(03-22-2026 06:37 PM)Claw Wrote: I lived there 30 years. I don't anymore. Sue me.
Not wanting to sue you. I lived away for a while too. I know how hard it is to get back for games.
But what I didn't do when I lived away was complain about a stadium that I no longer attended. Just trying to figure out why you do.
I thought about this. I can and have ranted about what I don't like.
Boiling it down to the core, I don't believe the stadium fits any strategic plan for the University. When it's all built and operational, we won't really be any better as a university. We'll just have a stadium that Fred Smith wanted - or part of it anyway.
Or a stadium that the University could afford .... Shirley Raines killed the OCS plan that could / would have worked (location, cost, etc) ... Even a new scaled down stadium would be in the $300+million range ...
Nope. The ongoing upkeep would have been an anchor around our neck.
(03-20-2026 07:49 AM)Tiger87 Wrote: Oh, he's definitely narcissistic. That doesn't necessarily mean he's not "up to the job". He's done some good and some not so good IMO. The jury is still out.
I don't read narcissist in ADS. I think he is just demonstrating confidence, and optimism. I believe he is emphasizing the importance of football over other athletic programs. This was probably one of the stipulations of his employment.
Narcissism has nothing to do with what he's doing with fb vs bb.
It has to do with how much he talks about himself during pressers.
I happen to think he can be narcissistic and still be a good AD - we will see.
(This post was last modified: 03-26-2026 08:04 AM by Tiger87.)
(03-23-2026 07:56 AM)Tiger87 Wrote: Not wanting to sue you. I lived away for a while too. I know how hard it is to get back for games.
But what I didn't do when I lived away was complain about a stadium that I no longer attended. Just trying to figure out why you do.
I thought about this. I can and have ranted about what I don't like.
Boiling it down to the core, I don't believe the stadium fits any strategic plan for the University. When it's all built and operational, we won't really be any better as a university. We'll just have a stadium that Fred Smith wanted - or part of it anyway.
Or a stadium that the University could afford .... Shirley Raines killed the OCS plan that could / would have worked (location, cost, etc) ... Even a new scaled down stadium would be in the $300+million range ...
Nope. The ongoing upkeep would have been an anchor around our neck.
LOL! We just put an anchor on this year.
Exactly. Do you think the city would have given us a money maker?
(03-22-2026 06:37 PM)Claw Wrote: I lived there 30 years. I don't anymore. Sue me.
Not wanting to sue you. I lived away for a while too. I know how hard it is to get back for games.
But what I didn't do when I lived away was complain about a stadium that I no longer attended. Just trying to figure out why you do.
I thought about this. I can and have ranted about what I don't like.
Boiling it down to the core, I don't believe the stadium fits any strategic plan for the University. When it's all built and operational, we won't really be any better as a university. We'll just have a stadium that Fred Smith wanted - or part of it anyway.
Or a stadium that the University could afford .... Shirley Raines killed the OCS plan that could / would have worked (location, cost, etc) ... Even a new scaled down stadium would be in the $300+million range ...
Nope. The ongoing upkeep would have been an anchor around our neck.
I do not Memphis at the time (not sure about now) did not want the Liberty Bowl Stadium, yet with the Smith Family made the offer, it was a bit of a surprise to the AD, so they had no choice but to go along and take the stadium. We are getting a very nice stadium out of it so it's great. Not sure of the long term capital and true operating cost to make any determination.
(03-23-2026 07:56 AM)Tiger87 Wrote: Not wanting to sue you. I lived away for a while too. I know how hard it is to get back for games.
But what I didn't do when I lived away was complain about a stadium that I no longer attended. Just trying to figure out why you do.
I thought about this. I can and have ranted about what I don't like.
Boiling it down to the core, I don't believe the stadium fits any strategic plan for the University. When it's all built and operational, we won't really be any better as a university. We'll just have a stadium that Fred Smith wanted - or part of it anyway.
Or a stadium that the University could afford .... Shirley Raines killed the OCS plan that could / would have worked (location, cost, etc) ... Even a new scaled down stadium would be in the $300+million range ...
Nope. The ongoing upkeep would have been an anchor around our neck.
I do not Memphis at the time (not sure about now) did not want the Liberty Bowl Stadium, yet with the Smith Family made the offer, it was a bit of a surprise to the AD, so they had no choice but to go along and take the stadium. We are getting a very nice stadium out of it so it's great. Not sure of the long term capital and true operating cost to make any determination.
Trying to make everyone happy usually results in no one being happy.
I am hopeful the redesigned Liberty Bowl will be the catalyst to get us into a P4 league, but will always believe an OCS would have been better for the university.
(03-26-2026 10:06 AM)Marc Mensa Wrote: Trying to make everyone happy usually results in no one being happy.
I am hopeful the redesigned Liberty Bowl will be the catalyst to get us into a P4 league, but will always believe an OCS would have been better for the university.
It's hard not to be impressed with what looks to be a magnificent stadium which will show up fantastic on TV.
Impressed with all of the various donors stepping up as well, impressive.
(03-26-2026 10:06 AM)Marc Mensa Wrote: Trying to make everyone happy usually results in no one being happy.
I am hopeful the redesigned Liberty Bowl will be the catalyst to get us into a P4 league, but will always believe an OCS would have been better for the university.
It's hard not to be impressed with what looks to be a magnificent stadium which will show up fantastic on TV.
Impressed with all of the various donors stepping up as well, impressive.
I sincerely hope you guys are right about the new stadium.
(03-22-2026 06:37 PM)Claw Wrote: I lived there 30 years. I don't anymore. Sue me.
Not wanting to sue you. I lived away for a while too. I know how hard it is to get back for games.
But what I didn't do when I lived away was complain about a stadium that I no longer attended. Just trying to figure out why you do.
I thought about this. I can and have ranted about what I don't like.
Boiling it down to the core, I don't believe the stadium fits any strategic plan for the University. When it's all built and operational, we won't really be any better as a university. We'll just have a stadium that Fred Smith wanted - or part of it anyway.
Or a stadium that the University could afford .... Shirley Raines killed the OCS plan that could / would have worked (location, cost, etc) ... Even a new scaled down stadium would be in the $300+million range ...
Nope. The ongoing upkeep would have been an anchor around our neck.
No different than what we have now ... We basically have an OCS that just isn't on our campus now ...
(03-23-2026 07:56 AM)Tiger87 Wrote: Not wanting to sue you. I lived away for a while too. I know how hard it is to get back for games.
But what I didn't do when I lived away was complain about a stadium that I no longer attended. Just trying to figure out why you do.
I thought about this. I can and have ranted about what I don't like.
Boiling it down to the core, I don't believe the stadium fits any strategic plan for the University. When it's all built and operational, we won't really be any better as a university. We'll just have a stadium that Fred Smith wanted - or part of it anyway.
Or a stadium that the University could afford .... Shirley Raines killed the OCS plan that could / would have worked (location, cost, etc) ... Even a new scaled down stadium would be in the $300+million range ...
Nope. The ongoing upkeep would have been an anchor around our neck.
No different than what we have now ... We basically have an OCS that just isn't on our campus now ...
(03-26-2026 10:06 AM)Marc Mensa Wrote: Trying to make everyone happy usually results in no one being happy.
I am hopeful the redesigned Liberty Bowl will be the catalyst to get us into a P4 league, but will always believe an OCS would have been better for the university.
It's hard not to be impressed with what looks to be a magnificent stadium which will show up fantastic on TV.
Impressed with all of the various donors stepping up as well, impressive.
There will be a beautifully renovated Citrus Bowl stadium in Orlando… likely much nicer than UCF’s on campus stadium. UCF will not consider moving off campus. Tampa has an impressive NFL stadium. USF is building on campus. The renovated Liberty Bowl will undoubtedly be an impressive off campus facility. As an alumni, I’d prefer to spend my Saturdays back on campus.
(03-26-2026 10:06 AM)Marc Mensa Wrote: Trying to make everyone happy usually results in no one being happy.
I am hopeful the redesigned Liberty Bowl will be the catalyst to get us into a P4 league, but will always believe an OCS would have been better for the university.
It's hard not to be impressed with what looks to be a magnificent stadium which will show up fantastic on TV.
Impressed with all of the various donors stepping up as well, impressive.
There will be a beautifully renovated Citrus Bowl stadium in Orlando… likely much nicer than UCF’s on campus stadium. UCF will not consider moving off campus. Tampa has an impressive NFL stadium. USF is building on campus. The renovated Liberty Bowl will undoubtedly be an impressive off campus facility. As an alumni, I’d prefer to spend my Saturdays back on campus.
Agree. And I think you speak for the majority on this.
(03-26-2026 10:06 AM)Marc Mensa Wrote: Trying to make everyone happy usually results in no one being happy.
I am hopeful the redesigned Liberty Bowl will be the catalyst to get us into a P4 league, but will always believe an OCS would have been better for the university.
It's hard not to be impressed with what looks to be a magnificent stadium which will show up fantastic on TV.
Impressed with all of the various donors stepping up as well, impressive.
There will be a beautifully renovated Citrus Bowl stadium in Orlando… likely much nicer than UCF’s on campus stadium. UCF will not consider moving off campus. Tampa has an impressive NFL stadium. USF is building on campus. The renovated Liberty Bowl will undoubtedly be an impressive off campus facility. As an alumni, I’d prefer to spend my Saturdays back on campus.
No problem you can spend as much time as you like everyday of the week on campus, without disrupting campus life just don't expect to get a beer or a cocktail. Liberty is a near campus stadium.
(03-26-2026 10:06 AM)Marc Mensa Wrote: Trying to make everyone happy usually results in no one being happy.
I am hopeful the redesigned Liberty Bowl will be the catalyst to get us into a P4 league, but will always believe an OCS would have been better for the university.
It's hard not to be impressed with what looks to be a magnificent stadium which will show up fantastic on TV.
Impressed with all of the various donors stepping up as well, impressive.
There will be a beautifully renovated Citrus Bowl stadium in Orlando… likely much nicer than UCF’s on campus stadium. UCF will not consider moving off campus. Tampa has an impressive NFL stadium. USF is building on campus. The renovated Liberty Bowl will undoubtedly be an impressive off campus facility. As an alumni, I’d prefer to spend my Saturdays back on campus.
Agree. And I think you speak for the majority on this.
Would love for this to have happened, but unfortunately this is what we’ll have for probably the rest of my lifetime so I’m going to make the best of our football home …
(03-26-2026 10:06 AM)Marc Mensa Wrote: Trying to make everyone happy usually results in no one being happy.
I am hopeful the redesigned Liberty Bowl will be the catalyst to get us into a P4 league, but will always believe an OCS would have been better for the university.
It's hard not to be impressed with what looks to be a magnificent stadium which will show up fantastic on TV.
Impressed with all of the various donors stepping up as well, impressive.
There will be a beautifully renovated Citrus Bowl stadium in Orlando… likely much nicer than UCF’s on campus stadium. UCF will not consider moving off campus. Tampa has an impressive NFL stadium. USF is building on campus. The renovated Liberty Bowl will undoubtedly be an impressive off campus facility. As an alumni, I’d prefer to spend my Saturdays back on campus.
No problem you can spend as much time as you like everyday of the week on campus, without disrupting campus life just don't expect to get a beer or a cocktail. Liberty is a near campus stadium.
Near campus stadiums do not bring donating alumni back to campus. No, they bring them to an asphalt parking lot at the fairgrounds, and help suppress of alumni giving percentage. The percentage of UofM alumni who donate to the university is embarrassingly low… less than 10%… and one of the reasons is there is no connection to the university. Hate to disrupt campus life
(03-26-2026 10:06 AM)Marc Mensa Wrote: Trying to make everyone happy usually results in no one being happy.
I am hopeful the redesigned Liberty Bowl will be the catalyst to get us into a P4 league, but will always believe an OCS would have been better for the university.
It's hard not to be impressed with what looks to be a magnificent stadium which will show up fantastic on TV.
Impressed with all of the various donors stepping up as well, impressive.
There will be a beautifully renovated Citrus Bowl stadium in Orlando… likely much nicer than UCF’s on campus stadium. UCF will not consider moving off campus. Tampa has an impressive NFL stadium. USF is building on campus. The renovated Liberty Bowl will undoubtedly be an impressive off campus facility. As an alumni, I’d prefer to spend my Saturdays back on campus.
No problem you can spend as much time as you like everyday of the week on campus, without disrupting campus life just don't expect to get a beer or a cocktail. Liberty is a near campus stadium.
Near campus stadiums do not bring donating alumni back to campus. No, they bring them to an asphalt parking lot at the fairgrounds, and help suppress of alumni giving percentage. The percentage of UofM alumni who donate to the university is embarrassingly low… less than 10%… and one of the reasons is there is no connection to the university. Hate to disrupt campus life
The truth is an ugly thing. Most likely this shiny new stadium will be another Mud Island or Pyramid in twenty years. I'd love to be wrong, but that is the actual history of the Liberty Bowl. It takes a major cash infusion every twenty years or so for fresh lipstick on the pig (1965, 1987, 2013, 2026)
(03-10-2026 01:34 PM)TigerBlue4Ever Wrote: Some of us suffer from uh...oh, yeah, ADD. Or is it ADAD? Speaking of getting old, how about the MSC, or our losing streak and program? What's that AD's name again? Man, this BBQ out here in T-County is good!
.
(03-26-2026 10:16 AM)griffin Wrote: It's hard not to be impressed with what looks to be a magnificent stadium which will show up fantastic on TV.
Impressed with all of the various donors stepping up as well, impressive.
There will be a beautifully renovated Citrus Bowl stadium in Orlando… likely much nicer than UCF’s on campus stadium. UCF will not consider moving off campus. Tampa has an impressive NFL stadium. USF is building on campus. The renovated Liberty Bowl will undoubtedly be an impressive off campus facility. As an alumni, I’d prefer to spend my Saturdays back on campus.
No problem you can spend as much time as you like everyday of the week on campus, without disrupting campus life just don't expect to get a beer or a cocktail. Liberty is a near campus stadium.
Near campus stadiums do not bring donating alumni back to campus. No, they bring them to an asphalt parking lot at the fairgrounds, and help suppress of alumni giving percentage. The percentage of UofM alumni who donate to the university is embarrassingly low… less than 10%… and one of the reasons is there is no connection to the university. Hate to disrupt campus life
The truth is an ugly thing. Most likely this shiny new stadium will be another Mud Island or Pyramid in twenty years. I'd love to be wrong, but that is the actual history of the Liberty Bowl. It takes a major cash infusion every twenty years or so for fresh lipstick on the pig (1965, 1987, 2013, 2026)
The Liberty Bowl stadium suffered from municipal neglect for decades. Now that Liberty Stadium is owned by the University I do not believe that neglect will be an issue. I know it took more than 20 years for some to realize the University of Memphis is no longer Memphis State. I hope it will not take as long for those to realize that Liberty Bowl Stadium is now just Liberty Stadium Home of the Tigers.
(This post was last modified: 03-28-2026 04:01 PM by Keeper.)
(03-26-2026 10:16 AM)griffin Wrote: It's hard not to be impressed with what looks to be a magnificent stadium which will show up fantastic on TV.
Impressed with all of the various donors stepping up as well, impressive.
There will be a beautifully renovated Citrus Bowl stadium in Orlando… likely much nicer than UCF’s on campus stadium. UCF will not consider moving off campus. Tampa has an impressive NFL stadium. USF is building on campus. The renovated Liberty Bowl will undoubtedly be an impressive off campus facility. As an alumni, I’d prefer to spend my Saturdays back on campus.
No problem you can spend as much time as you like everyday of the week on campus, without disrupting campus life just don't expect to get a beer or a cocktail. Liberty is a near campus stadium.
Near campus stadiums do not bring donating alumni back to campus. No, they bring them to an asphalt parking lot at the fairgrounds, and help suppress of alumni giving percentage. The percentage of UofM alumni who donate to the university is embarrassingly low… less than 10%… and one of the reasons is there is no connection to the university. Hate to disrupt campus life
The truth is an ugly thing. Most likely this shiny new stadium will be another Mud Island or Pyramid in twenty years. I'd love to be wrong, but that is the actual history of the Liberty Bowl. It takes a major cash infusion every twenty years or so for fresh lipstick on the pig (1965, 1987, 2013, 2026)
Not saying you’re wrong, but this is a massive reno compared to past projects. I think it’ll be a nice improvement. I also like that they’re shrinking capacity. Anyway, we’ll see….