(02-16-2026 02:57 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: I think this forum vastly overrates (and is sometimes even thirsty for) the prospect of schools moving down from FBS or FCS or downgrading at any level (e.g. Division I to Division II or III).
Schools may even make noise about strained budgets and/or losing money.
However, actually pulling a trigger on a downgrade is something most college leaders aren’t willing to do right now (if ever).
First, we just saw how valuable a spot is in FBS in and of itself with the North Dakota State and Sacramento State moves: on the order of $17 million-plus simply to get a *spot* in an FBS league. So, a school has to calculate that their spot in an FBS league alone is effectively an asset worth that much (akin to the valuation of a pro sports franchise). How many schools are willing to simply unilaterally give away a $17 million asset? Not many. It’s also a likely irreversible move where the costs of getting *back* to FBS status could be way more in the future if it’s even possible.
Second, and I can’t emphasize this enough, but the educational marketplace does NOT reward downgrading in any form. No school actually gets credit for taking austerity measures in the name of financial prudence. If anything, we see how any news of a school going backwards (and that includes athletics) often creates a vicious circle where new student applications go down, which in turn drops enrollment, which in turn makes the financial issues at that school get even worse. There are simply too many other competitors in the marketplace that offer the full package of academics and athletics that cutting back simply isn’t rewarded, particularly for places that aren’t in large metro area locations.
I agree with your conclusion, that pulling the trigger on a downgrade isn't something most schools are willing to do right now, if ever. But I am not sure about the two reasons.
First, while there is a clear market price of around $17m to join FBS, I am not sure that is a reason for a school to remain FBS, as it isn't an asset it can leverage. Can a school sell its slot to another? If so, that would be a $17m asset on the books, so to speak, and one it might want to keep because it might grow in value. But I don't think that can happen, so it's kind of a symbolic asset, I think. It really just reflects the desire of some FCS and lower schools to "move up" to FBS, whether that's a good idea or not being another issue. Point taken, though, about that being a cost to move up again, should it move down. But that is a one-time $17m potential cost, whereas football often loses millions on an annual basis. If a school really is ready to move up to FBS, it should be able to come up with a one-time fee like that.
About the second reason, I quasi-agree. I do think that the educational marketplace does not reward downgrading, but I have what I think is a different twist on this.
First, I don't think there is a vicious cycle where downgrading athletics hurts enrollment, etc. Schools have downgraded and done pretty well. IIRC, Western Washington ended its football program in 2009, and its enrollment today is basically the same as what it was at that time, despite general downward trends. In contrast, Eastern Washington has clung to its FCS program, and its enrollment has continued to erode. Those are just two cases of course, but if there is a general trend of a vicious cycle I am not aware of it.
Even if there are cases where a school downgraded athletics and then lost enrollment, etc. and failed, IMO it probably downgraded athletics because it was struggling, and doing that was an attempt to save itself. So we can't necessarily blame the downgrade for the failure. It's like if I am on a life raft with a cow, the raft springs a leak and I throw the cow overboard to try and lessen the load to save myself, but even after jettisoning the cow the boat continues to leak and I drown anyway, we can't say that it was wrong for me to jettison the cow. It probably bought me a bit more time, in end it just wasn't enough. Of course, it is also possible that jettisoning the cow (or athletics) may have hastened my demised as well. but I think it more likely the former.
This of course refers to cause and effect, about which I have often said that I think causality is often reversed in these cases. What I mean is, I think that when a school expands athletics, like adding football, this forum tends to think of this as a growth move, as in "we want to grow, and adding football will boost enrollment" and the like. I see it is as the reverse - IMO expanding athletics is usually a result of previous growth. Upgrading athletics is more of an effect of growth rather than a cause. A school is growing, and at a certain point they say to themselves, "hey, we now have 15,000 students, why don't we have a football team like cross-state U does"? It's a symbol of growth and new status, like a newly-rich person buying an expensive car or joining a country club, not a cause of it. It sends a signal to the neighbors about who we have become, not so much what we hope to become. I think that was the case for my USF when we added football in 1997. Has USF grown a lot since then? Yes it has. But it was growing a lot before adding football too, and by 1997 the elites decided that we needed to signal our "big time" status by having football. Of course,, something can be both a cause and an effect, in a cyclical sense. But regarding USF IMO there is no evidence that football has enhanced our growth above and beyond what it would have been.
Which IMO also involves another aspect of the educational marketplace: while it may well be good for a school to "downgrade" athletics, it is almost never good for the admin elites who run it to do so. If you are a university provost or president or chancellor and are on the market, you know that schools want to see growth on your resume, not "downgrades". Did football "move up" from D2 to FCS on your watch? That's something you'll be proud to discuss in an interview at a bigger school. Did they downgrade from FCS to D2, or drop football, on your watch? That's going to be a very uncomfortable conversation in that same type of interview. It may well have been best for the school you are leaving that you led that downgrade, but the school you want to hire you is unlikely to view it that way. So IMO, elites who make these decisions have a personal-career interest in resisting downgrades.
There's also the matter of pay. IIRC, about 5 years ago, when Eastern Washington was thinking about downgrading its football from FCS to D2, it was shown that their AD made considerably more money than the Western Washington AD, even though WW had higher enrollment and a much sounder budget thanks to no football. Football is a big program, with a big budget, lots of staff and facilities and jobs, and those things add up to more money for the top bureaucrats and admins who preside over them.
Just MO.