(03-10-2026 01:07 PM)sigke Wrote: NDSU won't leave the Mountain West.
Right now? No. In five years? If CUSA manages (hypothetically) to snag both Tarleton and SDSU, and all the youngsters in CUSA (those two, plus Jax State, Sam Houston, Kennesaw, Delaware, and Mo State) all continue to improve on their trajectories and become not just consistent bowl teams but consistent contenders for the CUSA title and even the CFP, older teams like WKU and Liberty don't quietly give those trophies away, and FIU, NMSU, and MT improve enough that, if they don't become contenders, they're consistently no worse than the lower 100s?
It's a lot to ask. But it's realistic. And to be clear, becoming a consistent contender for the CFP doesn't imply making the CFP. But when that school's name is mentioned, the reaction is more, "Yeah, they could certainly make it," rather than, "C'mon, man."
IF that comes to pass -- if it MOSTLY comes to pass -- and if CUSA's media deal is solid and competitive with the Sun Belt and MWC, then there's no reason for NDSU not to consider a change.
Everyone plugs them into the MWC because the western schools are used to flying everywhere they go. But the northern plains are not culturally bound to the Rocky Mountains or the Pacific West.
As long as Hawai'i is included, the average distance from Fargo to CUSA schools is about 200 miles closer than than MWC schools (1,091 miles vs 1,288 miles). Remove Hawai'i from the equation, and the MWC gets only a slight advantage versus CUSA (dropping from 1,288 to 974 miles).
The MAC (859 mile average) has us both beat, but even then, it's only a difference of a little over 200 miles versus CUSA.
No conference in its 2026 configuration offers a travel time shorter than 512 miles.
So NDSU COULD happen. It'd just take a lot of things falling into place. (The same could honestly be said for most if not all potential FCS and G6 realignment moves.)
Quote:I'm all for South Dakota State over anyone.
No arguments here. I *wish* we had better alternatives regionally, but we don't. Maybe that will change in 5-10 years...?
Quote:However, I was just thinking whether UTRGV was a better long term option over Tarlton State?
To be fair, I don't think either is a great short-term option. (Not that "short-term" really matters at this point.)
But as long-term options go, I disagree about Tarleton. The region of Texas they're in is booming. Most of the growth has NOT gotten to Stephenville yet, but it's coming. You can't be located less than 100 miles from DFW (7th fastest growing large metro area in the U.S.), 100 miles from Killeen-Temple (6th fastest growing midsize metro), and about 150 miles from Austin-Round Rock-Georgetown (No. 1 fastest growing large metro) without eventually getting swept up in it.
I just don't see the Edinburg area having that same kind of long-term potential.