(04-30-2026 08:39 PM)MemTigers1998 Wrote: (04-30-2026 03:12 PM)Tiger87 Wrote: Jury still very much out on Scott. What makes it "resounding NO" to you?
Because we’re still in the AAC, Penny still coaches MBB and we have little to no NIL $ for the only sport Memphis could compete on a national level because he has diverted it to football?
Scott coordinated a large offer to the B12. But he didn't handle the PAC very well. He's 1-1 in that area. But you can't really hold it against him that we're not in a P4.
He inherited Penny and a contract that would have cost us $6M to get rid of him last year, plus an additional $2M-$3M for a new coach buyout, staff, NIL. Along with being one of the most important alums and Memphians in modern history. That said, if the big boosters who pay for mbb coach salaries wanted Penny fired, he'd be fired. You can't hold that against Ed.
We have the most NIL in the AAC in mbb. The money "diverted" to fb is mostly earmarked for fb from the people donating it (e.g. FedEx/Smith family). So we have one of the highest NIL in both mbb and fb, outside of the power conferences, and we can no longer match them due to their conference rev shares. Not Ed's fault.
And fb currently has a better shot of competing on a national level than bb. There will be one non-P4 playing for a natty in the final 12 this year - guaranteed. How many non-power teams even made it to the S16 this year? Zero.
Let alone the fact that there is one more seismic shift coming in conference realignment in 3-4 years. Basketball will not be a factor, but football is.
Ed's success/failure is still to be determined. Certainly not a "resounding no" so far.