Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
Protect College Sports Act
Author Message
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,874
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #301
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(06-05-2026 12:00 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(06-04-2026 10:52 PM)Acres Wrote:  Who is Omar’s King in this scenario. Is it the BIG/ SEC or Congress and the masses.

The P2 are picking a fight against populism. Marie Antoinette says hello.

Go ahead and create your own elite club. See how long it takes before you are the center of political base ball, subpoenas and committee hearing.

The SEC/ BIG’s fatal error was going to congress. They’ve gotten the politicians involved. Icarus folly. This bill will fail, but it won’t end well

They’ve just made themselves the foil for populist office seekers.

100% the kings are the Big Ten and SEC and let’s not pretend otherwise.

The rest of college football (or at a minimum Cody Campbell associated with the Big 12 specifically) went to Congress and wrote a bill that straight up targeted the P2. With the very high likelihood that this bill will fail, this will likely kill all legislation for another longer period of time or possibly forever as Congress turns over after the election this November. So, the only progress is going to come from the college conferences working together without federal help… and now the P2 have pretty much zero incentive to give an inch at all (not that they had much incentive to do so before).

The history of populism is also riddled with failure throughout history. It will always come in waves from time to time, but once they get their pound of flesh, those waves die out because you ultimately can’t get growth by simply by cutting the top of society down. Growth doesn’t come from pretending that the most educated or talented should be treated the same as the lowest common denominator and history continues to show that (even if we get those periods of populism from time to time).

Now, you are certainly correct that it was a mistake by everyone involved, including the Big Ten and SEC, to go to the federal government in the first place. I have long said that the federal government shouldn’t be involved at all and there ought to be an open free market for college sports. If schools want to complain about player compensation costs, then stop spending the money and the market will come back into balance just like any other industry would be doing if expenses exceed revenue. The choices are the collectively bargain with the players or let the free market reign. I say let the money flow. Conferences should be able to make as much revenue as they want possible and so should the players.

Do you think anything can happen without anti-trust protection? And why would fb and bb players want to collectively bargain? Those court decisions you love create endless litigation.
06-05-2026 06:00 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Wahoowa84 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,436
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 1176
I Root For: UVa
Location:
Post: #302
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(06-05-2026 06:00 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 12:00 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(06-04-2026 10:52 PM)Acres Wrote:  Who is Omar’s King in this scenario. Is it the BIG/ SEC or Congress and the masses.

The P2 are picking a fight against populism. Marie Antoinette says hello.

Go ahead and create your own elite club. See how long it takes before you are the center of political base ball, subpoenas and committee hearing.

The SEC/ BIG’s fatal error was going to congress. They’ve gotten the politicians involved. Icarus folly. This bill will fail, but it won’t end well

They’ve just made themselves the foil for populist office seekers.

100% the kings are the Big Ten and SEC and let’s not pretend otherwise.

The rest of college football (or at a minimum Cody Campbell associated with the Big 12 specifically) went to Congress and wrote a bill that straight up targeted the P2. With the very high likelihood that this bill will fail, this will likely kill all legislation for another longer period of time or possibly forever as Congress turns over after the election this November. So, the only progress is going to come from the college conferences working together without federal help… and now the P2 have pretty much zero incentive to give an inch at all (not that they had much incentive to do so before).

The history of populism is also riddled with failure throughout history. It will always come in waves from time to time, but once they get their pound of flesh, those waves die out because you ultimately can’t get growth by simply by cutting the top of society down. Growth doesn’t come from pretending that the most educated or talented should be treated the same as the lowest common denominator and history continues to show that (even if we get those periods of populism from time to time).

Now, you are certainly correct that it was a mistake by everyone involved, including the Big Ten and SEC, to go to the federal government in the first place. I have long said that the federal government shouldn’t be involved at all and there ought to be an open free market for college sports. If schools want to complain about player compensation costs, then stop spending the money and the market will come back into balance just like any other industry would be doing if expenses exceed revenue. The choices are the collectively bargain with the players or let the free market reign. I say let the money flow. Conferences should be able to make as much revenue as they want possible and so should the players.

Do you think anything can happen without anti-trust protection? And why would fb and bb players want to collectively bargain? Those court decisions you love create endless litigation.

Isn’t antitrust protection mainly needed to have national standards for NIL and athlete eligibility? In other words, to enable the NCAA and CSC to enforce consistent rules…as opposed to state judges/legislators regulating their local university’s athletics.
06-05-2026 07:42 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Ned Low Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,475
Joined: Nov 2010
Reputation: 561
I Root For: ECU
Location: Durham, NC
Post: #303
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(06-05-2026 07:42 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 06:00 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 12:00 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(06-04-2026 10:52 PM)Acres Wrote:  Who is Omar’s King in this scenario. Is it the BIG/ SEC or Congress and the masses.

The P2 are picking a fight against populism. Marie Antoinette says hello.

Go ahead and create your own elite club. See how long it takes before you are the center of political base ball, subpoenas and committee hearing.

The SEC/ BIG’s fatal error was going to congress. They’ve gotten the politicians involved. Icarus folly. This bill will fail, but it won’t end well

They’ve just made themselves the foil for populist office seekers.

100% the kings are the Big Ten and SEC and let’s not pretend otherwise.

The rest of college football (or at a minimum Cody Campbell associated with the Big 12 specifically) went to Congress and wrote a bill that straight up targeted the P2. With the very high likelihood that this bill will fail, this will likely kill all legislation for another longer period of time or possibly forever as Congress turns over after the election this November. So, the only progress is going to come from the college conferences working together without federal help… and now the P2 have pretty much zero incentive to give an inch at all (not that they had much incentive to do so before).

The history of populism is also riddled with failure throughout history. It will always come in waves from time to time, but once they get their pound of flesh, those waves die out because you ultimately can’t get growth by simply by cutting the top of society down. Growth doesn’t come from pretending that the most educated or talented should be treated the same as the lowest common denominator and history continues to show that (even if we get those periods of populism from time to time).

Now, you are certainly correct that it was a mistake by everyone involved, including the Big Ten and SEC, to go to the federal government in the first place. I have long said that the federal government shouldn’t be involved at all and there ought to be an open free market for college sports. If schools want to complain about player compensation costs, then stop spending the money and the market will come back into balance just like any other industry would be doing if expenses exceed revenue. The choices are the collectively bargain with the players or let the free market reign. I say let the money flow. Conferences should be able to make as much revenue as they want possible and so should the players.

Do you think anything can happen without anti-trust protection? And why would fb and bb players want to collectively bargain? Those court decisions you love create endless litigation.

Isn’t antitrust protection mainly needed to have national standards for NIL and athlete eligibility? In other words, to enable the NCAA and CSC to enforce consistent rules…as opposed to state judges/legislators regulating their local university’s athletics.

Yes, antitrust protections are needed for the reasons you listed. Until rules can be enforced no progress can be made.

Without them, we will continue to have states make it so good ol’ State U has an advantage over their competition in other states.

Would rule breakers continue to act as they do now? Probably. However, they could then be dealt with so severely as to discourage others from doing the same in the future (or so we would hope).
(This post was last modified: 06-05-2026 08:35 PM by Ned Low.)
06-05-2026 08:33 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Online
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,947
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #304
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(06-05-2026 08:33 PM)Ned Low Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 07:42 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 06:00 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 12:00 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(06-04-2026 10:52 PM)Acres Wrote:  Who is Omar’s King in this scenario. Is it the BIG/ SEC or Congress and the masses.

The P2 are picking a fight against populism. Marie Antoinette says hello.

Go ahead and create your own elite club. See how long it takes before you are the center of political base ball, subpoenas and committee hearing.

The SEC/ BIG’s fatal error was going to congress. They’ve gotten the politicians involved. Icarus folly. This bill will fail, but it won’t end well

They’ve just made themselves the foil for populist office seekers.

100% the kings are the Big Ten and SEC and let’s not pretend otherwise.

The rest of college football (or at a minimum Cody Campbell associated with the Big 12 specifically) went to Congress and wrote a bill that straight up targeted the P2. With the very high likelihood that this bill will fail, this will likely kill all legislation for another longer period of time or possibly forever as Congress turns over after the election this November. So, the only progress is going to come from the college conferences working together without federal help… and now the P2 have pretty much zero incentive to give an inch at all (not that they had much incentive to do so before).

The history of populism is also riddled with failure throughout history. It will always come in waves from time to time, but once they get their pound of flesh, those waves die out because you ultimately can’t get growth by simply by cutting the top of society down. Growth doesn’t come from pretending that the most educated or talented should be treated the same as the lowest common denominator and history continues to show that (even if we get those periods of populism from time to time).

Now, you are certainly correct that it was a mistake by everyone involved, including the Big Ten and SEC, to go to the federal government in the first place. I have long said that the federal government shouldn’t be involved at all and there ought to be an open free market for college sports. If schools want to complain about player compensation costs, then stop spending the money and the market will come back into balance just like any other industry would be doing if expenses exceed revenue. The choices are the collectively bargain with the players or let the free market reign. I say let the money flow. Conferences should be able to make as much revenue as they want possible and so should the players.

Do you think anything can happen without anti-trust protection? And why would fb and bb players want to collectively bargain? Those court decisions you love create endless litigation.

Isn’t antitrust protection mainly needed to have national standards for NIL and athlete eligibility? In other words, to enable the NCAA and CSC to enforce consistent rules…as opposed to state judges/legislators regulating their local university’s athletics.

Yes, antitrust protections are needed for the reasons you listed. Until rules can be enforced no progress can be made.

Without them, we will continue to have states make it so good ol’ State U has an advantage over their competition in other states.

Would rule breakers continue to act as they do now? Probably. However, they could then be dealt with so severely as to discourage others from doing the same in the future (or so we would hope).

Would be the height of irony if Saban ends up as College Sports Czar. Would he actually hammer anybody for coloring outside the lines? Hard to see how he could do it with a straight face.
06-05-2026 09:42 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Ned Low Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,475
Joined: Nov 2010
Reputation: 561
I Root For: ECU
Location: Durham, NC
Post: #305
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(06-05-2026 09:42 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 08:33 PM)Ned Low Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 07:42 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 06:00 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 12:00 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  100% the kings are the Big Ten and SEC and let’s not pretend otherwise.

The rest of college football (or at a minimum Cody Campbell associated with the Big 12 specifically) went to Congress and wrote a bill that straight up targeted the P2. With the very high likelihood that this bill will fail, this will likely kill all legislation for another longer period of time or possibly forever as Congress turns over after the election this November. So, the only progress is going to come from the college conferences working together without federal help… and now the P2 have pretty much zero incentive to give an inch at all (not that they had much incentive to do so before).

The history of populism is also riddled with failure throughout history. It will always come in waves from time to time, but once they get their pound of flesh, those waves die out because you ultimately can’t get growth by simply by cutting the top of society down. Growth doesn’t come from pretending that the most educated or talented should be treated the same as the lowest common denominator and history continues to show that (even if we get those periods of populism from time to time).

Now, you are certainly correct that it was a mistake by everyone involved, including the Big Ten and SEC, to go to the federal government in the first place. I have long said that the federal government shouldn’t be involved at all and there ought to be an open free market for college sports. If schools want to complain about player compensation costs, then stop spending the money and the market will come back into balance just like any other industry would be doing if expenses exceed revenue. The choices are the collectively bargain with the players or let the free market reign. I say let the money flow. Conferences should be able to make as much revenue as they want possible and so should the players.

Do you think anything can happen without anti-trust protection? And why would fb and bb players want to collectively bargain? Those court decisions you love create endless litigation.

Isn’t antitrust protection mainly needed to have national standards for NIL and athlete eligibility? In other words, to enable the NCAA and CSC to enforce consistent rules…as opposed to state judges/legislators regulating their local university’s athletics.

Yes, antitrust protections are needed for the reasons you listed. Until rules can be enforced no progress can be made.

Without them, we will continue to have states make it so good ol’ State U has an advantage over their competition in other states.

Would rule breakers continue to act as they do now? Probably. However, they could then be dealt with so severely as to discourage others from doing the same in the future (or so we would hope).

Would be the height of irony if Saban ends up as College Sports Czar. Would he actually hammer anybody for coloring outside the lines? Hard to see how he could do it with a straight face.

Saban falls into the category of “Don’t hate the player, hate the game”.

The game is the problem. Fix that with enforceable rules and the offending players will fall in line.

This legislation is a good start to doing just that.
06-05-2026 10:16 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13521
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #306
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(06-05-2026 10:16 PM)Ned Low Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 09:42 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 08:33 PM)Ned Low Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 07:42 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 06:00 PM)bullet Wrote:  Do you think anything can happen without anti-trust protection? And why would fb and bb players want to collectively bargain? Those court decisions you love create endless litigation.

Isn’t antitrust protection mainly needed to have national standards for NIL and athlete eligibility? In other words, to enable the NCAA and CSC to enforce consistent rules…as opposed to state judges/legislators regulating their local university’s athletics.

Yes, antitrust protections are needed for the reasons you listed. Until rules can be enforced no progress can be made.

Without them, we will continue to have states make it so good ol’ State U has an advantage over their competition in other states.

Would rule breakers continue to act as they do now? Probably. However, they could then be dealt with so severely as to discourage others from doing the same in the future (or so we would hope).

Would be the height of irony if Saban ends up as College Sports Czar. Would he actually hammer anybody for coloring outside the lines? Hard to see how he could do it with a straight face.

Saban falls into the category of “Don’t hate the player, hate the game”.

The game is the problem. Fix that with enforceable rules and the offending players will fall in line.

This legislation is a good start to doing just that.

It's all just more denial. The Supreme Court ruled on Alston and House. Saban's end run to Congress just reflects the desire to keep things as they were, and the controls he wants he never abided by while coaching. He was just a consummate manager of all things pertaining to his program and he was adamant about absolute control. What made it work for him was he so meticulous with how he developed coaches and talent and so attentive to every detail that his fastidious nature translated into winning.

Alston and House provide the tools for compliance, and it is existing business law. It's just nobody wants to formally acknowledge the change of status from amateur to paid player and employee. The longer they wait to adhere to the rulings the worse it is going to be. And if Congress gets involved that's when it all gets bogged down legally and bureaucratically and tweaked until it is an unrecognizable mess, worse than the one they fear they have now.
06-05-2026 11:14 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Ned Low Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,475
Joined: Nov 2010
Reputation: 561
I Root For: ECU
Location: Durham, NC
Post: #307
RE: Protect College Sports Act
I saw something on Reddit last night that I had not considered previously, regarding the PCSA's section on the pooling of media rights and the requirement that 75% of FBS schools would have to approve of such a measure before it could be accomplished.

I don't think that it's been discussed on this thread but if two or more FCS programs move up to D1 (maybe Montana and Montana State?) it would mean that the P2 plus Notre Dame could do nothing to block such a move.

Of course, the M2 would still be required to get on board. In addition, if the act were to be signed into law the P2 could be spurred into action: they could add a few M2 programs in defense of their postiion.

Maybe it's something, maybe it's nothing... but the ramifications are interesting to consider.
(This post was last modified: 06-06-2026 09:29 AM by Ned Low.)
06-06-2026 08:28 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Online
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,947
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #308
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(06-06-2026 08:28 AM)Ned Low Wrote:  I saw something on Reddit last night that I had not considered previously, regarding the PCSA's section on the pooling of media rights and the requirement that 75% of FBS schools would have to approve of such a measure before it could be accomplished.

I don't think that it's been discussed on this thread but if two or more FCS programs move up to D1 (maybe Montana and Montana State?) it would mean that the P2 plus Notre Dame could do nothing to block such a move.

Of course, the M2 would still be required to get on board. In addition, if the act were to be signed into law the P2 could be spurred into action: they could add a few M2 programs in defense of their postiion.

Maybe it's something, maybe it's nothing... but the ramifications are interesting to consider.

Easy way to accomplish that is to just flood FBS with enough FCS schools to get to 75%. It's hard enough for the richest 75% to get anything done in FBS, and now we're trying to give the keys to the kingdom to the poorest 75%? Would be awfully funny if the P2 absolutely hammer the M2 and take half their members now, but leave Texas Tech out in the cold b/c everyone is so pissed off at Campbell. We already have enough schools that don't think they need to follow the rules as it is, do we really want to add a school with Miss St's resources that behaves more like Texas or Tennessee? Most of the M2 would be happy to stay in an upper tier or get an invite to the P2, but Cody Campbell seems to think that he should be able to dictate terms to everybody.
06-06-2026 02:25 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Dr Dawgma III Offline
Hark the Sound
*

Posts: 26,072
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2768
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
Post: #309
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(06-06-2026 02:25 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(06-06-2026 08:28 AM)Ned Low Wrote:  I saw something on Reddit last night that I had not considered previously, regarding the PCSA's section on the pooling of media rights and the requirement that 75% of FBS schools would have to approve of such a measure before it could be accomplished.

I don't think that it's been discussed on this thread but if two or more FCS programs move up to D1 (maybe Montana and Montana State?) it would mean that the P2 plus Notre Dame could do nothing to block such a move.

Of course, the M2 would still be required to get on board. In addition, if the act were to be signed into law the P2 could be spurred into action: they could add a few M2 programs in defense of their postiion.

Maybe it's something, maybe it's nothing... but the ramifications are interesting to consider.

Easy way to accomplish that is to just flood FBS with enough FCS schools to get to 75%. It's hard enough for the richest 75% to get anything done in FBS, and now we're trying to give the keys to the kingdom to the poorest 75%? Would be awfully funny if the P2 absolutely hammer the M2 and take half their members now, but leave Texas Tech out in the cold b/c everyone is so pissed off at Campbell. We already have enough schools that don't think they need to follow the rules as it is, do we really want to add a school with Miss St's resources that behaves more like Texas or Tennessee? Most of the M2 would be happy to stay in an upper tier or get an invite to the P2, but Cody Campbell seems to think that he should be able to dictate terms to everybody.

You inadvertently sent out the David St Bat Signal
06-06-2026 02:56 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13521
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #310
RE: Protect College Sports Act
It's not law yet and may never be.

There is nothing to keep the SEC and or Big Ten from acting now.

The main provision of the act locks schools into conferences until the media rights expire. That disproportionately harms the ACC who will be last to renegotiate. The law would even circumvent their early graduated exit fee sliding scale.

The SEC and Big Ten would be fine staying where they are, but why do that if you could be free to monetize more fully all revenue sports by running your own tournaments and expanding those to be included by invitation.

The interesting legal question will be whether a school also seeking an new association predicated upon fulfilling the requirements of the Alston and House rulings would even be subject to an exit fee because they would be establishing a new construct for college football which would be substantially different in that they would pay all athletes and be governed by business law. And there is precedent for giving entities establishing new organizations just to be compliant with ruling receiving the largess to do so.

The one thing I would say about this Summer and the next one is if the SEC and Big Ten make a move, it will be fascinating to see how the rest of this plays out legally since the SCOTUS would be inclined to favor the breakaway establishment of a group that acknowledges and accepts the changes wrought by the courts, fascinating to see how or whether exit fees will be allowed, and how much a divided congress wants to get into an even greater divisive mess.

Look on the bright side, at least it will keep this forum humming, or something to that effect.

And if the SEC and Big Ten make a move before the passage of legislation they will not be subject to being held to laws passed after their moves.
06-06-2026 03:19 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Dr Dawgma III Offline
Hark the Sound
*

Posts: 26,072
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2768
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
Post: #311
RE: Protect College Sports Act
The B1G and SEC breaking away without exemptions is a disaster waiting to happen. The only future without protection is actually declaring the players employees; so get out the W2's!

Then what happens if Vandy offers "full-time" status to certain student athletes? You're talking about a crazy arms race that could potentially bankrupt athletic departments. Good luck, State U.

This fantasy that the SCOTUS decision* is the end all be all is naive. It's for fans who want status quo because it benefits their barnacle school.


*As far as no further legislation. The SCOTUS decision enables the players (which I support 100%), but says nothing of employment status. This benefits the best players and the big spender collectives the most. At some point the employment question needs to be answered, and if the B1G and SEC jump the gun, they will be subject to accepting their athletes as employees, not students. If it was as rosy as some would like us to believe, why haven't they done it yet?
(This post was last modified: 06-06-2026 04:56 PM by Dr Dawgma III.)
06-06-2026 04:42 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13521
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #312
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(06-06-2026 04:42 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  The B1G and SEC breaking away without exemptions is a disaster waiting to happen. The only future without protection is actually declaring the players employees; so get out the W2's!

Then what happens if Vandy offers "full-time" status to certain student athletes? You're talking about a crazy arms race that could potentially bankrupt athletic departments. Good luck, State U.

This fantasy that the SCOTUS decision is the end all be all is naive. It's for fans who want status quo because it benefits their barnacle school.

Blather away. The SCOTUS does provide all we need. The law exists to govern it. What it doesn't do is to allow the athletes to continue providing essentially free labor for the millions made in athletic departments. Yeah, yeah, they get a grant & aid and rudimentary health care. What they don't get is the fruit of their real work, playing sports. But then the Victorian Era view of amateurism has been allowed to create an institution of indentured servitude which the SCOTUS saw fit to end.

I doubt there are many in Congress who want to publicly go on record as being against the paying of athletes of which half are women and a disproportionate number to the actual racial mix of the country are minorities. They won't have a lobby which is for it, nor will they have the public sentiment from women and minorities to overturn it.

And none of that takes into consideration what the SCOTUS did, namely constitutionality. This isn't going away and the longer the universities stall, whine and bellyache about their costs in a business where just about all of the P4 athletic departments take in more than 125 annually the worse off it's going to be for them.

If the Big Ten and SEC want to get out in front on this it is because they realize how much more, they could lose. I still get lost in the irony of UNC cheating to keep athletes eligible by teaching African American studies on a campus dedicated to remaining a plantation.

We had the ruling, a period of silence for it to sink in, those who immediately misused NIL as a recruitment tool instead of commercial endorsement revenue, and now we have the delayed reaction of denial by many who want to put the free athletes back on the menu of some kind of halfassed makeover of the NCAA.

The best breaks in life are clean breaks. It's time for one!

Oh, and one more thing. The mission of a college or university is education. If they can afford to have athletics it will enhance the college experience. But...having college athletics is not a right the schools are entitled to have. It is a luxury they can afford or not afford and if they can't afford it the taxpayers damn sure shouldn't have to pay for it!
(This post was last modified: 06-06-2026 05:01 PM by JRsec.)
06-06-2026 04:55 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Dr Dawgma III Offline
Hark the Sound
*

Posts: 26,072
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2768
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
Post: #313
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(06-06-2026 04:55 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(06-06-2026 04:42 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  The B1G and SEC breaking away without exemptions is a disaster waiting to happen. The only future without protection is actually declaring the players employees; so get out the W2's!

Then what happens if Vandy offers "full-time" status to certain student athletes? You're talking about a crazy arms race that could potentially bankrupt athletic departments. Good luck, State U.

This fantasy that the SCOTUS decision is the end all be all is naive. It's for fans who want status quo because it benefits their barnacle school.

Blather away. The SCOTUS does provide all we need. The law exists to govern it. What it doesn't do is to allow the athletes to continue providing essentially free labor for the millions made in athletic departments. Yeah, yeah, they get a grant & aid and rudimentary health care. What they don't get is the fruit of their real work, playing sports. But then the Victorian Era view of amateurism has been allowed to create an institution of indentured servitude which the SCOTUS saw fit to end.

I doubt there are many in Congress who want to publicly go on record as being against the paying of athletes of which half are women and a disproportionate number to the actual racial mix of the country are minorities. They won't have a lobby which is for it, nor will they have the public sentiment from women and minorities to overturn it.

And none of that takes into consideration what the SCOTUS did, namely constitutionality. This isn't going away and the longer the universities stall, whine and bellyache about their costs in a business where just about all of the P4 athletic departments take in more than 125 annually the worse off it's going to be for them.

If the Big Ten and SEC want to get out in front on this it is they realize how much more they could lose. I still get lost in the irony of UNC cheating to keep athletes eligible by teaching African American studies on a campus dedicated to remaining a plantation.

We had the ruling, a period of silence for it to sink in, those who immediately misused NIL as a recruitment tool instead of commercial endorsement revenue, and now we have the delayed reaction of denial by many who want to put the free athletes back on the menu of some kind of halfassed makeover of the NCAA.

The best breaks in life are clean breaks. It's time for one!

Nice try. You're repeating points I made years ago about the inequity in revenue sharing. You think that's going away with employment status?

Try focusing on what I'm talking about instead of my avatar. Do I need to change it back to Uga?

If the break is so rosy, do it already. That's the thing, they will be heading into minor league sports territory, and maybe that's what you want because it keeps the SEC status quo and Auburn somewhat relevant.

The B1G and SEC Triple A NFL Football. That's what you get. Pros hovering around campus, no more student athletes, 401k's and full benefits eventually. Just what universities were designed for!
(This post was last modified: 06-06-2026 05:02 PM by Dr Dawgma III.)
06-06-2026 05:01 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13521
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #314
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(06-06-2026 05:01 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  
(06-06-2026 04:55 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(06-06-2026 04:42 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  The B1G and SEC breaking away without exemptions is a disaster waiting to happen. The only future without protection is actually declaring the players employees; so get out the W2's!

Then what happens if Vandy offers "full-time" status to certain student athletes? You're talking about a crazy arms race that could potentially bankrupt athletic departments. Good luck, State U.

This fantasy that the SCOTUS decision is the end all be all is naive. It's for fans who want status quo because it benefits their barnacle school.

Blather away. The SCOTUS does provide all we need. The law exists to govern it. What it doesn't do is to allow the athletes to continue providing essentially free labor for the millions made in athletic departments. Yeah, yeah, they get a grant & aid and rudimentary health care. What they don't get is the fruit of their real work, playing sports. But then the Victorian Era view of amateurism has been allowed to create an institution of indentured servitude which the SCOTUS saw fit to end.

I doubt there are many in Congress who want to publicly go on record as being against the paying of athletes of which half are women and a disproportionate number to the actual racial mix of the country are minorities. They won't have a lobby which is for it, nor will they have the public sentiment from women and minorities to overturn it.

And none of that takes into consideration what the SCOTUS did, namely constitutionality. This isn't going away and the longer the universities stall, whine and bellyache about their costs in a business where just about all of the P4 athletic departments take in more than 125 annually the worse off it's going to be for them.

If the Big Ten and SEC want to get out in front on this it is they realize how much more they could lose. I still get lost in the irony of UNC cheating to keep athletes eligible by teaching African American studies on a campus dedicated to remaining a plantation.

We had the ruling, a period of silence for it to sink in, those who immediately misused NIL as a recruitment tool instead of commercial endorsement revenue, and now we have the delayed reaction of denial by many who want to put the free athletes back on the menu of some kind of halfassed makeover of the NCAA.

The best breaks in life are clean breaks. It's time for one!

Nice try. You're repeating points I made years ago about the inequity in revenue sharing. You think that's going away with employment status?

Try focusing on what I'm talking about instead of my avatar. Do I need to change it back to Uga?

If the break is so rosy, do it already. That's the thing, they will be heading into minor league sports territory, and maybe that's what you want because it keeps the SEC status quo and Auburn somewhat relevant.

The B1G and SEC Triple A NFL Football. That's what you get. Pros hovering around campus, no more student athletes, 401k's and full benefits eventually. Just what universities were designed for!
1. I don't repeat your points, neither does Frank, or most of the posters. Your 40 something. I have 3 more decades of memories than you do, and I actually knew people involved in decisions in the 80's, 90's & 2000's. What you remember from that period is found in the few pieces you can Google. And at this point it is about pay not revenue sharing.

2. I believe it will come, but initially I think the timeline was a bit longer to prepare for it. So, we'll see if the current state of affairs ramps that up.

And when it does come it won't change the nature of campuses, and whether there are benefits will depend on if they are classified as full employees or seasonal ones. But what the campuses will find for those who are part of it, is that the exposure will be greater than it ever was.

I won't be surprised if UNC is part of it. I think every prominent P4 school will want to be seen in that grouping and will also want to be seen supporting women athletes and enfranchising those who play their revenue sports.

There are some issues in life you don't want to be on the wrong side of, this is one of them.
06-06-2026 05:12 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
The Beaver Online
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,341
Joined: Apr 2024
Reputation: 955
I Root For: Penn State
Location:
Post: #315
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(06-06-2026 08:28 AM)Ned Low Wrote:  I saw something on Reddit last night that I had not considered previously, regarding the PCSA's section on the pooling of media rights and the requirement that 75% of FBS schools would have to approve of such a measure before it could be accomplished.

I don't think that it's been discussed on this thread but if two or more FCS programs move up to D1 (maybe Montana and Montana State?) it would mean that the P2 plus Notre Dame could do nothing to block such a move.

Of course, the M2 would still be required to get on board. In addition, if the act were to be signed into law the P2 could be spurred into action: they could add a few M2 programs in defense of their postiion.

Maybe it's something, maybe it's nothing... but the ramifications are interesting to consider.

Well, I don't really see how a bundling of M2 and G6 rights really competes with P2 games beyond a very select few ACC programs. I also can't imagine how much fun it would be for them to work out who gets paid what in such a scenario. The ACC's top games are obviously worth the most, and they have their own TV network to support, but the Big XII would probably demand parity with them. And its entirely possible that some head in the clouds schools at places like the Pac might do so too. And who would even bid on such a package? Surely only Disney would have the sports slots available to actually do something with that content and even then they would likely sublicense it out to other networks.
06-06-2026 05:15 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Dr Dawgma III Offline
Hark the Sound
*

Posts: 26,072
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2768
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
Post: #316
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(06-06-2026 05:12 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(06-06-2026 05:01 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  
(06-06-2026 04:55 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(06-06-2026 04:42 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  The B1G and SEC breaking away without exemptions is a disaster waiting to happen. The only future without protection is actually declaring the players employees; so get out the W2's!

Then what happens if Vandy offers "full-time" status to certain student athletes? You're talking about a crazy arms race that could potentially bankrupt athletic departments. Good luck, State U.

This fantasy that the SCOTUS decision is the end all be all is naive. It's for fans who want status quo because it benefits their barnacle school.

Blather away. The SCOTUS does provide all we need. The law exists to govern it. What it doesn't do is to allow the athletes to continue providing essentially free labor for the millions made in athletic departments. Yeah, yeah, they get a grant & aid and rudimentary health care. What they don't get is the fruit of their real work, playing sports. But then the Victorian Era view of amateurism has been allowed to create an institution of indentured servitude which the SCOTUS saw fit to end.

I doubt there are many in Congress who want to publicly go on record as being against the paying of athletes of which half are women and a disproportionate number to the actual racial mix of the country are minorities. They won't have a lobby which is for it, nor will they have the public sentiment from women and minorities to overturn it.

And none of that takes into consideration what the SCOTUS did, namely constitutionality. This isn't going away and the longer the universities stall, whine and bellyache about their costs in a business where just about all of the P4 athletic departments take in more than 125 annually the worse off it's going to be for them.

If the Big Ten and SEC want to get out in front on this it is they realize how much more they could lose. I still get lost in the irony of UNC cheating to keep athletes eligible by teaching African American studies on a campus dedicated to remaining a plantation.

We had the ruling, a period of silence for it to sink in, those who immediately misused NIL as a recruitment tool instead of commercial endorsement revenue, and now we have the delayed reaction of denial by many who want to put the free athletes back on the menu of some kind of halfassed makeover of the NCAA.

The best breaks in life are clean breaks. It's time for one!

Nice try. You're repeating points I made years ago about the inequity in revenue sharing. You think that's going away with employment status?

Try focusing on what I'm talking about instead of my avatar. Do I need to change it back to Uga?

If the break is so rosy, do it already. That's the thing, they will be heading into minor league sports territory, and maybe that's what you want because it keeps the SEC status quo and Auburn somewhat relevant.

The B1G and SEC Triple A NFL Football. That's what you get. Pros hovering around campus, no more student athletes, 401k's and full benefits eventually. Just what universities were designed for!
1. I don't repeat your points, neither does Frank, or most of the posters. Your 40 something. I have 3 more decades of memories than you do, and I actually knew people involved in decisions in the 80's, 90's & 2000's. What you remember from that period is found in the few pieces you can Google. And at this point it is about pay not revenue sharing.

2. I believe it will come, but initially I think the timeline was a bit longer to prepare for it. So, we'll see if the current state of affairs ramps that up.

And when it does come it won't change the nature of campuses, and whether there are benefits will depend on if they are classified as full employees or seasonal ones. But what the campuses will find for those who are part of it, is that the exposure will be greater than it ever was.

I won't be surprised if UNC is part of it. I think every prominent P4 school will want to be seen in that grouping and will also want to be seen supporting women athletes and enfranchising those who play their revenue sports.

There are some issues in life you don't want to be on the wrong side of, this is one of them.

1. Yeah, you're spinning some moral high ground. Who cares if I'm in my 40's? This is happening now.

2. The wrong side of what? You keep attempting to paint me into some anti-athlete corner when it was me who was telling all of you congress was going to get involved due to inequity in revenue sharing, due to specifically non-rev and female athletes. And look at these acts coming out. Sure, some of them have been shot down because they are TOO non-revenue friendly. I would love to be on the wrong side of that.

You need an exemption, or you're headed to full employment status. I don't get where the confidence comes from. I guess I don't know why my perspective is so controversial.
06-06-2026 05:28 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Attackcoog Offline
Moderator
*

Posts: 49,239
Joined: Oct 2011
Reputation: 3527
I Root For: Houston
Location:
Post: #317
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(06-05-2026 11:14 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 10:16 PM)Ned Low Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 09:42 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 08:33 PM)Ned Low Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 07:42 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  Isn’t antitrust protection mainly needed to have national standards for NIL and athlete eligibility? In other words, to enable the NCAA and CSC to enforce consistent rules…as opposed to state judges/legislators regulating their local university’s athletics.

Yes, antitrust protections are needed for the reasons you listed. Until rules can be enforced no progress can be made.

Without them, we will continue to have states make it so good ol’ State U has an advantage over their competition in other states.

Would rule breakers continue to act as they do now? Probably. However, they could then be dealt with so severely as to discourage others from doing the same in the future (or so we would hope).

Would be the height of irony if Saban ends up as College Sports Czar. Would he actually hammer anybody for coloring outside the lines? Hard to see how he could do it with a straight face.

Saban falls into the category of “Don’t hate the player, hate the game”.

The game is the problem. Fix that with enforceable rules and the offending players will fall in line.

This legislation is a good start to doing just that.

It's all just more denial. The Supreme Court ruled on Alston and House. Saban's end run to Congress just reflects the desire to keep things as they were, and the controls he wants he never abided by while coaching. He was just a consummate manager of all things pertaining to his program and he was adamant about absolute control. What made it work for him was he so meticulous with how he developed coaches and talent and so attentive to every detail that his fastidious nature translated into winning.

Alston and House provide the tools for compliance, and it is existing business law. It's just nobody wants to formally acknowledge the change of status from amateur to paid player and employee. The longer they wait to adhere to the rulings the worse it is going to be. And if Congress gets involved that's when it all gets bogged down legally and bureaucratically and tweaked until it is an unrecognizable mess, worse than the one they fear they have now.

Just so nobody misunderstands, the House and Alston SC rulings were specific to those settlements and those plaintiffs ONLY. The ruling is not a universal settlement and in no way precludes a new set of plaintiffs from suing those same organizations for anti-trust violations. In fact, Kavanaugh's scalding separately authored opinion essentially warns the NCAA that the current model would be an obvious anti-trust violation and sets the stage for a challenge of any attempt to use the settlement as a universal settlement. The ONLY way to make this a universal settlement is for the players to organize a union and have that union put its collective bargaining stamp of approval on the settlement---or for Congress to grant the schools a limited anti-trust exemption that allows them to unilaterally implement the settlement (which is basically what the primary function of this bill is).

I agree that the settlement is about as close to collective bargaining as one can get right now when it comes to setting up a framework that seems fair and workable---but thats all it really is without a collective bargaining agreement or an anti-trust exemption legalizing the settlement.
(This post was last modified: 06-06-2026 06:00 PM by Attackcoog.)
06-06-2026 05:57 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Lurker Above Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 2,232
Joined: Apr 2011
Reputation: 330
I Root For: UGA
Location:
Post: #318
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(06-05-2026 09:30 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 08:51 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 07:48 AM)Lurker Above Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 07:36 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(06-04-2026 02:15 PM)bullet Wrote:  TV consultants and university presidents and university ADs almost universally say that the disjointed negotiations result in lower contracts that if they were consolidated.

I don't know that the G conferences would add much, but if the P4 negotiated together, they would all get more money. Probably not triple, but more than they get now.

I'm not sure that they would. This is a hot topic around here these days ofc, and I'm coming around to the idea that the best way to fully maximize ratings and income would be an NFL-like top division composed of ~30 programs. The only problem is that the next 30 would be close enough to cause the top tier problems, perhaps not in the ratings, but many of them could compete for the same kids that are looking at Florida and Michigan, we'd go back to split national titles, etc etc etc. So, we probably need something closer to 60 than 30, and doing a contract with that many programs dilutes things considerably. After all, there are only so many broadcast windows. Under the current setup, CBS, NBC, Fox, or ABC/ESPN all have a chance at huge ratings from week to week, and they've all paid accordingly. But consolidate everything together into one huge package, and we still only have Fridays after 6 pm and all day Saturday to broadcast every single game. Do we really want to go h2h with the NFL on Sundays, Mondays and Thursdays? How much/little would that pay us? I think that the only way to make a really huge ~60+ school megacontract produce the type of ratings necessary to double or triple the income for everyone would be to move CFB to the spring. Then, we could dominate Fridays, Saturdays, Sundays, you name it, but it would wreak havoc with the sport. I'm not saying that it couldn't happen, clearly it could, but I don't see any momentum for it right now.

College football currently benefits from federal legislation that prevents the NFL from playing on Saturdays in the fall. No such protection exists for spring football.

I think we’re all getting into the weeds a bit too much here.

The intent of the pooled rights language is to bring the Big Ten and SEC back in so that they can be sold with the rest of college football. Ted Cruz himself has said that the money doesn’t work without the participation of the Big Ten and SEC.

So, everyone that says that all of college football would make more in TOTAL with pooled rights is probably right. Of course Texas Tech and Boise State and Eastern Michigan would make more money if their rights are pooled with Ohio State, Alabama, and the other major P2 brands.

That really isn’t the question. The question is whether the Big Ten and SEC schools *specifically* make more money in that pooled system and, more importantly, do they maintain the same money *advantage* over everyone else. Telling the Big Ten and SEC schools that they will make $5 million more per year with pooled rights sounds nice in a vacuum, but it’s not as nice if the Big 12 and ACC schools are making $40 million more per year and now have equal revenue and spending power as the P2… and the whole reason for that increase for the Big 12/ACC is the value of the P2 subsidizing them. That makes little sense for the P2.

The ND AD thankfully said the quiet part out loud: the biggest revenue driver wouldn’t be just pooling everyone in a democratic and equalized way, but rather chop off the very top 20-30 schools in a targeted and even more elitist way to have NFL-like brand vs. brand scheduling. Once again, saying that Texas Tech can raise its revenue by pooling their rights with Ohio State and Alabama is a “Duh!” obvious statement. But these decisions are going to be made by what makes Ohio State and Alabama even more money relative to the rest of college football, which means the exact opposite of the Act’s proposal: separating from the P2 themselves and creating their own elite of the elite Super League. That is certainly the real danger that I’ll always be more worried about as an Illinois alum or those in places like Mississippi State should be worrying about the most.

Well, media rights aren't the whole story, else Texas and Miss St would have the same total Revenues, right? Instead, Texas is more that doubling up Miss St this season, same for OSU vs the bottom revenue producing schools in the B1G. Give the biggest schools a $5m raise and the smaller schools a $40m raise and the biggest schools are still far ahead of the others. However, I still maintain that the best way to do that would be to remove the possibility of competing with the NFL, and nobody is clamoring for that these days.

@lurker above, we don't need protection from the NFL in the spring b/c the NFL has no games in the spring.

Well, neither does college football. Things change. Place college football at a time when the UFL is also playing and the NFL might decide they too must plant a flag there.
06-06-2026 06:18 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Lurker Above Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 2,232
Joined: Apr 2011
Reputation: 330
I Root For: UGA
Location:
Post: #319
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(06-05-2026 10:47 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 09:40 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 09:32 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  Think of other pooled rights:

Notre Dame, Louisville, VaTech, State, Carolina, Clemson, GaTech, FSU, and Miami.

That football-only (ND exemption) contract makes more than what we have now, and major conference realignment wouldn't be necessary.

Remember, the ACC has football-only breakaway built into the settlement language.

That’s not a realistic proposal because you’re including ND as a conference member. Everything always looks great with the pipe dream of ND joining a league, which they won’t do.

An actual realistic proposal would be taking the top half of the ACC (not including ND) and seeing what the market value would be for a standalone conference. Sure, I believe that would be worth more per school compared to staying with the entire ACC. However, is that more than what UNC, FSU, Miami, etc. would make by them individually joining the Big Ten and or SEC? There’s not realistic.


I gave ND an exemption of joining the conference. Think outside the box. They'd still be pooling their rights like Indies did back in the CFA era. It's no different so, yes, very realistic as it happened with major Indies in the past.

A main reason ND has never wanted to join a conference is because they do not want to pool their rights. Historically, they made the most they could make being independent. Whether that is still true compared to the SEC and B1G is questionable, but not compared to the upper half of an ACC breakaway. And if any school of a possible ACC breakaway gets a P2 invite, that is where they are going.
06-06-2026 06:26 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Dr Dawgma III Offline
Hark the Sound
*

Posts: 26,072
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2768
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
Post: #320
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(06-06-2026 06:26 PM)Lurker Above Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 10:47 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 09:40 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 09:32 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  Think of other pooled rights:

Notre Dame, Louisville, VaTech, State, Carolina, Clemson, GaTech, FSU, and Miami.

That football-only (ND exemption) contract makes more than what we have now, and major conference realignment wouldn't be necessary.

Remember, the ACC has football-only breakaway built into the settlement language.

That’s not a realistic proposal because you’re including ND as a conference member. Everything always looks great with the pipe dream of ND joining a league, which they won’t do.

An actual realistic proposal would be taking the top half of the ACC (not including ND) and seeing what the market value would be for a standalone conference. Sure, I believe that would be worth more per school compared to staying with the entire ACC. However, is that more than what UNC, FSU, Miami, etc. would make by them individually joining the Big Ten and or SEC? There’s not realistic.


I gave ND an exemption of joining the conference. Think outside the box. They'd still be pooling their rights like Indies did back in the CFA era. It's no different so, yes, very realistic as it happened with major Indies in the past.

A main reason ND has never wanted to join a conference is because they do not want to pool their rights. Historically, they made the most they could make being independent. Whether that is still true compared to the SEC and B1G is questionable, but not compared to the upper half of an ACC breakaway. And if any school of a possible ACC breakaway gets a P2 invite, that is where they are going.

I don’t think your first statement is true. They could have made more money over the years joining a number of power leagues. They made more alone rather than being lumped in the CFA, where they could have remained Independent. These are two different scenarios, and what I’m proposing is a third alternate scenario which combines the best of both.
(This post was last modified: 06-07-2026 06:33 AM by Dr Dawgma III.)
06-07-2026 06:31 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 3 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.