bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,947
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(06-05-2026 10:34 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (06-05-2026 09:30 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (06-05-2026 08:51 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (06-05-2026 07:48 AM)Lurker Above Wrote: (06-05-2026 07:36 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote: I'm not sure that they would. This is a hot topic around here these days ofc, and I'm coming around to the idea that the best way to fully maximize ratings and income would be an NFL-like top division composed of ~30 programs. The only problem is that the next 30 would be close enough to cause the top tier problems, perhaps not in the ratings, but many of them could compete for the same kids that are looking at Florida and Michigan, we'd go back to split national titles, etc etc etc. So, we probably need something closer to 60 than 30, and doing a contract with that many programs dilutes things considerably. After all, there are only so many broadcast windows. Under the current setup, CBS, NBC, Fox, or ABC/ESPN all have a chance at huge ratings from week to week, and they've all paid accordingly. But consolidate everything together into one huge package, and we still only have Fridays after 6 pm and all day Saturday to broadcast every single game. Do we really want to go h2h with the NFL on Sundays, Mondays and Thursdays? How much/little would that pay us? I think that the only way to make a really huge ~60+ school megacontract produce the type of ratings necessary to double or triple the income for everyone would be to move CFB to the spring. Then, we could dominate Fridays, Saturdays, Sundays, you name it, but it would wreak havoc with the sport. I'm not saying that it couldn't happen, clearly it could, but I don't see any momentum for it right now.
College football currently benefits from federal legislation that prevents the NFL from playing on Saturdays in the fall. No such protection exists for spring football.
I think we’re all getting into the weeds a bit too much here.
The intent of the pooled rights language is to bring the Big Ten and SEC back in so that they can be sold with the rest of college football. Ted Cruz himself has said that the money doesn’t work without the participation of the Big Ten and SEC.
So, everyone that says that all of college football would make more in TOTAL with pooled rights is probably right. Of course Texas Tech and Boise State and Eastern Michigan would make more money if their rights are pooled with Ohio State, Alabama, and the other major P2 brands.
That really isn’t the question. The question is whether the Big Ten and SEC schools *specifically* make more money in that pooled system and, more importantly, do they maintain the same money *advantage* over everyone else. Telling the Big Ten and SEC schools that they will make $5 million more per year with pooled rights sounds nice in a vacuum, but it’s not as nice if the Big 12 and ACC schools are making $40 million more per year and now have equal revenue and spending power as the P2… and the whole reason for that increase for the Big 12/ACC is the value of the P2 subsidizing them. That makes little sense for the P2.
The ND AD thankfully said the quiet part out loud: the biggest revenue driver wouldn’t be just pooling everyone in a democratic and equalized way, but rather chop off the very top 20-30 schools in a targeted and even more elitist way to have NFL-like brand vs. brand scheduling. Once again, saying that Texas Tech can raise its revenue by pooling their rights with Ohio State and Alabama is a “Duh!” obvious statement. But these decisions are going to be made by what makes Ohio State and Alabama even more money relative to the rest of college football, which means the exact opposite of the Act’s proposal: separating from the P2 themselves and creating their own elite of the elite Super League. That is certainly the real danger that I’ll always be more worried about as an Illinois alum or those in places like Mississippi State should be worrying about the most.
Well, media rights aren't the whole story, else Texas and Miss St would have the same total Revenues, right? Instead, Texas is more that doubling up Miss St this season, same for OSU vs the bottom revenue producing schools in the B1G. Give the biggest schools a $5m raise and the smaller schools a $40m raise and the biggest schools are still far ahead of the others. However, I still maintain that the best way to do that would be to remove the possibility of competing with the NFL, and nobody is clamoring for that these days.
@lurker above, we don't need protection from the NFL in the spring b/c the NFL has no games in the spring.
Media rights *are* effectively the entire story when it comes to what we’re talking about here with respect to conference realignment. Texas would be making a lot more school-specific revenue than Mississippi State whether they’re in the SEC, Big 12, Sun Belt or MAC. However, media rights are the variable specifically tied to conference membership and they also aren’t restricted by stadium size or real estate or other factors. For media rights, the potential universe is the entire population of the world that has access to a television and/or smartphone. That might sound like hyperbole, but that is how power players like Netflix and Disney explicitly approach everything that they do and anyone that wants to compete in this fragmented entertainment world needs to think of it that way. There’s only so much local revenue that can be wrung out of your highest value donors and ticket holders and often really isn’t tied to conference membership, but media rights can be unlimited and is explicitly tied to conference membership. Hence why so much more value is rationally put on media rights in all of these conference realignment discussions and this Act spent so much of its ink addressing media rights directly.
Ask Del Conte what his revenues (sans conference distributions) have been like since joining the SEC. Media rights were the straw that broke the camel's back for them, but, like my Aggies, Texas has found out that your donor base, merchandise sales, game day revenues, etc etc etc skyrocket in the SEC. The story has been similar for OU. Now, that might not work in a hypothetical "P1" style breakaway, and perhaps the move to the B1G hasn't helped UCLA and Washington very much with gameday revenues and booster enthusiasm, maybe that's just one more advantage to joining a conference full of long time rivals instead of joining a Conference that's mostly 1500-2000 miles away.
|
|