2021 Tiger Football!!
All American

Posts: 2,846
Joined: Aug 2021
Reputation: 181
I Root For: Memphis Tigers
Location:
|
RE: Players that are staying, through the portal, high school recruits watch thread
(05-25-2026 04:46 PM)passat25 Wrote: (05-25-2026 10:20 AM)dannyb73 Wrote: Here is why Fred Smith doesn't really matter. He is not going to be a meaningful piece his freshman year and then they are just going to leave for what they believe to be greener pastures (or more money) from somewhere else. Bottom line is he had no other significant offers (meaning more money) so dad made the decision to stay home. Senior thought he could get someone to add him to the staff and had a coach been naive enough to do that, that is where he would be.
At this point Memphis should move on.. There is a scale for an incoming freshman ranked where he was.. A price was agreed upon and now they're trying to renege.. Dad is a cancer.
100%
|
|
| 05-25-2026 05:10 PM |
|
msu35
Observing Reality

Posts: 21,655
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2234
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
|
RE: Players that are staying, through the portal, high school recruits watch thread
A reportedly undersized freshman "big" simply isn't worth $300K as a freshman who is not projected to start. If they are genuinely holding the staff's feet to the fire, best to let him walk and wish him a prosperous future elsewhere. Losing his "production" at the end of the bench as a developmental prospect will have no material impact on the team; and the last thing Penny needs is inadvertently setting a precedent that this type of bait and switch, extortionary tactic is viable and effective.
Again, if the rumors are valid, I hope the staff is scouring the portal for a superior replacement:
Fred Smith Jr. still has not signed his letter of intent
Quote:The Freshman class consists of Smith, Cello Jackson, and Parker Pounds. 6-foot-8 Smith is the only one of the three not to make it official.
The NIL package does not match what his father, Fred Smith Sr., thinks is enough for his two-time Mr. Tennessee Basketball winner.
There is a lot of pressure involved in this upcoming season. The Briarcrest High senior is a good kid who could become a key piece in the Memphis Tigers' future. But not right now, as Fred Smith Jr. will have to learn to play with college-grown men and adjust to the game's speed.
According to a source, Fred Smith Sr. is asking for $300k, and Memphis is offering $150k for his NIL package.
|
|
| 05-25-2026 05:14 PM |
|
Tiger87
Hall of Famer

Posts: 23,720
Joined: Jan 2012
Reputation: 1743
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: Players that are staying, through the portal, high school recruits watch thread
(05-25-2026 05:14 PM)msu35 Wrote: A reportedly undersized freshman "big" simply isn't worth $300K as a freshman who is not projected to start. If they are genuinely holding the staff's feet to the fire, best to let him walk and wish him a prosperous future elsewhere. Losing his "production" at the end of the bench as a developmental prospect will have no material impact on the team; and the last thing Penny needs is inadvertently setting a precedent that this type of bait and switch, extortionary tactic is viable and effective.
Again, if the rumors are valid, I hope the staff is scouring the portal for a superior replacement:
Fred Smith Jr. still has not signed his letter of intent
Quote:The Freshman class consists of Smith, Cello Jackson, and Parker Pounds. 6-foot-8 Smith is the only one of the three not to make it official.
The NIL package does not match what his father, Fred Smith Sr., thinks is enough for his two-time Mr. Tennessee Basketball winner.
There is a lot of pressure involved in this upcoming season. The Briarcrest High senior is a good kid who could become a key piece in the Memphis Tigers' future. But not right now, as Fred Smith Jr. will have to learn to play with college-grown men and adjust to the game's speed.
According to a source, Fred Smith Sr. is asking for $300k, and Memphis is offering $150k for his NIL package.
As I understand it, they all agreed on $150k, and a 2-3 year development track with an opportunity for a "raise" next year. Then FS Sr talked to other coaches (Nolan Smith, for one) who told him he should be getting more. So Sr now is wanting more money.
|
|
| 05-26-2026 08:20 AM |
|
Tiger87
Hall of Famer

Posts: 23,720
Joined: Jan 2012
Reputation: 1743
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: Players that are staying, through the portal, high school recruits watch thread
(05-25-2026 01:38 PM)Eagleonpar Wrote: There is no sense in Penny signing any freshmen now unless he KNOWS
From the jump that they will start
Or unless they are 100% onboard with a 2-3 year development plan. Cello and the other kid might be okay with that.
|
|
| 05-26-2026 08:22 AM |
|
Tiger87
Hall of Famer

Posts: 23,720
Joined: Jan 2012
Reputation: 1743
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: Players that are staying, through the portal, high school recruits watch thread
|
|
| 05-26-2026 08:23 AM |
|
Tiger87
Hall of Famer

Posts: 23,720
Joined: Jan 2012
Reputation: 1743
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: Players that are staying, through the portal, high school recruits watch thread
(05-24-2026 09:00 AM)MemphisTigerPawr Wrote: I'm down for another Keith Lee/Aaron Price transaction.
Finch should have taken the Beck/Elmer Martin/Dwight Stewart deal.
As far as Smith goes Im good with letting him go. Sign an upperclassmen late. We just don't need anybody or anyone that is going to be a me first player.
Penny can set the tone now, but he won't.
Sources are saying that Penny is setting that tone. The GM role might be just enough separation Penny needs to tell a kid "no". That, or it could be the pressure to win next year.
|
|
| 05-26-2026 08:26 AM |
|
Gomemphis
Water Engineer

Posts: 12
Joined: Jan 2026
Reputation: 0
I Root For: University of Memphis
Location:
|
RE: Players that are staying, through the portal, high school recruits watch thread
(05-26-2026 08:26 AM)Tiger87 Wrote: (05-24-2026 09:00 AM)MemphisTigerPawr Wrote: I'm down for another Keith Lee/Aaron Price transaction.
Finch should have taken the Beck/Elmer Martin/Dwight Stewart deal.
As far as Smith goes Im good with letting him go. Sign an upperclassmen late. We just don't need anybody or anyone that is going to be a me first player.
Penny can set the tone now, but he won't.
Sources are saying that Penny is setting that tone. The GM role might be just enough separation Penny needs to tell a kid "no". That, or it could be the pressure to win next year.
If college basketball is just about dollar bills now Fred should go to a low level conference and get paid equivalent to what Memphis will pay him. He dominates and then gets paid between 500-1MM at Memphis or another mid major next year. If it's about love for the city he should play for Memphis. If it's a business decision coming to Memphis makes zero sense.
|
|
| 05-26-2026 12:43 PM |
|
memphistiger89
Heisman

Posts: 7,798
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 551
I Root For: Memphis Tigers
Location:
|
RE: Players that are staying, through the portal, high school recruits watch thread
Big Fred certainly isn’t the first to try to use their kid to land a cushy gig. I’ve even seen it at the high school level. But as a father, I have to say it’s pretty pathetic.
|
|
| 05-26-2026 01:23 PM |
|
Tiger87
Hall of Famer

Posts: 23,720
Joined: Jan 2012
Reputation: 1743
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: Players that are staying, through the portal, high school recruits watch thread
(05-26-2026 12:43 PM)Gomemphis Wrote: (05-26-2026 08:26 AM)Tiger87 Wrote: (05-24-2026 09:00 AM)MemphisTigerPawr Wrote: I'm down for another Keith Lee/Aaron Price transaction.
Finch should have taken the Beck/Elmer Martin/Dwight Stewart deal.
As far as Smith goes Im good with letting him go. Sign an upperclassmen late. We just don't need anybody or anyone that is going to be a me first player.
Penny can set the tone now, but he won't.
Sources are saying that Penny is setting that tone. The GM role might be just enough separation Penny needs to tell a kid "no". That, or it could be the pressure to win next year.
If college basketball is just about dollar bills now Fred should go to a low level conference and get paid equivalent to what Memphis will pay him. He dominates and then gets paid between 500-1MM at Memphis or another mid major next year. If it's about love for the city he should play for Memphis. If it's a business decision coming to Memphis makes zero sense.
Can Tenn State pay him $150k? I dunno - maybe they can.
It depends on what the overall goal is. If they think Jr doesn't really have a lot of developmental upside and this is his peak, then yeah - go wherever and squeeze as many college $$ as you can. But if you're on a 3-year plan of development with the goal being pro ball, then the development (and ultimately, the exposure) would be much better at Memphis than at Tn State.
Does Sr want to bet on his kid's future, or his now? Because the difference between $150k and $300k isn't a whole lot if the kid has upside.
But I'm like everyone else at this point - stick to your budget, and let him walk. He's not going to matter next year, and we HAVE to win next year.
(This post was last modified: 05-27-2026 07:59 AM by Tiger87.)
|
|
| 05-27-2026 07:57 AM |
|
memtiger1987
Heisman

Posts: 7,068
Joined: May 2010
Reputation: 370
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: Players that are staying, through the portal, high school recruits watch thread
(05-27-2026 07:57 AM)Tiger87 Wrote: (05-26-2026 12:43 PM)Gomemphis Wrote: (05-26-2026 08:26 AM)Tiger87 Wrote: (05-24-2026 09:00 AM)MemphisTigerPawr Wrote: I'm down for another Keith Lee/Aaron Price transaction.
Finch should have taken the Beck/Elmer Martin/Dwight Stewart deal.
As far as Smith goes Im good with letting him go. Sign an upperclassmen late. We just don't need anybody or anyone that is going to be a me first player.
Penny can set the tone now, but he won't.
Sources are saying that Penny is setting that tone. The GM role might be just enough separation Penny needs to tell a kid "no". That, or it could be the pressure to win next year.
If college basketball is just about dollar bills now Fred should go to a low level conference and get paid equivalent to what Memphis will pay him. He dominates and then gets paid between 500-1MM at Memphis or another mid major next year. If it's about love for the city he should play for Memphis. If it's a business decision coming to Memphis makes zero sense.
Can Tenn State pay him $150k? I dunno - maybe they can.
It depends on what the overall goal is. If they think Jr doesn't really have a lot of developmental upside and this is his peak, then yeah - go wherever and squeeze as many college $$ as you can. But if you're on a 3-year plan of development with the goal being pro ball, then the development (and ultimately, the exposure) would be much better at Memphis than at Tn State.
Does Sr want to bet on his kid's future, or his now? Because the difference between $150k and $300k isn't a whole lot if the kid has upside.
But I'm like everyone else at this point - stick to your budget, and let him walk. He's not going to matter next year, and we HAVE to win next year.
This sums up college sports these days. It’s all about the $$$. Highest bidder. I totally understand it from the players standpoint, but it is absolutely ruining college sports. Absolutely no loyalty (either way).
Fred Jr hasn’t shown me that he can play significant minutes next year. I’ve seen him play weak opponents and still not really stand out. He may develop into a solid player, but if he plays starter minutes next year, it’s because we really suck. If he’s having second thoughts, cut bait and move on. Today’s basketball isn’t about developing, it’s about what you can do this year. Penny’s history has shown that retention isn’t a strength. We don’t need another opportunist dad making waves.
|
|
| 05-27-2026 07:49 PM |
|
TIGERBUDDY
All American

Posts: 3,729
Joined: Mar 2004
Reputation: 278
I Root For: MEMPHIS TIGERS
Location: Germantown/Sarasota
|
RE: Players that are staying, through the portal, high school recruits watch thread
(05-27-2026 07:49 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (05-27-2026 07:57 AM)Tiger87 Wrote: (05-26-2026 12:43 PM)Gomemphis Wrote: (05-26-2026 08:26 AM)Tiger87 Wrote: (05-24-2026 09:00 AM)MemphisTigerPawr Wrote: I'm down for another Keith Lee/Aaron Price transaction.
Finch should have taken the Beck/Elmer Martin/Dwight Stewart deal.
As far as Smith goes Im good with letting him go. Sign an upperclassmen late. We just don't need anybody or anyone that is going to be a me first player.
Penny can set the tone now, but he won't.
Sources are saying that Penny is setting that tone. The GM role might be just enough separation Penny needs to tell a kid "no". That, or it could be the pressure to win next year.
If college basketball is just about dollar bills now Fred should go to a low level conference and get paid equivalent to what Memphis will pay him. He dominates and then gets paid between 500-1MM at Memphis or another mid major next year. If it's about love for the city he should play for Memphis. If it's a business decision coming to Memphis makes zero sense.
Can Tenn State pay him $150k? I dunno - maybe they can.
It depends on what the overall goal is. If they think Jr doesn't really have a lot of developmental upside and this is his peak, then yeah - go wherever and squeeze as many college $$ as you can. But if you're on a 3-year plan of development with the goal being pro ball, then the development (and ultimately, the exposure) would be much better at Memphis than at Tn State.
Does Sr want to bet on his kid's future, or his now? Because the difference between $150k and $300k isn't a whole lot if the kid has upside.
But I'm like everyone else at this point - stick to your budget, and let him walk. He's not going to matter next year, and we HAVE to win next year.
This sums up college sports these days. It’s all about the $$$. Highest bidder. I totally understand it from the players standpoint, but it is absolutely ruining college sports. Absolutely no loyalty (either way).
Fred Jr hasn’t shown me that he can play significant minutes next year. I’ve seen him play weak opponents and still not really stand out. He may develop into a solid player, but if he plays starter minutes next year, it’s because we really suck. If he’s having second thoughts, cut bait and move on. Today’s basketball isn’t about developing, it’s about what you can do this year. Penny’s history has shown that retention isn’t a strength. We don’t need another opportunist dad making waves.
  
|
|
| 05-28-2026 08:09 AM |
|
Marc Mensa
You'll Get Nothing and Like It

Posts: 16,312
Joined: Mar 2004
Reputation: 934
I Root For: The Underdog
Location: Samaria
|
RE: Players that are staying, through the portal, high school recruits watch thread
$300k is not development money at least not at Memphis.
I believe Cisse was making $360k at Ole Miss before they cut bait & I don’t think FS jr has nearly the upside. NiL is a double edged sword for incoming freshmen; yes they now “get paid”, but teams aren’t going to pay for what they might become. By then, they’ve already transferred 3x’s.
(This post was last modified: 05-29-2026 07:47 AM by Marc Mensa.)
|
|
| 05-29-2026 07:46 AM |
|
ncrdbl1
Legend

Posts: 31,082
Joined: Nov 2005
Reputation: 608
I Root For: Memphis Tigers
Location: Horn Lake
|
RE: Players that are staying, through the portal, high school recruits watch thread
(05-25-2026 10:20 AM)dannyb73 Wrote: Here is why Fred Smith doesn't really matter. He is not going to be a meaningful piece his freshman year and then they are just going to leave for what they believe to be greener pastures (or more money) from somewhere else. Bottom line is he had no other significant offers (meaning more money) so dad made the decision to stay home. Senior thought he could get someone to add him to the staff and had a coach been naive enough to do that, that is where he would be.
Let's not go there.
The only reason we're in this situation is because people here and other social media started treating this kid as if he was the second coming of Jesus Christ.
Now that he is waiting to hear other offers before officially signing here comes all the foxes out of the woods.
|
|
| 05-29-2026 08:18 AM |
|
VetsvillageTiger
Water Engineer

Posts: 33
Joined: Apr 2025
Reputation: 5
I Root For: Tigers
Location:
|
RE: Players that are staying, through the portal, high school recruits watch thread
John Martin of the Daily Memphian reported this morning that Fred Smith Jr. will be at summer workouts starting Tuesday 6/2, per Fred Smith Sr.
|
|
| 05-29-2026 10:05 AM |
|
tigerengineer
All American

Posts: 3,894
Joined: Sep 2005
Reputation: 183
I Root For: The Tigers!
Location:
|
RE: Players that are staying, through the portal, high school recruits watch thread
To play devil's advocate - he will be at the workout, will he be a participant?
|
|
| 05-29-2026 12:10 PM |
|
Eagleonpar
Heisman

Posts: 8,308
Joined: May 2018
Reputation: 540
I Root For: UOFM
Location:
|
RE: Players that are staying, through the portal, high school recruits watch thread
(05-29-2026 12:10 PM)tigerengineer Wrote: To play devil's advocate - he will be at the workout, will he be a participant?
Seems like we don’t do well with kids with the strong D influence
Nichols left, Nick King left, Lawson’s all left, Emoni Bates, Landers Nolley, Tyler Harris etc. Curtis Givens is the latest plus Billy Richmond who never came here. Saying that I hope Fred is the exception, but it’s not starting out well
|
|
| 05-29-2026 01:22 PM |
|
VetsvillageTiger
Water Engineer

Posts: 33
Joined: Apr 2025
Reputation: 5
I Root For: Tigers
Location:
|
RE: Players that are staying, through the portal, high school recruits watch thread
(05-29-2026 12:10 PM)tigerengineer Wrote: To play devil's advocate - he will be at the workout, will he be a participant?
The article says he will participate.
|
|
| 05-29-2026 03:22 PM |
|
former guest
Heisman

Posts: 5,123
Joined: Nov 2007
Reputation: 510
I Root For: Memphis Tigers!
Location: Huntsville, AL
|
RE: Players that are staying, through the portal, high school recruits watch thread
(05-29-2026 03:22 PM)VetsvillageTiger Wrote: (05-29-2026 12:10 PM)tigerengineer Wrote: To play devil's advocate - he will be at the workout, will he be a participant?
The article says he will participate.
And where will Fred Sr. be? Hopefully at home minding his own business....
But I wouldn't bet on it!
|
|
| 05-29-2026 03:51 PM |
|
Tiger87
Hall of Famer

Posts: 23,720
Joined: Jan 2012
Reputation: 1743
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: Players that are staying, through the portal, high school recruits watch thread
(05-29-2026 01:22 PM)Eagleonpar Wrote: (05-29-2026 12:10 PM)tigerengineer Wrote: To play devil's advocate - he will be at the workout, will he be a participant?
Seems like we don’t do well with kids with the strong D influence
Nichols left, Nick King left, Lawson’s all left, Emoni Bates, Landers Nolley, Tyler Harris etc. Curtis Givens is the latest plus Billy Richmond who never came here. Saying that I hope Fred is the exception, but it’s not starting out well
I can think of a couple of +.
Wagner, and going way back, Lorenzen.
I'm sure there are more.
|
|
| 05-29-2026 04:12 PM |
|
2021 Tiger Football!!
All American

Posts: 2,846
Joined: Aug 2021
Reputation: 181
I Root For: Memphis Tigers
Location:
|
RE: Players that are staying, through the portal, high school recruits watch thread
(05-29-2026 04:12 PM)Tiger87 Wrote: (05-29-2026 01:22 PM)Eagleonpar Wrote: (05-29-2026 12:10 PM)tigerengineer Wrote: To play devil's advocate - he will be at the workout, will he be a participant?
Seems like we don’t do well with kids with the strong D influence
Nichols left, Nick King left, Lawson’s all left, Emoni Bates, Landers Nolley, Tyler Harris etc. Curtis Givens is the latest plus Billy Richmond who never came here. Saying that I hope Fred is the exception, but it’s not starting out well
I can think of a couple of +.
Wagner, and going way back, Lorenzen.
I'm sure there are more.
Wagner was really a bust. By that time playing for 65th best was already a joke.
|
|
| 05-29-2026 05:45 PM |
|