msu35
Observing Reality

Posts: 21,517
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2229
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
|
RE: Yahoo: Class-action lawsuit filed against NCAA, P4, CSC & over House Settlement
(06-10-2026 04:33 AM)Gitanole Wrote: (06-10-2026 03:48 AM)msu35 Wrote: (06-10-2026 03:12 AM)Gitanole Wrote: (06-10-2026 02:53 AM)msu35 Wrote: (06-10-2026 02:32 AM)Gitanole Wrote: Agree that until a collective bargaining structure is set up it’s going to be hard for the NCAA to make regulation stick. In this case, though, we are not really looking at erosion. The House ruling already had it that enforcement (the Commission) had to operate within state law.
A breakaway group has more latitude to set up its own structures—including collective bargaining mechanisms—and secure its members’ compliance via contract. Membership in the group is voluntary, after all.
Yes, there would still be lawsuits. Someone will always try that. But even if it has to pay an entity here and there by way of apology for the trouble, the group is in better shape to make a long-term go of it. It has successful models to guide it (NFL, etc) and can even point to more effective compliance with law (bargaining rights).
___
First, I appreciate having a healthy discussion with good-faith arguments. It's rare on here.
You make good points, and assuming everything is predicated on a functioning CBA, much of that would hold true. Where I take exception, however, is that a CBA isn't a unilateral choice the league can make. It requires a legally recognized labor union. The process of getting college athletes to unionize, elect leadership, and agree to cap their own earning potential is incredibly complex, and until that happens, the antitrust exposure doesn't go away.
The need for collective bargaining was my point. A big part of it, anyway.
Quote:Regarding a breakaway league, I'm also not convinced it would be so easy to skirt scrutiny. Even a "voluntary" association can be classified as an illegal cartel if it engages in coordinated group boycotts or anti-competitive market restraints. If the fix were as simple as breaking away and signing a new voluntary contract, the P2 would have likely already insulated themselves and formed a super league by now.
No one said anything was simple.
Anything will be scrutinized and everything is complex.
That is why planners would take care before making a major move like a breakaway. It is important to get details right.
A big part of getting things right is paying attention to, and taking seriously, what judges have ruled. Instead of wishing rulings would go away, one incorporates what has been learned. Athletes’ rights are part of the set of givens.
I believe that we're generally in agreement on the core thesis, and a CBA being a pre-requisite was obvious from your initial response -- that was never the challenge. Any stable future requires explicitly integrating athlete rights, likely via unionization and a CBA. Where the disconnect usually happens in these discussions, and why a breakaway isn't the silver bullet many think it is, comes down to a fundamental conflict of interest between the planners and the athletes.
The only reason the networks and conferences want a super league is to create economic growth, which means cost containment (capping player payroll, restricting the transfer portal, and ending bidding wars). The problem is that the athletes have absolutely no legal or financial incentive to form a union just to help the schools cap their wages and restrict their mobility. Under the current open market, the elite players have maximum leverage. Getting them to voluntarily vote away that leverage to help a new league "get the details right" is a massive hurdle and incredibly optimistic.
Assuming the players unionize in the first place, it still faces massive antitrust exposure from the outside. If the P2 forms a closed ecosystem that cuts off the postseason and tier-one television revenue from the remaining FBS schools, that is textbook competitor foreclosure. You don't just face lawsuits from the players at this stage. You're facing predatory antitrust litigation and group boycott claims from the "left-behind" universities and their state Attorneys General, who have nothing left to lose.
That's the real "can of worms" that I alluded to in my prior post. You simply can't just plan your way out of antitrust law by being smart inside your own house if the creation of that house intentionally destroys the enterprise value of everyone outside of it. Without a literal Act of Congress granting an explicit antitrust exemption for this super league, a breakaway league is just a smaller target for the exact same legal assault. College sports are big business now and the conventional wisdom no longer holds -- the Supreme Court has spoken and the aftershocks will continue for years, perhaps even decades, unless the federal government reins it in. That is the likely endgame.
Regarding your paragraph 2: This can probably be handled by taking revshare as the norm. A revenue pie is assembled and slices are distributed by set mathematical rules, with player reps observing and even participating. It’s worth doing for players because the players would rather be part of this breakaway league than whatever the alternatives are. And because they see exactly what the league brings in and are guaranteed their cut of it. There is little reason for players to push for more advantage than the league can afford because everyone has a shared interest in not killing the golden goose that lays the eggs.
In any event, athletes have their own wish lists. They have requests regarding eligibility, health care and disability, validity of degree progress over time, and so on. They naturally would bring these requests to the table as negotiations begin.
The NFL already does all of this. It works, thanks to similar factors. So no great optimism is required. Models exist.
Regarding your paragraph 3: Of course a breakaway league will be sued. That follows for the reasons you mention. From this position, though, a breakaway league has several defenses.
Key is that a breakaway group can seek antitrust protection of the sort other national leagues already have in pro sports. The arguments that worked for them are still on record and available for study. The group can point out that as the league that better ensures players’ rights (CBA, etc), it has earned consideration. And this time, when going to DC with requests, the petitioners can have a focused effort. The league only needs a few specific things. It’s not like now, when some people want realistic options to comply with rulings as others are unrealistically trying to make the same rulings go away, and no one is on the same page.
Being sued is inevitable when you’re conspicuous and have money. Losing, though... that’s on you.
But yes, it’s a complex undertaking and not for the squeamish. Patience is required.
And if all else fails, more Draconian measures exist. Make a big enough mess and the goose can simply be killed. That leaves no gold for anyone to fight over.
That's a highly idealized viewpoint, but it relies on a number of fundamental misconceptions about how professional leagues operate and the unique legal boundaries of public universities.
You suggest that a breakaway league can simply establish a revenue-sharing "pie" with set mathematical rules, and that players will comply because they want to be part of the league. Under federal antitrust law, that is the literal definition of horizontal price-fixing. One has to understand that the NFL can't and doesn't unilaterally set a mathematical revenue pie to cap player costs. The only reason the NFL salary cap is legal is because the NFL Players Association (NFLPA) is a certified labor union that explicitly signs away the players' individual open-market rights via a CBA. If a breakaway college league attempts to implement a "revenue pie" before a union is legally certified, the very first elite five-star recruit who wants to negotiate for more than his "allotted slice" will sue the league for an antitrust violation, and he will certainly win.
You mention that a breakaway group can "seek antitrust protection of the sort other national leagues already have." Frankly, this is historical revisionism. Major League Baseball is the only North American sports league with a general, judicially granted antitrust exemption. It's a 1922 anomaly that the Supreme Court has repeatedly characterized as an aberration they will never replicate. This simply won't happen.
The NFL, NBA, and NHL do not have general antitrust exemptions. The NFL had to lobby Congress for a highly specific, narrow carve-out just to pool its television broadcast rights (the Sports Broadcasting Act of 1961). When it comes to player labor, the NFL gets sued constantly (e.g., Reggie White v. NFL) the moment a CBA expires. The idea that a brand-new corporate cartel of college teams can walk into Washington D.C. and secure a sweeping federal antitrust exemption to cap athlete labor is completely detached from the current political climate.
Finally, the suggestion that planners can simply "kill the goose" if things get too messy ignores what these institutions actually are. The Dallas Cowboys are a private corporation; Ohio State, Alabama, and Texas are public state universities. There is a difference.
These institutions are bound by a century of established tradition, public funding, and deep-rooted commerce. Over the last hundred years, entire regional economies, local businesses, and university systems have invested billions in infrastructure based on the reliance interest of a shared collegiate ecosystem. If a university's board intentionally destroys its own athletic enterprise value or pulls out of historic arrangements to evade legal compliance, they are violating their fiduciary duty to the state. State Attorneys General, taxpayers, and local business coalitions -- most especially from the schools left behind -- will launch a barrage of predatory litigation before the first brick of a breakaway league is ever laid.
Don't misunderstand, being sued is indeed inevitable. Assuming you can simply "plan" your way around the Sherman Act and state property laws without a union or an unprecedented Act of Congress isn't a functional strategy and business plan. Frankly, it's wishful thinking. College sports are a multi-billion dollar business and no amount of boardroom maneuvering can bypass the law. Again, if it were easy, the super league would have already happened. The P2 aren't hanging around in the NCAA because they want to, and again, motivating players to voluntarily give up their current astronomic wages and infinite mobility is going to be exceedingly difficult. Claiming they can be forced without government intervention is a non sequitur -- let's not pretend they can't get paid in the league that was left behind. Hard to have a league without players, so this isn't the simple, binary solution being suggested.
|
|