(02-19-2026 01:05 PM)johnbragg Wrote: (02-19-2026 12:38 PM)bullet Wrote: (02-19-2026 12:22 PM)JSchmack Wrote: (02-18-2026 07:45 AM)Gemofthehills Wrote: Does anyone really believe a school will drop down to FCS when the price tag to come back will be 20+ million? Maybe drop sports all together but hard to grasp someone going from FBS to FCS since the savings will be zero or even a bigger loss.
Moving from FBS to FCS makes literally zero sense. You're going to upset all your boosters/donors/fans/alumni massively by dropping to FCS... which those people are the ones buying tickets and making donations.
So you're gonna lose all the revenue, but keep paying like 90% or more of the expenses. FCS teams take 100 guys to away games, sleeping in hotels and eating food. The biggest difference in expense of FBS vs FCS is coaches salaries and scholarships.
(02-18-2026 10:41 AM)MattBrownEP Wrote: For what it's worth, I haven't heard anybody I trust directly tell me a MAC school was seriously considering moving to FCS in the last few years. I HAVE heard that there were MAC schools seriously considering going FBS independent and moving their other sports to the Horizon.
THAT is interesting to me. Logically, that points to a belief that:
A - "the MAC has the SWC problem of limited to one specific region with a need to expand the footprint"
(the rumors about Illinois State, and the addition of Sac State would reinforce that).
B - But adding new members dilutes the shares of conference revenue within the MAC.
In most cases, it makes more sense to drop football. But the ones who are thinking about dropping down don't have many fans or donors to lose. And they get rid of a lot more than 10% of the expenses. Most FCS schools are in the $10-$25 million in total spending. There were only 3 FBS schools under $28 million (2023-4). The largest amount of institutional support by far are the G5/6 schools. Having continually losing teams with no fans doesn't really achieve any of the goals of having an athletic program. Would you rather be a North Dakota St. or a UL-Monroe or Eastern Michigan?
It's not apples-to-apples to compare the absolute apex of FCS with the dregs of FBS.
Would you rather be Northern Colorado or Eastern Michigan? Would you rather be ULM or Northwestern State? Those are more reasonable comparisons to the bottom bottom of FBS. (At least I think so, I picked FCS schools mostly at random)
I think what we all have to remember is that we all here generally look at things at a rational macroeconomic level of how schools are valued in relation to the whole college sports landscape.
However, each university president is an actual person. They may or may not be at that school in 5 years. Many of them are being charged to make action plans *now* with respect to the enrollment cliff and other challenges facing universities.
So, if university presidents have short-term individual incentives, how many of them choose to say, “You know what? We can’t actually compete with the best of the best at the FBS level. We can downgrade and start winning games again against right-sized comparable competition in FCS. We’re lesser and we should just acknowledge it.” From a pure psychological self-preservation standpoint, how many university presidents (who move around with as much frequency as football coaches), who is making that type of monumental unilateral downgrade in this environment? Which university leaders have statues built for them (or simply financial bonuses paid) for going backwards? I doubt many or any of us here would have the intestinal fortitude to do it if we were sitting in that chair with our own job on the line.
On the flip side, though, what can a university president actually do in what will likely be a short-term (less than 5 years) position that has significant growth impact or at least can be sold as such? Academic rankings take decades to change, if they can ever realistically be changed at all. You can’t just move a school from the middle of North Dakota to Florida or Southern California to create a more attractive location.
So, what can you actually do in the short-term that will get headlines, though? Investment in athletics is a pretty high profile level to pull. I have continued to find it disingenuous that so many critique a school like Sacramento State for the cost of moving up to the FBS on the one hand, yet on the other hand, for 99.9% of us, this will be the most that any of us talked or even thought about Sacramento State in our entire lives. Who are we kidding here? These schools know what gets attention in an insanely crowded marketplace.
I’ve said this many times before: schools are just reflecting the values of society as opposed to the other way around. There are literally millions or frankly *billions* of more media stories, social media posts, and message board posts about college football on top of the billions of dollars that TV networks pay for college football compared to anything that any schools have done academically. None of us should complain that schools keep investing in bread and circuses when the general public (including all of us here) spend exponentially more time watching, consuming and thinking about the bread and circuses compared to anything else that these schools do.