potential for growth in the northeast than in California. There are serious sports fans in the northeast.

Maybe a unified pitch for D1 collegiate horse racing.
06-17-2026 03:13 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
AztecEmpire Online
1st String
*

Posts: 1,079
Joined: May 2020
Reputation: 105
I Root For: SDSU
Location:
Post: #55
RE: Hypothetical for Cal
(06-17-2026 02:40 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(06-17-2026 02:08 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  The problem with Cal is that folks on the West Coast don’t follow college sports on a per capita basis anywhere near the way they do in the South and the Midwest. You’re blue collar folks are following pro sports teams and don’t really have any strong connections to elite academic institutions like Cal, Stanford, Cal, and maybe to a lesser extent Washington, Colorado, Arizona, and Arizona State. (USC seems to be able to maintain a t-shirt fan basis when their good, but even then, there’s some truth behind the nickname University of Spoiled Children — the kids going to USC/Cal/Stanford/UCLA aren’t your average California teenagers, they come from money and/or out-of-state. )

I think that among the 4 California schools, Cal struggles the most with athletic support because in addition to the aforementioned reasons, they also heavily lean into the far left wing political ideology and to that crowd your popular sports represent some of their major negative buzz words — capitalism, patriarchy, etc. They simply don’t cultivate a campus culture that’s going to ravenously consume sports and are much more likely to champion the collapse of the whole system.

It’s more of what your comparison point is.

I agree that the Bay Area has less college sports fandom compared to the core Midwest and South.

However, I do think the Bay Area and the West Coast in general has better natural college sports fandom compared to the attempts to make the NYC-to-Boston corridor into a college sports area.

At the same time, the growth in college sports isn’t from just getting more Midwestern and Southern viewers (who are already largely tapped out), but rather those coastal viewers who are just straight up more valuable to media companies due to higher education and income levels. This is an audience that college sports need to cultivate if they want long-term growth. The wealth and affluence of the Bay Area and similar markets is a major feature as opposed to a bug - you’re not selling Teslas and Mercedes en masse in small rural college towns.

Finally, I think you’re projecting some personal political viewpoints onto your perception of Cal sports fandom. Once again, sure, Cal isn’t like Ohio State or Alabama. However, all of those political projections really don’t track with the reality. Cal is more like UVA or Maryland on the college sports fandom spectrum with fairweatherness but certainly not nonexistent - this isn’t some type of inherently anti-sports environment that you seem to have on your mind.

It seems like a lot of folks conflate the town of Berkeley with the school. Berkeley is a hippie town through and through but UC Berkeley is more complex even if they do have plenty of liberal student like any major university on the coasts.
06-17-2026 03:27 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Fighting Muskie Offline
Senior Chief Realignmentologist
*

Posts: 15,080
Joined: Sep 2016
Reputation: 1214
I Root For: Bishop Sycamore
Location: Secret Lair
Post: #56
RE: Hypothetical for Cal
(06-17-2026 02:40 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(06-17-2026 02:08 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  The problem with Cal is that folks on the West Coast don’t follow college sports on a per capita basis anywhere near the way they do in the South and the Midwest. You’re blue collar folks are following pro sports teams and don’t really have any strong connections to elite academic institutions like Cal, Stanford, Cal, and maybe to a lesser extent Washington, Colorado, Arizona, and Arizona State. (USC seems to be able to maintain a t-shirt fan basis when their good, but even then, there’s some truth behind the nickname University of Spoiled Children — the kids going to USC/Cal/Stanford/UCLA aren’t your average California teenagers, they come from money and/or out-of-state. )

I think that among the 4 California schools, Cal struggles the most with athletic support because in addition to the aforementioned reasons, they also heavily lean into the far left wing political ideology and to that crowd your popular sports represent some of their major negative buzz words — capitalism, patriarchy, etc. They simply don’t cultivate a campus culture that’s going to ravenously consume sports and are much more likely to champion the collapse of the whole system.

It’s more of what your comparison point is.

I agree that the Bay Area has less college sports fandom compared to the core Midwest and South.

However, I do think the Bay Area and the West Coast in general has better natural college sports fandom compared to the attempts to make the NYC-to-Boston corridor into a college sports area.

At the same time, the growth in college sports isn’t from just getting more Midwestern and Southern viewers (who are already largely tapped out), but rather those coastal viewers who are just straight up more valuable to media companies due to higher education and income levels. This is an audience that college sports need to cultivate if they want long-term growth. The wealth and affluence of the Bay Area and similar markets is a major feature as opposed to a bug - you’re not selling Teslas and Mercedes en masse in small rural college towns.

Finally, I think you’re projecting some personal political viewpoints onto your perception of Cal sports fandom. Once again, sure, Cal isn’t like Ohio State or Alabama. However, all of those political projections really don’t track with the reality. Cal is more like UVA or Maryland on the college sports fandom spectrum with fairweatherness but certainly not nonexistent - this isn’t some type of inherently anti-sports environment that you seem to have on your mind.

I’m more right here than you care to admit. The truth is there’s not a lot of casual college sports viewers in west coast markets so if you’re not an alum or family you’re not likely to watch. For a school like Berkeley, the kinds of students they attract aren’t predisposed to following collegiate sports, especially the international ones. The older generation alums are probably a good audience to advertise Mercedes and Rolex to but the young alums are a different animal entirely.

Look at UC Santa Cruz—they could be D1 like Irvine, Davis, Riverside, UCSB, and UCSD but they are deliberate in their underfunding of athletics.

Berkeley is a place that will never invest enough to be successful enough to attract t-shirt fans and even if they did, there’s no guarantee that they will.

There’s a category of schools out there who, due to a combination of pro sports competition, high admissions standards resulting in low local enrollment, now have their best athletic years behind them. I’d put Cal, Stanford, and GT all in that category.
06-17-2026 03:57 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Frank the Tank Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 23,551
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3294
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
Post: #57
RE: Hypothetical for Cal
(06-17-2026 03:57 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  
(06-17-2026 02:40 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(06-17-2026 02:08 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  The problem with Cal is that folks on the West Coast don’t follow college sports on a per capita basis anywhere near the way they do in the South and the Midwest. You’re blue collar folks are following pro sports teams and don’t really have any strong connections to elite academic institutions like Cal, Stanford, Cal, and maybe to a lesser extent Washington, Colorado, Arizona, and Arizona State. (USC seems to be able to maintain a t-shirt fan basis when their good, but even then, there’s some truth behind the nickname University of Spoiled Children — the kids going to USC/Cal/Stanford/UCLA aren’t your average California teenagers, they come from money and/or out-of-state. )

I think that among the 4 California schools, Cal struggles the most with athletic support because in addition to the aforementioned reasons, they also heavily lean into the far left wing political ideology and to that crowd your popular sports represent some of their major negative buzz words — capitalism, patriarchy, etc. They simply don’t cultivate a campus culture that’s going to ravenously consume sports and are much more likely to champion the collapse of the whole system.

It’s more of what your comparison point is.

I agree that the Bay Area has less college sports fandom compared to the core Midwest and South.

However, I do think the Bay Area and the West Coast in general has better natural college sports fandom compared to the attempts to make the NYC-to-Boston corridor into a college sports area.

At the same time, the growth in college sports isn’t from just getting more Midwestern and Southern viewers (who are already largely tapped out), but rather those coastal viewers who are just straight up more valuable to media companies due to higher education and income levels. This is an audience that college sports need to cultivate if they want long-term growth. The wealth and affluence of the Bay Area and similar markets is a major feature as opposed to a bug - you’re not selling Teslas and Mercedes en masse in small rural college towns.

Finally, I think you’re projecting some personal political viewpoints onto your perception of Cal sports fandom. Once again, sure, Cal isn’t like Ohio State or Alabama. However, all of those political projections really don’t track with the reality. Cal is more like UVA or Maryland on the college sports fandom spectrum with fairweatherness but certainly not nonexistent - this isn’t some type of inherently anti-sports environment that you seem to have on your mind.

I’m more right here than you care to admit. The truth is there’s not a lot of casual college sports viewers in west coast markets so if you’re not an alum or family you’re not likely to watch. For a school like Berkeley, the kinds of students they attract aren’t predisposed to following collegiate sports, especially the international ones. The older generation alums are probably a good audience to advertise Mercedes and Rolex to but the young alums are a different animal entirely.

Look at UC Santa Cruz—they could be D1 like Irvine, Davis, Riverside, UCSB, and UCSD but they are deliberate in their underfunding of athletics.

Berkeley is a place that will never invest enough to be successful enough to attract t-shirt fans and even if they did, there’s no guarantee that they will.

There’s a category of schools out there who, due to a combination of pro sports competition, high admissions standards resulting in low local enrollment, now have their best athletic years behind them. I’d put Cal, Stanford, and GT all in that category.

I categorically disagree about having high admissions standards as a barrier in and of itself.

The vast majority of Notre Dame fans don’t have SAT scores anywhere near the bottom 10% of that school’s student body.

That’s even more the case for Duke.

Michigan, Texas, Florida, and UNC are all examples of massive flagship universities that are extremely difficult to gain admission to, yet are monster athletic brands.

Aspirational brands are generally what actually drive higher engagement across nearly all business and product categories (not just college sports). People generally want to go upscale as opposed to downscale if they have choice.

At the same time, I think this forum constantly underrates the West Coast markets because it can’t get past the inward belief that only the South and, to a lesser extent, the Midwest have acceptable levels of college sports fandom (and I’m a lifelong Midwesterner). Once again, I don’t think anyone is arguing that the Bay Area is like Birmingham or Columbus… but that’s exactly what makes the Bay Area a far more attractive target area compared to Birmingham and Columbus. No one needs more overindexing in the South or Midwest. Unlike the Northeast, the West Coast does have major flagship schools and brands playing in the power conferences. These aren’t as heavy lifts as a lot of people seem to have in their minds.

In any event, it doesn’t matter what you say or I say. I have it on good authority that Stanford and Cal aren’t out of the Big Ten mix. That’s not to say that they’re guaranteed, but they’re certainly higher on the list than a whole host of names that get frequently bandied about here.
(This post was last modified: 06-17-2026 04:22 PM by Frank the Tank.)
06-17-2026 04:21 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Stugray2 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 9,340
Joined: Jan 2017
Reputation: 975
I Root For: tOSU SJSU Stan'
Location: South Bay Area CA
Post: #58
RE: Hypothetical for Cal
Frank is probably right. If the B1G adds one Bay Area school they will almost certainly (99% chance) add both. They are a package deal and boost prestige enormously, as both are top 10 academically. UCLA and USC would insist on both as well. Do not think for a second that any President in the B1G is against either of these two schools or against taking both. The political pressure from the State of California would be enormous as well. The only hurdle is TV partners. While TV loves the Bay Area for professional sports, it is a notoriously weak market for college football (too NFL focused) and basketball (too divided, none of the 6 D-I schools gets much traction, while the Warriors take all the oxygen out of the room). In the Dr. Pepper commercials the greater SF Bay Area's 6+ million residents would qualify as "pro town." But NorCal is such a huge market (it pulls all the way to Reno), larger than Georgia and Alabama combined, that it is hard to have a college football hole in a major market of that size (and super wealthy with lots of fortune 500 company HQs). For now, I think they pass. But if things consolidate into a super league, TV will insist that as many market holes as reasonably possible be filled, just as they do in pro-sports, to maximize advertising revenue. Cal + Stanford fills one of the three large holes an SEC/B1G super league would have (assuming UNC/UVa/Miami are picked up in expansion). Something in the four corners (a few decent options) and something in New England (???) are the other two big holes.
(This post was last modified: 06-17-2026 04:44 PM by Stugray2.)
06-17-2026 04:42 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
DFW HOYA Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,299
Joined: May 2004
Reputation: 533
I Root For: Georgetown
Location: Dallas, TX
Post: #59
RE: Hypothetical for Cal
(06-17-2026 08:35 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  People thought that the demise of the SWC would be damaging to Texas (State) football, but it's been quite the opposite.

Hasn't helped Rice, of course.
06-17-2026 05:10 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,873
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #60
RE: Hypothetical for Cal
(06-17-2026 04:42 PM)Stugray2 Wrote:  Frank is probably right. If the B1G adds one Bay Area school they will almost certainly (99% chance) add both. They are a package deal and boost prestige enormously, as both are top 10 academically. UCLA and USC would insist on both as well. Do not think for a second that any President in the B1G is against either of these two schools or against taking both. The political pressure from the State of California would be enormous as well. The only hurdle is TV partners. While TV loves the Bay Area for professional sports, it is a notoriously weak market for college football (too NFL focused) and basketball (too divided, none of the 6 D-I schools gets much traction, while the Warriors take all the oxygen out of the room). In the Dr. Pepper commercials the greater SF Bay Area's 6+ million residents would qualify as "pro town." But NorCal is such a huge market (it pulls all the way to Reno), larger than Georgia and Alabama combined, that it is hard to have a college football hole in a major market of that size (and super wealthy with lots of fortune 500 company HQs). For now, I think they pass. But if things consolidate into a super league, TV will insist that as many market holes as reasonably possible be filled, just as they do in pro-sports, to maximize advertising revenue. Cal + Stanford fills one of the three large holes an SEC/B1G super league would have (assuming UNC/UVa/Miami are picked up in expansion). Something in the four corners (a few decent options) and something in New England (???) are the other two big holes.
They would certainly look at Stanford/Cal in expansion to 24, but I would think the Big Ten's top 3 would be FSU, Miami and UNC with UVA #4. Of course they may not get all of those schools.
06-17-2026 06:04 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.