drherenton
Water Engineer

Posts: 42
Joined: Sep 2021
Reputation: 9
I Root For: memphis
Location:
|
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-09-2026 03:48 PM)msu35 Wrote: (06-09-2026 03:42 PM)drherenton Wrote: If I was USF, I would take that gamble. Fortune favors the bold
That said, it's much easier to be bold if you're USF. Tampa is a growing city, Florida is growing, USF is growing; their enrollment is around 50k, ours is around 20k.
Let's be honest here: if there is another realignment, USF has better prospects than we do.
Financial literacy is important, and bumper sticker slogans change none of the realities of modern realignment. No "power" conference on this planet is inviting a structurally insolvent athletic department. Full stop. Review my prior post if you continue to be confused with regards to the reality of USF's position:
(06-06-2026 02:40 PM)msu35 Wrote: This was from another thread, but it greatly enhances context, so I'm posting it here too:
(06-06-2026 08:12 AM)TIGERCITY Wrote: South Florida is betting with a credit card at the casino recognizing that the next few years are all that matter. You win , you're a big winner , you lose , it doesn't matter anyway.
Frankly, not the same thing at all. Not even close. To be blunt, you probably get better odds at the casino.
One can't treat a $350M+ state-backed capital project like a casual trip to a Vegas blackjack table. A state university can't declare bankruptcy and walk away from a commercial bank note. Director J. Ben Watkins III immediately noticed the extreme structural danger and wrote an explicit warning memo to the Board of Governors outlining the systemic risks.
This is exactly what the State of Florida put on the record, and what it really means for USF, irrespective of their misdirection and spin:
- The 386% Revenue Lie: "Projected stadium revenues were increased by $15.2 million, from $5.3 million to $20.5 million, favorably impacting projected financial performance of the Project."
This reads exactly how it looks. When the interest rate spiked to 7%, the surging cost of the debt service meant USF could no longer legally justify the loan under their original metrics. Instead of acting with prudence by scaling back or postponing, they hired a consultant to suddenly "discover" an extra $15.2 million in annual revenue -- objectively a nearly 400% increase over their original baseline. They fabricated an extreme best-case scenario out of thin air just to make the debt-to-income ratio look legal on paper.
.
- The Ghost Capital: "The revisions to the projections for the Project highlight the uncertainty of future financial performance and dependence on generating substantial untapped revenue sources."
The state is politely calling out a fantasy. That extra $15.2 million in "untapped revenue" has no historical basis in reality for a G6 program that couldn't even generate enough discretionary donor capital to prevent Providence from poaching their conference-champion basketball coach.
.
- Zero Margin for Error: "Whatever conservatism was baked into the original assumptions has been eliminated and revenue projections/financial performance are fully dependent on realizing the consultants estimates."
By wiping out any conservative budgeting buffer to justify the Truist loan, USF has left themselves with literally zero margin for error. For this financing structure not to become an immediate disaster, every single highly volatile variable -- from premium seating donations to naming rights -- must hit 100% execution, perfectly, every single year for two decades.
.
- Compounding Financial Risk: "The material operating risk exacerbates the potential financial pressure on USF's endowment and fundraising efforts..."
Director Watkins is reminding the Board of Governors that USF's original, more conservative model already posed a structural threat to the university's broader endowment and fundraising health. By overlaying a hyper-aggressive, fabricated revenue projection on top of a significantly higher interest rate, they have escalated that pressure from a standard operational risk to a catastrophic one.
.
- The Permanent Lien on USF Athletics: "The debt being incurred is secured by gross revenues from athletics so that any negative operating performance or failure to meet fundraising goals will likely necessitate budget cuts for athletics or require additional subsidies from unrestricted funds from the USF endowment."
This is the ultimate indictment of the "casino" logic. Truist Bank isn't gambling; they have a permanent, legally binding lien on the gross revenues of the athletic department. Before USF pays a single coach, funds a single roster spot, or distributes a dime of NIL, Truist Bank takes their $20M debt service right off the top. If the stadium underperforms by even a fraction, the university faces a brutal choice: trigger immediate, crippling budget cuts across all sports, or systematically raid the university's unrestricted endowment to bail out a football stadium.
.
- The TSA Agreement and Asymmetric Risk: The facility operating framework under the Tampa Sports Authority (TSA) term sheet shifts 100% of the downside financial volatility onto the university while protecting the operator's primary asset.
The TSA's chief institutional priority is -- and always will be -- managing and funding the massive $1B+ upcoming renovations at Raymond James Stadium to keep their primary tenant, the Tampa Bay Buccaneers (the premier sports product in Tampa), locked down long-term. Under the new on-campus operating agreement, the TSA has explicitly insulated itself from any upfront cash exposure. The deal ensures the TSA captures a protected 15% to 20% gross revenue skim from non-USF stadium bookings to offset its own broader operational ecosystem, while requiring the USF Intercollegiate Athletic Association to cover all day-to-day operating overhead. If the consultant's hyper-aggressive ticket sales or event bookings fail to materialize, the TSA's bottom line is legally protected; leaving USF entirely exposed to absorb every single dime of the downside operating deficits. This greatly reduces the feasibility of hitting the unrealistic revenue projections that must materialize to avoid financial disaster.
Stating that if you lose, "it doesn't matter anyway" might make sense if this only impacted football. Where this idea fails is the fact that this places great exposure on both athletics and the health of the entire university. This isn't theoretical, and the only way to avoid disaster is for everything to align perfectly -- for 20 years -- based on an egregious financial fiction. It wouldn't be an exaggeration to state that this places even their oft bragged about AAU membership at risk. AAU isn't a static state, and it's not unprecedented for a school to be stripped of their membership due to financial mismanagement and lapses in governance.
Consider that even an "M2 promotion" won't solve this. No G6 program is receiving an invite at full shares. Even Stanford and Cal were offered 30% revenue shares when they were invited to the ACC. That's not nearly enough for USF when year over year for the next two decades, they start out of the gate in a $20M hole they have to dig out of. Furthermore, playing in the bigger pond means they have to find a way to not only cover their liabilities, they will be required to dramatically scale up their operations to even compete on the court and the field. A "power" conference invite isn't a silver bullet and won't fix this easily. It's far worse than anyone has been admitting.
It's no surprise that the USF Board of Trustees Chairman Will Weatherford -- former Florida Speaker of the House -- has recently stepped down now that the financial realities are coming to fruition. It's better to let this be the "next guy's" problem while retaining all of the political capital tied to plastering your name over the "sunshine and rainbows" marketing spiel and groundbreaking photo ops that lead up to construction. Vibes over competence indeed.
Hopefully this clarifies.
You have done a good job of laying out the financial realities and describing the gambit that USF is undertaking. There are plenty of 'financially literate' individuals at USF and they are behind this plan. These financially literate individuals also recognize the inherent risk in their plans and have still authorized their efforts.
They are neither financially illiterate nor irrational. Given their situation, I think it is worth the risk that they are undertaking.
You state ' No "power" conference on this planet is inviting a structurally insolvent athletic department. Full stop.
Well, apparently the people at USF are either (a) unaware of your statement or (b) differ in your assessment of whether a power conference would be willing to invite them if they are 'structurally insolvent' or © recognize the inherent risk in this proposal but are willing to take that risk because they believe there will be another conference realignment and that the course they are taking would position them better than the remaining AAC members to join a power conference.
I am saying that © makes sense given their current situation and their growth prospects. USF has a better current situation than us and Tampa and USF clearly have a better growth trajectory.
|
|