bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,947
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: Thought patrol: What are we working with? My views on conference goals & strat...
(06-15-2026 11:00 AM)The Beaver Wrote: (06-15-2026 10:22 AM)WhidbeyWolf Wrote: (06-15-2026 01:11 AM)The Beaver Wrote: Alright then, let me finish my thought.
So what does the Big Ten do, then? They want to improve their schools' prestige, which would mean schools like Cal and Stanford, UVA too. UNC would complete the quad. But the truth is that those schools fly in the face of all of the conference's other goals. They do not help it make money if taken in full, do not help it gain an advantage over the SEC, beyond perhaps UNC and UVA in full. Perhaps a balanced approach, where a single school from Northern California is taken, along with a single prestigious school from the southern coast, could better thread that needle. Then, if the nay-sayers are sufficiently placated they can circle back for the second norcal twin (likely Cal, if we're being honest) and pair them with whichever the best remaining team in the southeast is (likely Miami, depending on what the SEC does but NCST and GT both offer positives of their own, along with Duke if both of the teams I mentioned previously are taken by the SEC.)
Beyond expansion the Big Ten has huge trouble with "load bearers" versus "free riders" simmering just beneath (and sometimes on) the surface. We've seen it in the latest round of expansion where sources at schools like Penn State were comfortable going off the record to oppose the PNW 2 as well in the failed PI deal where schools were openly fighting about which "tier" they belonged in. You don't see this in the SEC and Big XII, where schools are relatively flat, only in the more stratified conferences like the Big 10, the ACC, the old MWC, etc. That they had to go with stratified payments in that PI deal means, to me, that the Rubicon has been crossed and that will be part of the next media deal. Of course, this also means that they might be a less attractive destination for schools that are lucky enough to get a choice of conferences. UNC likely, at least, could claim middle tier in the Big Ten but could UVA? GT? Duke? I sincerely doubt it. Stanford and Cal likely in the bottom tier too but the SEC isn't sending them roses so oh well.
In regards to their much balleyhooed quest for relevance among the middle schools of the Big Ten in football, I just don't see it going anywhere in the time of the current deal. Their latest push (24 teams) seems to have fizzled out due to being unable to get the three sides (B1G, SEC and M2) to agree. They can work something out that the SEC would find acceptable, or something palatable to the M2, but they can't please all sides. The focus then, there, should be on what the CFP becomes after the current deal expires. Same with the basketball tournament, I suppose. My recommendation would be to pick the SEC as the main partner to please then and work something out with them, specifically, then tell the others to join or die. But that's six or so years away at this point.
And lastly, as the league with the largest and richest alumni bases the Big Ten should consider pushing for a higher limit on NIL caps, should those become an option. All teams are dealing with spending pressures in the post-House and post-Alston landscape but with more money available we can survive far better than the M2 and, at the highest level, compete with or even beyond most of the SEC. I don't think that has sunk in yet, and teams at the bottom like UMD, Rutgers, etc. are already in financial trouble. As said above, this is one of the Big Ten's issues, it is hard to fight for the whole league in the same way that a conference like the SEC, SBC or Big XII can.
Now then, about the SEC. So their main goal is to keep their high levels of engagement between their schools and their alumni bases and surrounding areas and their main way of doing that has been rivalry games and having a high level of competition in football. They could, in that sense, just forgo expansion and stay at 16. But from Disney's perspective there is still some money to be made from "promoting" other southeastern schools into the conference. So what are their choices then? They could seek to bring remaining OOC rivalries fully in-house. The main ones to consider are FSU vs Florida, Miami vs Florida (and FSU, should both be taken,) Georgia Tech versus both Georgia and Auburn, Clemson versus USC, Louisville vs Kentucky, Kansas vs Missouri and OSU vs Oklahoma. UNC, a second school of NCST and Duke, UVa and their rival V Tech (who I will be referring to as VPI from here on out) are all additive of southeastern markets though they have few if any ties to existing SEC schools. You can long list West Virginia and Texas Tech too, if you want, though neither would be top targets in my opinion. Of those mentioned schools I think we can safely discount Louisville, OSU, Kansas, WV, TTU and sadly VPI, who would need to not only come in with UVA but do so with UNC too and then somehow earn the nod as a second Virginia school over FSU as a second Florida school, Clemson as a second SC school with infinitely more fans, etc. So that leaves, from bottom to top geographically, Miami, Florida State, Georgia Tech, Clemson, UNC, Duke or NC State and Virginia as your choices.
The SEC seems to be sticking with full, equal payouts for all schools at this time, giving them first pick over the Big Ten. UNC seems to be consensus first choice among all pickers, so they get in first and even get to bring one rival with them. For the sake of JrSEC's stories we will say that they take Duke as their rival though maybe tides have changed and they'd want NC ST or UVA. For the sake of argument I don't think conferences are going to add more than four teams at a time and even then might space them out over a few years. So which of the remaining candidates have the most potential? Florida State, to me, is clearly the top choice of the rest, as they have a great rivalry with UF, are a great pick in their own right, are in a great state, would give the Big Ten an in to Florida if not chosen and just fit the bill of being an SEC team by all appearances. The other choices are, in my opinion, Clemson who are like FSU lite, GT, who are possibly highly under-rated with their two traditional SEC rivalries, great location in the Atlanta area, under-rated fanbase and, for whatever its worth, strong academic profile, and finally UVA as a second UNC rival who also provide you with a block on the Big Ten in a second potential market. I've been on the "UNC and FSU followed by Duke and Clemson a year later" train for awhile now but looking at it like this there's a real case to be made for going FSU, UNC, GT, NC's buddy school and omitting the Carolinian Tigers. Or going with Miami to have a third Florida team, possibly ditching the goatfeet all together for a lineup of FSU and GT followed by Clemson and Miami.
Though realignment is top of everyone's minds here its actually just one of many things conferences have to deal with. Their main goals beyond fan support for member schools were all about athletic dominance while building up a veneer of respectability. Things they could do to help here include adding UNC, which is one of the nation's most historically successful athletic programs, beefing up basketball with a UNC+Duke (or UNC+Kansas, etc.) combo, fighting for a restricted/traditional NIL system that lets them better use their innate geographic advantage more effectively or going the other way, tossing the door open and letting Texas, Texas A&M, Florida, Georgia and a few others carry the flag against the bagmen of the north. But their biggest advantage here is that the current CFP set-up advantages them alone at the expense of the other three relevant leagues. It gives all but five slots to at large teams and, in recent decades, the SEC has been far more effective than other conferences at dominating the top eleven. In that sense if they aren't given a dream deal by their negotiating partners they can just veto changes and keep the current system.
Many here have questioned, sometimes angrily, why they recently agreed to switch to a nine game IC schedule in exchange for a minor increase in the tv payout. Well, looking at my list of their priorities I think this helps explain why. It helps them with their number one goal, by giving teams three annual series to contend with plus, for many, a single OOC rivalry matchup for four (in theory) hype games per season. It also helps their number 3 (make money) and number 5 (don't embarrass yourselves) goals but does so at the expense of 2 (win natties) and 4 (gain or keep an advantage over the B1G.) Its a tricky balancing act, especially for the teams that feel they are being hurt more by this, but a look at the numbers seems to point towards it being the right decision.
Its very late at night and I've been at this for hours. I'll finish the ACC surgery and Big XII purgatory portions of this post tomorrow, likely while being paid in real life money by my in real life employer.
That's a lot for these old eyes...but after you say the SEC takes Duke instead of NC State, you don't say where or how far State falls. Or you did, and I missed it.
I think we have good football value, which is what the money is following. The bolded State/GT part intrigues me. What are the comparative positives?
ETA: I see this is only Part 1. I'll need some sleep too. 
Well among other things I haven't talked about your conference yet. But if they aren't taken then they don't get taken, should be as easy as that. I did allude to them being on the Big Ten longboard the math really doesn't math for that, there's always going to be a Miami, GT or even Clemson getting in over them. Your best option is to get into whichever conference UNC prefers (the SEC, likely,) as their partner whether that means joining as a pair or unofficially being the next team in a year later when the payment fee drops.
This also isn't a dominoes thread. I mentioned realignment as a part of SEC strategy but it wasn't really the focus of the article. They seem likely to take one traditional UNC rival when taking the Heels and to them it likely doesn't really matter which as they all offer positives.
NC St just isn't a Big Brand. Never mind PSU or OU, they're 2 steps behind Iowa, Wisconsin, Arkansas and South Carolina. At least Duke has elite Academics and a huge Brand in something that we care about, plus they're 1/2 of the biggest rivalry in mbb. If we decide to add a rival for an existing member, I'd prefer Kansas over Duke, who I'd prefer over UVA, over NC St. Now, that's a pretty nice group of schools to be compared to, but coming in at the bottom of the list when P2 expansion at all is up in the air and very large P2 expansion is highly speculative is a bad place to be.
|
|