Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
NCSU considering suing LSU
Author Message
Hokie Mark Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 26,875
Joined: Sep 2011
Reputation: 2011
I Root For: VT, ACC teams
Location: Greensboro, NC
Post: #21
RE: NCSU considering suing LSU
New College Sports Slogan seems to be

If You Ain't Suing,
You Ain't Trying!
06-11-2026 12:58 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Gitanole Offline
Barista
*

Posts: 13,916
Joined: May 2016
Reputation: 2818
I Root For: Florida State
Location: Speared Turf
Post: #22
RE: NCSU considering suing LSU
(06-10-2026 06:59 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  The underhanded nature of LSU’s recent moves leads one to believe that they probably did something wrong here. However, NC State is going to struggle to collect on a Louisiana school that they sue in North Carolina.
....

A legal ruling is legally binding. It sticks.

If LSU doesn’t like the result, LSU will appeal and hope for a legal ruling it likes better.
06-11-2026 01:22 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
b2b Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 10,141
Joined: May 2021
Reputation: 1426
I Root For: Fam+ECU/CSU/App
Location: Land of Confusion
Post: #23
RE: NCSU considering suing LSU
UConn, the Big East and ACC come to mind. I know it's not apples to apples but I'd tread carefully if I were NC State. This isn't worth fighting for at this point.
06-11-2026 02:06 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
BruceMcF Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 15,765
Joined: Jan 2013
Reputation: 1019
I Root For: Reds/Buckeyes/.
Location:
Post: #24
RE: NCSU considering suing LSU
(06-10-2026 05:07 PM)FULL_MONTY Wrote:  Where's the popcorn.

Both schools are public universities that qualify as "arms of the state" under the law:LSU (via its Board of Supervisors) is an arm of the State of Louisiana and enjoys full sovereign immunity.

But hey, this is a free market where State's are sponsoring athletic endeavors. Adam Smith wrote books on the magical free market of State Sponsored athletics. It doesn't get any more free market than that Crony State politicking.

Plaudits for knowing that he also wrote the Theory of Moral Sentiments. Most people only know about the one book.
06-11-2026 02:08 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
FULL_MONTY Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,058
Joined: Jun 2005
Reputation: 134
I Root For:
Location:
Post: #25
RE: NCSU considering suing LSU
(06-11-2026 02:08 PM)BruceMcF Wrote:  
(06-10-2026 05:07 PM)FULL_MONTY Wrote:  Where's the popcorn.

Both schools are public universities that qualify as "arms of the state" under the law:LSU (via its Board of Supervisors) is an arm of the State of Louisiana and enjoys full sovereign immunity.

But hey, this is a free market where State's are sponsoring athletic endeavors. Adam Smith wrote books on the magical free market of State Sponsored athletics. It doesn't get any more free market than that Crony State politicking.

Plaudits for knowing that he also wrote the Theory of Moral Sentiments. Most people only know about the one book.

A good read. All snark aside, Smith should be required reading with Locke. JMO.
06-11-2026 02:19 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13521
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #26
RE: NCSU considering suing LSU
And meanwhile Storrs and Disney are watching this and not saying a word. Why would that be the case amid what is their family of properties until at least 2034?

Oh, I don't know, maybe it gives them what they've needed for some time now, a reason, uhm, excuse, to utilize the decreasing exit fee windows they helped to create so they can move the properties they most want to keep to where those properties new revenue totals will secure them for some time to come. After all that preserves ESPN's profit structure while reducing overhead at best and keeping a wash in outlay at worst. How? Then they can roll over the other 9 to 11 properties into a pot pie of Big 12 and former ACC brands all of a similar value and split the tab with FOX. Between the two groups FOX gets games in the Southeast (which they have wanted) and ESPN and FOX have enough late-night West Coast football to fill their time slots for games ending after midnight Eastern Time.

Why shouldn't N.C. State file suit against LSU? LSU will be in a super conference, and N.C. State might not be. They are likely sick and tired of being discounted behind UNC and realize that it would take state intervention to get a better home for themselves. A lawsuit might be a good means of gauging their support within the Universities of North Carolina System, and making their legislature notice their plight. It is a better political tactic than the actual case.

Why shouldn't the MAC commissioner gripe about the P4. He's going to be getting less and less revenue when some of the remnants of the Big 12 and ACC start filling other time slots because they draw larger audiences. And as Full Monty alluded to, he can't siphon off funds from the Big Ten and SEC or any P4 which now will schedule more P games and fewer games against the MAC, and should they pull out altogether they won't be paying the kitty for the NCAA tournament. For him it's pretty much sour grapes which face it are what a great many posters spew about here. Think of it as the Howard Beal catharsis. "I'm mad as hell and I'm not going to take it anymore!" Look it up if you are under 60.

Of course there is more discourse. Big damn changes are coming, and nobody is certain how far they will go, or if they will be curtailed, because the Congress's impact will be a grab bag in that neither side will know what they will get. The NCAA is neutered and muzzled and can't sanction anything. There is no new governing body. Nobody can state what NIL is and isn't. How each conference will provide pay to athletes is miles away from consensus. And as with the case in 1983 (Oklahoma and Georgia vs the NCAA) the courts have changed the paradigm. Corporations will rush into the dead space where presidents are thinking what comes next, just like outside private equity entities with capital infusion plans for a % of the profits, and all of that frankly produces the impetus for the SEC and Big Ten to want to do their own thing so they can work with the SCOTUS ruling to set operational guidelines to prevent the lawsuits being between schools from different conferences becoming lawsuits between schools in the same conference. Or something even worse like Texas Tech QB fiasco.

The problem for the Big Ten and SEC and why you haven't heard a mumbling word from either of them for over a week, is that they don't want to jump and then deal with Congress. They want Congress to jump so they know what it is exactly they need to do. But if we go into the midterms without any Congressional direction they may well act while trusting it is easier to get forgiveness than approval (especially if you are comprised of sizeable voting alumni groups).

For all of you who keep yelling anti-trust setting up a new format in response to Supreme Court rulings and accepting schools which want to be a part of that and can afford the minimum investment levels isn't anti-trust, has historically received cooperation from the courts if they are meeting court mandates, and would not be competing with anyone left in any other system of college football because their rules and governance and structure would be different and because it was done in conjunction with court compliance.

Now all of that said we still have what we have, a big damn mess. But it is no more the fault of the Big Ten and SEC than it is the Ivy League or any conference. It is a direct result of the NCAA's failure to adapt to the times, or the ignoring of inferences from those advising them pertaining to the court cases prior to the rulings. In a strong wind that which will not bend breaks. The NCAA broke. And that's why they have no credibility with regard to governance. And there is where the blame resides. Now rather than muddying the waters they need to go away and let every tier of collegiate athletics organize itself as it benefits schools facing the same financial stressors befitting their tier.

The second problem here is that most college presidents don't want to have to deal with a sports mess. They want to direct education at their institutions. So now that the mess is here, they are the least prepared as a whole to know where to even start to rebuild it.

When you have this much stress, and this little leadership, of course it is disharmonious.

I suspect that if nothing constructive comes to the forefront of discussion that it is highly likely the SEC and Big Ten make a move and that any institution of their scope and financial means will likely want to be a part of it, and will very likely be welcomed. But first the parameters will have to be set and they can't be set if nobody moves first. And when the SEC and Big Ten move together, expect their media partners to have a big say about what constitutes the scope of that tier.
(This post was last modified: 06-11-2026 03:01 PM by JRsec.)
06-11-2026 02:53 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
msu35 Offline
Observing Reality
*

Posts: 21,517
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2229
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
Post: #27
RE: NCSU considering suing LSU
...or the B1G and SEC are remaining silent because their high-dollar representation is telling them the exact opposite.
06-11-2026 03:05 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13521
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #28
RE: NCSU considering suing LSU
(06-11-2026 03:05 PM)msu35 Wrote:  ...or the B1G and SEC are remaining silent because their high-dollar representation is telling them the exact opposite.

That's your narrative, and it is similar to some others, but it is not what is going on for Sankey and Petitti. They simply want as much information about what various parties are seeking and whether Congress intends to act, and if so, what Congress will be seeking and then to get an informed assessment of whether the votes even exist to pass it, before they respond. It's what any corporation would do. You never play your hand until it is called. There are some aspects of the Congressional proposal they favor, some they don't. But the final form has yet to be derived. So, they wait.
06-11-2026 03:20 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
msu35 Offline
Observing Reality
*

Posts: 21,517
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2229
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
Post: #29
RE: NCSU considering suing LSU
(06-11-2026 03:20 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(06-11-2026 03:05 PM)msu35 Wrote:  ...or the B1G and SEC are remaining silent because their high-dollar representation is telling them the exact opposite.

That's your narrative, and it is similar to some others, but it is not what is going on for Sankey and Petitti. They simply want as much information about what various parties are seeking and whether Congress intends to act, and if so, what Congress will be seeking and then to get an informed assessment of whether the votes even exist to pass it, before they respond. It's what any corporation would do. You never play your hand until it is called. There are some aspects of the Congressional proposal they favor, some they don't. But the final form has yet to be derived. So, they wait.

There's a massive difference between a calculated corporate wait-and-see strategy and being legally paralyzed. If they're just waiting to see if Congress has the votes, then the grand narrative of an imminent, corporate-backed P2 breakaway super league that "begs for forgiveness later" is dead on arrival. They aren't playing a hidden hand; they're waiting for a legislative lifeline because their lawyers know an independent breakaway is an antitrust suicide mission.
06-11-2026 03:23 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13521
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #30
RE: NCSU considering suing LSU
(06-11-2026 03:23 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-11-2026 03:20 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(06-11-2026 03:05 PM)msu35 Wrote:  ...or the B1G and SEC are remaining silent because their high-dollar representation is telling them the exact opposite.

That's your narrative, and it is similar to some others, but it is not what is going on for Sankey and Petitti. They simply want as much information about what various parties are seeking and whether Congress intends to act, and if so, what Congress will be seeking and then to get an informed assessment of whether the votes even exist to pass it, before they respond. It's what any corporation would do. You never play your hand until it is called. There are some aspects of the Congressional proposal they favor, some they don't. But the final form has yet to be derived. So, they wait.

There's a massive difference between a calculated corporate wait-and-see strategy and being legally paralyzed. If they're just waiting to see if Congress has the votes, then the grand narrative of an imminent, corporate-backed P2 breakaway super league that "begs for forgiveness later" is dead on arrival. They aren't playing a hidden hand; they're waiting for a legislative lifeline because their lawyers know an independent breakaway is an antitrust suicide mission.
Do you have anything else but supposition? You are talking about two massively valuable billion-dollar conferences backed by massive media networks all of which have tremendous political pull in Washington D.C. Sankey and Petitti's possible objectives are the poorest kept secret in the industry. As long as what they do abides by the rulings in the Alston and House cases they are not politically paralyzed. They have more to fear from the Supreme Court than they would Congress.

Who comprises congress? Will those Senators and Representatives go on record as being against their own state schools' best interests knowing they have the largest alumni base, and they are generally more passionate about their college's sports than politics? I don't think so. Will they go against the sports media giants which also help to shape the news by trying to gouge their best cash cow, sports? I don't think so. Petitti and Sankey aren't scared. They just want to see the lay of the land and then respond.
06-11-2026 03:53 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
msu35 Offline
Observing Reality
*

Posts: 21,517
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2229
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
Post: #31
RE: NCSU considering suing LSU
(06-11-2026 03:53 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(06-11-2026 03:23 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-11-2026 03:20 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(06-11-2026 03:05 PM)msu35 Wrote:  ...or the B1G and SEC are remaining silent because their high-dollar representation is telling them the exact opposite.

That's your narrative, and it is similar to some others, but it is not what is going on for Sankey and Petitti. They simply want as much information about what various parties are seeking and whether Congress intends to act, and if so, what Congress will be seeking and then to get an informed assessment of whether the votes even exist to pass it, before they respond. It's what any corporation would do. You never play your hand until it is called. There are some aspects of the Congressional proposal they favor, some they don't. But the final form has yet to be derived. So, they wait.

There's a massive difference between a calculated corporate wait-and-see strategy and being legally paralyzed. If they're just waiting to see if Congress has the votes, then the grand narrative of an imminent, corporate-backed P2 breakaway super league that "begs for forgiveness later" is dead on arrival. They aren't playing a hidden hand; they're waiting for a legislative lifeline because their lawyers know an independent breakaway is an antitrust suicide mission.

Do you have anything else but supposition? You are talking about two massively valuable billion-dollar conferences backed by massive media networks all of which have tremendous political pull in Washington D.C. Sankey and Petitti's possible objectives are the poorest kept secret in the industry. As long as what they do abides by the rulings in the Alston and House cases they are not politically paralyzed. They have more to fear from the Supreme Court than they would Congress.

Who comprises congress? Will those Senators and Representatives go on record as being against their own state schools' best interests knowing they have the largest alumni base, and they are generally more passionate about their college's sports than politics? I don't think so. Will they go against the sports media giants which also help to shape the news by trying to gouge their best cash cow, sports? I don't think so. Petitti and Sankey aren't scared. They just want to see the lay of the land and then respond.

Accusing me of supposition while claiming Congress bases federal antitrust policy on the passion of football alumni is a curious choice.

More importantly, citing Alston and House completely defeats the argument. Alston was a unanimous 9-0 Supreme Court beatdown that explicitly established that college sports are bound by the Sherman Act, and House is forcing a multi-billion dollar revenue-sharing model. The P2 is quiet precisely because the courts have already proven they will dismantle any independent breakaway that doesn't have explicit Congressional antitrust immunity. They aren't "surveying the lay of the land" -- they're waiting to see if Washington will hand them an umbrella before the legal thunderstorms drowns them.
06-11-2026 04:04 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
FULL_MONTY Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,058
Joined: Jun 2005
Reputation: 134
I Root For:
Location:
Post: #32
RE: NCSU considering suing LSU
(06-11-2026 04:04 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-11-2026 03:53 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(06-11-2026 03:23 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-11-2026 03:20 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(06-11-2026 03:05 PM)msu35 Wrote:  ...or the B1G and SEC are remaining silent because their high-dollar representation is telling them the exact opposite.

That's your narrative, and it is similar to some others, but it is not what is going on for Sankey and Petitti. They simply want as much information about what various parties are seeking and whether Congress intends to act, and if so, what Congress will be seeking and then to get an informed assessment of whether the votes even exist to pass it, before they respond. It's what any corporation would do. You never play your hand until it is called. There are some aspects of the Congressional proposal they favor, some they don't. But the final form has yet to be derived. So, they wait.

There's a massive difference between a calculated corporate wait-and-see strategy and being legally paralyzed. If they're just waiting to see if Congress has the votes, then the grand narrative of an imminent, corporate-backed P2 breakaway super league that "begs for forgiveness later" is dead on arrival. They aren't playing a hidden hand; they're waiting for a legislative lifeline because their lawyers know an independent breakaway is an antitrust suicide mission.

Do you have anything else but supposition? You are talking about two massively valuable billion-dollar conferences backed by massive media networks all of which have tremendous political pull in Washington D.C. Sankey and Petitti's possible objectives are the poorest kept secret in the industry. As long as what they do abides by the rulings in the Alston and House cases they are not politically paralyzed. They have more to fear from the Supreme Court than they would Congress.

Who comprises congress? Will those Senators and Representatives go on record as being against their own state schools' best interests knowing they have the largest alumni base, and they are generally more passionate about their college's sports than politics? I don't think so. Will they go against the sports media giants which also help to shape the news by trying to gouge their best cash cow, sports? I don't think so. Petitti and Sankey aren't scared. They just want to see the lay of the land and then respond.

Accusing me of supposition while claiming Congress bases federal antitrust policy on the passion of football alumni is a curious choice.

More importantly, citing Alston and House completely defeats the argument. Alston was a unanimous 9-0 Supreme Court beatdown that explicitly established that college sports are bound by the Sherman Act, and House is forcing a multi-billion dollar revenue-sharing model. The P2 is quiet precisely because the courts have already proven they will dismantle any independent breakaway that doesn't have explicit Congressional antitrust immunity. They aren't "surveying the lay of the land" -- they're waiting to see if Washington will hand them an umbrella before the legal thunderstorms drowns them.

It's pretty clear that the SEC and B1G are far from being in control at this point. This is as amusing as people believing that largely public Universities using State and Federal dollars are just competing in a free market.

ASU is using eminent domain to oust a home owner to make way for their Medical School. If that isn't a free market action, then nothing is a free market action.
06-11-2026 04:17 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Wahoowa84 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,436
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 1176
I Root For: UVa
Location:
Post: #33
RE: NCSU considering suing LSU
(06-11-2026 03:53 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(06-11-2026 03:23 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-11-2026 03:20 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(06-11-2026 03:05 PM)msu35 Wrote:  ...or the B1G and SEC are remaining silent because their high-dollar representation is telling them the exact opposite.

That's your narrative, and it is similar to some others, but it is not what is going on for Sankey and Petitti. They simply want as much information about what various parties are seeking and whether Congress intends to act, and if so, what Congress will be seeking and then to get an informed assessment of whether the votes even exist to pass it, before they respond. It's what any corporation would do. You never play your hand until it is called. There are some aspects of the Congressional proposal they favor, some they don't. But the final form has yet to be derived. So, they wait.

There's a massive difference between a calculated corporate wait-and-see strategy and being legally paralyzed. If they're just waiting to see if Congress has the votes, then the grand narrative of an imminent, corporate-backed P2 breakaway super league that "begs for forgiveness later" is dead on arrival. They aren't playing a hidden hand; they're waiting for a legislative lifeline because their lawyers know an independent breakaway is an antitrust suicide mission.
Do you have anything else but supposition? You are talking about two massively valuable billion-dollar conferences backed by massive media networks all of which have tremendous political pull in Washington D.C. Sankey and Petitti's possible objectives are the poorest kept secret in the industry. As long as what they do abides by the rulings in the Alston and House cases they are not politically paralyzed. They have more to fear from the Supreme Court than they would Congress.

Who comprises congress? Will those Senators and Representatives go on record as being against their own state schools' best interests knowing they have the largest alumni base, and they are generally more passionate about their college's sports than politics? I don't think so. Will they go against the sports media giants which also help to shape the news by trying to gouge their best cash cow, sports? I don't think so. Petitti and Sankey aren't scared. They just want to see the lay of the land and then respond.

FWIW, one clear message from the recently proposed Protect College Sports Act…politicians will only help if inclusion and compromise are promoted. A breakaway, is the opposite of any political solution…a breakaway is the proverbial middle finger response that is preventing any potential political intervention. Of the four senators who co-sponsored the bill, three are from P2 states (Cruz, R-TX; Cantwell, D-WA; and Schmitt, R-MO).

For perspective, there are two Texas universities in the P2…both of which are incredibly rich and powerful. By comparison, the NCAA has 56 Texas universities that compete in their sponsored divisions, including 25 universities that compete in the NCAA D1 level. Furthermore, only about one-third of Texas adults have a college degree. It would be political suicide for Congress to get involved in a potential breakaway by a few select elite schools at the expense of the masses.
(This post was last modified: 06-11-2026 04:35 PM by Wahoowa84.)
06-11-2026 04:33 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13521
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #34
RE: NCSU considering suing LSU
(06-11-2026 04:17 PM)FULL_MONTY Wrote:  
(06-11-2026 04:04 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-11-2026 03:53 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(06-11-2026 03:23 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-11-2026 03:20 PM)JRsec Wrote:  That's your narrative, and it is similar to some others, but it is not what is going on for Sankey and Petitti. They simply want as much information about what various parties are seeking and whether Congress intends to act, and if so, what Congress will be seeking and then to get an informed assessment of whether the votes even exist to pass it, before they respond. It's what any corporation would do. You never play your hand until it is called. There are some aspects of the Congressional proposal they favor, some they don't. But the final form has yet to be derived. So, they wait.

There's a massive difference between a calculated corporate wait-and-see strategy and being legally paralyzed. If they're just waiting to see if Congress has the votes, then the grand narrative of an imminent, corporate-backed P2 breakaway super league that "begs for forgiveness later" is dead on arrival. They aren't playing a hidden hand; they're waiting for a legislative lifeline because their lawyers know an independent breakaway is an antitrust suicide mission.

Do you have anything else but supposition? You are talking about two massively valuable billion-dollar conferences backed by massive media networks all of which have tremendous political pull in Washington D.C. Sankey and Petitti's possible objectives are the poorest kept secret in the industry. As long as what they do abides by the rulings in the Alston and House cases they are not politically paralyzed. They have more to fear from the Supreme Court than they would Congress.

Who comprises congress? Will those Senators and Representatives go on record as being against their own state schools' best interests knowing they have the largest alumni base, and they are generally more passionate about their college's sports than politics? I don't think so. Will they go against the sports media giants which also help to shape the news by trying to gouge their best cash cow, sports? I don't think so. Petitti and Sankey aren't scared. They just want to see the lay of the land and then respond.

Accusing me of supposition while claiming Congress bases federal antitrust policy on the passion of football alumni is a curious choice.

More importantly, citing Alston and House completely defeats the argument. Alston was a unanimous 9-0 Supreme Court beatdown that explicitly established that college sports are bound by the Sherman Act, and House is forcing a multi-billion dollar revenue-sharing model. The P2 is quiet precisely because the courts have already proven they will dismantle any independent breakaway that doesn't have explicit Congressional antitrust immunity. They aren't "surveying the lay of the land" -- they're waiting to see if Washington will hand them an umbrella before the legal thunderstorms drowns them.

It's pretty clear that the SEC and B1G are far from being in control at this point. This is as amusing as people believing that largely public Universities using State and Federal dollars are just competing in a free market.

ASU is using eminent domain to oust a home owner to make way for their Medical School. If that isn't a free market action, then nothing is a free market action.

Eminent domain has been misused before and regrettably will likely be misused again. But in the case of a state university, it is more in line with how it was intended than when a city takes an older sub-division to locate businesses because the estimated tax exceeds the ad valorem on the properties.

The argument over free market and state schools should have been made when media rights were collectivized into the hands of their respective conferences. OU/UGa vs the NCAA placed them back in the hands of the schools. The schools then ceded them to the conferences. The conferences then sold them for a set period of time to the media that would broadcast them, and some of them sublet them. That's all pretty much how business happens. To date no court has taken them back from a media company. And yet the heart of the issue regarding realignment is tied up in media companies encouraging the taking of other properties by the conference to drive up the valuation on their media deal when it is time to renegotiate it, and if the media company wants the added schools badly enough they offer a pro rata until the contract comes open again.

Nobody is challenging any of that, though the university is tax payer funded and is a state institution. I think Frank the Tank has covered a good deal of that angle in the past here.

What the NCAA and all of the rest should be very afraid of is the NCAA's revenue sharing model. It violates state's rights and taxpayer obligations when funds withheld during a paid competition are used to assist a program from a different state.

OU/UGa took the right of the NCAA to manage a revenue sport away from them. The precedent is now there for basketball, baseball, or any sport which is revenue producing. Those rights belong to the school and not the NCAA per that ruling.

The Big Ten and SEC are hardly scared of anything. They are billion-dollar enterprises. If Congress tempers the Alston or House implications through passed legislation that may benefit them, but being forced back into a media bundle would be in violation of established law. They know their rights already and have since 1983. And they stand quite prepared to abide by the ruling of the Supreme Court on both the House and Alston cases and know what kind of legal restraints they can place on the Portal (contracts) and what kind of cap they can set on players salaries (collective bargaining).

All they are doing in the meantime is waiting to see exactly what comes out of Congress. Congress granted the NCAA the largess they lost in 1983 over revenue producing football. All state schools were observant of Title IX when it impacted athletics in the mid 70's. To think that the large state institutions are going to be powerless before Congress when Supreme Court rulings have met with the full compliance in the past and will in the future is just fiction. They may not like everything they have to comply with, but it will not impact their status, and it is highly doubtful it would impact the formation of a different tier. All that need be argued is the number of schools moving up yearly from FCS to FBS so they can draw funds from the NCAA that are derived off of another revenue sport of most of the large state universities and frankly from many of the mid level programs to boot, basketball.

Nothing is going to change the classification structure of the FBS. It is revenue predicated. And revenue predicated with those in the G classification of schools all being subsidized at least 25% and the majority by much more, just so they can offer sports. That subsidy is also taxpayer funded.

It seems to me the reverse of what you each suggest is likelier to come true. And that it will be imposed by factors beyond the control of government, like the enrollment cliff where the largest state schools are building additional housing for the students that will head their way as smaller state schools are either closed or given a specific discipline like nursing, teaching, etc. And that A.I. is going to sink the R.O.I. on many non STEM degree fields at even a higher rate in the future and that too will impact college enrollment, and that states realizing that they can't squeeze blood from the proverbial turnip will see to cut subsidies for duplicate sports at smaller state schools. The fear here, and it is quite palpable, is that the top schools will get to form an upper tier. It is not the the SEC and Big Ten would have to continue funding the NCAA through the basketball tournament. They do that already.

And the original congressional statement only said that the Big Ten and SEC couldn't continue to expand until the rights were back in the hands of the school seeking membership. That's quite different from "can't expand." By the original reading of the proposed bill the GOR signed for the conference which sold the media rights has to expire before they can move.

Now that's bad news for schools in the ACC and Big 12 which have hopes to move now, but worse news for those in the ACC which have to wait a decade. But none of that impacts where the SEC and Big Ten currently stand. And since the worst that could happen to the SEC and Big Ten would be to remain bound to the NCAA for basketball, baseball, softball, etc., they aren't afraid of anything. They are fat now. If they get to breakaway they'll get richer and that will help cover the reparations which they know about and are making, and the cost of paying players. Until then the impact of remaining as is would be much less severe to them than it would be to the rest. Would they be impacted? Sure. But they would still be making 40 million more than the ACC and Big 12 which are making 15 to 20 million more than most of the rest.

So no, I don't buy anything that talks about how the top state universities in this nation in a few conferences mostly comprised of the oldest state universities in this country have anything to fear from Congress, the NCAA or the rest of the schools. If the news is bad for Petitti and Sankey nothing has changed, and I mean nothing. They still keep all of their football revenue and will be less motivate than every to share a nickel of it with anyone not in the SEC or Big Ten which means scheduling all games between the two of them or possibly the P4 depending on where they stand. No FCS and no G or lower games. That will get them another boost in media revenue when the time comes. They are free to conduct their own internal playoff and have a game where their champs meet. That too makes them more money without violating anything.

So sorry guys, I don't buy your argument that they have anything to fear because the worst that can happen for them is status quo. Meanwhile what can happen to the rest will be more dire because the obligations are there for them as well and the ability to generate more revenue from your football media contracts is not gong to be proportional to the costs

Personally, I think they breakaway and start a new tier. The best that can happen for the NCAA is that the compromise requires basketball to stay with them, along with other revenue from tournaments like baseball, softball, lacrosse, hockey, etc.

And all of that against the backdrop of declining enrollment, and it will be declining, and the impact of more A.I., the lack of job creation that pays a living wage beyond mid management, coupled with automation is going to make for a helluva headwind for those seeking a degree.

Say what you will, if I'm wrong and you are right, I'll come back and rep you. You don't even have to do the same.

Sine Die.
06-11-2026 05:08 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13521
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #35
RE: NCSU considering suing LSU
(06-11-2026 04:33 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(06-11-2026 03:53 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(06-11-2026 03:23 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-11-2026 03:20 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(06-11-2026 03:05 PM)msu35 Wrote:  ...or the B1G and SEC are remaining silent because their high-dollar representation is telling them the exact opposite.

That's your narrative, and it is similar to some others, but it is not what is going on for Sankey and Petitti. They simply want as much information about what various parties are seeking and whether Congress intends to act, and if so, what Congress will be seeking and then to get an informed assessment of whether the votes even exist to pass it, before they respond. It's what any corporation would do. You never play your hand until it is called. There are some aspects of the Congressional proposal they favor, some they don't. But the final form has yet to be derived. So, they wait.

There's a massive difference between a calculated corporate wait-and-see strategy and being legally paralyzed. If they're just waiting to see if Congress has the votes, then the grand narrative of an imminent, corporate-backed P2 breakaway super league that "begs for forgiveness later" is dead on arrival. They aren't playing a hidden hand; they're waiting for a legislative lifeline because their lawyers know an independent breakaway is an antitrust suicide mission.
Do you have anything else but supposition? You are talking about two massively valuable billion-dollar conferences backed by massive media networks all of which have tremendous political pull in Washington D.C. Sankey and Petitti's possible objectives are the poorest kept secret in the industry. As long as what they do abides by the rulings in the Alston and House cases they are not politically paralyzed. They have more to fear from the Supreme Court than they would Congress.

Who comprises congress? Will those Senators and Representatives go on record as being against their own state schools' best interests knowing they have the largest alumni base, and they are generally more passionate about their college's sports than politics? I don't think so. Will they go against the sports media giants which also help to shape the news by trying to gouge their best cash cow, sports? I don't think so. Petitti and Sankey aren't scared. They just want to see the lay of the land and then respond.

FWIW, one clear message from the recently proposed Protect College Sports Act…politicians will only help if inclusion and compromise are promoted. A breakaway, is the opposite of any political solution…a breakaway is the proverbial middle finger response that is preventing any potential political intervention. Of the four senators who co-sponsored the bill, three are from P2 states (Cruz, R-TX; Cantwell, D-WA; and Schmitt, R-MO).

For perspective, there are two Texas universities in the P2…both of which are incredibly rich and powerful. By comparison, the NCAA has 56 Texas universities that compete in their sponsored divisions, including 25 universities that compete in the NCAA D1 level. Furthermore, only about one-third of Texas adults have a college degree. It would be political suicide for Congress to get involved in a potential breakaway by a few select elite schools at the expense of the masses.

No sir. It's simply not the type of political solution you are looking for. And the burden for the other 56 Texas schools belongs to Texas, not to Congress. It is at the state level that the downsizing of higher education will occur precisely because it will have political fallout and that is precisely why Senators and Congressmen will be wont to be involved in a visible way with any action on their part. Damned if they do (offends large state U donors in their home states and a considerable size of alumni) and Damned if they don't (as you pointed out).
06-11-2026 05:15 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
msu35 Offline
Observing Reality
*

Posts: 21,517
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2229
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
Post: #36
RE: NCSU considering suing LSU
To objectively evaluate where college athletics is heading, it's helpful to look past conference-level positioning and focus on the rigid federal legal boundaries governing the industry. The theories of a total, exclusive "P2 breakaway" or an insulated, unregulated market run into immediate, insurmountable conflicts with modern antitrust law and statutory reality.

The premise that the B1G and SEC can seamlessly form an independent upper tier and set internal salary caps or transfer restrictions via "collective bargaining" contains a massive legal contradiction. Under federal labor law, collective bargaining and salary caps are legally impossible unless the athletes are formally classified as employees of the universities or the conferences. The problem is that if players are employees, institutions face massive structural exposures, including state/federal payroll taxes, workers' compensation liabilities, and strict Title IX compliance. Because Title IX applies to the educational institution as a whole, an institution can't selectively professionalize its football team while leaving its women's programs under an amateur model without facing immediate, catastrophic civil rights litigation.

If the players aren't employees, any collective attempt by an independent breakaway league to set salary caps, restrict the transfer portal, or enforce roster limits constitutes an explicit, textbook horizontal restraint of trade under the Sherman Antitrust Act. As established unanimously by the Supreme Court in NCAA v. Alston (2021), commercial sports entertainment cartels possess zero inherent immunity from federal antitrust law.

The introduction of the bipartisan Protect College Sports Act by the Senate Commerce Committee demonstrates why Congress -- not individual states -- holds the structural power. The bill doesn't offer a blank check for an exclusive super-league; instead, it utilizes a highly calculated "carrot-and-stick" mechanism. It offers a targeted, conditional antitrust exemption to help schools enforce the House v. NCAA revenue-sharing caps and stabilize the transfer portal.

To receive this legal protection, the Act explicitly includes anti-consolidation guardrails aimed at preventing the total fragmentation of the FBS. The legislative math is clear on this. If the B1G and SEC attempt an exclusive breakaway outside of this federal framework, they lose the antitrust shield. This leaves them completely exposed in federal court against a relentless barrage of ongoing player and agent lawsuits. The P2 conferences are engaging heavily with Washington because they recognize this "status quo" means unlimited retroactive damages and structural instability.

Citing NCAA v. Board of Regents (1984) as a precedent for conference autonomy over labor markets is a fundamental misinterpretation of sports law history. Board of Regents dealt strictly with media broadcast rights; the property right of a school to sell its television appearances. It established that the NCAA could not artificially restrict the supply of televised games. What it didn't do was grant conferences the right to restrict labor markets. In fact, the antitrust principles used by the Supreme Court to rule against the NCAA in 1984 are the exact same legal foundations used by plaintiffs to dismantle amateurism regulations in Alston and House. While media companies can freely negotiate TV contracts, they can't contractually insulate a sports league from federal antitrust laws governing how that league treats its labor force.

Arguments regarding "state's rights" or the funding mechanisms of smaller programs do not alter federal commerce jurisdictions. The reality is that the NCAA is a voluntary, private 501( c)(3) association. Its revenue-sharing distribution models (such as tournament units) are governed by private contract law, not state sovereignty. If a state university disagrees with the distribution, its legal recourse is to exit the association, not to claim a Tenth Amendment violation. While it's true that many G6 and lower-tier institutions subsidize their athletic departments through institutional fees or state funds, this has no bearing on federal antitrust liability. A multi-billion-dollar commercial enterprise is bound by the Sherman Act regardless of whether its competitors are subsidized or facing enrollment shifts.

The takeaway is that the trajectory of college sports isn't being driven by conference loyalty, regional sentiment, or macro-demographic trends like enrollment cliffs. It's trapped within a rigid legal box. The P2 conferences can't execute an exclusive breakaway minor-league model because they lack the legal infrastructure to do so safely. Without a comprehensive federal statute like the Protect College Sports Act to shield them, an independent tier would be instantly dismantled by the federal judiciary under existing antitrust precedents. The delay we're seeing isn't a strategic choice -- it's a mandatory pause while the industry waits to see if Washington will provide the legal shield required to simply survive.
06-11-2026 05:58 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
WhidbeyWolf Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,596
Joined: Jul 2025
Reputation: 242
I Root For: Wolfpack
Location: Olympic Shadow
Post: #37
RE: NCSU considering suing LSU
(06-11-2026 02:53 PM)JRsec Wrote:  And meanwhile Storrs and Disney are watching this and not saying a word. Why would that be the case amid what is their family of properties until at least 2034?

Oh, I don't know, maybe it gives them what they've needed for some time now, a reason, uhm, excuse, to utilize the decreasing exit fee windows they helped to create so they can move the properties they most want to keep to where those properties new revenue totals will secure them for some time to come. After all that preserves ESPN's profit structure while reducing overhead at best and keeping a wash in outlay at worst. How? Then they can roll over the other 9 to 11 properties into a pot pie of Big 12 and former ACC brands all of a similar value and split the tab with FOX. Between the two groups FOX gets games in the Southeast (which they have wanted) and ESPN and FOX have enough late-night West Coast football to fill their time slots for games ending after midnight Eastern Time.

Why shouldn't N.C. State file suit against LSU? LSU will be in a super conference, and N.C. State might not be. They are likely sick and tired of being discounted behind UNC and realize that it would take state intervention to get a better home for themselves. A lawsuit might be a good means of gauging their support within the Universities of North Carolina System, and making their legislature notice their plight. It is a better political tactic than the actual case.

Why shouldn't the MAC commissioner gripe about the P4. He's going to be getting less and less revenue when some of the remnants of the Big 12 and ACC start filling other time slots because they draw larger audiences. And as Full Monty alluded to, he can't siphon off funds from the Big Ten and SEC or any P4 which now will schedule more P games and fewer games against the MAC, and should they pull out altogether they won't be paying the kitty for the NCAA tournament. For him it's pretty much sour grapes which face it are what a great many posters spew about here. Think of it as the Howard Beal catharsis. "I'm mad as hell and I'm not going to take it anymore!" Look it up if you are under 60.

Of course there is more discourse. Big damn changes are coming, and nobody is certain how far they will go, or if they will be curtailed, because the Congress's impact will be a grab bag in that neither side will know what they will get. The NCAA is neutered and muzzled and can't sanction anything. There is no new governing body. Nobody can state what NIL is and isn't. How each conference will provide pay to athletes is miles away from consensus. And as with the case in 1983 (Oklahoma and Georgia vs the NCAA) the courts have changed the paradigm. Corporations will rush into the dead space where presidents are thinking what comes next, just like outside private equity entities with capital infusion plans for a % of the profits, and all of that frankly produces the impetus for the SEC and Big Ten to want to do their own thing so they can work with the SCOTUS ruling to set operational guidelines to prevent the lawsuits being between schools from different conferences becoming lawsuits between schools in the same conference. Or something even worse like Texas Tech QB fiasco.

The problem for the Big Ten and SEC and why you haven't heard a mumbling word from either of them for over a week, is that they don't want to jump and then deal with Congress. They want Congress to jump so they know what it is exactly they need to do. But if we go into the midterms without any Congressional direction they may well act while trusting it is easier to get forgiveness than approval (especially if you are comprised of sizeable voting alumni groups).

For all of you who keep yelling anti-trust setting up a new format in response to Supreme Court rulings and accepting schools which want to be a part of that and can afford the minimum investment levels isn't anti-trust, has historically received cooperation from the courts if they are meeting court mandates, and would not be competing with anyone left in any other system of college football because their rules and governance and structure would be different and because it was done in conjunction with court compliance.

Now all of that said we still have what we have, a big damn mess. But it is no more the fault of the Big Ten and SEC than it is the Ivy League or any conference. It is a direct result of the NCAA's failure to adapt to the times, or the ignoring of inferences from those advising them pertaining to the court cases prior to the rulings. In a strong wind that which will not bend breaks. The NCAA broke. And that's why they have no credibility with regard to governance. And there is where the blame resides. Now rather than muddying the waters they need to go away and let every tier of collegiate athletics organize itself as it benefits schools facing the same financial stressors befitting their tier.

The second problem here is that most college presidents don't want to have to deal with a sports mess. They want to direct education at their institutions. So now that the mess is here, they are the least prepared as a whole to know where to even start to rebuild it.

When you have this much stress, and this little leadership, of course it is disharmonious.

I suspect that if nothing constructive comes to the forefront of discussion that it is highly likely the SEC and Big Ten make a move and that any institution of their scope and financial means will likely want to be a part of it, and will very likely be welcomed. But first the parameters will have to be set and they can't be set if nobody moves first. And when the SEC and Big Ten move together, expect their media partners to have a big say about what constitutes the scope of that tier.

THERE it is.
06-11-2026 06:08 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
FULL_MONTY Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,058
Joined: Jun 2005
Reputation: 134
I Root For:
Location:
Post: #38
RE: NCSU considering suing LSU
(06-11-2026 05:58 PM)msu35 Wrote:  To objectively evaluate where college athletics is heading, it's helpful to look past conference-level positioning and focus on the rigid federal legal boundaries governing the industry. The theories of a total, exclusive "P2 breakaway" or an insulated, unregulated market run into immediate, insurmountable conflicts with modern antitrust law and statutory reality.

The premise that the B1G and SEC can seamlessly form an independent upper tier and set internal salary caps or transfer restrictions via "collective bargaining" contains a massive legal contradiction. Under federal labor law, collective bargaining and salary caps are legally impossible unless the athletes are formally classified as employees of the universities or the conferences. The problem is that if players are employees, institutions face massive structural exposures, including state/federal payroll taxes, workers' compensation liabilities, and strict Title IX compliance. Because Title IX applies to the educational institution as a whole, an institution can't selectively professionalize its football team while leaving its women's programs under an amateur model without facing immediate, catastrophic civil rights litigation.

If the players aren't employees, any collective attempt by an independent breakaway league to set salary caps, restrict the transfer portal, or enforce roster limits constitutes an explicit, textbook horizontal restraint of trade under the Sherman Antitrust Act. As established unanimously by the Supreme Court in NCAA v. Alston (2021), commercial sports entertainment cartels possess zero inherent immunity from federal antitrust law.

The introduction of the bipartisan Protect College Sports Act by the Senate Commerce Committee demonstrates why Congress -- not individual states -- holds the structural power. The bill doesn't offer a blank check for an exclusive super-league; instead, it utilizes a highly calculated "carrot-and-stick" mechanism. It offers a targeted, conditional antitrust exemption to help schools enforce the House v. NCAA revenue-sharing caps and stabilize the transfer portal.

To receive this legal protection, the Act explicitly includes anti-consolidation guardrails aimed at preventing the total fragmentation of the FBS. The legislative math is clear on this. If the B1G and SEC attempt an exclusive breakaway outside of this federal framework, they lose the antitrust shield. This leaves them completely exposed in federal court against a relentless barrage of ongoing player and agent lawsuits. The P2 conferences are engaging heavily with Washington because they recognize this "status quo" means unlimited retroactive damages and structural instability.

Citing NCAA v. Board of Regents (1984) as a precedent for conference autonomy over labor markets is a fundamental misinterpretation of sports law history. Board of Regents dealt strictly with media broadcast rights; the property right of a school to sell its television appearances. It established that the NCAA could not artificially restrict the supply of televised games. What it didn't do was grant conferences the right to restrict labor markets. In fact, the antitrust principles used by the Supreme Court to rule against the NCAA in 1984 are the exact same legal foundations used by plaintiffs to dismantle amateurism regulations in Alston and House. While media companies can freely negotiate TV contracts, they can't contractually insulate a sports league from federal antitrust laws governing how that league treats its labor force.

Arguments regarding "state's rights" or the funding mechanisms of smaller programs do not alter federal commerce jurisdictions. The reality is that the NCAA is a voluntary, private 501( c)(3) association. Its revenue-sharing distribution models (such as tournament units) are governed by private contract law, not state sovereignty. If a state university disagrees with the distribution, its legal recourse is to exit the association, not to claim a Tenth Amendment violation. While it's true that many G6 and lower-tier institutions subsidize their athletic departments through institutional fees or state funds, this has no bearing on federal antitrust liability. A multi-billion-dollar commercial enterprise is bound by the Sherman Act regardless of whether its competitors are subsidized or facing enrollment shifts.

The takeaway is that the trajectory of college sports isn't being driven by conference loyalty, regional sentiment, or macro-demographic trends like enrollment cliffs. It's trapped within a rigid legal box. The P2 conferences can't execute an exclusive breakaway minor-league model because they lack the legal infrastructure to do so safely. Without a comprehensive federal statute like the Protect College Sports Act to shield them, an independent tier would be instantly dismantled by the federal judiciary under existing antitrust precedents. The delay we're seeing isn't a strategic choice -- it's a mandatory pause while the industry waits to see if Washington will provide the legal shield required to simply survive.

Honestly, no one wants to hit bottom, but that's what is going to happen here. There aren't 60 votes to get over the filibuster in the senate for the current bill. The SEC and B1G learned via the SCORE bill that they may have the muscle to force the NCAA who has limited involvement in college football to foot 40% of the house settlement to solve a largely football problem but is miles short of being able to get any legislative help on their own.

Everyone was reticent to file lawsuits but that bandaid has been ripped. I think we are in the beginning stages of litigation.
06-11-2026 06:16 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
msu35 Offline
Observing Reality
*

Posts: 21,517
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2229
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
Post: #39
RE: NCSU considering suing LSU
(06-11-2026 06:16 PM)FULL_MONTY Wrote:  
(06-11-2026 05:58 PM)msu35 Wrote:  To objectively evaluate where college athletics is heading, it's helpful to look past conference-level positioning and focus on the rigid federal legal boundaries governing the industry. The theories of a total, exclusive "P2 breakaway" or an insulated, unregulated market run into immediate, insurmountable conflicts with modern antitrust law and statutory reality.

The premise that the B1G and SEC can seamlessly form an independent upper tier and set internal salary caps or transfer restrictions via "collective bargaining" contains a massive legal contradiction. Under federal labor law, collective bargaining and salary caps are legally impossible unless the athletes are formally classified as employees of the universities or the conferences. The problem is that if players are employees, institutions face massive structural exposures, including state/federal payroll taxes, workers' compensation liabilities, and strict Title IX compliance. Because Title IX applies to the educational institution as a whole, an institution can't selectively professionalize its football team while leaving its women's programs under an amateur model without facing immediate, catastrophic civil rights litigation.

If the players aren't employees, any collective attempt by an independent breakaway league to set salary caps, restrict the transfer portal, or enforce roster limits constitutes an explicit, textbook horizontal restraint of trade under the Sherman Antitrust Act. As established unanimously by the Supreme Court in NCAA v. Alston (2021), commercial sports entertainment cartels possess zero inherent immunity from federal antitrust law.

The introduction of the bipartisan Protect College Sports Act by the Senate Commerce Committee demonstrates why Congress -- not individual states -- holds the structural power. The bill doesn't offer a blank check for an exclusive super-league; instead, it utilizes a highly calculated "carrot-and-stick" mechanism. It offers a targeted, conditional antitrust exemption to help schools enforce the House v. NCAA revenue-sharing caps and stabilize the transfer portal.

To receive this legal protection, the Act explicitly includes anti-consolidation guardrails aimed at preventing the total fragmentation of the FBS. The legislative math is clear on this. If the B1G and SEC attempt an exclusive breakaway outside of this federal framework, they lose the antitrust shield. This leaves them completely exposed in federal court against a relentless barrage of ongoing player and agent lawsuits. The P2 conferences are engaging heavily with Washington because they recognize this "status quo" means unlimited retroactive damages and structural instability.

Citing NCAA v. Board of Regents (1984) as a precedent for conference autonomy over labor markets is a fundamental misinterpretation of sports law history. Board of Regents dealt strictly with media broadcast rights; the property right of a school to sell its television appearances. It established that the NCAA could not artificially restrict the supply of televised games. What it didn't do was grant conferences the right to restrict labor markets. In fact, the antitrust principles used by the Supreme Court to rule against the NCAA in 1984 are the exact same legal foundations used by plaintiffs to dismantle amateurism regulations in Alston and House. While media companies can freely negotiate TV contracts, they can't contractually insulate a sports league from federal antitrust laws governing how that league treats its labor force.

Arguments regarding "state's rights" or the funding mechanisms of smaller programs do not alter federal commerce jurisdictions. The reality is that the NCAA is a voluntary, private 501( c)(3) association. Its revenue-sharing distribution models (such as tournament units) are governed by private contract law, not state sovereignty. If a state university disagrees with the distribution, its legal recourse is to exit the association, not to claim a Tenth Amendment violation. While it's true that many G6 and lower-tier institutions subsidize their athletic departments through institutional fees or state funds, this has no bearing on federal antitrust liability. A multi-billion-dollar commercial enterprise is bound by the Sherman Act regardless of whether its competitors are subsidized or facing enrollment shifts.

The takeaway is that the trajectory of college sports isn't being driven by conference loyalty, regional sentiment, or macro-demographic trends like enrollment cliffs. It's trapped within a rigid legal box. The P2 conferences can't execute an exclusive breakaway minor-league model because they lack the legal infrastructure to do so safely. Without a comprehensive federal statute like the Protect College Sports Act to shield them, an independent tier would be instantly dismantled by the federal judiciary under existing antitrust precedents. The delay we're seeing isn't a strategic choice -- it's a mandatory pause while the industry waits to see if Washington will provide the legal shield required to simply survive.

Honestly, no one wants to hit bottom, but that's what is going to happen here. There aren't 60 votes to get over the filibuster in the senate for the current bill. The SEC and B1G learned via the SCORE bill that they may have the muscle to force the NCAA who has limited involvement in college football to foot 40% of the house settlement to solve a largely football problem but is miles short of being able to get any legislative help on their own.

Everyone was reticent to file lawsuits but that bandaid has been ripped. I think we are in the beginning stages of litigation.

Unfortunately, I have to agree. If Congress remains deadlocked, the result isn't a triumphant P2 breakaway minor league; the result is total structural paralysis. The major conferences simply can't move forward into an exclusive upper tier because the federal judiciary will dismantle it the moment it's formed. The push for a federal solution isn't a luxury the B1G and SEC are flirting with. Objectively, it's the only viable exit strategy they have from a relentless cycle of destruction through litigation. Those with the most money and power are typically the primary target -- can't squeeze blood from a G6 turnip.
06-11-2026 06:24 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
FULL_MONTY Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,058
Joined: Jun 2005
Reputation: 134
I Root For:
Location:
Post: #40
RE: NCSU considering suing LSU
(06-11-2026 06:24 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-11-2026 06:16 PM)FULL_MONTY Wrote:  
(06-11-2026 05:58 PM)msu35 Wrote:  To objectively evaluate where college athletics is heading, it's helpful to look past conference-level positioning and focus on the rigid federal legal boundaries governing the industry. The theories of a total, exclusive "P2 breakaway" or an insulated, unregulated market run into immediate, insurmountable conflicts with modern antitrust law and statutory reality.

The premise that the B1G and SEC can seamlessly form an independent upper tier and set internal salary caps or transfer restrictions via "collective bargaining" contains a massive legal contradiction. Under federal labor law, collective bargaining and salary caps are legally impossible unless the athletes are formally classified as employees of the universities or the conferences. The problem is that if players are employees, institutions face massive structural exposures, including state/federal payroll taxes, workers' compensation liabilities, and strict Title IX compliance. Because Title IX applies to the educational institution as a whole, an institution can't selectively professionalize its football team while leaving its women's programs under an amateur model without facing immediate, catastrophic civil rights litigation.

If the players aren't employees, any collective attempt by an independent breakaway league to set salary caps, restrict the transfer portal, or enforce roster limits constitutes an explicit, textbook horizontal restraint of trade under the Sherman Antitrust Act. As established unanimously by the Supreme Court in NCAA v. Alston (2021), commercial sports entertainment cartels possess zero inherent immunity from federal antitrust law.

The introduction of the bipartisan Protect College Sports Act by the Senate Commerce Committee demonstrates why Congress -- not individual states -- holds the structural power. The bill doesn't offer a blank check for an exclusive super-league; instead, it utilizes a highly calculated "carrot-and-stick" mechanism. It offers a targeted, conditional antitrust exemption to help schools enforce the House v. NCAA revenue-sharing caps and stabilize the transfer portal.

To receive this legal protection, the Act explicitly includes anti-consolidation guardrails aimed at preventing the total fragmentation of the FBS. The legislative math is clear on this. If the B1G and SEC attempt an exclusive breakaway outside of this federal framework, they lose the antitrust shield. This leaves them completely exposed in federal court against a relentless barrage of ongoing player and agent lawsuits. The P2 conferences are engaging heavily with Washington because they recognize this "status quo" means unlimited retroactive damages and structural instability.

Citing NCAA v. Board of Regents (1984) as a precedent for conference autonomy over labor markets is a fundamental misinterpretation of sports law history. Board of Regents dealt strictly with media broadcast rights; the property right of a school to sell its television appearances. It established that the NCAA could not artificially restrict the supply of televised games. What it didn't do was grant conferences the right to restrict labor markets. In fact, the antitrust principles used by the Supreme Court to rule against the NCAA in 1984 are the exact same legal foundations used by plaintiffs to dismantle amateurism regulations in Alston and House. While media companies can freely negotiate TV contracts, they can't contractually insulate a sports league from federal antitrust laws governing how that league treats its labor force.

Arguments regarding "state's rights" or the funding mechanisms of smaller programs do not alter federal commerce jurisdictions. The reality is that the NCAA is a voluntary, private 501( c)(3) association. Its revenue-sharing distribution models (such as tournament units) are governed by private contract law, not state sovereignty. If a state university disagrees with the distribution, its legal recourse is to exit the association, not to claim a Tenth Amendment violation. While it's true that many G6 and lower-tier institutions subsidize their athletic departments through institutional fees or state funds, this has no bearing on federal antitrust liability. A multi-billion-dollar commercial enterprise is bound by the Sherman Act regardless of whether its competitors are subsidized or facing enrollment shifts.

The takeaway is that the trajectory of college sports isn't being driven by conference loyalty, regional sentiment, or macro-demographic trends like enrollment cliffs. It's trapped within a rigid legal box. The P2 conferences can't execute an exclusive breakaway minor-league model because they lack the legal infrastructure to do so safely. Without a comprehensive federal statute like the Protect College Sports Act to shield them, an independent tier would be instantly dismantled by the federal judiciary under existing antitrust precedents. The delay we're seeing isn't a strategic choice -- it's a mandatory pause while the industry waits to see if Washington will provide the legal shield required to simply survive.

Honestly, no one wants to hit bottom, but that's what is going to happen here. There aren't 60 votes to get over the filibuster in the senate for the current bill. The SEC and B1G learned via the SCORE bill that they may have the muscle to force the NCAA who has limited involvement in college football to foot 40% of the house settlement to solve a largely football problem but is miles short of being able to get any legislative help on their own.

Everyone was reticent to file lawsuits but that bandaid has been ripped. I think we are in the beginning stages of litigation.

Unfortunately, I have to agree. If Congress remains deadlocked, the result isn't a triumphant P2 breakaway minor league; the result is total structural paralysis. The major conferences simply can't move forward into an exclusive upper tier because the federal judiciary will dismantle it the moment it's formed. The push for a federal solution isn't a luxury the B1G and SEC are flirting with. Objectively, it's the only viable exit strategy they have from a relentless cycle of destruction through litigation. Those with the most money and power are typically the primary target -- can't squeeze blood from a G6 turnip.

The SEC and B1G have done themselves no favors. Even this TTech issue, they are going to be loud and bang on trash cans about the injustice. But as TTech has already put out in the ether, where do you people get off trying to shame and harm us, we didn't have alleged mass sexual abuse across multiple sports, evils perpetrated against children, murder, academic fraud, diversion hospital funds to pay a player, and the like.

A lot of things are going to come home to roost.
06-11-2026 06:39 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.